Podcast
Questions and Answers
What urgent question for urban scholars is posed by the intensifying climate-related disasters in the United States?
What urgent question for urban scholars is posed by the intensifying climate-related disasters in the United States?
how homeowners, mortgage lenders, federal institutions/regulators, and investors will encounter and manage climate risk
What are some of the illustrative moments of U.S. mortgage finance highlighted in the paper?
What are some of the illustrative moments of U.S. mortgage finance highlighted in the paper?
Climate change may destabilize the U.S. housing market and the broader financial system.
Climate change may destabilize the U.S. housing market and the broader financial system.
True
What does Françoise feel trapped between in the South Florida housing market under climate change?
What does Françoise feel trapped between in the South Florida housing market under climate change?
Signup and view all the answers
Why does Françoise feel burdened by the increasing property values in Liberty City, Miami?
Why does Françoise feel burdened by the increasing property values in Liberty City, Miami?
Signup and view all the answers
Why does Françoise feel selling the house and moving somewhere more affordable is not a viable solution for her?
Why does Françoise feel selling the house and moving somewhere more affordable is not a viable solution for her?
Signup and view all the answers
What is one of the concerns highlighted in Françoise's story?
What is one of the concerns highlighted in Françoise's story?
Signup and view all the answers
Floodplains and climate change impacts may result in drastic changes in insurance premiums and coverage.
Floodplains and climate change impacts may result in drastic changes in insurance premiums and coverage.
Signup and view all the answers
What was the standard duration of a mortgage loan first authorized by Congress in 1948?
What was the standard duration of a mortgage loan first authorized by Congress in 1948?
Signup and view all the answers
Mortgage lenders are directly exposed to __________ risks in both acute and chronic terms.
Mortgage lenders are directly exposed to __________ risks in both acute and chronic terms.
Signup and view all the answers
What was the key risk targeted in the reforms undertaken by GSEs during the financial crisis?
What was the key risk targeted in the reforms undertaken by GSEs during the financial crisis?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the purpose of Credit Risk Transfer (CRT) in the mortgage system?
What is the purpose of Credit Risk Transfer (CRT) in the mortgage system?
Signup and view all the answers
Credit Risk Transfers (CRTs) involve the sale of underlying loans to investors.
Credit Risk Transfers (CRTs) involve the sale of underlying loans to investors.
Signup and view all the answers
With Credit Risk Transfers (CRTs), GSEs 'sell' much of the risk of mortgage defaults to investors via __________ markets.
With Credit Risk Transfers (CRTs), GSEs 'sell' much of the risk of mortgage defaults to investors via __________ markets.
Signup and view all the answers
What form of government assistance, including debt forbearance, have mortgage lenders relied on after disasters?
What form of government assistance, including debt forbearance, have mortgage lenders relied on after disasters?
Signup and view all the answers
According to Kaul and Goodman, when does debt forbearance work best?
According to Kaul and Goodman, when does debt forbearance work best?
Signup and view all the answers
Mortgage GSEs purchase and securitize mortgages made by private lenders.
Mortgage GSEs purchase and securitize mortgages made by private lenders.
Signup and view all the answers
In the aftermath of natural disasters, lenders are more likely to approve mortgages that can be securitized, thereby transferring __________ risk.
In the aftermath of natural disasters, lenders are more likely to approve mortgages that can be securitized, thereby transferring __________ risk.
Signup and view all the answers
What are some key questions for climate justice as mentioned in the text?
What are some key questions for climate justice as mentioned in the text?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the main concern about the emerging risk management efforts discussed in the text?
What is the main concern about the emerging risk management efforts discussed in the text?
Signup and view all the answers
Mainstream regulators may not perceive climate risks accurately according to the text.
Mainstream regulators may not perceive climate risks accurately according to the text.
Signup and view all the answers
Financial strategies often depend on insurance-based risk transfer tools rather than a more profound rethinking of today’s urban infrastructures and planning norms, leading to the primacy of _______ value as the priority object of risk mitigation.
Financial strategies often depend on insurance-based risk transfer tools rather than a more profound rethinking of today’s urban infrastructures and planning norms, leading to the primacy of _______ value as the priority object of risk mitigation.
Signup and view all the answers
Which journal published the article 'The challenges facing public housing authorities in a brave new world' by Quercia & Galster in 1997?
Which journal published the article 'The challenges facing public housing authorities in a brave new world' by Quercia & Galster in 1997?
Signup and view all the answers
The article 'Hurricane Harvey: Issues for urban development' was included in the book 'U.S. emergency management in the 21st century' edited by Rubin & Cutter.
The article 'Hurricane Harvey: Issues for urban development' was included in the book 'U.S. emergency management in the 21st century' edited by Rubin & Cutter.
Signup and view all the answers
Who wrote the book 'American bonds' in 2019?
Who wrote the book 'American bonds' in 2019?
Signup and view all the answers
The article 'Roadmap towards justice in urban climate adaptation research' was published in the journal Nature Climate Change, volume ______, issue 2, from pages 131 to 137.
The article 'Roadmap towards justice in urban climate adaptation research' was published in the journal Nature Climate Change, volume ______, issue 2, from pages 131 to 137.
Signup and view all the answers
Who led the analysis and writing of the 'Moment II' section?
Who led the analysis and writing of the 'Moment II' section?
Signup and view all the answers
Who contributed to the literature review and co-led analysis and writing of the 'Moment III' section?
Who contributed to the literature review and co-led analysis and writing of the 'Moment III' section?
Signup and view all the answers
Who supported the analysis and writing of the 'Moment IV' section and co-led figure design?
Who supported the analysis and writing of the 'Moment IV' section and co-led figure design?
Signup and view all the answers
Study Notes
Interrupted Rhythms and Uncertain Futures: Mortgage Finance and Climate Breakdown
Climate Change Impacts on US Housing Market
- Intensifying climate-related disasters are striking cities across the US, provoking concern for the stability of the US housing market and broader financial system.
- Research estimates that US residential properties exposed to worsened flood risk are overvalued by $121-237 billion.
- Climate change could cause a new mortgage default crisis.
The 30-Year Mortgage and Its Uncertain Future
- For 75 years, working households in the US have been encouraged to pursue homeownership as a means of achieving middle-class status and securing personal livelihoods.
- The 30-year mortgage has been a key innovation, but experts are now warning that it may soon become a thing of the past due to long- and medium-term climate risks.
Racial Exclusion and Financial Instability
- The project of homeownership has been racially exclusionary and frequently disappointed in practice.
- Strains were acutely exposed a decade ago in the Global Financial Crisis.
- The financial system was stabilized in a way that worsened risks for many households.
Climate Risks and Mortgage Finance
- Climate risks are increasingly being experienced and governed at multiple illustrative moments of US mortgage finance.
- The paper takes a multi-scalar view, exploring how climate risks are being tracked and governed at different moments, including:
- Working households at the front line of urban climate impacts.
- Mortgage professionals brokering loans to these households.
- Government-sponsored enterprises (GSEs) negotiating incoming federal climate risk disclosure requirements.
- Capital markets off-taking GSE risks through financial derivatives like credit risk transfers.
Gaps and Tensions in Climate Risk Governance
- Gaps and tensions exist between household risks and financial system-preserving responses.
- New dangers of "climate redlining" are emerging.
- The financial system may stabilise in a way that worsens risks for many households.
Following U.S. Mortgage Finance
- The paper follows U.S. mortgage finance through four illustrative moments of emerging climate risk impact and intervention.
- These moments are grounded in extensive fieldwork, interviews, and/or document analysis.
Climate Change and Housing Reform
- The paper offers new insights into longstanding concerns for urban studies scholars, particularly issues of displacement and housing reform.
- These concerns are increasingly inflected by consideration of climate change.### Climate Disclosure Regimes and Financial Markets
- Christophers (2017) argues that emerging climate disclosure regimes fail to discard neoliberal notions of market discipline and rationality, which have led to the progressive deregulation of financial markets since the 1970s.
- These regimes continue to equate disclosing climate risks with actually lowering them, and keep private financial actors and markets in the driver's seat of governance efforts.
The Financial "Following" Method
- The financial "following" method, used by scholars such as Aalbers (2009), Crump et al. (2008), and Wyly et al. (2009), exposes important distributional and justice concerns in the subprime crisis.
- This method explores the multi-scalar mortgage value chains and breakdowns that generated the subprime collapse.
Climate Change and Housing Markets
- Experts estimate that in the coming decades, approximately half a million homes in the United States will be on land that floods once a year.
- This may result in drastic changes in insurance premiums and coverage, as well as property values, with the state of Florida alone expected to see between $10 billion to $30 billion in property devaluations linked to climate change by 2030.
Mortgage Professionals and Climate Risk
- Mortgage professionals, including loan officers, mortgage underwriters, and risk modelers, play a key role in shaping what households know about climate-related risks before they are "locked in" via long-term mortgage contracts.
- Mortgage lenders are directly exposed to climate risks in both acute and chronic terms, and may transfer these risks to other market stakeholders.
Mortgage GSEs under Federal Climate Risk Disclosure
- The 2021 Executive Order on Climate-Related Financial Risk compelled a government-wide accounting of climate exposures, including for Mortgage GSEs like Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.
- These institutions have crucially supported—and assumed much of the systemic risk of—the U.S. residential mortgage system, and will be affected by climate risk disclosure pushes.
Four Moments of Climate-Financial Risk in U.S. Housing
- Moment I: Frontline households, such as Françoise's, face daunting futures due to climate-related risks and rising insurance premiums.
- Moment II: Mortgage professionals, including lenders, brokers, and underwriters, are increasingly aware of climate-related risks, but may transfer these risks to other market stakeholders.
- Moment III: Mortgage GSEs under federal climate risk disclosure, with institutions like Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, will be affected by climate risk disclosure pushes.
- Moment IV: (Not explicitly mentioned, but implied) The need for constructive ways to tie these disparate dynamics together without prompting substantial disruptions to housing provision or financial markets.### Climate Change and Mortgage Lending
- In May 2021, the Biden administration issued an executive order to assess climate-related financial risks to the federal government and the US financial system.
- The order may significantly affect US residential mortgage lending, particularly for government-sponsored enterprises (GSEs) like Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.
GSEs and Mortgage Securities
- GSEs purchase a significant share of mortgages made by private lenders and securitize them, aggregating pools of individual mortgages with a common risk profile and selling them to capital markets.
- This practice allows mortgage lenders to recycle their capital into new loans and transfers much of the risk to GSEs and other investors.
- In the 2000s, private investment banks took up this established GSE practice, using it to channel more capital into high-risk, high-return predatory home lending, creating a boom in "private-label" mortgage-backed securities (MBSs).
Climate Risk and Mortgage Lending
- Climate change poses significant risks to the mortgage system, and regulators are taking steps to address this risk.
- The Federal Reserve has launched a pilot climate scenario analysis to evaluate the aggregate credit risk relating to residential and commercial real estate.
- The Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) has published draft principles for managing climate-related financial risks across banking activities, including mortgage lending.
- These moves will increase the regulatory burden on mortgage lending, and may lead to changes in lending practices, such as incorporating climate risk into underwriting and risk management.
Credit Risk Transfer (CRT)
- CRT is a financial derivative product that allows GSEs to sell credit risk to investors, aiming to reduce their own exposure to mortgage defaults.
- CRTs are used to transfer credit risk from GSEs to private market investors, which can help to reduce systemic financial risk.
- Advocates argue that CRTs can help to mitigate climate risk by spreading risk to a more geographically and institutionally diverse network of investors.
Criticisms of CRT
- Critics argue that CRTs may not be effective in managing climate risk, and may even exacerbate existing inequalities and injustices.
- CRTs may create an additional ethical concern, as they allow speculative financial investors to bet on—and against—communities and cities' futures under climate change.
Conclusion
- The management of climate risk in mortgage lending raises crucial questions about justice, equity, and the prioritization of interests.
- As new frontiers of financial practice emerge in relation to climate risk, it is essential to examine whose interests are being privileged and what underlying housing risks are being managed.
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.
Description
This quiz covers the relationship between mortgage finance and climate change, exploring the spatio-temporal impacts of climate breakdown. It discusses the uncertain futures and interrupted rhythms of urban affairs. Based on a research article by Sarah Knuth and co-authors.
