B24 MED Past Papers Singapore PDF
Document Details
Uploaded by AthleticSilver740
NUS Faculty of Law
Tags
Summary
This document provides lecture notes on mediation and dispute resolution mechanisms. It covers various aspects including legal frameworks, types of mediation, and ethical considerations for mediators. It also includes case studies and examples from Singapore.
Full Transcript
B24 MED Lecture 1 ❖ Mediation and other Dispute Resolution Mechanisms Decision maker Nature/Process Costs Duration Focus ❖ What is Mediation? ❖ Common Types of Mediation and Mediators ❖ Benefits of Mediation ❖ Disadvantages of Mediation ❖ Evolving Roles of the Advocate in Mediation ❖ Me...
B24 MED Lecture 1 ❖ Mediation and other Dispute Resolution Mechanisms Decision maker Nature/Process Costs Duration Focus ❖ What is Mediation? ❖ Common Types of Mediation and Mediators ❖ Benefits of Mediation ❖ Disadvantages of Mediation ❖ Evolving Roles of the Advocate in Mediation ❖ Mediation Institutions Lecture 2 A. Singapore Mediation Centre (SMC) B. Singapore International Mediation Centre (SIMC) C. Community Mediation Centre (CMC) D. Law Society Mediation Scheme (LSMS) E. Industry-Specific Mediation F. Private Organisations G. Singapore International Mediation Institute (SIMI) H. Singapore International Dispute Resolution Academy (SIDRA) Interest-based negotiation by Harvard The difference between **[position]** and **[interest]**. Lecture 3 - legal framework A. Legal Sources B. Basis of Mediation ❖ By Agreement ❖ By Statutes or Subsidiary Legislation ❖ By Court's / Authorised Body's Directions **[ Rules of Court (O. 5, r. 3)]** Personal Data Protection Act 2012, s 48G Where a Party declines ADR C. Mediation Act 2017 s3 Mediation Act - What is mediation s6 Mediation Act applicability of the Mediation Act s8 Mediation Act - Stay of proceedings s9 Mediation Act - Confidentiality s10 Mediation Act - Without Prejudice privilege Mariwu Industrial Co (S) Pte Ltd v Dextra Asia Co Ltd \[2006\] 4 SLR(R) 807 at \[24\] Greenline-Onyx Envirotech Phils, Inc v Otto Systems Singapore Pte Ltd \[2007\] 3 SLR(R) 40 Mediated Settlement Agreement checklist Subject to contract doctrines s12 Mediation Act - Mediation Agreement recorded as consent order s12(3) and (4) Mediation Act s2 Mediation Act - **[Requirements]** of the Mediated Settlement Agreement Mediated settlement Agreement in **[Family law]** s12 (5) Mediation Act - **[Enforcement]** of Settlement Agreement D. Conduct of Lawyers PD 53 - Duty to advise on ADR and associated cost orders Lock Han Chng Jonathan (Jonathan Luo Hancheng) v Goh Jessiline \[2007\] SGCA 56 Maxx Engineering v PQ Builders Pte Ltd \[2023\] SGHC 71 - **[Court cannot force parties to mediate]** E. Conduct of Parties and Costs Consequences Rules of Court 2021, O. 5, r. 1 and r. 2 - **[The mindset now is before you start litigation, think about settling.]** Rules of Court 2021, O. 21, r. 2(2)(a) - **[face costs consequences for rejecting mediation]** Supreme Court Practice **[Directions 53]** and **[Appendix D]** State Courts Practice **[Directions 34]** The **[Test]** of whether a party has unreasonably refused ADR Churchill v Merthyr Tydfil \[2023\] EWCA Civ 1416 - **[Stay of proceedings in favour of mediation]** Nigel Witham Ltd v Smith and another \[2008\] EWHC 12 (TCC), at \[32\] "\[32\] - **[identify the happy medium]** PGF II SA v OMFS Co 1 Ltd \[2014\] 1 WLR 1386 at \[34\] - **[silence towards ADR is unreasonable]** Legis Point LLC v Tay Choon Ai \[2018\] 3 SLR 1269 - **[cost of mediation work is considered in party-to-party cost]** Lecture 4- Elements of effective negotiation Positional Bargaining Interests versus position Options **[Criteria]** **[Alternatives (to a negotiated agreement)]** Communication Relationship Commitment Lecture 5 - Ethical Considerations ❖ Role of a Mediation Advocate Legal Profession (Professional Conduct) Rules 2015 ("PCR 2015"), Rule 15A ❖ Ethical Considerations for a Mediation Advocate Rule 5 -- Competence in advising the client; **[BATNA]** Rule 6 -- Protection of the client's confidentiality **[s9 Mediation Act]** Rule 6 (Confidentiality) Rule 22 -- Avoidance of conflict of interest Rule 7 -- Courtesy and Fairness Rule 8 -- Honesty, honourability and good faith in conducting the negotiation Rule 8A **[❖ Duties of a lawyer to a client]**