Animal Disorders - W25 PDF
Document Details
Uploaded by UnparalleledDouglasFir
University of Guelph
Tags
Related
Summary
This document explores animal health, focusing on the vital role of stress. Stress is a significant factor influencing various animal disorders. The text examines the impact of climate change and various stressors on animal health, including the relationships between stress and production, product quality and animal welfare, along with the physiological responses to stress. It also delves into zoonotic diseases and other issues related to pathogens.
Full Transcript
Animal Disorders - W25 Stress and Animal Health Stress is important in animal health because it can reduce production, product quality, and welfare Animal health is of concern because consumers expect high quality, ethically raised with lower price Zoonoses are also of great concern...
Animal Disorders - W25 Stress and Animal Health Stress is important in animal health because it can reduce production, product quality, and welfare Animal health is of concern because consumers expect high quality, ethically raised with lower price Zoonoses are also of great concern - avoiding diseases contracted from animals Zoonotic disease- a disease that goes from animals to humans, reverse is the opposite ○ Quite a number of livestock pathogens that are considered to be zoonotic Since 1950s, use of antimicrobials to prevent bacterial, fungal, and parasitic infections has increased ○ Antimicrobial resistance is a growing problem in animal health because antimicrobials are less effective in animals and humans as well Genetic selection for production traits is inversely correlated with health and fertility ○ All your energy in milk production, less energy for immune system Climate change is expected to effect livestock and aquaculture species as it progresses ○ Climate is unstable, plants are stressed, mold can grow, mycotoxins can grow Physiological effects of stress are important to study for many reasons, including biomarkers of illness/stress to monitor animal health, phenotypes for selection for stress resistant animals Domestic animals are subjected to physical, chemical, biological and psychological stress Response to stress Response to stress is highly conserved series of reactions shared between mammals Stress response characterized by cardiovascular, metabolic, musculoskeletal, neuroendocrine, and immune changes as body prepared to deal Stress response is often inappropriate due to its primitive nature placed in context of modern day Triggers for stress response vary between species and individuals A stress response is revolutionary, manifests by having responses in different organs and manifests a fight, flight or freeze response dependant on the species and individual A stressor is something that disrupts homeostasis Examples of common stressors to animals include: ○ Physical: temperature, climate change shipping, air and water quality, light intensity/duration/wavelength, injury, stray voltage, UV radiation, processing, noise, restraint/confinement, surgery, predation ○ Chemical: mycotoxins, heavy metals, organochlorides, poisonous plants ○ Biological: nutrient excess/deficiency, feed restriction, parturition, negative energy balance (lactation), acidosis, inadequate rest, over-training, dehydration, infection ○ Psychological: mixing, weaning, herding, showing Stressful sensory inputs occur externally through five senses and internally through immune system recognition and changes in microbiome ○ Gut-brain link is an important part of stress response, lots of new research about this field ○ Touch, taste, smell, hearing, sight, immune system recognition, microbiome ○ Microbiome: microbes that are found on epithelial surfaces, provide us with nutrients like vitamin K and we give them an environment for them to survive and feed us, occupy space so a pathogen can’t stick ○ As we get older, we can't regulate inflammation as well ○ How our immune system regulates is what determines if we survive or not ○ Glucocorticoid = anti-inflammatory Sensory inputs are relayed by a neural, endocrine, and immune systems to brain which interprets them and puts out a stress response through conscious and unconscious processing Individuals that are hypersensitive to stressors are more susceptible to disease due to compromised immune function and other dysfunctions in stress response Desensitization to stressors can increase susceptibility to other risks due to lower/impaired processing of stressful inputs ○ Desensitization is usually an adaptive feature to be able to cope with greater stress Variation= Genetics+Environment+Gene*Environment ○ V- phenotypic output of stress, determined by internal and external factors ○ G - genetically determined response ○ E - environmentally determined response (changes acquired during lifetime) ○ G*E - interactions between genetics and environment, epigenetics Combination and interactions of stressors can decrease an animals resilience to stress Q0 - estimate of potential infection pressure of a parasitic nematode in ruminants ○ Increases with climate change due to effect of temperature on growth ○ Stressors can interact to produce a greater effect on an animal, in this case parasites + climate change Fun fact! 10x more likely to get an infection in the morning than afternoon Circadian rhythm that affects our stress pathways Cortisol levels peak at 9/10am Sympathetic and immune system affect each other BMAL1 gene regulates a whole bunch of circadian cycle genes If we disrupt clockwork genes it makes us more susceptible to infection Jetlag is really hard on your body BMAL1 can be measured in your blood Lowest levels are in the winter, highest levels are in the summer Viral infections can disrupt these genes to their advantage Mismatch of animal to its environment can cause stress and disease ○ Fainting goats - occur due to Congenital myotonia, a response to stress. A gene encoded temptation (CNCL1 gene) that effects the chloride channel protein causing the pump to stop working and chloride isn’t removed, causing a “freeze” in the muscles ○ The changing environment of Laying Hens - closed system is restricted in terms of pathogens and going back to free range could be a problem ○ A proper match of the genotype and epitype to the environment to allow for as little stress as possible - most farmed species are not well matched to intensive farming systems, most endangered species are not well matched to zoos and aquariums where they are kept Stress Physiology Are exotic species such as water buffalo, ostrich and a new aquaculture species matched to current intensive farming systems? ○ No, breeding can contribute to it but no Are endangered species that have been reintroduced into the wild from zoos/aquariums appropriately matched for optimal survival? ○ No, they have no survival instincts and would not survive in the wild, better to keep them in their best care and provide with enrichments Many ways to determine if an animal is stressed based on physiological signs such as: ○ Flock/herd mortality- by then it's probably too late ○ Weight loss - weighing animals on a regular basis could be helpful but not practical ○ Reduced fertility - another too late ○ Clinical disease - good indication, too late hard to assess ○ Behavioural changes - learned helplessness, aggression, real time monitoring of productivity ○ stress is a broad term, and not always bad Biomarkers - a measurable substance in an organism whose presence is indicative of some phenomenon such as disease, infection, or environment exposure Biomarkers of stress have certain criteria to be valid measurements ○ Must be easy to obtain from tissues blood sample if efficient waste products - possible but not easy milk - real time collecting of data ○ Minimal discomfort to retrieve ○ Sensitive to changes ○ Specific to the species and animal SCC - somatic cell count - when a cow develops a mammary infection, SCC will go up very quickly when they have acute mastitis , specific to the mammogram ○ Systemic vs local? Should be known which it is when performed SCC is localized infection ○ Repeatable Can collect again and it is still accurate and reliable ○ Potential for high throughput analysis cost efficient, lots can be processed at the same time ○ Economical to collect ○ Assay developed if we have to develop an assay, that’s gonna cost money ○ Real-time precision monitoring 2 main physiological pathways of stress Sympathetic-adrenal medulla (SAM) axis ○ activated quickly - within seconds ○ mediates/ initiates the fight flight or freeze response by causing neuroendocrine and immune function changes ○ Stimulus processed by the brain causes release of ACh into bloodstream which binds nicotinic ACh receptors in adrenal medulla ○ Medullary cells produce epinephrine which prevents degranulation of mast cells to prevent dilation of peripheral blood vessels and keep blood in vicinity of major organs ○ NOTE: remember L-tyrosine and PNMT Different stressors influence amounts of PNMT (enzyme) which determines intensity of immediate stress response due to its role in conversion of norepinephrine to epinephrine Hypothalamus-pituitary-adrenal cortex (HPA) axis ○ HPA axis is slower, hormonal response to stress that involves release of corticosteroids ○ Processing of stressful stimulus in hypothalamus causes corticotropin releasing hormone to be released into pituitary gland and binds receptor (CRH-R1) ○ Binding causes release of POMC which is converted by enzyme PC1 into ACTH There is no gene for ACTH, only one for POMC and one for PC1 ○ ACTH released from antipituitary into blood and stimulated receptor in adrenal cortex, MC2R ○ Adrenal cortex stimulated to synthesize and release glucocorticoids (GCs) Substrate of GCs is cholesterol, which undergoes conversion to pregnenolone by a cytochrome P450 enzyme into pathways for corticosterone or cortisol ○ Corticosterone is found in birds and rodents, cortisol is found in mammals and humans, important to use correct antibody in appropriate species NOTE: Enzymes to know : 3β-hydroxysteroid dehydrogenase and cytochrome P450 (has different isoforms) Chronic Stress leads to behavioural and immune changes due to effects of Gcs: ○ Mineralocorticoid receptors (MRs) MRs have a high affinity for mineralocorticoids and GCs ○ Glucocorticoid receptors (GRs) have low affinity for GCs No GCs bind GRs bind GRs bind until MRs are fully saturated due to differences in affinity Level of MR expression controls sensitivity to stress, whereas GR expression controls entire stress response In a non-stress state, cortisol-binding globulin (CBG) and albumin (ALB) sequester 95% of cortisol released from adrenal glands so only 5% of cortisol is free in blood ○ During stress, GC,CBG and ALB production occurs to buffer surge in GCs ○ Around 60% GCs bound and 40% free GC levels are also influences by levels of hydroxysteroid dehydrogenase enzymes which either activate ot inactivate GC depending on isoform of enzyme ○ 11BHSD-2 converts cortisol into inactive cortisone, whereas 11BHSD-1 activates Suprachiasmatic nuclei (SCN) - region within hypothalamus that is responsive to light and feeding cycles and influences cortisol levels according to these stimuli Splanchnic nerve - sympathetic nerve that stimulates adrenal medulla (produces catecholamines) ○ Can pick up light signals from optic chiasmata and directly trigger response i n adrenal medulla ○ Immediate neural pathway (like SAM axis) unlike neuroendocrine nature of HPA axis Cortisol concentration is typically high in morning and low at night and is regulated by level of expression of MRs which in turn is related to circadian rhythm MR expression > GR expression during normal circadian cycling due to lack of need for GCs During acute stress, GR>MR expression ○ Negative feedback triggered by binding of GCs to GRs which only occurs once MRs are fully saturated by GCs; prevents GCs from getting way too high Chronic stress - MR and GR expression both decrease as cells become desensitized to GCs ○ Higher daytime cortisol levels and lack of drop at night means overstimulation Synthesis of epinephrine Synthesized from L-tyrosine by adrenal chromaffin cells through an enzymatic pathway, which ends with the conversion of NEPI to EPI via the enzyme phenylethanolamine N-methyltransferase (PNMT) Rate of catecholamines are so physiologically influential, circulating concentrations are tightly regulated by the enzyme activity and expression levels Catecholamine bioavailability is regulated by different plasma binding proteins - only 50% is bioavailable in human serum Bioactivity is short-lived, and the ½ life is within minutes because enzymes quickly inactivate catecholamines Tissue specific expression of a and b adrenergic receptors can also affect catecholamine bioactivity in target tissues Summary of GC regulation mechanisms during stress: ○ Increase in CBG and ALB production to buffer amount of CGs ○ increase in GR expression to induce sensitivity to GCs ○ Hydroxysteroid dehydrogenase enzymes converting glucocorticoids to active or inactive forms Stressed state: surge in cortisol because of perceived danger ○ Liver secretes more cortisol but it's not enough Negative feedback loop ○ Still so low that it binds to MR - MR expressed highly in hippocampus and we think it regulates the circadian cycle ○ MR determines sensitivity, GR shuts off response ○ GR is primarily expressed in hippocampus, hypothalamus and pituitary ○ During chronic stress, cortisol concentration might not be as high, but remains elevated for longer, higher free cortisol affecting the body Biomarkers of Stress Catecholamines - can be analyzed in blood or urine as a marker of immediate stress but its short half-life and high sensitivity makes them difficult to measure ○ Eg. white coat effect - picking up an animal causes their catecholamines to skyrocket ○ Used in research to measure stress by catheterizing a blood vessel before the experiment to allow animal to adjust to stress of being handled and then can have trial with less bias ○ Essentially good for research and not much else Glucocorticoids - most widely used biomarker of long-term stress, does not degrade quickly but also isn't the fastest response to stressful stimulus ○ Sampling protocol is important because glucocorticoid levels correspond to circadian rhythm ○ Sampling over the course of a stress challenge (rather than just morning of night) helps to get a better picture of overall changes and average increases in GCs ○ GC levels decrease with age until very old age so must be factored into measurements ○ Barrows (castrated male pigs) have higher average GCs than gilts ( females before 1st litter) ○ Must specify test to whether you are measuring free ot total cortisol (protein-bound + free) Saliva only has free cortisol vs blood which has free and bound cortisol ○ There are non-adrenal sources of cortisol that may interfere but these normally contribute very little to overall GC levels ○ Typically measured with an ELISA or a radioimmunoassay for high sensitivity (for free cortisol) ACTH - can be measured in blood and is stable but since it travels from pituitary to adrenal, its in the middle of the pathway so not really an end result measure ○ ACTH levels change with circadian rhythm like GCs ○ Concentration in blood might not be reflective of amount in adrenals so may not be accurate ○ Skin and leukocytes produce ACTH in amounts that may interfere with measurement ○ Measured with an ELISA or a radioimmunoassay Chromogranin A - indirect biomarker produced by chromaffin cells of adrenal medulla (along with E and NE) and is positively correlated with NE levels so indicates sympathetic response ○ Considered indirect because it doesn’t see, to evoke any effect in stress response, just released in parallel with NE ○ Not affected by sex, age, and time of day so better in that way Blood pressure - use a blood pressure (sphygmomanometer) over brachial artery or catheterize heart and sense (but would have to sedate animal, difficult to do large scale) Heart rate - use a heart rate monitor but these are very expensive and animals usually take them off ○ Even though a heart rate is a reliable measurement of stress, logistics make it challenging ○ Considered an indirect biomarker since it isn't necessarily directly related to stress Immunoregulation & Disease Best way to avoid disease is prevention, second best is recognition and elimination of pathogen Infection is a stressor that activates immune system for recognition and elimination Immune system response must be regulated (by HPA and SAM) in order to prevent overzealous response Skin, stomach acid, mucous membranes, body temperature and gut bacteria are some examples of non-immune barriers to prevent microbial growth If these barriers are breached, innate immune response will kick in and attempt to eliminate pathogen If innate is insufficient, acquired immunity will contribute to response to clear pathogen Commensal microbes are those that live on skin and mucosa without harming health and may contribute to host defense mechanisms Commensal gut bacteria may have many important roles , such as producing vitamins B&K and VFA occupying space and resources that pathogenic microbes might otherwise occupy, and producing antimicrobial toxins against those pathogenic microbes At birth, commensal microbiome is not yet established so must be acquired by receiving from mother’s bodily fluids and other resources in order to establish tolerance to microbes later in life Tolerance to these microbes is key to survival, loss or underdevelopment of tolerance results in disease and potentially death ○ Microbes that are normally harmless become pathogenic because of a weakened/overly sensitive host Unsuccessful elimination of these pathogens due to lack of defenses, prevention, or treatment leads to disease and potentially death Neuroendocrine stress axes (SAM &HPA) are activated in response to stress and to immune system activity Depending on degree of immune response, immunity may be impaired ○ Attenuated (weakened) response increases risk of pathogenic disease and cancer ○ Excessive response leads to inflammatory disease, allergies, autoimmune disease, and cancer Host Defense Definitions: Ab = antibody, Ag = antigen, TNF = tumor necrosis factor, IL = interleukin, PAMP = pathogen associated molecular pattern, DAMP = damage associated molecular pattern, IFN = interferon Immune system is like a sixth sense that signals danger to brain to activate a stress response via SAM and HPA as well as an inflammatory response Signaling between immune system and neuroendocrine systems is bidirectional TNF, IL-1 and IL-6 are most important proinflammatory cytokines for mounting a systemic inflammatory response (across tissues) ○ Systemic inflammatory response syndrome (SIRS) - aka cytokine storm, an overly enthusiastic response from cytokine that causes tissue damage due to its strength, can cause sepsis → organ failure → death Acute-phase response - systemic response to infection caused by cytokines ○ Hypothalamus - cytokines elicit fever which induces sickness response ○ Muscle - cytokines induce protein catabolism in order to synthesize immune cells, antimicrobial proteins and to repair tissues after the pathogen is cleared Many of these are synthesized in liver, called “hepatic acute phase proteins” Increasing strength of barriers (epithelial, pH, temperature,etc) is the first strategy to improve defense Innate immunity - first line of defense following breach of barriers mounted by sentinel cells ○ Cells of innate immune response roam around body looking for “foreign” proteins ○ These cells have pattern recognition proteins (PRPs) on their surfaces such as PAMP receptors that help recognize pathogens and tumour cells ○ Distressed cells release alarmins to signal to sentinel cells that tissue damage occurred Not pathogenic but still stims innate response to cause inflammation ○ Innate immunity is a quick and necessary short term response but lacks immunological memory of acquired immunity Acquired immunity - highly specific immune response from T and B lymphocytes that depends on whether pathogen is extracellular (Ab- mediated) or intracellular (cell-mediated) NOTE: T helper cells contribute to AbMIR and CMIR depending on which cytokines are present Antibody-mediated immune response (AbMIR) - targets intracellular pathogens (I.e. viruses, certain bacteria) that causes host cell to release distress signals (DAMPs aka alarmins) ○ Antigen-presenting cells (APC) recognize and bind Ag and present it to T helper cells APC have major histocompatibility complexes (MHCs) which are surface proteins that bind Ag fragments and present All nucleated cells have MHC-I but only certain immune cells (macrophages, dendritic cells (APC), and B cells) have MHC-II which present Ag fragments to T cells MHC-I help prevent destruction of normal healthy cells (like an ID tag) ○ Once T helper cells have recognized this MHC-II + Ag complex on the APC surface, they sound the alarm by releasing cytokines (IL-4 and IL-13 which trigger AbMIR and IFN-y for CMIR) Remember that IFN-y is cytokine of interest in CMR ○ In CMIR, T helper cell signal macrophages to engulf Ag ○ In AbMIR, T helper cells activate B cells to differentiate into plasma cells and produce Ab ○ Another cell type in CMIR is cytotoxic T cells which kill cells with Ag on their MHC-I Since all cells have MHC-I, cytotoxic T cells don't require those specific APCs to recognize Ag, they can just recognize it in a normal body cell Memory B and T cells are generated during acquired immune response which facilitate long term immunity by providing immunological memory Acquired immune response takes time to mount because specific Ab need to be produced by B cells Both innate and acquired immunity cause inflammation Immunological biomarkers of stress: innate immunity related proteins and acquired immunity related ○ Cytokines (innate) - good general indicator (very sensitive to stress) but poor at indicating specific stressor, just general stress ○ Hepatic acute-phase proteins (innate) - serum amyloid A, C-reactive protein, haptoglobin, complement proteins; same pros and cons as cytokines ○ Temperature response (innate) - does not occur for everyone ○ Cytokines assessing AbMIR (Il-4, IL-13) or CMIR (IFN-y) occur in acquired response Same pros and cons as other cytokines ○ Antibodies (acquired) - indicator of past or latent infections Ab are highly specific, long-lasting indicators of disease which make them good biomarkers for infection Ab isotypes are species and tissue specific, meaning that sampling location must be considered ○ IgA present in saliva, IgG-1 present in blood and milk ○ Bovine IgG1 in blood is indicative of an AbMIR whereas IgG2 in blood indicates a CMIR Due to these different specific responses, we can learn more about the Ag in question Should we measure basal or inducible Ab? ○ AbMIR may be induced by a novel Ag or vaccine to assess capacity to mount a response Are we measuring total Ab or just specific Ab? Depends on what what you wanna know Sampling time is also of importance: ○ Level of Ab production depends on how many times you've had the Ag in your system ○ First infection has a slower, lesser production whereas second and third are faster and more productive; basal and inducible levels of production do not change over time Immune response to stress is influenced by environmental factors which can be somewhat controlled Immune efficacy can be evaluated by an immune challenge ○ Immune challenge in sheep - if you were to develop a stress-resistant phenotype in an animal, what kind of stressor would you use? ○ Used a bacterial endotoxin injected into sheep which elicited a cortisol response ○ Some sheep did not respond at all, which begs the question, how are they different? ○ Is it that they can process toxins better, or they are less responsive in terms of cortisol release? ○ Bacterial endotoxin is of interest because heat stress causes gut to become purpose and release bacterial endotoxins into blood ○ Injected bacterial endotoxin should theoretically cause same response as heat stress but due to individual differences, each animal responds differently ○ Highly stressed animals responded similarly to different stressors (eg. shipping challenge) so its more about individuals than stressor itself Acute stress has an immunostimulatory effect whereas chronic stress nas an immunosuppressive effect due to change in GC receptor sensitivity and density ○ Glucocorticoids have immunosuppressive and immunostimulatory effects, depending on dosage and location (local or systemic) E.g. dexamethasone is a steroid cream that treats autoimmune skin conditions by suppressing local immune inflammatory response Bovine Johne’s Diseases - early diagnosis of JD is difficult because Ab levels don’t show up when disease is subclinical ○ Disease may be subclinical until 3rd stage of infection ○ Ab only show up when disease becomes clinical, and at that point it can be difficult to stop progress of disease ○ IFN-y is the best biomarker for stages 1-3d of disease but it drops after 3rd stage, therefore a panel of biomarkers is better In case of chronic stress, immune challenge can be conducted to assess animals resilience to stress and physiological responses ○ SAM, HPA, AbMIR and CMIR are monitored over time to assess stress resistance, habituation, recovery, and sensitization to stress Stress challenges can be conducted with a variety of stressors ○ Physiological - isolation, regrouping ○ Physical - heat, cold, transport, noise, electricity, restraint ○ Chemical - toxins or bacterial toxins (MAMPs-LPS), pro-inflammatory cytokines, neuropeptides (corticotropin releasing factor, arginine vasopressin, ACTH) ○ Biological - acidosis, sleep deprivation, intense exercise, pathogen challenge Microbial stressors require a panel of biomarkers to assess innate and acquired immune responses Genetics of Stress Genetics variants (such as SNPs) predetermine gene activity and are permanent and inherited Epigenetic variants are established by environmental factors during mitosis and provide adaptive mechanism for phenotypic change in the individual ○ May be inherited so can contribute to phenotypic variation within populations Genetics contributes to variation in sensory input, stress perception and subsequent stress response ○ Blood cortisol level phenotype has moderate to high heritability and is a food biomarker of stress, hence why it may be selected for/against in trials Measuring epigenetic changes helps to understand long-term effects of stress because the changes are acquired throughout an animals lifetime Epigenetic changes include methylation (adding -Ch3) of cytosine and modification of histones ○ Me of cytosine - typically silences genes ○ Modification of histones - histone tail is subject to environmental changes and methylation, acetylation, or phosphorylation of these tails can either prevent or promote DNA transcription These modifications are enzyme regulated and effect which genes are expressed MicroRNA (miRNA) - non-coding RNA that binds to mRNA to negatively regulate its expression All of these modifications influence expression of neuropeptides and therefore have an effect on neuroendocrine stress responses (SAM, HPA) Stress can have a negative effect om CMIR due to effect of glucocorticoids on epigenetics GCs can pause de-acetylation of histones which reduces ability of transcription factors to bind to promoter region of IFN-y (important signal molecule for CMIR) and express it CMIR is very suppressed by Cushing’s disease due to overproduction of GC ○ Cushings disease is typically caused by cancer of pituitary gland ○ In humans, polymorphisms in ubiquitin-specific protease 8 (USP8) gene are a risk factor for cushing's disease due to indirect contribution too ACTH production Addisons disease - autoimmune disease that targets and destroys outer 2 layers of adrenal cortex and causes underproduction of glucocorticoids (opposite of cushings) and aldosterone ○ ACTH is produced but not absorbed due to destruction of adrenal tissues by immune system, therefore there is free ACTH circulating in blood ○ Melanocyte-stimulating hormones and ACTH share the same precursor molecule so free ACTH into MSH and melanin production increases Results in hyperpigmentation, common diagnostic symptom of Addisons Does this symptom still have clinical significance for those with darker skin? If a animal is not able to recover from stress, become habituated to stressor, r if it becomes overly sensitive to stressor due to epigenetic modifications, risk of disease is increased Neuroendocrine immune system is especially sensitive to epigenetic modifications during early development which is why microbiome is so important (affects immunological tolerance) Single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) in cytochrome p450 (CYP) enzymes may have an effect on steroidogenesis of glucocorticoids (think back to steroidogenesis pathway seen last week) Unit 3 - Antimicrobials Antimicrobial usage in animal production has become an accepted practice today to minimize - Commensal might share or swap with AMR - Group that discovered e coli plasmid(small DNA molecule that replicates on its own and can travel across species) in pork, carrying a gene - Antibiotic comes from a mold to control its competition - Examples of misuse: - Wrong antimicrobial - High dose and refuse to follow withdrawal time increases drug residues - Use of banned AMR - Use of poor quality or expired AMR - Shorten recommended treatment period - Poorly treated animal waste - Administered to prevent disease - Unnecessary treatment of humans - Conceptual drivers for AMR - listen to voice - AMR can be found in animal bedding, dust particles, agricultural runoff