Podcast
Questions and Answers
What was the main reason the Soviet Union insisted on a base year of 1990 during the Montreal negotiations?
What was the main reason the Soviet Union insisted on a base year of 1990 during the Montreal negotiations?
- It was the year when the global environmental crisis peaked.
- It coincided with the end of their five-year planning cycle. (correct)
- It aligned with their desired timeline for production cuts.
- It was the year agreed upon by the majority of negotiators.
What caused the deadlock in the Montreal negotiations regarding the base year for CFC reductions?
What caused the deadlock in the Montreal negotiations regarding the base year for CFC reductions?
- A lack of communication among the negotiating parties.
- Conflicting national interests between the United States and Soviet Union. (correct)
- Uncertainty about the impact of production cuts on future economies.
- Disagreements over the scientific data concerning CFC usage.
How was the deadlock in the Montreal negotiations eventually resolved?
How was the deadlock in the Montreal negotiations eventually resolved?
- By convening a new panel of experts to reevaluate the issue.
- By adjusting the treaty text to include a qualification. (correct)
- By introducing an entirely new base year.
- Through the use of an interpreter to facilitate communication.
What unexpected event contributed to breaking the negotiation deadlock?
What unexpected event contributed to breaking the negotiation deadlock?
What negative consequence was anticipated if the Soviet Union's preferred base year of 1990 was adopted?
What negative consequence was anticipated if the Soviet Union's preferred base year of 1990 was adopted?
What was one of the deterrents for entry into the polar bear products trade?
What was one of the deterrents for entry into the polar bear products trade?
Which countries were excluded from the negotiations leading to the Nile Waters Agreement in 1959?
Which countries were excluded from the negotiations leading to the Nile Waters Agreement in 1959?
Which treaty restricts trade in polar bear products, as mentioned in the content?
Which treaty restricts trade in polar bear products, as mentioned in the content?
What was the main issue regarding participation restrictions in the Antarctic Treaty?
What was the main issue regarding participation restrictions in the Antarctic Treaty?
What implication does the exclusion of other Nile riparians have on the legitimacy of the Nile Waters Agreement?
What implication does the exclusion of other Nile riparians have on the legitimacy of the Nile Waters Agreement?
What does a signature on a treaty usually indicate for a country?
What does a signature on a treaty usually indicate for a country?
What is required for a treaty to legally enter into force?
What is required for a treaty to legally enter into force?
What can happen if a negotiator strikes a bargain that the executive does not like?
What can happen if a negotiator strikes a bargain that the executive does not like?
What action carries the same legal weight as ratification?
What action carries the same legal weight as ratification?
What duty is imposed on a country that has signed a treaty?
What duty is imposed on a country that has signed a treaty?
What is typically the first act a country takes regarding a treaty before ratification?
What is typically the first act a country takes regarding a treaty before ratification?
Why was President Bill Clinton's signing of the Kyoto Protocol significant?
Why was President Bill Clinton's signing of the Kyoto Protocol significant?
How are bilateral and multilateral agreements treated differently regarding signature obligations?
How are bilateral and multilateral agreements treated differently regarding signature obligations?
What is a reason parties might prefer to protect more of a resource in the near term?
What is a reason parties might prefer to protect more of a resource in the near term?
What may countries negotiate based on uncertainty about the future environment?
What may countries negotiate based on uncertainty about the future environment?
How can a treaty be renegotiated?
How can a treaty be renegotiated?
What distinguishes an amendment from an adjustment of a treaty?
What distinguishes an amendment from an adjustment of a treaty?
What requirement must be met for a state that accedes to a treaty after amendments take effect?
What requirement must be met for a state that accedes to a treaty after amendments take effect?
What is a characteristic of the Montreal Protocol?
What is a characteristic of the Montreal Protocol?
Why might parties withdraw from a treaty?
Why might parties withdraw from a treaty?
What is one impact of anticipating irreversibility in development for negotiations?
What is one impact of anticipating irreversibility in development for negotiations?
What is the significance of including every country as a player in the modeling of fur seals?
What is the significance of including every country as a player in the modeling of fur seals?
Why are participation restrictions common in treaties like the Montreal Protocol?
Why are participation restrictions common in treaties like the Montreal Protocol?
In the context of conservation agreements, what does 'N' typically define?
In the context of conservation agreements, what does 'N' typically define?
What was a significant factor that led to the creation of the Agreement on the Conservation of Polar Bears?
What was a significant factor that led to the creation of the Agreement on the Conservation of Polar Bears?
What is a common reason for restricting participation in some international treaties?
What is a common reason for restricting participation in some international treaties?
What misconception may arise regarding the membership of the Vienna Convention?
What misconception may arise regarding the membership of the Vienna Convention?
Which statement reflects a misconception about the hunting of polar bears in relation to conservation efforts?
Which statement reflects a misconception about the hunting of polar bears in relation to conservation efforts?
What misconception might people have about high seas fisheries management?
What misconception might people have about high seas fisheries management?
What was the main purpose of the ICRW in relation to whale stocks?
What was the main purpose of the ICRW in relation to whale stocks?
What significant change occurred regarding the signatories of the ICRW over time?
What significant change occurred regarding the signatories of the ICRW over time?
Which of the following best describes the major conflict within the IWC today?
Which of the following best describes the major conflict within the IWC today?
What prompted Iceland's withdrawal from the IWC in 1992?
What prompted Iceland's withdrawal from the IWC in 1992?
What role does the 'North Atlantic Marine Mammals Conservation Organisation' play?
What role does the 'North Atlantic Marine Mammals Conservation Organisation' play?
Which country joined the IWC in 1994 with the aim to stop whaling?
Which country joined the IWC in 1994 with the aim to stop whaling?
What was a key issue with the membership of the ICRW?
What was a key issue with the membership of the ICRW?
What consensus was reached about mineral development in Antarctica?
What consensus was reached about mineral development in Antarctica?
Flashcards
Chance in Negotiations
Chance in Negotiations
Unforeseen events or circumstances that can significantly impact the outcome of negotiations.
Strategic Behavior in Negotiations
Strategic Behavior in Negotiations
The use of tactics or strategies designed to gain an advantage during negotiations, often by creating artificial pressure.
Negotiation Deadlock
Negotiation Deadlock
A situation where negotiations stall or fail to progress due to a lack of agreement on a key issue.
Base Year in Negotiations
Base Year in Negotiations
Signup and view all the flashcards
Negotiations Proceeding Smoothly
Negotiations Proceeding Smoothly
Signup and view all the flashcards
Ratification
Ratification
Signup and view all the flashcards
Signing a Treaty
Signing a Treaty
Signup and view all the flashcards
Accession
Accession
Signup and view all the flashcards
Bilateral Agreement
Bilateral Agreement
Signup and view all the flashcards
Multilateral Agreement
Multilateral Agreement
Signup and view all the flashcards
Denunciation
Denunciation
Signup and view all the flashcards
Kyoto Protocol
Kyoto Protocol
Signup and view all the flashcards
Convention on Biological Diversity
Convention on Biological Diversity
Signup and view all the flashcards
Treaty Renegotiation
Treaty Renegotiation
Signup and view all the flashcards
Treaty Supercession
Treaty Supercession
Signup and view all the flashcards
Negotiated Adjustments
Negotiated Adjustments
Signup and view all the flashcards
Treaty Amendments
Treaty Amendments
Signup and view all the flashcards
Amendment Obligations
Amendment Obligations
Signup and view all the flashcards
Montreal Protocol Flexibility
Montreal Protocol Flexibility
Signup and view all the flashcards
Treaty Flexibility
Treaty Flexibility
Signup and view all the flashcards
Negotiations with Future Uncertainty
Negotiations with Future Uncertainty
Signup and view all the flashcards
N (in International Negotiations)
N (in International Negotiations)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Open Membership in Global Agreements
Open Membership in Global Agreements
Signup and view all the flashcards
Accession to Treaties
Accession to Treaties
Signup and view all the flashcards
Restricted Participation in Agreements
Restricted Participation in Agreements
Signup and view all the flashcards
Agreement on the Conservation of Polar Bears
Agreement on the Conservation of Polar Bears
Signup and view all the flashcards
Restricted Participation based on Lack of Interest
Restricted Participation based on Lack of Interest
Signup and view all the flashcards
Hunting of Polar Bears
Hunting of Polar Bears
Signup and view all the flashcards
Aerial Safaris for Polar Bear Hunting
Aerial Safaris for Polar Bear Hunting
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is CITES?
What is CITES?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is a territorial sea?
What is a territorial sea?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is an Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ)?
What is an Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ)?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What are participation restrictions in treaties?
What are participation restrictions in treaties?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Why is the Antarctic Treaty an example of participation restrictions?
Why is the Antarctic Treaty an example of participation restrictions?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Cloud of Illegitimacy
Cloud of Illegitimacy
Signup and view all the flashcards
Inclusiveness in Agreements
Inclusiveness in Agreements
Signup and view all the flashcards
Sustained Yield Management
Sustained Yield Management
Signup and view all the flashcards
Clash of Objectives in Agreements
Clash of Objectives in Agreements
Signup and view all the flashcards
Splinter Organization
Splinter Organization
Signup and view all the flashcards
New Treaty Constitution
New Treaty Constitution
Signup and view all the flashcards
Agreement Postponing a Decision
Agreement Postponing a Decision
Signup and view all the flashcards
Study Notes
International Environmental Agreements
- International agreements are increasingly used to address international cooperation problems.
- Treaty-making is a process that shapes outcomes.
- Treaties have minimum participation levels, basic obligations, withdrawal clauses, and may use trade restrictions.
- There are over 4,300 treaties and international agreements, with two-thirds entered into in the past 25 years.
- International agreements address transnational environmental issues, such as conserving wildlife (marine mammals, fish, birds, etc.), preserving unique ecosystems, controlling pests and diseases, managing shared resources (rivers, seas), and regulating hazardous materials.
Introduction
- International Environmental Agreements (IEAs) are negotiated, written, and legally binding on participating countries.
- They offer specific remedies to transnational environmental problems, unlike general customary solutions.
The Environmental Treaty
-
The appendix provides a list of current and potential IEAs.
-
Decisions about including or excluding certain treaties in the list are not straightforward.
-
It is not a comprehensive or totally current list.
-
Treaties have increased in number since 1945.
The number of International Environmental Agreements
- The graph illustrates the increasing number of IEAs since 1900.
- There has been a significant increase in the number of IEAs, especially since the Second World War.
EU Directives
- The EU has numerous environmental regulations, directives, and decisions.
- EU agreements have distinct features due to their unique institutional context.
- EU directives have implications for the European single market, not just transboundary externalities.
- EU directives are different from IEAs.
Bilateral Agreements
- Bilateral agreements are more challenging to analyze comprehensively than multilateral agreements.
The Process of Treaty-Making
- Treaty-making is a complex, not linear process.
- Key stages are pre-negotiation, negotiation, ratification, implementation, and renegotiation.
- Pre-negotiation involves maneuvering between different parties (and countries) with varied views.
- Negotiation and agreements can be difficult and require a long time and considerable effort from all parties involved.
Procedural Arrangements
- Treaty negotiations often use committees.
- The use of committees to discuss different aspects of the same issue at the same time.
- Treaty texts are frequently adjusted and reworked throughout the process
Transparency
- Recent emphasis on transparency (in negotiations) could possibly hinder, rather than advance cooperation
- Parties may attempt to compromise in private, and openness is not always a major driver for success.
Negotiation of Compliance
- Compliance requirements and clauses for treaties vary considerably
- Reports are required for many international agreements
Ratification
- Ratification is needed for multilateral agreements to have legal force.
- A country's parliament or equivalent often has the final say in approving or rejecting a treaty.
Renegotiation
-
Treaties can be renegotiated in response to changes in the environment, technology, or circumstances.
-
Irreversible costs and changes can potentially impact the need for renegotiation and compromise.
-
Parties may deviate from initial compromises if they foresee future changes.
-
Renegotiations often lead to further complications.
Participation Restrictions
- Participation in agreements varies depending on the subject matter, context, and circumstances.
- The number of parties involved (N) in agreements related to global public goods can be easily calculated, but in other situations determining this value can be quite complex.
- Some agreements limit or restrict participation to specific parties, while others are open to all countries.
- A treaty's usefulness can depend on whether parties are adequately represented and interested in its success.
Entry into Force and Minimum Participation
- Often, a minimum number of ratifications are required for an IEA to come into effect.
- Time taken for a treaty to come into force varies considerably, from immediate effect to decades.
Trade Restrictions
- Trade restrictions are a feature of some IEAs used to achieve objectives or deter potentially undesirable behaviours.
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.