27Lesson Thirteen: Al-Mustadrakaat

Study Notes

Al-Mustadrakaat Overview

Al-Mustadrakaat consists of Ahaadith that meet the authenticity criteria of the Saheehayn but were not included in them.
Includes Ahaadith deemed authentic by the author, despite not meeting Saheehayn conditions.

Organization of Ahaadith

Ahaadith are typically organized according to the chapters of Islamic jurisprudence.

Pioneer Compiler

Ad-Daaraqutni is recognized as the first to compile such Ahaadith in his work titled "al-Ilzaamaat."

Al-Mustadrak 'ala as-Saheehayn

Authored by Muhammad ibn 'Abdillah an-Naysaboori, known as al-Haakim.
Focuses on authentic Ahaadith that satisfy the conditions of the Saheehayn but were omitted from them.

Purpose of Compilation

Compiled in response to requests for Ahaadith acceptable by al-Bukhari and Muslim.
Aims to defend Sunni beliefs and refute claims regarding the scarcity of authentic Ahaadith.

Inclusion Criteria

Al-Haakim aimed to include Hadith that would be recognized as evidence by the Shaykhayn (Al-Bukhari and Muslim).

Methodology for Arrangement

Ahaadith are organized thematically into chapters and sub-chapters.

Ahaadith Authenticity

Contains classifications such as Sahih, Hassan, Da'eef, and some Mawdoo' (fabricated).
Houses a total of 9029 Ahaadith, with several not found in other collections.

Criticism of Al-Mustadrak

Criticized for his leniency in deeming Ahaadith authentic according to Saheehayn standards.
Faced scrutiny for incorrectly stating the absence of some Ahaadith in the Saheehayn.
Some scholars argue that al-Haakim intended to revise his work but passed away before completion.

Description

Explore the intricacies of Al-Mustadrakaat, which includes Ahaadith considered authentic but omitted from the Saheehayn. This lesson focuses on the organization of Ahaadith and highlights Ad-Daaraqutni's contributions. Gain a deeper understanding of the criteria for authenticity in Ahaadith.