Podcast
Questions and Answers
What is the primary aim of stakeholder analysis in environmental conflicts?
What is the primary aim of stakeholder analysis in environmental conflicts?
Which of the following groups is NOT considered a stakeholder in environmental conflicts?
Which of the following groups is NOT considered a stakeholder in environmental conflicts?
Across which scales do stakeholders exert their influence in environmental issues?
Across which scales do stakeholders exert their influence in environmental issues?
What type of organization is represented by WWF, Greenpeace, and similar groups?
What type of organization is represented by WWF, Greenpeace, and similar groups?
Signup and view all the answers
Which method is essential for understanding the relationships and influences of various stakeholders in environmental conflicts?
Which method is essential for understanding the relationships and influences of various stakeholders in environmental conflicts?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the primary purpose of conducting stakeholder analysis in environmental conflicts?
What is the primary purpose of conducting stakeholder analysis in environmental conflicts?
Signup and view all the answers
Which of the following is not a reason for mapping stakeholders?
Which of the following is not a reason for mapping stakeholders?
Signup and view all the answers
When analyzing the relationships among stakeholders, which variable is not typically considered?
When analyzing the relationships among stakeholders, which variable is not typically considered?
Signup and view all the answers
In the context of stakeholder analysis, why is fairness and justice considered important?
In the context of stakeholder analysis, why is fairness and justice considered important?
Signup and view all the answers
Which of the following methods is suggested for visualizing relationships among stakeholders?
Which of the following methods is suggested for visualizing relationships among stakeholders?
Signup and view all the answers
What should be included when identifying key actors in an environmental conflict?
What should be included when identifying key actors in an environmental conflict?
Signup and view all the answers
Which factor is crucial in relationship analysis of environmental conflicts?
Which factor is crucial in relationship analysis of environmental conflicts?
Signup and view all the answers
In the context of environmental justice, what is a key aspect to be aware of?
In the context of environmental justice, what is a key aspect to be aware of?
Signup and view all the answers
What is an effective strategy for addressing an environmental conflict in a presentation?
What is an effective strategy for addressing an environmental conflict in a presentation?
Signup and view all the answers
Which of the following reflects a consideration needed for complex narratives in environmental conflicts?
Which of the following reflects a consideration needed for complex narratives in environmental conflicts?
Signup and view all the answers
Which type of organization does Adani represent in the context of stakeholder analysis?
Which type of organization does Adani represent in the context of stakeholder analysis?
Signup and view all the answers
What is a primary benefit of conducting stakeholder analysis in environmental conflicts?
What is a primary benefit of conducting stakeholder analysis in environmental conflicts?
Signup and view all the answers
From which perspective do stakeholders typically exert influence in environmental issues?
From which perspective do stakeholders typically exert influence in environmental issues?
Signup and view all the answers
Which of the following groups would fall under civil society in environmental conflicts?
Which of the following groups would fall under civil society in environmental conflicts?
Signup and view all the answers
Which of the following is most crucial for stakeholder analysis related to environmental conflicts?
Which of the following is most crucial for stakeholder analysis related to environmental conflicts?
Signup and view all the answers
What impact does the expansion of the Abbot Point Terminal have on the Great Barrier Reef ecosystem?
What impact does the expansion of the Abbot Point Terminal have on the Great Barrier Reef ecosystem?
Signup and view all the answers
How many jobs does Adani claim will be created by the Carmichael Mine?
How many jobs does Adani claim will be created by the Carmichael Mine?
Signup and view all the answers
What does native title allow the Wangan and Jagalingou people to do regarding their land?
What does native title allow the Wangan and Jagalingou people to do regarding their land?
Signup and view all the answers
What was the fate of the native title rights of the Wangan and Jagalingou people as determined by the Queensland government?
What was the fate of the native title rights of the Wangan and Jagalingou people as determined by the Queensland government?
Signup and view all the answers
What type of agreements can potentially rule out native title rights for Traditional Owner groups?
What type of agreements can potentially rule out native title rights for Traditional Owner groups?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the main objective of conducting a stakeholder analysis in environmental conflicts?
What is the main objective of conducting a stakeholder analysis in environmental conflicts?
Signup and view all the answers
In stakeholder analysis, what aspect should be considered when mapping relationships among stakeholders?
In stakeholder analysis, what aspect should be considered when mapping relationships among stakeholders?
Signup and view all the answers
What is a potential outcome of understanding where controversies in environmental conflicts originate?
What is a potential outcome of understanding where controversies in environmental conflicts originate?
Signup and view all the answers
Which of the following best describes the fairness and ethics aspect of stakeholder analysis?
Which of the following best describes the fairness and ethics aspect of stakeholder analysis?
Signup and view all the answers
What must be included in a stakeholder map for an environmental conflict according to the guidelines?
What must be included in a stakeholder map for an environmental conflict according to the guidelines?
Signup and view all the answers
What rank would the Galilee Basin hold in global CO2 emissions if compared to other countries?
What rank would the Galilee Basin hold in global CO2 emissions if compared to other countries?
Signup and view all the answers
What is a consequence of the proposed expansion of coal ports along the GBR coast?
What is a consequence of the proposed expansion of coal ports along the GBR coast?
Signup and view all the answers
Which group is part of environmental and social movements in stakeholder analysis?
Which group is part of environmental and social movements in stakeholder analysis?
Signup and view all the answers
What did the former Prime Minister Scott Morrison highlight as essential for Australia's energy transition?
What did the former Prime Minister Scott Morrison highlight as essential for Australia's energy transition?
Signup and view all the answers
What is a characteristic of the growing anti-coal movement?
What is a characteristic of the growing anti-coal movement?
Signup and view all the answers
What best describes the nature of the Adani’s Carmichael Mine project?
What best describes the nature of the Adani’s Carmichael Mine project?
Signup and view all the answers
Which of the following is a characteristic of 'hidden stakeholders'?
Which of the following is a characteristic of 'hidden stakeholders'?
Signup and view all the answers
How does expanded development of the Australian economy relate to fossil fuels?
How does expanded development of the Australian economy relate to fossil fuels?
Signup and view all the answers
What significant impact is expected from the proposed Galilee Basin projects at full production?
What significant impact is expected from the proposed Galilee Basin projects at full production?
Signup and view all the answers
What potential issue arises from the new railway from the Galilee Basin to the Abbot Point Terminal?
What potential issue arises from the new railway from the Galilee Basin to the Abbot Point Terminal?
Signup and view all the answers
Which of the following factors is most relevant when identifying stakeholders in environmental planning?
Which of the following factors is most relevant when identifying stakeholders in environmental planning?
Signup and view all the answers
Which of the following reflects a political dimension tied to energy supply in India?
Which of the following reflects a political dimension tied to energy supply in India?
Signup and view all the answers
What role do environmental groups play in the context of elections regarding coal exports?
What role do environmental groups play in the context of elections regarding coal exports?
Signup and view all the answers
Who initiated the #StopAdani campaign?
Who initiated the #StopAdani campaign?
Signup and view all the answers
What year did construction of the Carmichael Mine officially begin?
What year did construction of the Carmichael Mine officially begin?
Signup and view all the answers
Which of the following best captures the significance of the term 'talismanic' in reference to Adani’s projects?
Which of the following best captures the significance of the term 'talismanic' in reference to Adani’s projects?
Signup and view all the answers
Study Notes
Stakeholders
- A range of actors and organizations represent differing values and positions within an environmental problem.
- Arms of the State include Federal and State governments, political parties and courts.
- Multilateral bodies include international organizations like UNESCO and the UNFCCC.
- Civil Society includes unions, environmental organizations like WWF, Greenpeace, and GetUp!, local climate action groups, and community-based organizations.
- Business actors include large corporations, banks, and institutional investors.
Stakeholder Analysis
- This analysis identifies key actors and their interest in a particular policy issue.
- Interests can be studied in relation to the key actors.
-
Benefits of stakeholder analysis include:
- Helping with planning and policy development.
- Making diverse viewpoints and relationships visible.
- Understanding how policies and projects are determined.
- Understanding the origins of controversies and potential resolutions.
- Considering the fairness, justice, and ethics of the process and outcomes.
Identifying and Mapping Stakeholders
- Bryson (2004) and Vogler, Macey, & Sigouin (2017) offer methods for identifying and mapping stakeholders.
- Mapping stakeholders visually can be helpful to understand relationships, power dynamics, and potential conflicts.
Stakeholder Analysis Assignment
- You should design a stakeholder map of a current environmental conflict or controversy.
- The assignment should be no more than 2 pages, including the diagram and explanatory text.
- Due date: March 30th at 11:59 pm.
-
Conflict Selection:
- Choose a current and controversial environmental conflict, Australian or international.
- Provide a brief (150 words max) overview and link to relevant resources.
-
Stakeholder Identification:
- Identify the key actors associated with the conflict.
-
Relationship Analysis:
- Analyze the relationships between stakeholders, focusing on variables like networks, alliances, influence, resources, proximity, and interests.
-
Mapping and Explanation:
- Create a visual representation of the relationships and provide a brief explanation (150 words max).
Additional Notes
-
Sources:
- Utilize news websites, government agencies, and activist groups to find environmental conflicts.
-
Narrative Complexity:
- Consider the different narratives surrounding environmental conflicts and their impact on public perception.
- Analyze who has a voice in the debate and how power informs representation.
- Be mindful of stereotypes and archetypes in narratives.
-
Rubric:
- The assignment is assessed based on conflict selection, stakeholder identification, relationship analysis, and presentation/organization.
Stakeholders and Actors in Environmental Conflicts
- Diverse groups involved in environmental conflicts include resource users, Indigenous groups, environmental NGOs, political parties, corporations, and social movements.
- Hidden stakeholders can also influence outcomes, such as individuals directly affected and transnational campaigns.
- Identifying stakeholders is crucial for understanding and addressing environmental issues.
The Adani Carmichael Mine: Case Study
- Adani's Carmichael Mine in Queensland, Australia, is a major coal mining project that has attracted significant controversy.
- StopAdani is a worldwide environmental movement working to prevent the construction of new coal mines, with Adani becoming a symbol of the fight against climate change.
- Multiple actors are involved at various scales, including state, non-state, and transnational networks, engaging in social steering.
Adani's Carmichael Mine: Background and Context
- Adani (an Indian corporation) purchased the largest coal mine project in Australia in 2010 for $2.72 billion.
- The project was initially expected to begin production in 2014.
- The Galilee Basin (central Queensland) holds significant coal reserves, with the Carmichael Mine being the first new coal basin opened in 50 years.
- The mine would produce thermal coal, used for electricity generation, and planned to be the largest untapped coal reserve globally.
- Construction began in July 2019 following final government approvals.
- The Galilee Basin projects would double Australia's coal exports to over 600 million tonnes annually if they reach full production.
Political-Economic Dimensions of the Adani Mine
- The mine's development has national, international, and global ramifications.
- For India, the project represents energy supply security.
- For Australia, it addresses energy demand security and aligns with the country's fossil fuel-dependent economy.
- The project is seen as a continuation of the environmental history of colonization in Australia.
- A strong emphasis on gas as part of Australia's energy future reflects the country's reliance on fossil fuels for economic growth and its ambition to be an "energy superpower."
Social Movements and the Adani Mine
- The anti-coal movement is growing against the mine, with environmental groups increasing their sophistication and mobilization of resources.
- Strategic partnerships with non-traditional sectors are being formed to broaden the movement's reach.
- Internationalization of campaigns has amplified the global impact of the movement.
- Coal exports have become crucial election issues in Australia.
- Local grassroots engagement has been essential in generating widespread opposition.
Regional Issues: Railway, Port, Jobs, and the Great Barrier Reef
- A new railway is being built to link the Galilee Basin to the Abbot Point Terminal, raising concerns about land clearing and taxpayer funding.
- The expansion of the Abbot Point Terminal involves dredging the seafloor of the Great Barrier Reef, increasing the risk of spills and exacerbating existing threats to the ecosystem.
- The project has diverse impacts, including habitat loss, biodiversity loss, tourism and livelihoods, and economic impacts across the region.
- Estimates of employment at the Carmichael Mine vary widely, with Adani claiming 10,000 jobs, while others estimate closer to 1,464 jobs Australia-wide.
- Scrutiny surrounds the potential exaggeration of benefits.
Traditional Owners and the Adani Mine
- The Wangan and Jagalingou people have native title rights in the region, recognizing their prior connection to the land.
- Native title grants them the right to negotiate land uses with the government but not to veto projects.
- Indigenous Land Use Agreements (ILUA) have been negotiated with some Traditional Owner groups, potentially ruling out their native title rights.
- The Queensland government extinguished native title rights for the project, rendering the Wangan and Jagalingou people's objections legally insignificant.
Stakeholder Analysis
- Stakeholder analysis aims to identify key actors with vested interests in a specific policy problem.
- It highlights the connections between actors and their interests in understanding environmental conflicts and promoting sustainable solutions.
-
The analysis is useful for:
- Assisting in planning and policy development
- Making diverse perspectives and relationships visible
- Understanding how policies and projects are determined
- Identifying sources of controversy and potential resolutions
- Evaluating the fairness and ethics of processes and outcomes
Mapping Stakeholders
- Stakeholder mapping visually represents relationships between different actors influencing environmental issues.
-
It considers variables such as:
- Network and alliances
- Level of influence
- Resources
- Proximity
- Interests
- Existing problems and goals
- The map provides a clear understanding of the complexities and dynamics within an environmental conflict.
Stakeholder Analysis Assignment
- Students are required to carry out a stakeholder analysis for a current environmental conflict or controversy.
-
The analysis should include:
- Providing a brief overview of the selected conflict
- Identifying key stakeholders
- Analyzing the relationships between the stakeholders
- Creating a stakeholder map
- Providing text to explain the map
- Listing sources
- The assignment should be no more than two pages in length.
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.
Related Documents
Description
Explore the different stakeholders involved in environmental issues, including arms of the state, multilateral bodies, civil society, and business actors. Understand their interests and the benefits of conducting a thorough stakeholder analysis to inform policy development.
