Podcast
Questions and Answers
Which criterion tends to select models with fewer variables and thus potentially lower test error?
Which criterion tends to select models with fewer variables and thus potentially lower test error?
- Adjusted R2
- BIC (correct)
- AIC
- Mallow's Cp
What should be minimized to achieve a high Adjusted R2 value?
What should be minimized to achieve a high Adjusted R2 value?
- Cp
- RSS (correct)
- TSS
- BIC
Which approach can be used to adjust training error for model selection?
Which approach can be used to adjust training error for model selection?
- Cross-Validation (CV)
- Validation Sets
- All of the Above (correct)
- Estimating Test Error Indirectly
Which criterion is likely to favor models with a smaller test error due to its penalty formulation?
Which criterion is likely to favor models with a smaller test error due to its penalty formulation?
What characteristic is desired for values of Mallow's Cp?
What characteristic is desired for values of Mallow's Cp?
What does a larger Adjusted R2 indicate when comparing two models?
What does a larger Adjusted R2 indicate when comparing two models?
Why is the likelihood function important when estimating the best model?
Why is the likelihood function important when estimating the best model?
What is the objective when choosing the best model with AIC or BIC?
What is the objective when choosing the best model with AIC or BIC?
What is the primary characteristic of natural cubic splines?
What is the primary characteristic of natural cubic splines?
How many parameters are associated with a cubic spline that has k knots?
How many parameters are associated with a cubic spline that has k knots?
What does adding more internal knots to a natural cubic spline allow for?
What does adding more internal knots to a natural cubic spline allow for?
What is the main advantage of using piecewise polynomial functions?
What is the main advantage of using piecewise polynomial functions?
What aspect do cubic splines need to maintain at the knots?
What aspect do cubic splines need to maintain at the knots?
What does the term 'control wagging' refer to in spline models?
What does the term 'control wagging' refer to in spline models?
What is a key benefit of enforcing continuity in spline models?
What is a key benefit of enforcing continuity in spline models?
What is the role of knots in spline functions?
What is the role of knots in spline functions?
What is the purpose of cross-validation (CV) in model selection?
What is the purpose of cross-validation (CV) in model selection?
Which component of Principal Components Regression (PCR) captures the largest variance?
Which component of Principal Components Regression (PCR) captures the largest variance?
Why is dimension reduction important in regression modeling?
Why is dimension reduction important in regression modeling?
In the context of Ridge and Lasso regression, what role does cross-validation (CV) play?
In the context of Ridge and Lasso regression, what role does cross-validation (CV) play?
What does it mean when a model uses new predictors that are transformations of existing predictors?
What does it mean when a model uses new predictors that are transformations of existing predictors?
What does the loss function in regression help to achieve?
What does the loss function in regression help to achieve?
What is an expected consequence of dimensionality reduction in a regression context?
What is an expected consequence of dimensionality reduction in a regression context?
What is the goal when dividing the predictor space in decision trees?
What is the goal when dividing the predictor space in decision trees?
What does using a loss function that is equivalent to ordinary least squares imply?
What does using a loss function that is equivalent to ordinary least squares imply?
What is the most common approach used for selecting the best split in decision trees?
What is the most common approach used for selecting the best split in decision trees?
What risk is associated with building a large decision tree?
What risk is associated with building a large decision tree?
What method can be used to improve the decision tree after it has been built?
What method can be used to improve the decision tree after it has been built?
How is the value of α determined in the context of tree pruning?
How is the value of α determined in the context of tree pruning?
What is meant by a class tree in classification tasks?
What is meant by a class tree in classification tasks?
Which outcome is achieved by tuning hyperparameters in decision trees?
Which outcome is achieved by tuning hyperparameters in decision trees?
What does the process of binary splitting in decision trees involve?
What does the process of binary splitting in decision trees involve?
What is the main purpose of adding more trees in boosting?
What is the main purpose of adding more trees in boosting?
What is the purpose of using the Gini index in classification?
What is the purpose of using the Gini index in classification?
Which parameter is often tuned to change tree depth in a boosting model?
Which parameter is often tuned to change tree depth in a boosting model?
What does CV help to determine in boosting?
What does CV help to determine in boosting?
How does bagging contribute to reducing variance?
How does bagging contribute to reducing variance?
What is indicated by a larger drop in RSS during tree construction?
What is indicated by a larger drop in RSS during tree construction?
What is a key characteristic of the Random Forest algorithm?
What is a key characteristic of the Random Forest algorithm?
In boosting, what do you start with when building a tree?
In boosting, what do you start with when building a tree?
When building trees using bootstrap samples in bagging, what portion of data is typically used?
When building trees using bootstrap samples in bagging, what portion of data is typically used?
Why might Random Forest not overfit despite the number of trees used?
Why might Random Forest not overfit despite the number of trees used?
Which statistical measure is used in classification trees to assess variable importance?
Which statistical measure is used in classification trees to assess variable importance?
What is a characteristic of boosting compared to random forests?
What is a characteristic of boosting compared to random forests?
What does the term 'majority rules' refer to in a bagging context?
What does the term 'majority rules' refer to in a bagging context?
What is the role of predictors in Random Forest when making splits?
What is the role of predictors in Random Forest when making splits?
What does updating residuals in a boosting model achieve?
What does updating residuals in a boosting model achieve?
What does a small Gini index indicate about the classes?
What does a small Gini index indicate about the classes?
Flashcards
Principal Component Regression (PCR)
Principal Component Regression (PCR)
A statistical technique used to find the most important features in a dataset by identifying linear combinations of variables with the largest variance.
Dimension Reduction
Dimension Reduction
A technique that uses new predictors, which are linear combinations of the original predictors, to improve the accuracy of a regression model.
Least Squares Regression
Least Squares Regression
A mathematical method used to find the best linear combination of variables by minimizing the variance of the residuals.
Tuning Parameters
Tuning Parameters
Signup and view all the flashcards
Cross-Validation (CV)
Cross-Validation (CV)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Loss Function
Loss Function
Signup and view all the flashcards
Predictors
Predictors
Signup and view all the flashcards
Bias-Variance Tradeoff
Bias-Variance Tradeoff
Signup and view all the flashcards
Mallow's Cp
Mallow's Cp
Signup and view all the flashcards
Akaike Information Criterion (AIC)
Akaike Information Criterion (AIC)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Adjusted R-squared
Adjusted R-squared
Signup and view all the flashcards
Bayesian Information Criterion (BIC)
Bayesian Information Criterion (BIC)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Estimating test error
Estimating test error
Signup and view all the flashcards
Overfitting
Overfitting
Signup and view all the flashcards
AICc (corrected AIC)
AICc (corrected AIC)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Piecewise Polynomial
Piecewise Polynomial
Signup and view all the flashcards
Knots
Knots
Signup and view all the flashcards
Enforcing Continuity
Enforcing Continuity
Signup and view all the flashcards
Linear Splines
Linear Splines
Signup and view all the flashcards
Cubic Splines
Cubic Splines
Signup and view all the flashcards
Natural Cubic Splines
Natural Cubic Splines
Signup and view all the flashcards
Spline Interpolation
Spline Interpolation
Signup and view all the flashcards
Smoothing Splines
Smoothing Splines
Signup and view all the flashcards
Decision Trees
Decision Trees
Signup and view all the flashcards
Internal Nodes
Internal Nodes
Signup and view all the flashcards
Splitting the Predictor Space
Splitting the Predictor Space
Signup and view all the flashcards
Minimize Association Within Regions
Minimize Association Within Regions
Signup and view all the flashcards
Binary Splitting
Binary Splitting
Signup and view all the flashcards
Residual Sum of Squares (RSS)
Residual Sum of Squares (RSS)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Pruning Decision Trees
Pruning Decision Trees
Signup and view all the flashcards
Classification Trees
Classification Trees
Signup and view all the flashcards
Boosting
Boosting
Signup and view all the flashcards
Updating residuals in Boosting
Updating residuals in Boosting
Signup and view all the flashcards
Shrinkage parameter in Boosting
Shrinkage parameter in Boosting
Signup and view all the flashcards
Cross-validation in Boosting
Cross-validation in Boosting
Signup and view all the flashcards
Variable Importance in Boosting
Variable Importance in Boosting
Signup and view all the flashcards
Bayesian Additive Regression Trees (BART)
Bayesian Additive Regression Trees (BART)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Random Forest
Random Forest
Signup and view all the flashcards
Ensemble of trees
Ensemble of trees
Signup and view all the flashcards
Gini Impurity
Gini Impurity
Signup and view all the flashcards
Bagging
Bagging
Signup and view all the flashcards
Bootstrap Sampling
Bootstrap Sampling
Signup and view all the flashcards
Random Subset of Predictors
Random Subset of Predictors
Signup and view all the flashcards
Variance Reduction using Bagging
Variance Reduction using Bagging
Signup and view all the flashcards
Fraction of Predictors
Fraction of Predictors
Signup and view all the flashcards
Study Notes
Cross Validation + Bootstrapping
- Resampling methods are used to get more information about model fit
- Bootstrapping is best when a large dataset is not available, to get estimates for test set prediction error
- Cross validation is a method of estimating test set prediction error when a large dataset is not available
- Cross validation is typically used to estimate prediction error when creating a model
- A subsample of training observations is randomly selected
- This subset of data is used to train and build the model
- Randomly divide data into training and validation subsets
- Model is then fit using training subset
- Predictions are made using the model on the validation subset.
- Validation set error is then calculated and used as an estimate of the test error
- Validation error is used as an estimate of test error, usually to avoid overfitting
- Cross-validation provides an estimate of the test error
- Bootstrap can be used to estimate error
- Cross-validation is often preferable over a simple train/test split
- A lack of independence amongst data can make simple train/test splits less accurate
Drawbacks of Validation
- Validation error depends on the split of data into training and validation
- Validation error varies widely based on the random selection of data for the validation part.
- The validation error can be highly variable based on which data points are included in the validation / training subsets
Summary
- Cross-validation can be used to estimate prediction error
- Bootstrap can be used to estimate prediction error
- Cross-validation is often preferred for prediction error calculations versus simple train/test splits
- Variability of the validation set error depends on the random selection of data for the validation part.
- The validation error can be highly variable based on which data points are included in the validation / training subsets
K-Fold Validation
- Divide data into K equal parts
- Leave one part out to create the validation set
- Fit the model on the remaining K-1 parts of the data
- Use the model on the remaining part to calculate prediction error for validation
- Repeat process k times, using a different part of the data for each iteration
- Combine all test errors and divide by k to get an average validation error
Leave-One-Out Cross Validation
- A special type of k-fold cross validation
- A single observation is used for the validation dataset at each iteration in the process.
- Number of folds = Number of observations
Cross-Validation for Classification
- Estimate the test error for classification type models
- Used to estimate model fit on independent data
Issues in Cross Validation
- Training set is only a subset of the original data, can lead to biased estimates
- Need enough data for all the folds and iterations to be representative and provide trustworthy estimates
- Large dataset may lead to high computing cost
More Advanced Study Material
- If k=N, where N is the number of observations, this is Leave-One-Out Cross Validation
Best Subset Selection
- Starts with a null model (no predictors)
- Examines all possible models containing 1, 2, 3 ... up to all predictors
- Select the model with the minimal prediction error (e.g. lowest RSS)
Stepwise Selection
- Starts with the null model and adds predictors one at a time
- At each step, add a predictor that reduces the prediction error the most
- Alternative: start with a full model and remove one predictor at a time, choosing the model with minimal prediction error
Other Methods
- Best subset and step-wise selection are computationally expensive for a very large number of predictors
Shrinkage Methods
- Penalize model complexity using a penalty term, often to avoid overfitting
- Common example of shrinkage method = ridge regression
- Penalizing model complexity helps prevent overfitting
- If using a shrinkage method, tuning parameter lambda can be selected using cross validation.
Principle Component Regression
- Dimensionality reduction technique
- Reduces the number of predictors in the model
- Tries to identify combinations of predictors that explain most of the variance
- Useful for high-dimensional data
Partial Least Squares Regression
- Dimensionality reduction technique
- Combines elements of PCR and regression
- Can be used when predictors are correlated, can overcome issues with simple PCA
- Similar to principle component analysis
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.
Related Documents
Description
This quiz explores various criteria and approaches for model selection in statistical modeling, focusing on aspects like Adjusted R2, AIC, BIC, and Mallow's Cp. It delves into the characteristics of natural cubic splines and the advantages of piecewise polynomial functions. Test your understanding of these concepts and their implications in achieving accurate model predictions.