Sustainability: Unit 1
39 Questions
3 Views

Choose a study mode

Play Quiz
Study Flashcards
Spaced Repetition
Chat to lesson

Podcast

Play an AI-generated podcast conversation about this lesson

Questions and Answers

Which approach emphasizes the consideration of social, environmental, and economic dimensions when defining sustainability?

  • Products LCA
  • National natural capital accounting
  • Scope 1-2-3 Emissions
  • Triple Bottom Line (correct)

    • What is a criticism of an impact-focused approach to sustainability?

  • It is limited to quantifiable impacts.
  • It adequately addresses social inequalities.
  • Measurement challenges can hinder assessment. (correct)
  • It prioritizes human needs over ecological limits.

    • What does the Products Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) consider?

  • Social implications of product manufacturing
  • Only the emissions from final product use
  • Economic profitability of product sales
  • The environmental impact of a product's entire lifecycle (correct)

    • Which of the following is NOT a challenge mentioned regarding measuring ecological impacts?

    <p>Quantifying poverty levels</p> Signup and view all the answers

    Which ecological footprint measurement tool considers emissions from suppliers and sub-suppliers?

    <p>Scope 1-2-3 Emissions</p> Signup and view all the answers

    What is the main focus of sustainability development?

    <p>Meeting the needs of the present without harming future generations</p> Signup and view all the answers

    What do the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) aim to achieve?

    <p>Enhance sustainable development for humanity</p> Signup and view all the answers

    How does strong sustainability differ from weak sustainability?

    <p>Strong sustainability aims for equal resource sharing among generations.</p> Signup and view all the answers

    What is a key criticism of the development-focused approach to sustainability?

    <p>It fails to address the needs of future generations.</p> Signup and view all the answers

    Which of the following reflects the impact-focused definitions of sustainability?

    <p>Addressing humanity's environmental impact within planetary boundaries</p> Signup and view all the answers

    Which statement reflects a misconception about sustainability?

    <p>Sustainability is solely about environmental conservation.</p> Signup and view all the answers

    What is a potential drawback of linking SDGs to human-centric approaches?

    <p>It might ignore animal welfare and environmental concerns.</p> Signup and view all the answers

    Why is the progression of one Sustainable Development Goal often detrimental to another?

    <p>Progress often requires resource trade-offs.</p> Signup and view all the answers

    What is one of the criticisms of the pluralistic approach to sustainability performance metrics?

    <p>It emphasizes non-synergistic changes.</p> Signup and view all the answers

    According to Ehrenfeld, what common mistake do governments make when addressing global warming?

    <p>Implementing CO2 trading as a primary solution.</p> Signup and view all the answers

    What is implied by the term 'technohubris' as described by Ehrenfeld?

    <p>The belief that technology alone can solve complex sustainability problems.</p> Signup and view all the answers

    What does sustainability performance increasingly incorporate as measurement dimensions?

    <p>Environmental, Social, and Governance performance.</p> Signup and view all the answers

    What does Ehrenfeld suggest is a fundamental issue with the way society addresses unsustainable behavior?

    <p>Focusing on technological fixes rather than holistic solutions.</p> Signup and view all the answers

    Which of the following reflects a potential drawback of switching to LED streetlamps compared to sustainable energy sources?

    <p>Switching to sustainable energy may involve social disruptions.</p> Signup and view all the answers

    What approach to sustainability does Ehrenfeld appear to favor?

    <p>An impact-focused definition prioritizing long-term effects.</p> Signup and view all the answers

    Why might the approach of measuring companies solely on environmental performance be considered limiting?

    <p>It encourages companies to neglect social responsibilities.</p> Signup and view all the answers

    Match the following ecological footprint measurement tools with their primary focus:

    <p>National natural capital accounting = Measurement of natural resources used by nations Products LCA = Environmental impact assessment of product lifecycle Scope 1-2-3 Emissions = Emissions measurement from supply chains Triple Bottom Line = Balancing social, environmental, and economic dimensions</p> Signup and view all the answers

    Match the following terms with their definitions:

    <p>Ecological limits = Natural boundaries guiding sustainability Micro plastics = Example of non-quantifiable impacts Sustainability development = Focus on social, environmental, and economic aspects Win-win-win scenario = Ideal situation for triple bottom line advancement</p> Signup and view all the answers

    Match the following sustainability concepts with their main characteristics:

    <p>Strong sustainability = Focus on ecological limits over human needs Weak sustainability = Emphasis on human-centric approaches Ehrenfeld's technohubris = Overreliance on technology for solving environmental issues Sustainable Development Goals = Set of goals aiming at global sustainability</p> Signup and view all the answers

    Match the approaches to sustainability with their characteristics:

    <p>Strong Sustainability = Next generations also have a share of natural resources Weak Sustainability = Next generations can use produced resources only Development Focused = Includes human-centric perspectives Impact Focused = Emphasizes environmental impacts and planetary boundaries</p> Signup and view all the answers

    Match the criticisms of the development-focused approach with their descriptions:

    <p>Focus on vulnerability = Ignores future generations without a voice Wide domain consideration = Covers cultural, social, and environmental aspects Minimal frame shift = Fails to challenge the ever-increasing mentality Human-centric = Underappreciates environmental and animal concerns</p> Signup and view all the answers

    Match the sustainability concepts with their definitions:

    <p>Intergenerational equity = Same opportunities for future generations Technological innovation = Using existing resources more efficiently Planetary boundaries = Limits of environmental impact humanity can have Natural resource preservation = Maintaining resources for future generations</p> Signup and view all the answers

    Match the aspects of weak sustainability with their implications:

    <p>Resource utilization = Can use any produced resources Innovation reliance = Needs to focus on technological advancements Opportunity equality = Ensures same levels of opportunity for future generations Resource limitation = No more natural resources required</p> Signup and view all the answers

    Match the key ideas in sustainability with their corresponding terms:

    <p>Essential needs focus = Prioritizes the world’s poor Environmental impact consideration = Emphasizes humanity's effect on nature Equity among generations = Intergenerational share of resources Holistic approach = Links various cultural and environmental domains</p> Signup and view all the answers

    Match the concepts of sustainability with their contextual emphasis:

    <p>Human-centric perspective = Focuses on human needs and experiences Environmentalism = Centered around ecological impact Global resonance = Connects with widespread international perspectives Social inclusivity = Calls for involvement of marginalized groups</p> Signup and view all the answers

    Match the definitions of sustainability concepts with their examples:

    <p>Development that meets current needs = Meets present without compromising future Critique of current trends = Questions the sustainability of constant growth Sustainability goals = Aims to achieve multidisciplinary targets Regenerative practices = Focus on restoring natural systems</p> Signup and view all the answers

    Match the following concepts related to sustainability with their descriptions:

    <p>Technohubris = Reliance on technology to solve problems, often leading to side effects Impact-focused definition = Evaluation based on the consequences of actions Incremental changes = Small steps considered sufficient despite low impact Pluralistic approach = A framework that is generalizable and adaptable</p> Signup and view all the answers

    Match the following sustainability challenges with their implications:

    <p>Governments' CO2 trading = Slowing down research and development Sustainability design = Potential larger, unsustainable problems Neglecting social impacts = Misleading compensation possibilities Environmental focus only = Deemphasized non-synergistic changes</p> Signup and view all the answers

    Match the following dimensions of sustainability performance with their categories:

    <p>Environmental = Concerns related to nature and ecosystems Social = Focus on community and societal impacts Governance = Management and organizational practices Economic = Financial performance and economic growth</p> Signup and view all the answers

    Match the following sustainability approaches with their characteristics:

    <p>Triple Bottom Line = Balancing economic, social, and environmental outcomes ESG focus = Measuring companies on environmental, social, and governance aspects Sustainable Development Goals = International targets for a better world Holistic approach = Integrative consideration of multiple sustainability dimensions</p> Signup and view all the answers

    Match the following critiques of sustainability measures with their focus:

    <p>Incremental changes = Considered good even with low impact Implied compensation = Advancement in one dimension does not offset neglect in another Non-synergistic changes = Focused on individual elements rather than holistic impact Generalizable frameworks = Applicable to a wide range of contexts and situations</p> Signup and view all the answers

    Match the following responses to global challenges with their criticisms:

    <p>CO2 trading = Addresses symptoms rather than root cause Renewable Energy = Necessary for long-term sustainability Sustainable products = Can create larger problems over time Short-term solutions = May avoid deeper societal issues</p> Signup and view all the answers

    Match the following negative impacts of sustainability approaches with their descriptions:

    <p>Social disruptions = Short-term displacement for long-term gain Increased costs = Higher initial investment for sustainable solutions Environmental limits = Compromise in one area leading to detriment in another Technology reliance = Overdependence can lead to overlook other solutions</p> Signup and view all the answers

    Match the following terms with their meanings as per Ehrenfeld's perspective:

    <p>Sustainability by design = Designing solutions that may exacerbate sustainability issues Underlying issues = Fundamental problems overlooked by surface solutions Long-term sustainability = Desiring lasting change rather than temporary fixes Behavioral symptoms = Visible problems that are easy to address but don’t solve the cause</p> Signup and view all the answers

    Study Notes

    Development Focused Definitions

    • Sustainable development aims to meet present needs without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs.
    • Prioritizes the essential needs of the world's poorest population.
    • Acknowledges the limitations of technology and social organizations on the environment's ability to meet present and future needs.
    • The UN has formulated 17 Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) to enhance sustainable development.
    • Progress towards the SDGs is slow, and often progress in one SDG occurs at the expense of another.
    • Strong Sustainability: Future generations should have a certain share of natural resources, similar to present generations.
    • Weak Sustainability: Future generations should use resources already produced, utilizing innovative technologies to maintain a similar level of opportunities.
    • Strong and Weak Sustainability disagree on the degree of reversibility needed for achieving sustainability.

    Critics of Development Focused Approach

    • Focuses on the most vulnerable (the poor), but not on future generations who lack a voice in the debate.
    • Includes a wide range of domains, such as culture, social, and environmental.
    • Links to existing thinking and has global resonance.
    • Does not highlight potential issues with an ever-increasing mentality.
    • Centric on humans, underappreciating environmental and animal concerns.

    Impact Focused Definitions

    • Primarily focuses on environmental impact.
    • Emphasizes planetary boundaries and the environmental impact of humanity.
    • Ecological footprint measurement tools have developed to assess the natural resources used by nations, corporations, and individuals.
    • Other sustainability concepts for evaluating environmental impact include:
      • National Natural Capital Accounting
      • Product Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)
      • Scope 1-2-3 Emissions (considering emissions from supplier, sub-supplier, etc.).

    Critics of an Impact Focused Approach

    • Guided by natural boundaries.
    • Enables quantification and comparison.
    • Places ecological limits first, not human needs.
    • Measurement challenges exist.
    • Unquantifiable impacts, such as the effect of microplastics, cannot be fully measured.
    • Social domains, like poverty and inequality, receive inadequate representation.

    Dimension Focused Definitions

    • Often inclusive, but may neglect certain dimensions.
    • The Triple Bottom Line approach considers three dimensions:
      • Social: Social equity and well-being
      • Environmental: Ecological sustainability
      • Economic: Economic viability

    Problems with Triple Bottom Line

    • Lack of specificity makes it challenging to determine relevant components.
    • It is difficult to attain a win-win-win situation in all three dimensions.
    • Advancement in one dimension may compensate for another, but this can be misleading.

    Sustainability Performance

    • Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) performance is increasingly used to measure companies.

    Critics of Dimension Focused Approach

    • Offers a pluralistic, generalizable, and adaptable framework.
    • Promotes an integrative focus, considering more holistic factors beyond environmental impacts.
    • Emphasizes incremental change as a positive factor, even if the impact is relatively small.
    • Implicitly assumes compensation between dimensions, which can be misleading.
    • Discounts the importance of non-synergistic changes.

    Sustainability by Design (Ehrenfeld, 2008)

    • Being sustainable often leads to larger, more unsustainable problems than the initial issue.
    • Ehrenfeld believes humanity solves symptoms of unsustainable behavior, not the underlying problem.
    • This approach leads to even more unsustainability in the long run.
    • Technohubris: Solving problems with technology, leading to immediate solutions but potentially causing long-term side effects.

    What is Sustainability?

    • Sustainability is development that meets current needs without compromising future generations' ability to meet theirs.
    • Key considerations: Essential needs of the world's poor and limitations imposed by technology on the environment's ability to meet current and future needs.
    • Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs): 17 goals from the United Nations aiming to enhance sustainable development.
    • Strong vs. Weak Sustainability:
      • Strong: Future generations should inherit a certain share of natural resources, ensuring equal opportunities.
      • Weak: Future generations can use what has already been produced, maintaining equal opportunities through innovation.

    Criticisms of Development-focused Approach

    • Focus on the vulnerable: Emphasizes the most vulnerable (the poor) while neglecting the voice of future generations.
    • Broad range of domains: Incorporates various domains like culture, social, and environmental, potentially leading to complexities.
    • Links to existing thinking: Appeals to existing global thought, encouraging resonance and acceptance.
    • Minimal frame shift: Does not adequately address the potential problems of a continuous, higher-than-before mentality.
    • Human-centric: Underappreciates concerns of the environment and animals.

    Impact-focused Definitions

    • Focus on environmental impact: Emphasizes the environmental footprint of human activities.
    • Planetary Boundaries: Defines safe operational spaces for humanity within Earth's systems.
    • Ecological Footprint: A measurement tool to determine the natural resources consumed by nations, corporations, and individuals.
    • National Natural Capital Accounting: Tracks the value of natural resources.
    • Product Life Cycle Assessment (LCA): Analyzes environmental impact throughout the entire lifecycle of a product.
    • Scope 1-2-3 Emissions: Measures emissions from suppliers, sub-suppliers, and other entities in the supply chain.

    Criticisms of Impact-focused Approach

    • Guided by natural boundaries: Focuses on ecological limits.
    • Quantification and comparison: Allows for quantitative assessment and comparisons.
    • Frame shift: Emphasizes ecological limits over human needs.
    • Measurement challenges: Difficulties in measuring all impacts (e.g., microplastics).
    • Social domains underrepresented: Ignores aspects like poverty and social inequality.

    Dimension-focused Definitions

    • Inclusive approach: Considers various dimensions of sustainability without adequately addressing all aspects.
    • Triple Bottom Line: Considers social, environmental, and economic dimensions collectively.
    • ESG Performance: Evaluates corporations based on environmental, social, and governance performance.

    Criticisms of Dimension-focused Approach

    • Lack of specificity: Difficulty in identifying constituent elements.
    • Win-win-win feasibility: Challenges in achieving win-win-win scenarios across all dimensions.
    • Compensation: Potential misconception that progress in one area can compensate for neglecting another.
    • Pluralistic: Incorporates diverse perspectives.
    • Adaptable framework: Applicable and adaptable across various contexts.
    • Integrative focus: Offers a more holistic perspective by including environmental and social concerns.
    • Incremental changes: Focus on small steps, even with minimal impact.
    • Misleading compensation: Undermines the importance of addressing all dimensions of sustainability.
    • Non-synergistic changes: Deemphasizes the importance of interconnectedness and synergies across dimensions.

    Sustainability by Design

    • Symptom vs. Root cause: Often addresses the symptoms of unsustainable behavior rather than the underlying root causes, leading to increasing unsustainability.
    • Technohubris: Using technology to solve immediate problems without considering the long-term consequences.

    What is Sustainability?

    • Development Focus: Sustainability development ensures present needs are met without jeopardizing future generations’ abilities.
      • Prioritizes meeting the essential needs of the world's poor.
      • Recognizes technological and social limitations on the environment's ability to meet current and future needs.

    Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs)

    • The United Nations has set 17 SDGs to promote sustainable development for humanity.
    • Many organizations strive to implement these goals but progress is slow.
    • Often, achieving one SDG compromises another.

    Strong vs. Weak Sustainability

    • Strong Sustainability: Future generations should be guaranteed a certain share of natural resources (Intergenerational Equity).
    • Weak Sustainability: Future generations can utilize what is already produced, and innovative technologies can compensate for resource depletion.
    • The debate centers on the reversibility needed for sustainability.

    Criticisms of Development-Focused Approach

    • Prioritizes the most vulnerable (the poor) without giving voice to future generations.
    • Encompasses a wide range of domains (culture, social, environmental).
    • Connects to existing thought and resonates globally.
    • It doesn't fully address the problem of an ever-increasing consumption mentality.
    • Human-centric view: underestimates the importance of animals and the environment.

    Impact-Focused Definitions

    • Primarily concentrate on environmental impact.
    • Planetary Boundaries: Define the safe operating space for humanity on Earth.
    • Ecological Footprint: Measures the resource consumption of nations, corporations, and individuals.
    • National Natural Capital Accounting: Tracks the value of natural resources.
    • Product Life Cycle Assessment (LCA): Evaluates the environmental impact of a product's entire lifecycle.
    • Scope 1-2-3 Emissions: Accounts for emissions from a company's suppliers, sub-suppliers, and other relevant sources.

    Criticisms of Impact-Focused Approach

    • Guided by natural boundaries.
    • Enables quantification and comparison.
    • Shifts focus from human needs to ecological limits.
    • Measurement challenges exist for certain impacts (e.g., microplastics).
    • Social aspects (poverty and inequality) are underrepresented.

    Dimension-Focused Definitions

    • Often inclusive but can neglect certain dimensions.

    Triple Bottom Line

    • Emphasizes considering social, environmental, and economic dimensions when defining sustainability.
    • Challenges: Lack of specificity makes it difficult to determine constituent elements.
    • It's unclear whether advancements in one dimension can compensate for shortcomings in others.

    Sustainability Performance

    • Companies are increasingly judged based on their Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) performance.

    Criticisms of Dimension-Focused Approach

    • Offers a pluralistic and generalizable approach.
    • Encourages integrating multiple considerations.
    • Promotes incremental changes and doesn't require significant transformation.
    • Implies that advancements in one area can compensate for negligence in another, which is misleading.
    • Fails to prioritize synergistic changes that benefit all dimensions.

    Sustainability by Design (Ehrenfeld)

    • Often, solutions designed to be sustainable create larger, more unsustainable problems.
    • Reasons for Difficulty: Humans tend to address symptoms of unsustainable behavior rather than the fundamental causes.
    • Technohubris: The tendency to rely on technology to fix problems, leading to short-term solutions with long-term consequences.

    Studying That Suits You

    Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.

    Quiz Team

    Related Documents

    Learning Module 1: What is Sustainability PDF

    Description

    Test your knowledge on the definitions and principles of sustainable development. This quiz covers key concepts such as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), strong vs. weak sustainability, and the challenges faced in achieving these goals. Ideal for those interested in environmental studies and development.

    More Like This

    Use Quizgecko on...
    Browser
    Open
    Browser
    Browser