Podcast
Questions and Answers
Who should be employed to prosecute if the Government of India is interested in a criminal case?
Who should be employed to prosecute if the Government of India is interested in a criminal case?
- A local council representative appointed by the accused
- The Solicitor of the State Government where the accused is prosecuted (correct)
- Any private lawyer chosen by the accused
- An external counsel from a different state
What must happen before a prosecution is instituted according to the guidelines?
What must happen before a prosecution is instituted according to the guidelines?
- A public announcement must be made
- The accused must be consulted
- The Railway Ministry must approve the case
- Legal advice must be obtained in writing (correct)
In the event of a railway case going to the Supreme Court, who is responsible for the administration?
In the event of a railway case going to the Supreme Court, who is responsible for the administration?
- The Government Agent from the Central Agency Section, Ministry of Law (correct)
- The Indian Railways' internal legal team
- The State Government's legal department
- The Railway Minister personally handles it
What is required for advocates or legal practitioners engaged by the Government of India regarding settlements?
What is required for advocates or legal practitioners engaged by the Government of India regarding settlements?
Under what circumstances can a suit be settled out of court without consulting the Government?
Under what circumstances can a suit be settled out of court without consulting the Government?
What type of legal proceedings may involve a railway servant executing their official duty?
What type of legal proceedings may involve a railway servant executing their official duty?
In which situation will claims for reimbursement of legal expenses not be admissible?
In which situation will claims for reimbursement of legal expenses not be admissible?
Which body must be consulted regarding claims for costs incurred in type (i) legal proceedings?
Which body must be consulted regarding claims for costs incurred in type (i) legal proceedings?
Which type of case does NOT require consultation with the Union Public Service Commission?
Which type of case does NOT require consultation with the Union Public Service Commission?
How many counsel's fees are normally considered for reimbursement?
How many counsel's fees are normally considered for reimbursement?
What kind of reimbursement is excluded from the fees considered for legal expenses?
What kind of reimbursement is excluded from the fees considered for legal expenses?
Which type of cases does not lead to reimbursement by the Railway Board?
Which type of cases does not lead to reimbursement by the Railway Board?
Under what condition can a railway servant receive assistance when instituting proceedings Suo-Moto?
Under what condition can a railway servant receive assistance when instituting proceedings Suo-Moto?
What is the status of assistance if a railway servant is sued by another railway servant?
What is the status of assistance if a railway servant is sued by another railway servant?
What is the government's position on reimbursement for legal expenses in cases not connected with official duties?
What is the government's position on reimbursement for legal expenses in cases not connected with official duties?
Which of the following conditions allows the government to decide on the defense of a railway servant?
Which of the following conditions allows the government to decide on the defense of a railway servant?
In what situation can government assistance be denied for a railway servant's legal defense?
In what situation can government assistance be denied for a railway servant's legal defense?
What does the term 'private party' imply in the context of railway servants?
What does the term 'private party' imply in the context of railway servants?
What determines whether the defense should be undertaken at government's expense?
What determines whether the defense should be undertaken at government's expense?
Which of the following situations does NOT entitle a railway servant to reimbursement of legal expenses?
Which of the following situations does NOT entitle a railway servant to reimbursement of legal expenses?
What happens if a railway servant has acted improperly?
What happens if a railway servant has acted improperly?
What is the purpose of the Surety Bond as described in the document?
What is the purpose of the Surety Bond as described in the document?
Who is referred to as 'the Surety' in the Surety Bond?
Who is referred to as 'the Surety' in the Surety Bond?
What should be included in the bond according to the instructions provided?
What should be included in the bond according to the instructions provided?
Which of the following is NOT mentioned as a requirement in the document?
Which of the following is NOT mentioned as a requirement in the document?
What amount is referenced in the Surety Bond's main text?
What amount is referenced in the Surety Bond's main text?
What does 'firmly bound' indicate in the context of the Surety Bond?
What does 'firmly bound' indicate in the context of the Surety Bond?
What is the role of the 'attorney and client' as mentioned in the Surety Bond?
What is the role of the 'attorney and client' as mentioned in the Surety Bond?
What is the date format used in the Surety Bond for the signature?
What is the date format used in the Surety Bond for the signature?
What factors determine the reasonableness of fees for a lawyer?
What factors determine the reasonableness of fees for a lawyer?
What happens if the fees per case are considered prima-facie high?
What happens if the fees per case are considered prima-facie high?
Under what condition can payment up to the limits laid down by the High Court be regarded as reasonable?
Under what condition can payment up to the limits laid down by the High Court be regarded as reasonable?
What is required if a lawyer has multiple cases on the same day and each fee is within prescribed limits?
What is required if a lawyer has multiple cases on the same day and each fee is within prescribed limits?
What agreement does an individual make when taking an advance of money from the Government?
What agreement does an individual make when taking an advance of money from the Government?
What consequence occurs if a government employee ceases service and fails to repay the advance?
What consequence occurs if a government employee ceases service and fails to repay the advance?
What is the due date for the repayment after an advance is taken?
What is the due date for the repayment after an advance is taken?
What happens if the lawyer's total fees exceed the prescribed limits across multiple cases?
What happens if the lawyer's total fees exceed the prescribed limits across multiple cases?
What can the government do if the repayment is not made after six months of due date?
What can the government do if the repayment is not made after six months of due date?
Who has the authority to judge whether the proposed lawyer's fees are considered high?
Who has the authority to judge whether the proposed lawyer's fees are considered high?
What must occur before any prosecution involving the Government of India can be initiated?
What must occur before any prosecution involving the Government of India can be initiated?
What is the role of the Government Agent in cases concerning railway administration going to the Supreme Court?
What is the role of the Government Agent in cases concerning railway administration going to the Supreme Court?
Under what conditions can a lawyer settled out of court without prior government sanction?
Under what conditions can a lawyer settled out of court without prior government sanction?
What is the primary rule regarding the prosecution or withdrawal of any prosecution by the Government of India?
What is the primary rule regarding the prosecution or withdrawal of any prosecution by the Government of India?
What governs the engagement of advocates on behalf of the Government of India in legal matters?
What governs the engagement of advocates on behalf of the Government of India in legal matters?
What may happen if a railway servant fails to observe the prescribed procedure for their defense?
What may happen if a railway servant fails to observe the prescribed procedure for their defense?
Under which condition can a railway servant be sued for damages regarding their official duties?
Under which condition can a railway servant be sued for damages regarding their official duties?
What must a railway servant plead if they are being sued for wages arising from their official duties?
What must a railway servant plead if they are being sued for wages arising from their official duties?
What is the consequence for a railway servant who fails to defend a suit initiated against them appropriately?
What is the consequence for a railway servant who fails to defend a suit initiated against them appropriately?
In the context of legal procedures, what is a railway servant unable to claim as a defense against being sued for wrongs?
In the context of legal procedures, what is a railway servant unable to claim as a defense against being sued for wrongs?
What is the primary responsibility of a railway servant concerning legal suits brought against them in connection with their official duties?
What is the primary responsibility of a railway servant concerning legal suits brought against them in connection with their official duties?
What type of situation will a railway servant face where the government is not considered the party interested in the litigation?
What type of situation will a railway servant face where the government is not considered the party interested in the litigation?
Under what condition will the government arrange for the defense of a railway servant?
Under what condition will the government arrange for the defense of a railway servant?
Which document must a railway servant submit when the government agrees to undertake their defense?
Which document must a railway servant submit when the government agrees to undertake their defense?
What might happen if a railway servant conducts their own defense in legal proceedings?
What might happen if a railway servant conducts their own defense in legal proceedings?
What is required of a railway servant if the government agrees to their defense?
What is required of a railway servant if the government agrees to their defense?
In which standard scenario will the government not provide legal assistance to a railway servant?
In which standard scenario will the government not provide legal assistance to a railway servant?
What must happen before the government decides to undertake a common defense for a railway servant?
What must happen before the government decides to undertake a common defense for a railway servant?
What responsibilities does a railway servant have if the government defends them?
What responsibilities does a railway servant have if the government defends them?
What legal principle allows the government to arrange for a railway servant's defense?
What legal principle allows the government to arrange for a railway servant's defense?
What may be considered if a railway servant proposes to conduct their own defense?
What may be considered if a railway servant proposes to conduct their own defense?
Under what circumstances may a railway servant receive assistance from the government when instituting proceedings Suo-Moto?
Under what circumstances may a railway servant receive assistance from the government when instituting proceedings Suo-Moto?
What is the government's stance regarding reimbursement for a railway servant's legal expenses in cases not connected to their official duties?
What is the government's stance regarding reimbursement for a railway servant's legal expenses in cases not connected to their official duties?
What criteria must be met for a railway servant to be defended by the government in a case filed by another railway servant?
What criteria must be met for a railway servant to be defended by the government in a case filed by another railway servant?
What is expected of a railway servant if there is evidence indicating improper conduct on their part during legal proceedings?
What is expected of a railway servant if there is evidence indicating improper conduct on their part during legal proceedings?
In which scenario might the railway servant be deemed a 'private party' in legal proceedings?
In which scenario might the railway servant be deemed a 'private party' in legal proceedings?
Which factor is influential in determining if the government should bear the expense of a railway servant's legal defense?
Which factor is influential in determining if the government should bear the expense of a railway servant's legal defense?
Which types of cases do NOT allow for government assistance or reimbursement for railway servants?
Which types of cases do NOT allow for government assistance or reimbursement for railway servants?
What is the implication for a railway servant who joins another suit against the government regarding conditions of service?
What is the implication for a railway servant who joins another suit against the government regarding conditions of service?
What occurs if the legal expenses incurred by a railway servant ultimately exceed what the government considers reasonable?
What occurs if the legal expenses incurred by a railway servant ultimately exceed what the government considers reasonable?
What is the primary purpose of the Surety Bond as stated in the document?
What is the primary purpose of the Surety Bond as stated in the document?
Who is identified as 'the Surety' in the context of the Surety Bond?
Who is identified as 'the Surety' in the context of the Surety Bond?
What should be completed in the Surety Bond regarding the amount?
What should be completed in the Surety Bond regarding the amount?
What does the statement about 'heirs, executors, administrators and representatives' signify in the Surety Bond?
What does the statement about 'heirs, executors, administrators and representatives' signify in the Surety Bond?
What is the significance of the term 'bound' in the context of the Surety Bond?
What is the significance of the term 'bound' in the context of the Surety Bond?
In the surety bond, what is required from the government servant's witness?
In the surety bond, what is required from the government servant's witness?
What critical piece of information needs to be stated as the last detail in the Surety Bond?
What critical piece of information needs to be stated as the last detail in the Surety Bond?
What does the phrase 'with all costs between attorney and client' in the Surety Bond refer to?
What does the phrase 'with all costs between attorney and client' in the Surety Bond refer to?
What does the instruction about 'filling the name and particulars of the Government servant' imply in the process?
What does the instruction about 'filling the name and particulars of the Government servant' imply in the process?
What is indicated by the phrase 'which expression shall include his successors and assignees' in the Surety Bond?
What is indicated by the phrase 'which expression shall include his successors and assignees' in the Surety Bond?
Flashcards
Railway servant legal proceedings
Railway servant legal proceedings
Legal actions against railway employees, categorized by whether the actions were related to official duty, by virtue of their position, or neither.
Official duty legal cases
Official duty legal cases
Legal proceedings relating to actions performed during a railway employee's official duties
Position-related legal cases
Position-related legal cases
Legal cases stemming from an employee's official position, even if separate from duties.
Non-duty legal cases
Non-duty legal cases
Signup and view all the flashcards
Reimbursement of legal expenses
Reimbursement of legal expenses
Signup and view all the flashcards
No reimbursement for private matters
No reimbursement for private matters
Signup and view all the flashcards
Consultation on official duty cases
Consultation on official duty cases
Signup and view all the flashcards
Suo-Moto Proceedings
Suo-Moto Proceedings
Signup and view all the flashcards
Government Assistance for Official Conduct
Government Assistance for Official Conduct
Signup and view all the flashcards
Defending Against Another Railway Servant
Defending Against Another Railway Servant
Signup and view all the flashcards
Exclusions to Legal Assistance
Exclusions to Legal Assistance
Signup and view all the flashcards
Non-Official Matters
Non-Official Matters
Signup and view all the flashcards
Government Discretion on Defense
Government Discretion on Defense
Signup and view all the flashcards
Prima Facie Evidence of Misconduct
Prima Facie Evidence of Misconduct
Signup and view all the flashcards
Government's Role: Just and Proper
Government's Role: Just and Proper
Signup and view all the flashcards
Reasonableness of Legal Fees
Reasonableness of Legal Fees
Signup and view all the flashcards
Railway Administration's Role
Railway Administration's Role
Signup and view all the flashcards
Prima Facie High Fees
Prima Facie High Fees
Signup and view all the flashcards
High Court Fee Scale
High Court Fee Scale
Signup and view all the flashcards
Multiple Cases on One Day
Multiple Cases on One Day
Signup and view all the flashcards
Advance Payment to Government
Advance Payment to Government
Signup and view all the flashcards
Repayment Obligation
Repayment Obligation
Signup and view all the flashcards
Full Repayment after 6 Months
Full Repayment after 6 Months
Signup and view all the flashcards
Government's Right to Recovery
Government's Right to Recovery
Signup and view all the flashcards
Applicable Law
Applicable Law
Signup and view all the flashcards
Surety Bond
Surety Bond
Signup and view all the flashcards
Government Servant
Government Servant
Signup and view all the flashcards
President of India
President of India
Signup and view all the flashcards
Article 299 of the Constitution
Article 299 of the Constitution
Signup and view all the flashcards
Obligations of Government Servants
Obligations of Government Servants
Signup and view all the flashcards
Cost of Legal Defense
Cost of Legal Defense
Signup and view all the flashcards
Government Assistance in Legal Matters
Government Assistance in Legal Matters
Signup and view all the flashcards
Surety's Financial Responsibility
Surety's Financial Responsibility
Signup and view all the flashcards
Government Approval
Government Approval
Signup and view all the flashcards
Legal Advice for Prosecution
Legal Advice for Prosecution
Signup and view all the flashcards
Government's Role in Legal Cases
Government's Role in Legal Cases
Signup and view all the flashcards
Solicitor's Responsibility in Criminal Cases
Solicitor's Responsibility in Criminal Cases
Signup and view all the flashcards
Railway Cases in Supreme Court
Railway Cases in Supreme Court
Signup and view all the flashcards
No Prosecution Without Legal Advice
No Prosecution Without Legal Advice
Signup and view all the flashcards
When is a railway servant personally liable?
When is a railway servant personally liable?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What happens if a railway servant is sued for wages?
What happens if a railway servant is sued for wages?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What happens if a railway servant is sued for damages?
What happens if a railway servant is sued for damages?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What if a railway servant fails to defend the suit?
What if a railway servant fails to defend the suit?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is the role of the General Manager regarding defending a suit?
What is the role of the General Manager regarding defending a suit?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is the difference between suits for wages and suits for damages?
What is the difference between suits for wages and suits for damages?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Can government employees always count on government assistance in legal cases?
Can government employees always count on government assistance in legal cases?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Government Defense of Railway Servants
Government Defense of Railway Servants
Signup and view all the flashcards
Annexure 'A' Agreement
Annexure 'A' Agreement
Signup and view all the flashcards
Vicarious Liability
Vicarious Liability
Signup and view all the flashcards
Common Defense
Common Defense
Signup and view all the flashcards
Annexure 'B' Statement
Annexure 'B' Statement
Signup and view all the flashcards
Reimbursement for Defense Costs
Reimbursement for Defense Costs
Signup and view all the flashcards
Railway Servant's Defense
Railway Servant's Defense
Signup and view all the flashcards
Legal Officers' Consultation
Legal Officers' Consultation
Signup and view all the flashcards
Government Assistance in Legal Cases
Government Assistance in Legal Cases
Signup and view all the flashcards
Employee Sued by Another Employee
Employee Sued by Another Employee
Signup and view all the flashcards
Legal Expenses for Private Matters
Legal Expenses for Private Matters
Signup and view all the flashcards
No Government Assistance for Implicated Suits
No Government Assistance for Implicated Suits
Signup and view all the flashcards
Legal Defense Procedure
Legal Defense Procedure
Signup and view all the flashcards
Government's Role in Legal Defense
Government's Role in Legal Defense
Signup and view all the flashcards
Legal Expense Reimbursement
Legal Expense Reimbursement
Signup and view all the flashcards
What does a surety bond guarantee?
What does a surety bond guarantee?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Who is liable under a surety bond?
Who is liable under a surety bond?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is the role of the President of India in a surety bond?
What is the role of the President of India in a surety bond?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What does Article 299 of the Constitution say about government contracts?
What does Article 299 of the Constitution say about government contracts?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Why are surety bonds used for government servants?
Why are surety bonds used for government servants?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What happens if a government servant fails to fulfill their obligations?
What happens if a government servant fails to fulfill their obligations?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Government's Role in Prosecution
Government's Role in Prosecution
Signup and view all the flashcards
Railway Servant's Liability
Railway Servant's Liability
Signup and view all the flashcards
Government Defense for Servants
Government Defense for Servants
Signup and view all the flashcards
Study Notes
Indian Railway Establishment Code (Chapter 7)
-
Lawsuits against railway servants: Railway servants may be involved in legal proceedings in various situations
-
Official duty: Cases where actions are performed in the execution of formal duties
-
Connection with official position: Cases connected to the official position, but not directly within the official execution of duty.
-
Other, non-official actions: Cases not related to official duties or position
-
Legal expenses reimbursement: All expense claims (types 1 & 2) are referred to the Railway Board. Cases of type 3 may be considered on a case-by-case basis, but no reimbursement of expenses is usual.
-
Counsel fees: Typically, only one or senior counsel’s fees are reimbursed, not including items like travel or clerkage
-
Union Public Service Commission consultation: Consultation is required for cases involving official duties (Article 320 (3)(d))
-
Subsidiary rules: General managers can create rules for railway servants to follow when defending lawsuits. Failure to follow these rules could result in denied reimbursement.
-
Private party suits: If a railway servant is sued by a private party for wages/money related to official transactions, the railway servant must plead that the government is the defendant.
-
Damages suits: Suits contesting damages resulting from the actions of a railway servant as a government employee can be directed towards the servant.
-
Personal liability: If a railway servant fails to properly respond in legal suits, personal responsibility is assumed.
-
Government defense of railway servant: In suitable circumstances, the government may take on the defense of a railway worker.
-
Government initiated proceedings: No assistance or reimbursement is given if proceedings are initiated by the government on issues related to duty or position.
-
Official conduct vindication: If a railway servant's conduct is challenged legally after government permission, assistance is optional.
-
Suits by other railway servants: Cases against servants stemming from duties can often be assisted or handled as privately held matters.
-
Matters not related to official duties or position: No assistance or reimbursement is given for cases unconnected to official responsibilities.
-
Defense procedure: Government decides whether taking responsibility for defense in suitable cases. If employee acts improperly, they must defend themselves, reimbursement later considered.
-
High fees: Requests for high lawyer fees (over Rs. 750/day in Supreme Court or similar amounts elsewhere) require explicit government approval.
-
Government Attorney: Attorney General/Solicitor engaged in government cases only with government approval.
-
Multiple cases on same day: If total lawyer fees on a single court day exceed approved limits, specific procedure applies
-
Advances for legal fees: Interest-free advances are available, up to a maximum or servant’s pay (whichever is greater) to assist the railway employee
-
Police/judicial investigations: If a police or judicial investigation is taking place, this does not stop internal departmental investigation of any fraudulent activities. Legal advisor needs to be consulted before an internal investigation.
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.