Podcast
Questions and Answers
What is the primary advantage of having managers separate from stockholders in a firm?
What is the primary advantage of having managers separate from stockholders in a firm?
Managers are generally more skilled in running the firm, allowing for better daily operations.
Identify one significant disadvantage of the agency relationship between management and stockholders.
Identify one significant disadvantage of the agency relationship between management and stockholders.
Agency problems arise from asymmetric information, leading to conflicts of interest between shareholders and managers.
How can conflicts between stockholders and bondholders manifest in a firm's decisions?
How can conflicts between stockholders and bondholders manifest in a firm's decisions?
Conflicts can arise when managers make decisions that favor stockholders, potentially at the expense of bondholders.
Why might it be impossible for many shareholders to manage a firm together on a daily basis?
Why might it be impossible for many shareholders to manage a firm together on a daily basis?
Signup and view all the answers
What role does corporate governance play in addressing agency problems?
What role does corporate governance play in addressing agency problems?
Signup and view all the answers
How does the choice of effort impact the firm value according to the provided function?
How does the choice of effort impact the firm value according to the provided function?
Signup and view all the answers
Explain the significance of the slope $\frac{\partial V(F)}{\partial F} = -1$ in the context of firm value.
Explain the significance of the slope $\frac{\partial V(F)}{\partial F} = -1$ in the context of firm value.
Signup and view all the answers
What factors determine a manager’s utility of wealth according to the content provided?
What factors determine a manager’s utility of wealth according to the content provided?
Signup and view all the answers
How does a manager's optimal choice of activity relate to the $(V, F)$-constraint?
How does a manager's optimal choice of activity relate to the $(V, F)$-constraint?
Signup and view all the answers
Identify and explain one type of conflict that may arise between stockholders and bondholders.
Identify and explain one type of conflict that may arise between stockholders and bondholders.
Signup and view all the answers
What are agency costs and how do they impact firm value?
What are agency costs and how do they impact firm value?
Signup and view all the answers
Identify two direct costs associated with agency problems.
Identify two direct costs associated with agency problems.
Signup and view all the answers
What effect does financing through outside equity have on agency problems?
What effect does financing through outside equity have on agency problems?
Signup and view all the answers
Explain how dividend payouts can create conflicts between stockholders and bondholders.
Explain how dividend payouts can create conflicts between stockholders and bondholders.
Signup and view all the answers
What are the indirect agency costs mentioned in the context of agency problems?
What are the indirect agency costs mentioned in the context of agency problems?
Signup and view all the answers
List two main sources of conflict between stockholders and bondholders.
List two main sources of conflict between stockholders and bondholders.
Signup and view all the answers
How do monitoring costs relate to agency costs?
How do monitoring costs relate to agency costs?
Signup and view all the answers
What role does corporate governance play in managing agency costs?
What role does corporate governance play in managing agency costs?
Signup and view all the answers
How do increased dividends benefit stockholders?
How do increased dividends benefit stockholders?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the risk faced by bondholders when a firm increases its dividends?
What is the risk faced by bondholders when a firm increases its dividends?
Signup and view all the answers
Explain the concept of claim dilution as it relates to bondholders.
Explain the concept of claim dilution as it relates to bondholders.
Signup and view all the answers
What might a firm provide to enhance its equity value while posing a risk to bondholders?
What might a firm provide to enhance its equity value while posing a risk to bondholders?
Signup and view all the answers
What happens to the value of debt if a firm issues new debt with higher priority?
What happens to the value of debt if a firm issues new debt with higher priority?
Signup and view all the answers
Discuss the agency problem between stockholders and bondholders.
Discuss the agency problem between stockholders and bondholders.
Signup and view all the answers
Why is underinvestment a concern for bondholders?
Why is underinvestment a concern for bondholders?
Signup and view all the answers
What role does corporate governance play in addressing the conflicts between stockholders and bondholders?
What role does corporate governance play in addressing the conflicts between stockholders and bondholders?
Signup and view all the answers
How does an increase in the value of F affect outside investors and the firm’s value?
How does an increase in the value of F affect outside investors and the firm’s value?
Signup and view all the answers
What is a zero-sum game in the context of managers and outside investors?
What is a zero-sum game in the context of managers and outside investors?
Signup and view all the answers
What does the equation $V(F) = S + αV(F)$ signify in terms of firm ownership?
What does the equation $V(F) = S + αV(F)$ signify in terms of firm ownership?
Signup and view all the answers
What welfare loss does a manager experience in the presence of agency problems?
What welfare loss does a manager experience in the presence of agency problems?
Signup and view all the answers
How can direct agency costs be minimized in a company?
How can direct agency costs be minimized in a company?
Signup and view all the answers
What are the main sources of conflict between managers and stockholders?
What are the main sources of conflict between managers and stockholders?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the relationship between debt financing and agency costs?
What is the relationship between debt financing and agency costs?
Signup and view all the answers
Why might a manager ignore value-adding projects despite their potential?
Why might a manager ignore value-adding projects despite their potential?
Signup and view all the answers
How do differing time horizons affect managerial decision-making?
How do differing time horizons affect managerial decision-making?
Signup and view all the answers
List two ways indirect agency costs manifest in a firm's financial operations.
List two ways indirect agency costs manifest in a firm's financial operations.
Signup and view all the answers
What is the significance of internal controls in corporate governance?
What is the significance of internal controls in corporate governance?
Signup and view all the answers
What are agency costs and how are they calculated?
What are agency costs and how are they calculated?
Signup and view all the answers
What methods can be used to align managerial interests with those of shareholders?
What methods can be used to align managerial interests with those of shareholders?
Signup and view all the answers
Explain the impact of monitoring costs on agency costs.
Explain the impact of monitoring costs on agency costs.
Signup and view all the answers
Study Notes
Introduction
- Managers and stockholders, stockholders and bondholders
- Corporate governance
- Principles of Finance
- Lecture 16: Asymmetric information & Agency theory
- CWS ch. 12, section B & C
External Financing and Separation of Ownership and Management
- A firm using external financing: ownership and management are separated
- Corporate decisions made by managers (agents) on behalf of the firm's capital suppliers (principals)
- Advantages of separation:
- Managers generally more skilled to run the firm
- Impossible for many shareholders to run the firm together on a daily basis
- Ownership can change without affecting the company's operations
- Disadvantages of separation (agency problems):
- Conflicts arise from asymmetric information: Stockholders and bondholders don't have the same detailed information as management.
Conflicts Between Parties
-
Conflicts between Managers and Stockholders:
- Owners/shareholders and management have different interests and/or risk aversion
- Management may act against the stockholders' interests
-
Conflicts between Stockholders and Bondholders:
- Managers make decisions that benefit stockholders at the cost of bondholders
Conflict Between Managers and Stockholders (Main Sources)
- Choice of effort by managers: Managers may choose effort levels that benefit themselves more than the firm
- Manager's incentive to reduce overall risk: Managers have a vested interest in minimizing firm risk as it affects their future job prospects.
- Different horizons: Managers and stockholders may have different time horizons for evaluating projects and investments.
Choice of Effort by Managers (Based on Jensen & Meckling, 1976)
- X = vector of activities (managerial action/effort)
- F = manager's nonpecuniary benefits of activities
- C(X) = Present value to the firm of cost of activities
- P(X) = Present value to the firm of productive benefits of activities
- Gain to firm = V(X) = P(X) - C(X)
- Value of nonpecuniary benefits: F = V(X*) - V(X)
- X* defines the optimal choice of managerial activities for shareholders.
Firm Value and Nonpecuniary Benefits
- Firm value as a function of nonpecuniary benefits, F: V(F) = V(X*) - F
- Slope = dV(F)/dF = -1
Manager's Decision
- Manager's utility of wealth = U(V, F) depends on firm value (V) and nonpecuniary benefits (F)
- Manager's optimal choice of activity: max U(V, F)
- Manager's choice of F subject to the constraint that maximizes managerial wealth (V, F)
Comparing Two Cases: Manager Ownership
- 100% owner: No agency problem
- Partial owner: Agency problem exists
When Manager Owns 100% of the Firm
- Manager's wealth = W = V(F) = V(X*) - F
- Optimal level of activity = (V*, F*)
When Manager Is a Partial Owner (Ownership Fraction α)
- Manager sells a fraction (1-α) of the firm for S.
- Manager's wealth = W = S + αV(F) = S + α(V(X*)-F)
- Cost of consuming one additional F is (dF/dF) = -α
- Increasing F hurts outside investors, and outside investors are willing to pay S < (1 − α)V*.
Welfare Loss
- Manager incurs a welfare loss (U₁ < U₂) due to agency problems
- Agency Cost = V* - V'
Conflict Between Managers and Stockholders (Additional Points)
- Manager has incentive to reduce overall risk of firm for future job prospects.
- Risky projects increase likelihood of bad results and increase chances of losing job.
- Managers may ignore value-adding projects if they are too risky.
- Different horizons between manager and stockholders, firms with infinite life and managers with finite employment.
Conflicts Between Stockholders and Bondholders
- Sources of conflict:
- Dividend payout
- Claim dilution
- Asset substitution
- Underinvestment
Dividend Payout
- Agency problem arises when managers unexpectedly increase dividends financed by reducing assets or planned investments.
- Problem for bondholders: Increased debt risk and reduced debt value.
- Beneficial to stockholders: Increased equity value
Claim Dilution
- Agency problem arises when managers issue new debt with priority higher than existing debt.
- Existing bondholders have to share claims with new debt holders
- Costly to bondholders: Reduced value of debt of existing bondholders
Asset Substitution
- Agency problem arises when managers choose high-risk projects for low-risk projects.
- Costly to bondholders: Increased debt risk and reduced debt value
- Beneficial to stockholders: Increased equity value
Underinvestment
- Agency problem arises when managers ignore positive NPV projects that benefit bondholders but not stockholders.
- Costly to bondholders: Underinvestment causes opportunity loss
Agency Costs
- Agency costs are associated with agency problems: Loss in firm value, both direct and indirect
- Direct agency costs: minimizing agency problem costs, monitoring costs.
- Indirect agency costs: lower issuing prices, costs related to management ignoring value adding investment.
- Debt financing increases agency problems which increase agency costs.
Corporate Governance
- Processes, practices to support value creation and responsible management.
- Primarily minimize agency problems: minimize differences between manager and shareholder interests, reduce informational asymmetry.
- Examples: corporate loyalty, internal controls, compensation contracts, and principles of EU company law and OECD principles of corporate governance.
References
- CWS ch. 12, section B and C
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.
Related Documents
Description
Explore the complexities of corporate governance in finance through Lecture 16, focusing on asymmetric information and agency theory. This quiz addresses the dynamics between managers, stockholders, and bondholders, including conflicts and advantages of separating ownership and management. Test your understanding of the financial principles that govern these relationships.