Based on your reading and Pirates of the Senate, in at least 150 words, explain why you think the filibuster should be retained or eliminated. Consider the history of the filibuste... Based on your reading and Pirates of the Senate, in at least 150 words, explain why you think the filibuster should be retained or eliminated. Consider the history of the filibuster and why it’s been evoked. Comment on at least one other student's post.
Understand the Problem
The question is asking for a personal opinion on the filibuster's retention or elimination, supported by its historical context and the reasons for its use. The response should reflect an understanding of the filibuster's implications in legislative processes and possibly engage with peer opinions. The requirement is to write a 150-word explanation.
Answer
The filibuster should be eliminated due to its history of obstructing civil rights and promoting gridlock.
The filibuster should be eliminated because it has historically been used to obstruct civil rights legislation and maintains partisan gridlock. Reducing its power encourages cooperation and progress on critical issues. However, its retention as a tool for minority voices to be heard in pivotal debates is also compelling.
Answer for screen readers
The filibuster should be eliminated because it has historically been used to obstruct civil rights legislation and maintains partisan gridlock. Reducing its power encourages cooperation and progress on critical issues. However, its retention as a tool for minority voices to be heard in pivotal debates is also compelling.
More Information
The filibuster is often criticized for allowing a minority of senators to block legislation favored by the majority, especially in cases such as civil rights reforms. On the other hand, its defenders argue it ensures minority opinions are considered.
Tips
A common mistake is overlooking the dual nature of the filibuster, which serves both as a protective measure for minority opinions and a tool for obstruction.
Sources
- The Filibuster Explained | Brennan Center for Justice - brennancenter.org
- Filibuster | Pros, Cons, Debate, Arguments, U.S. Senate ... - Britannica - britannica.com
- About Filibusters and Cloture | Historical Overview - U.S. Senate - senate.gov
AI-generated content may contain errors. Please verify critical information
