Podcast
Questions and Answers
Why is strategy considered an iterative process?
Why is strategy considered an iterative process?
- Because where-to-play and how-to-win choices are independent of core capabilities.
- Because the aspiration is the final step in the process.
- Because new core capabilities never need investment after the initial strategic planning.
- Because insights gained at any stage may require revisiting choices made in other stages. (correct)
Which of the following statements correctly describes the nature of strategy within an organization?
Which of the following statements correctly describes the nature of strategy within an organization?
- Strategy operates at multiple levels and can be viewed as a set of interconnected cascades throughout the organization. (correct)
- Strategy development should primarily focus on where-to-play and how-to-win choices without regard to current capabilities.
- Strategy should be considered a linear process, moving step-by-step through a checklist.
- Strategy is most effective when formulated and executed solely by a small group of experts.
When developing a strategy, what should you keep in mind?
When developing a strategy, what should you keep in mind?
- Other cascades within the organization. (correct)
- The initial aspiration should never be re-evaluated or changed.
- Focusing solely on your cascade without considering other cascades within the organization.
- There is only one perfect strategy, and the goal is to find it.
What is a key characteristic of the 'winning aspiration' component in a strategic choice cascade?
What is a key characteristic of the 'winning aspiration' component in a strategic choice cascade?
Which of the following actions is least likely to contribute to an effective strategic process?
Which of the following actions is least likely to contribute to an effective strategic process?
What is the main purpose of the strategic choice cascade?
What is the main purpose of the strategic choice cascade?
In the context of strategic choices, what does 'where to play' primarily refer to?
In the context of strategic choices, what does 'where to play' primarily refer to?
What does it mean to say that strategy is about 'winning choices'?
What does it mean to say that strategy is about 'winning choices'?
What key factor contributed to Saturn's ultimate failure, despite producing reasonably good cars?
What key factor contributed to Saturn's ultimate failure, despite producing reasonably good cars?
How did GM's approach to Saturn differ from P&G's general approach to business ventures?
How did GM's approach to Saturn differ from P&G's general approach to business ventures?
What was the state of the IT sector during the dot-com bubble burst, and what opportunity arose from it?
What was the state of the IT sector during the dot-com bubble burst, and what opportunity arose from it?
Why was the selection of a BPO partner a critical decision for companies like P&G after the dot-com bubble?
Why was the selection of a BPO partner a critical decision for companies like P&G after the dot-com bubble?
What was the primary reason P&G reorganized its operations in 1999, gathering operations that might be outsourced?
What was the primary reason P&G reorganized its operations in 1999, gathering operations that might be outsourced?
What does it mean to 'play to win' according to the context?
What does it mean to 'play to win' according to the context?
In what area does Filippo Passerini exemplify the 'play to win' strategy at P&G, and what does this suggest about the applicability of the strategy?
In what area does Filippo Passerini exemplify the 'play to win' strategy at P&G, and what does this suggest about the applicability of the strategy?
Considering GM's challenges (union relations, healthcare costs) and P&G's successful 'play to win' strategy, what can be inferred about the importance of strategic focus?
Considering GM's challenges (union relations, healthcare costs) and P&G's successful 'play to win' strategy, what can be inferred about the importance of strategic focus?
What was the primary strategic goal behind GM's launch of the Saturn brand in 1990?
What was the primary strategic goal behind GM's launch of the Saturn brand in 1990?
Which of the following best describes the approach Saturn took towards customer service, differentiating it from other GM divisions?
Which of the following best describes the approach Saturn took towards customer service, differentiating it from other GM divisions?
What was the key trade-off made in the agreement between GM and the United Auto Workers (UAW) for the Saturn plant in Spring Hill?
What was the key trade-off made in the agreement between GM and the United Auto Workers (UAW) for the Saturn plant in Spring Hill?
Despite initial fanfare and innovative approaches, what ultimately contributed to the failure of the Saturn brand?
Despite initial fanfare and innovative approaches, what ultimately contributed to the failure of the Saturn brand?
How did Saturn's initial aspirations for the small-car segment differ from those of Toyota, Honda, and Nissan?
How did Saturn's initial aspirations for the small-car segment differ from those of Toyota, Honda, and Nissan?
Considering GM's overall situation during the launch of Saturn, how did the new brand relate to the company's broader challenges?
Considering GM's overall situation during the launch of Saturn, how did the new brand relate to the company's broader challenges?
According to the content, what is the primary risk associated with a company setting out to participate rather than win?
According to the content, what is the primary risk associated with a company setting out to participate rather than win?
What specific aspect of Saturn's labor agreement was intended to foster a different kind of working environment compared to traditional GM plants?
What specific aspect of Saturn's labor agreement was intended to foster a different kind of working environment compared to traditional GM plants?
Why is explicitly setting a winning aspiration so important for a company's strategy?
Why is explicitly setting a winning aspiration so important for a company's strategy?
What was the key factor that led younger car buyers to turn away from GM's core US brands in the 1980s?
What was the key factor that led younger car buyers to turn away from GM's core US brands in the 1980s?
How might GM's approach to Saturn be viewed in hindsight, considering the brand's eventual failure and GM's subsequent bankruptcy?
How might GM's approach to Saturn be viewed in hindsight, considering the brand's eventual failure and GM's subsequent bankruptcy?
How did General Motors' legacy costs affect their competitiveness in the automotive market?
How did General Motors' legacy costs affect their competitiveness in the automotive market?
What does the content suggest is a more dangerous approach for companies: too modest or too lofty aspirations?
What does the content suggest is a more dangerous approach for companies: too modest or too lofty aspirations?
According to the content, what is the ultimate criterion of a successful strategy?
According to the content, what is the ultimate criterion of a successful strategy?
Which of the following best describes the strategic shift that General Motors needed to make in response to the changing market conditions of the 1970s and 1980s?
Which of the following best describes the strategic shift that General Motors needed to make in response to the changing market conditions of the 1970s and 1980s?
What long-term impact did Alfred P. Sloan have on General Motors?
What long-term impact did Alfred P. Sloan have on General Motors?
In 2000, what were the initial options being considered for the future of P&G's Global Business Services (GBS)?
In 2000, what were the initial options being considered for the future of P&G's Global Business Services (GBS)?
What concerns arose among P&G employees when they learned about the potential changes to GBS?
What concerns arose among P&G employees when they learned about the potential changes to GBS?
Why was the option of a single large outsourcing deal with a premier BPO firm initially considered unattractive to P&G?
Why was the option of a single large outsourcing deal with a premier BPO firm initially considered unattractive to P&G?
What unconventional option could P&G have chosen for GBS, that may have seemed sensible, given the circumstances?
What unconventional option could P&G have chosen for GBS, that may have seemed sensible, given the circumstances?
What previous experience did Filippo Passerini have that made him qualified to re-evaluate P&G's options for GBS?
What previous experience did Filippo Passerini have that made him qualified to re-evaluate P&G's options for GBS?
Why did Passerini consider outsourcing to a BPO partner good for the BPO partner, but not necessarily good for P&G?
Why did Passerini consider outsourcing to a BPO partner good for the BPO partner, but not necessarily good for P&G?
What specific aspects beyond cost-effectiveness and service level agreements did P&G seek in a potential outsourcing partner for GBS?
What specific aspects beyond cost-effectiveness and service level agreements did P&G seek in a potential outsourcing partner for GBS?
Before Passerini's involvement, what was a major concern of the senior team regarding the initial options for GBS?
Before Passerini's involvement, what was a major concern of the senior team regarding the initial options for GBS?
What is the primary flaw in defining strategy solely as the optimization of the status quo?
What is the primary flaw in defining strategy solely as the optimization of the status quo?
According to the content, why is simply following 'best practices' not an effective strategy?
According to the content, why is simply following 'best practices' not an effective strategy?
What is the critical benefit of making clear, tough choices in strategy, even though they might limit options?
What is the critical benefit of making clear, tough choices in strategy, even though they might limit options?
According to the content, what distinguishes organizations that 'choose to win' from those that simply 'play'?
According to the content, what distinguishes organizations that 'choose to win' from those that simply 'play'?
Which of the following best describes the role of a 'winning aspiration' within the framework of strategy?
Which of the following best describes the role of a 'winning aspiration' within the framework of strategy?
An organization decides to implement a new customer relationship management (CRM) system that mirrors the one used by its most successful competitor. According to the content, what is the most likely outcome of this approach?
An organization decides to implement a new customer relationship management (CRM) system that mirrors the one used by its most successful competitor. According to the content, what is the most likely outcome of this approach?
A small, local bookstore is struggling to compete with large online retailers. Which of the following strategies would be LEAST aligned with the principles described in the content?
A small, local bookstore is struggling to compete with large online retailers. Which of the following strategies would be LEAST aligned with the principles described in the content?
A non-profit organization dedicated to environmental conservation is deciding how to allocate its limited resources. Which approach would best reflect a 'choose to win' strategy?
A non-profit organization dedicated to environmental conservation is deciding how to allocate its limited resources. Which approach would best reflect a 'choose to win' strategy?
Flashcards
Strategy Definition
Strategy Definition
Strategy is a coordinated, integrated set of choices focused on winning.
Strategic Choice Cascade
Strategic Choice Cascade
A strategic framework is a set of five interconnected questions that guide strategic thinking and decision-making at all levels of an organization.
Strategy as Iterative
Strategy as Iterative
Iterate through the levels to ensure alignment.
Multi-Level Strategy
Multi-Level Strategy
Signup and view all the flashcards
Cascade Awareness
Cascade Awareness
Signup and view all the flashcards
Distinctive Choices
Distinctive Choices
Signup and view all the flashcards
Core Capabilities First
Core Capabilities First
Signup and view all the flashcards
Five Questions
Five Questions
Signup and view all the flashcards
Strategy as Optimization?
Strategy as Optimization?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Strategy as Best Practices?
Strategy as Best Practices?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is Strategy?
What is Strategy?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Winning Aspiration
Winning Aspiration
Signup and view all the flashcards
Where to Play
Where to Play
Signup and view all the flashcards
How to Win
How to Win
Signup and view all the flashcards
Core Capabilities
Core Capabilities
Signup and view all the flashcards
Management Systems
Management Systems
Signup and view all the flashcards
Play to Win
Play to Win
Signup and view all the flashcards
Explicit Aspiration
Explicit Aspiration
Signup and view all the flashcards
Danger of Modesty
Danger of Modesty
Signup and view all the flashcards
Saturn's Launch
Saturn's Launch
Signup and view all the flashcards
GM's Golden Age
GM's Golden Age
Signup and view all the flashcards
Changing Tastes
Changing Tastes
Signup and view all the flashcards
Import Incursion
Import Incursion
Signup and view all the flashcards
Rising Legacy Costs
Rising Legacy Costs
Signup and view all the flashcards
Saturn (GM)
Saturn (GM)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Saturn's Unique Approach
Saturn's Unique Approach
Signup and view all the flashcards
No-Haggle Pricing (Saturn)
No-Haggle Pricing (Saturn)
Signup and view all the flashcards
UAW Deal at Saturn
UAW Deal at Saturn
Signup and view all the flashcards
Saturn's Outcome
Saturn's Outcome
Signup and view all the flashcards
Aspire to Participate
Aspire to Participate
Signup and view all the flashcards
Aspire to Win
Aspire to Win
Signup and view all the flashcards
Brand Loyalty
Brand Loyalty
Signup and view all the flashcards
What was GBS?
What was GBS?
Signup and view all the flashcards
GBS Future Options in 2000
GBS Future Options in 2000
Signup and view all the flashcards
Employee fears about outsourcing
Employee fears about outsourcing
Signup and view all the flashcards
The Easiest Option For GBS
The Easiest Option For GBS
Signup and view all the flashcards
Major uncertainty within P&G
Major uncertainty within P&G
Signup and view all the flashcards
A disadvantage of single BPO outsourcing
A disadvantage of single BPO outsourcing
Signup and view all the flashcards
P&G's ideal outsourcing goals
P&G's ideal outsourcing goals
Signup and view all the flashcards
Who is Filippo Passerini?
Who is Filippo Passerini?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Playing to Win
Playing to Win
Signup and view all the flashcards
Playing to Play
Playing to Play
Signup and view all the flashcards
Saturn's Example
Saturn's Example
Signup and view all the flashcards
P&G's GBS
P&G's GBS
Signup and view all the flashcards
Business Process Outsourcers (BPOs)
Business Process Outsourcers (BPOs)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Dot-com Bubble Burst
Dot-com Bubble Burst
Signup and view all the flashcards
Outsourcing
Outsourcing
Signup and view all the flashcards
P&G's 1999 Reorganization
P&G's 1999 Reorganization
Signup and view all the flashcards
Study Notes
How Strategy Really Works
- The book is about strategy, choice, strategic thinking, and practices.
- It uses Procter & Gamble (P&G) as the main example - the approach can be powerfully used in all manner of industries and all sizes of organizations.
- A.G. Lafley and Roger L. Martin developed a robust framework around their strategic approach.
- Michael Porter, Peter Drucker, and Chris Argyris were seminal influences who shaped their thinking and work
- The book's purpose is to illustrate the strategy concepts and tools through P&G brand, category, sector, function, and company examples.
- The lessons intend to become clear for any organization, regardless of whether all companies look like P&G.
What is Strategy?
- Strategy is about making specific choices to win in the marketplace.
- Strategy requires explicit choices, it is about doing some things and not others.
- It is building a business around those choices.
- Strategy is an integrated set of choices that uniquely positions the firm in its industry, creating sustainable advantage and superior value relative to the competition.
- Five essential choices: a winning aspiration, where to play, how to win, core capabilities, and management systems, together makes up the strategic choice cascade.
- Strategy requires clear and hard thinking, real creativity, courage, and personal leadership.
Ineffective Approaches to Strategy
- Some define strategy as a vision but vision statements don't include choices about what businesses to be in and not to be in.
- There is no focus on sustainable competitive advantage or the building blocks of value creation.
- Others define strategy a plan but a plan does not imply that the things it will do add up to sustainable competitive advantage.
- Some deny that long-term strategy is possible and believe a firm should respond to threats and opportunities as they emerge.
- It is possible in tumultuous change, it can be a competitive advantage and a source of significant value creation
- Optimizing current practices, does not address the very real possibility that the firm could be exhausting its assets and resources by optimizing the wrong activities.
- It's not strategy to define strategy as following best practices and benchmarking against competition, it is recipe for mediocrity.
Strategy is Choice
Olay's Strategic Problem
- In the late 1990s Procter & Gamble (P&G) needed to win in skin care as quarter of total beauty industry
- Skin care can engender intense consumer loyalty and skill transfer for other beauty categories.
- Oil of Olay was struggling, seen as old-fashioned, customer base was growing older every year.
P&G's choices to reimagine Oil of Olay
- Maintain status quo / launch more relevant alternative under a different brand.
- Buy an established skin-care leader.
- Extend one of its leading beauty brands into skin care.
- Revive Oil of Olay to compete in a new segment.
- Ultimately settled on reviving Olay due to brand's potential.
- Invested in the SK-II Japanese skin-care line in 1991.
- Invested in Cover Girl as its leading cosmetics brand.
- Invested in Head & Shoulders as its leading shampoo brand.
- Invested in Herbal Essences as its hair-care brand aimed at a yonger demographic.
- Eventually, the team worked to understand its consumers and its competition.
- Olay was competing for women concerned with fighting wrinkles, targeting the new point of growth, women in their midthirties.
- Traditional beauty industry took the lead creating department store brands, P&G scientists soucing and developing compounds to outperform its own competitors.
- Product showed that besides wrinkles, consumers had other needs (dry skin,age spots, and uneven skin tone)
- The name Olay needed to convince skin-care-savvy women that the new Olay products better than higher-priced competitors.
- The ads highlighted Olay and the way to "fight the seven signs of aging," consulting outside experts to test work the company was doing.
- The packaging needed to represent an aspiration, a design that a consumer could pump creams with
- They tested the products to determine what the pricing strategy for Olay Total Effects should be
- $12.99 had good purchase intent but reached mass shoppers only
- $18.99 was well received by shoppers spending 30 dollars+ on Clinique
Ultimate results for Olay
- Olay took lead and became priced at $18.99 for launch of Olay Total Effects.
- Team deepened capabilities on an ingredient, active ingredient
- Procter and Gamble (P&G)'s skincare grew 2-4% annually prior, with double digit sales after 2000.
- Became a $2.5 billion brand with extremely high margins.
Olay able to succeed spectacularly where so many fail?
- They way they thought about the choices made was different.
- Clear and defined approach to strategy and gave individual managers tools effectively make choices, what underpinned everything made a difference.
- What is your winning aspiration?
- Where will you play?
- How will you win?
- What capabilities mus be in place?
- What mangement systems are required?
- Choices can be understood as a cascade, choices at the top of the cascade setting the context, with choices at the botton set the contraints
Winning Aspirations
- The first question sets the frame for all the others and is what is the company
- Defines direction to win and the level of the market share
- To define what and how enable Olay see larger purpose, Clarity directed ideal by brand,category,sector, and company -Winning was delivering most valuable value created, To create sustainable competitive advantage, financial return.
- Aspirations be refined over time, align consistently, defines provider of context, it in all cases within from the company
Where to Play
- Represents set of choices that Narrow Competitive field
- Understand what enable company
- Compete by Markets, Customers and Consumers, and the list vertical stages of industry
- A firm can compete in multiple demographic segments and geographies, myriad services and categories,
How To Win
- Defines the choices of playing field, Recipe for segments, and the channels with intimately choice ties
- What to create for unique value, sustainable delivery to way make a firm's competitors for a customer
- Formulate skin-care power, brand, and promise of best practices to know best P&G a
- Core, home, care, win-win and to do in the rights in the world to do in the know of everything for every for you
Core Capabilities
- Support of all the heart and soul by support, set choice of the quality is the process of P&G by create choices
- Deep consmer understanding-to understand their users and consumers than all for the others
- Innovation-P&G seeks help by and work for consumers by applied support models -Brand Building long and best strength that is P&G and improve and train P&G to what to build market team efficiently -To market the cost and global scale better to find the customers
Managment Systems
- The final way that helps people to the strategy, measures
- To support help human, resource pool better and systems, marketing with new mix created for next innovation step, systems to speak credibility to dermatology editors, it is in the design shop
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.