Podcast
Questions and Answers
Which of the following best describes the primary reason for the collapse of the Knights of Labor?
Which of the following best describes the primary reason for the collapse of the Knights of Labor?
- Poor strike support and adaptability. (correct)
- Lack of government recognition.
- Exclusion of skilled workers.
- Emphasis on political reform over economic gains.
The Privy Council Order 1003 (1944 – Canada) included a 'good faith' bargaining requirement, similar to the Wagner Act.
The Privy Council Order 1003 (1944 – Canada) included a 'good faith' bargaining requirement, similar to the Wagner Act.
False (B)
Define 'surface bargaining' and provide one example of it, as understood in the context of labor negotiations.
Define 'surface bargaining' and provide one example of it, as understood in the context of labor negotiations.
Surface bargaining is pretending to bargain without the intent to reach an agreement. An example is making proposals that are designed to be rejected.
Under the Ontario Labour Relations Act (OLRA), bargaining rights can be acquired through voluntary recognition, where the union and employer ______, or through certification, where the union applies to the ______.
Under the Ontario Labour Relations Act (OLRA), bargaining rights can be acquired through voluntary recognition, where the union and employer ______, or through certification, where the union applies to the ______.
Match each model of public sector bargaining with its description:
Match each model of public sector bargaining with its description:
Which section of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms allows for the most explicit protection of the right to strike and bargain collectively?
Which section of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms allows for the most explicit protection of the right to strike and bargain collectively?
A 'no-board' report must be issued before a strike or lockout can legally occur.
A 'no-board' report must be issued before a strike or lockout can legally occur.
Explain the 'narcotic effect' in the context of interest arbitration and its potential negative impact on collective bargaining.
Explain the 'narcotic effect' in the context of interest arbitration and its potential negative impact on collective bargaining.
In rights arbitration, the ______ has the burden of proof in discipline cases, while the ______ has the burden of proof in other types of cases.
In rights arbitration, the ______ has the burden of proof in discipline cases, while the ______ has the burden of proof in other types of cases.
Match each step in the grievance process with its description:
Match each step in the grievance process with its description:
Which of the following best describes a 'statutory freeze' in the context of labor relations?
Which of the following best describes a 'statutory freeze' in the context of labor relations?
Mediation occurs before a 'no-board' report is issued.
Mediation occurs before a 'no-board' report is issued.
Explain the role of demonstrated need in arbitral criteria during interest arbitration.
Explain the role of demonstrated need in arbitral criteria during interest arbitration.
According to Week 4, Section ______ of the Charter of Rights and Freedom, also known as the notwithstanding clause, allows the government to override certain rights.
According to Week 4, Section ______ of the Charter of Rights and Freedom, also known as the notwithstanding clause, allows the government to override certain rights.
Match the following concepts with their descriptions within the context of labor negotiations:
Match the following concepts with their descriptions within the context of labor negotiations:
Which of the following actions would be considered 'bad faith bargaining'?
Which of the following actions would be considered 'bad faith bargaining'?
Craft unions typically included unskilled workers, women, and racial minorities in their membership.
Craft unions typically included unskilled workers, women, and racial minorities in their membership.
What are the four mandatory bargaining issues that must be in every collective agreement?
What are the four mandatory bargaining issues that must be in every collective agreement?
Week 12 states the three pillars of Government intervention are: Third Party in Bargaining, ______, and ______
Week 12 states the three pillars of Government intervention are: Third Party in Bargaining, ______, and ______
Match the following arbitration concepts to their respective descriptions:
Match the following arbitration concepts to their respective descriptions:
What did the Wagner Act (1935 – USA) achieve?
What did the Wagner Act (1935 – USA) achieve?
Expedited arbitration (s.49) involves a more extensive process with more steps compared to traditional arbitration.
Expedited arbitration (s.49) involves a more extensive process with more steps compared to traditional arbitration.
Describe what is meant by a 'chilling effect' in the context of labor negotiations.
Describe what is meant by a 'chilling effect' in the context of labor negotiations.
The two types of time limits, mentioned from Week 10, for grievances are ______ and ______
The two types of time limits, mentioned from Week 10, for grievances are ______ and ______
Match the following steps in preparing for bargaining with their correct description:
Match the following steps in preparing for bargaining with their correct description:
Flashcards
Craft Unions
Craft Unions
Skilled male workers, excluding women, racial minorities, and immigrants.
Knights of Labor
Knights of Labor
An inclusive union, it eventually collapsed due to poor strike support and adaptability.
Wagner Act (1935 – USA)
Wagner Act (1935 – USA)
U.S. act providing the right to unionize, union representation, bans on unfair labor practices and requiring good faith bargaining
Privy Council Order 1003 (1944 – Canada)
Privy Council Order 1003 (1944 – Canada)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Bad Faith Bargaining
Bad Faith Bargaining
Signup and view all the flashcards
Single Sector Bargaining Model
Single Sector Bargaining Model
Signup and view all the flashcards
Industry Specific Bargaining Model
Industry Specific Bargaining Model
Signup and view all the flashcards
Combination Bargaining Model
Combination Bargaining Model
Signup and view all the flashcards
Voluntary Recognition
Voluntary Recognition
Signup and view all the flashcards
Certification
Certification
Signup and view all the flashcards
Recognition Clause
Recognition Clause
Signup and view all the flashcards
Grievance & Arbitration Procedure
Grievance & Arbitration Procedure
Signup and view all the flashcards
No Strike / No Lockout Clause
No Strike / No Lockout Clause
Signup and view all the flashcards
Duration of Agreement
Duration of Agreement
Signup and view all the flashcards
Charter of Rights & Freedoms: s.1
Charter of Rights & Freedoms: s.1
Signup and view all the flashcards
Charter of Rights & Freedoms: s.2(b)
Charter of Rights & Freedoms: s.2(b)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Charter of Rights & Freedoms: s.2(c)
Charter of Rights & Freedoms: s.2(c)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Charter of Rights & Freedoms: s.2(d)
Charter of Rights & Freedoms: s.2(d)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Charter of Rights & Freedoms: s.15
Charter of Rights & Freedoms: s.15
Signup and view all the flashcards
Charter of Rights & Freedoms: s.33
Charter of Rights & Freedoms: s.33
Signup and view all the flashcards
Conciliation
Conciliation
Signup and view all the flashcards
Mediation
Mediation
Signup and view all the flashcards
Sidebar Discussions
Sidebar Discussions
Signup and view all the flashcards
Final Offer Vote
Final Offer Vote
Signup and view all the flashcards
Narcotic Effect
Narcotic Effect
Signup and view all the flashcards
Study Notes
Early Unions & Labour Legislation
- Craft Unions consisted of skilled male workers like carpenters and masons, but excluded women, racial minorities, and immigrants
- The Knights of Labour included more workers; however, they collapsed because of poor strike support and adaptability
Wagner Act (1935 – USA)
- Gave workers the right to unionize
- Provided the right to union representation
- Banned unfair labour practices
- Required good faith bargaining
Privy Council Order 1003 (1944 – Canada)
- This was the same as the Wagner Act, except with no “good faith” requirement
- Ensured no strikes/lockouts during agreement
- Mandated conciliation and arbitration
- It did not apply to the public sector
Bad Faith Bargaining Examples
- Surface bargaining (pretending to negotiate)
- Submitting proposals that are intended to be rejected
- Using unauthorized representatives
- Refusing to share business information
Models of Public Sector Bargaining
- Single Sector Model - There is one law for both the public and private sector (e.g., Saskatchewan)
- Industry Specific Model - Laws are different for different public sectors
- Combination Model - Combination of private/public rules (e.g., Ontario hospitals, fire)
Bargaining Rights (OLRA)
- Voluntary Recognition applies when the union and employer agree
- Certification occurs when the union applies to the OLRB and the employer’s approval is not needed
Mandatory Bargaining Issues
- These issues must be addressed in every collective agreement
- Recognition Clause - Specifies who is covered by the union
- Grievance & Arbitration Procedure - Required by OLRA s.48
- No Strike / No Lockout Clause - States that there will be no strikes or lockouts for the agreement's duration
- Duration of Agreement - Specifies the start and end dates of the agreement
Charter of Rights & Freedoms
- s.1 - Rights can be limited if justified by law
- s.2(b) - Guarantees freedom of expression (e.g., picketing)
- s.2(c) - Provides the right to peacefully assemble
- s.2(d) - Freedom to associate, allowing people to join unions, strike, and bargain
- s.15 - Ensures equality rights, preventing discrimination
- s.33 - Allows the government to override some rights using the notwithstanding clause
Preparing for Bargaining Steps
- Evaluate past agreements
- Form a bargaining team (with roles)
- Set union/employer goals
- Consider laws and government policies
- Review internal (e.g., grievances) and external (e.g., economy) factors
- Get bargaining mandate
- Cost proposals
- Plan strategy (timing, votes, mediation)
Impasse Resolution
- Conciliation: A government-appointed officer helps negotiate
- Mediation: Similar to conciliation, but takes place after a "no-board" report
- Sidebar Discussions: Private talks held between negotiators
- Final Offer Vote: The government or employer calls a vote on the final offer
- Strike/Lockout: Only legal if a no-board report is issued, a strike vote is passed and an essential services deal is in place
Impasse Tools
- Industrial Inquiry Commission
- Dispute Advisory Committee
- Special Officer
- Fact Finding
- Med-Arb (mediation + arbitration)
Interest Arbitration
- Used when strikes/lockouts aren't allowed (e.g., police, fire)
- A neutral third party imposes agreement terms
Types of interest arbitration
- Back to Work Legislation ends a strike and triggers arbitration
- First Contract Arbitration (OLRA s.43) occurs if there is no agreement after certification
- Final Offer Selection (FOS) can involve a total package, issue-by-issue decisions, or modifications by an arbitrator
Interest Arbitration Criteria
- Comparability, what other employers have done
- Replication, what parties would've agreed to on their own
- Incrementalism, small, step-by-step changes
- Total Compensation includes wages + benefits considered together
- Demonstrated Need must show evidence for changes
- Statutory Criteria includes the ability to pay, economy, etc
Interest Arbitration Criticisms
- Narcotic Effect - Parties rely too much on arbitrators
- Chilling Effect - Parties don’t negotiate seriously
Grievances & Rights Arbitration
- Grievance - A dispute about contract interpretation or violations
- Rights Arbitration - Final, binding decision by neutral third party
- Grievance Process: Involves an informal complaint, a written grievance, resolution steps (1–5 steps), and arbitration
Types of Grievances
- Individual
- Group
- Policy
Time Limits for Grievances
- Mandatory time limits must be followed
- Directory time limits are flexible and can be extended
Arbitration
- Arbitrator’s Powers (s.48(12)) allow them to summon witnesses, set hearings, inspect the workplace, etc
- Expedited Arbitration (s.49) is faster and skips steps
- Burden of Proof: The union proves their case while the employer proves discipline
- Grievance Mediation - An optional, faster process that is not for discharge cases
Government Intervention
- Statutory Freeze: the Employer can't change conditions when a union applied for certification, or the union gave notice to bargain (1st or renewal agreement)
Pillars of Government Intervention
- Third Party in Bargaining: The government plays an active role (e.g., education)
- Direct Legislation: Directives regarding anti-inflation, wage freezes, and back-to-work mandates
- Economic Regulation: Control over interest rates (monetary) and spending/taxes (fiscal)
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.