Podcast
Questions and Answers
The value of the appellant's interest in the township should be treated as separate stands.
The value of the appellant's interest in the township should be treated as separate stands.
False
The Supreme Court was asked to determine if the pipes were movable or immovable.
The Supreme Court was asked to determine if the pipes were movable or immovable.
True
The pipes were attached to the concrete footings with permanent fixtures.
The pipes were attached to the concrete footings with permanent fixtures.
False
The intention of the parties plays no role in determining whether an item is movable or immovable.
The intention of the parties plays no role in determining whether an item is movable or immovable.
Signup and view all the answers
Integral parts of a physical property are considered immovable.
Integral parts of a physical property are considered immovable.
Signup and view all the answers
The discussion about the pipes included considerations of their functional integration in a complex assembly.
The discussion about the pipes included considerations of their functional integration in a complex assembly.
Signup and view all the answers
The degree of attachment and the nature of an article do not influence its classification.
The degree of attachment and the nature of an article do not influence its classification.
Signup and view all the answers
The Supreme Court did not provide any arguments regarding the intention of the parties in this case.
The Supreme Court did not provide any arguments regarding the intention of the parties in this case.
Signup and view all the answers
The Judge allowed costs for purchasing new clothes for the children's schools.
The Judge allowed costs for purchasing new clothes for the children's schools.
Signup and view all the answers
The municipal area of Johannesburg has a township called Parkview.
The municipal area of Johannesburg has a township called Parkview.
Signup and view all the answers
The appelant argued that the unsold stands should be valued based on past sale prices.
The appelant argued that the unsold stands should be valued based on past sale prices.
Signup and view all the answers
The court indicated that a valuer should consider the seller's asking price.
The court indicated that a valuer should consider the seller's asking price.
Signup and view all the answers
The Judge interpreted 'or' in the context of costs and inconvenience as meaning 'and'.
The Judge interpreted 'or' in the context of costs and inconvenience as meaning 'and'.
Signup and view all the answers
Braamfontein Co. Ltd appealed against the valuation of their property as separate units.
Braamfontein Co. Ltd appealed against the valuation of their property as separate units.
Signup and view all the answers
A total of 1,094 erven were sold in the township of Parkview.
A total of 1,094 erven were sold in the township of Parkview.
Signup and view all the answers
The valuation of property must be based on an unreasonable sale price according to the court's ruling.
The valuation of property must be based on an unreasonable sale price according to the court's ruling.
Signup and view all the answers
Study Notes
Expropriation
- When a residential unit is expropriated, it is generally expected that the expropriated person will obtain another dwelling.
- Costs associated with searching for a new house, transfer costs, cost of moving, a small amount for a pool cover, and curtains are allowed.
- Costs of purchasing new clothes for children's schools are not allowed as it is not absolutely necessary to move to another area.
- Loss of income and additional printing costs of letterheads are also not allowed.
- Inconvenience can be interpreted as "and" or "or" meaning payment for one heading may exclude the other.
Valuation of Property
- A township's unsold stands should be valued on the basis of the present value of the prices that may be realized over a period of time in the future.
- The valuer must value property "according to the capital sum which the property is expected to realize if offered for sale at the time of valuation on such reasonable terms and conditions as a bona fide seller would require".
- The valuer should consider the price the property would fetch at a sale under reasonable terms and conditions.
- A township's interest should be treated as a single unit as far as the valuer has to ascertain the value of the interest as if all the stands are sold within a reasonable period.
Movables & Immovables
- The determination of whether property is movable or immovable depends on the nature of the article, the degree and manner of its attachment to the realty, and the intention of the person attaching it.
- Pipes joined at storage tanks by nuts and bolts and laid along the ground on concrete footings, but not attached to the concrete footings, are considered immovable.
- An article can be an integral part of an entity without itself becoming immovable.
- An article that is physically integrated with an immovable entity, like a door or window, is considered immovable.
- If an entity is considered a unit in a functional sense, e.g. production, construction, storage, the article may not necessarily become immovable.
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.
Description
This quiz covers key concepts related to expropriation and the valuation of property. Learn about the rights of expropriated individuals, allowable costs, and the valuation methods for unsold stands. Test your understanding of these critical topics in property law.
