Podcast
Questions and Answers
What is the primary basis for order in the first case?
What is the primary basis for order in the first case?
- Political legislation
- Consensus of wills (correct)
- Contractual sociableness
- Public opinion
What is the primary source of order in the second case?
What is the primary source of order in the second case?
- Folkways and mores
- Public opinion (correct)
- Family spirit
- Religious beliefs
What is the role of religion in the first case?
What is the role of religion in the first case?
- It reinforces the consensus of wills (correct)
- It is irrelevant
- It is the sole source of order
- It is opposed to the consensus of wills
What is the nature of the law in the first case?
What is the nature of the law in the first case?
What is the primary basis for order in the second case?
What is the primary basis for order in the second case?
What is the relationship between the first and second case?
What is the relationship between the first and second case?
What is the role of law in the second case?
What is the role of law in the second case?
Which of these best describes the distinction between the first and second cases?
Which of these best describes the distinction between the first and second cases?
What type of relationship does the text primarily focus on?
What type of relationship does the text primarily focus on?
What is the primary factor that shapes the social control exercised by a group?
What is the primary factor that shapes the social control exercised by a group?
What is the main argument made about the relationship between closed groups and the will of the people?
What is the main argument made about the relationship between closed groups and the will of the people?
What does the text suggest about the nature of peaceful relations between community members?
What does the text suggest about the nature of peaceful relations between community members?
What is the primary method used by merchants to gain economic control, according to the text?
What is the primary method used by merchants to gain economic control, according to the text?
What is the highest form of economic control that the text identifies?
What is the highest form of economic control that the text identifies?
What is the main implication of the text's focus on economic control?
What is the main implication of the text's focus on economic control?
What kind of relationship does the text imply exists between merchants and the people?
What kind of relationship does the text imply exists between merchants and the people?
What is the relationship between Gesellschaft and community life, according to the passage?
What is the relationship between Gesellschaft and community life, according to the passage?
What is the significance of the contract in the passage?
What is the significance of the contract in the passage?
How does the author describe the change in law with the rise of Gesellschaft?
How does the author describe the change in law with the rise of Gesellschaft?
What are the two main forces that shape the legal system in Gesellschaft, according to the passage?
What are the two main forces that shape the legal system in Gesellschaft, according to the passage?
What conclusion can be drawn from the passage regarding the relationship between Gesellschaft and the state?
What conclusion can be drawn from the passage regarding the relationship between Gesellschaft and the state?
What has science replaced in terms of supremacy according to the content?
What has science replaced in terms of supremacy according to the content?
What is said to be the nature of religion in relation to human experience?
What is said to be the nature of religion in relation to human experience?
How does the structure of Gesellschaft vary with its general conditions within a nation or group?
How does the structure of Gesellschaft vary with its general conditions within a nation or group?
Which social strata are described as being truly active and alive in a Gesellschaft environment like a city?
Which social strata are described as being truly active and alive in a Gesellschaft environment like a city?
What link does religion create according to the content?
What link does religion create according to the content?
How do lower classes interact with the standards set by the upper strata?
How do lower classes interact with the standards set by the upper strata?
What does the text imply about the nature of consciousness in relation to learning and culture?
What does the text imply about the nature of consciousness in relation to learning and culture?
In a Gesellschaft environment, how does population density influence social behavior?
In a Gesellschaft environment, how does population density influence social behavior?
What primarily limits individuals' striving for pleasure in Gesellschaft?
What primarily limits individuals' striving for pleasure in Gesellschaft?
How does convention influence behavior in Gesellschaft?
How does convention influence behavior in Gesellschaft?
Who is exempt from legal responsibilities in Gesellschaft?
Who is exempt from legal responsibilities in Gesellschaft?
What role does the state fulfill regarding societal behavior in Gesellschaft?
What role does the state fulfill regarding societal behavior in Gesellschaft?
What encourages individuals' varied expenditures of money in Gesellschaft?
What encourages individuals' varied expenditures of money in Gesellschaft?
What motivates the restraint of desires in individuals within Gesellschaft?
What motivates the restraint of desires in individuals within Gesellschaft?
What has convention supplanted in the context of Gesellschaft?
What has convention supplanted in the context of Gesellschaft?
What does the relationship between capitalists and individuals in Gesellschaft reveal?
What does the relationship between capitalists and individuals in Gesellschaft reveal?
How does the intellectual attitude of individuals in the city change over time?
How does the intellectual attitude of individuals in the city change over time?
What does social life in the city lead to in terms of organization?
What does social life in the city lead to in terms of organization?
What do external contracts and relations tend to obscure in urban society?
What do external contracts and relations tend to obscure in urban society?
Why might the relationships within the city not contribute to a strong Gemeinschaft?
Why might the relationships within the city not contribute to a strong Gemeinschaft?
What is a significant aspect of social interactions in urban environments?
What is a significant aspect of social interactions in urban environments?
What characterizes the social structure in urban areas, according to the content?
What characterizes the social structure in urban areas, according to the content?
What is suggested about the influences on social organization in the city?
What is suggested about the influences on social organization in the city?
What aspect of urban life does the term 'contractual relations' refer to?
What aspect of urban life does the term 'contractual relations' refer to?
Flashcards
Order Based on Consensus of Wills
Order Based on Consensus of Wills
A system of rules based on shared values and traditions, often rooted in family life and land ownership. It's guided by customs and moral principles.
Enforcement in Order Based on Consensus of Wills
Enforcement in Order Based on Consensus of Wills
These rules are enforced by the collective will of the group, using customs, traditions, and religious beliefs as guides.
Order Based on Public Opinion
Order Based on Public Opinion
A system of rules created by formal laws and agreements, based on public opinion and political intentions.
Enforcement in Order Based on Public Opinion
Enforcement in Order Based on Public Opinion
Signup and view all the flashcards
Natural Law
Natural Law
Signup and view all the flashcards
Positive Law
Positive Law
Signup and view all the flashcards
Ideal Law
Ideal Law
Signup and view all the flashcards
Social Will
Social Will
Signup and view all the flashcards
Veiled hostility
Veiled hostility
Signup and view all the flashcards
Fear of clever retaliation
Fear of clever retaliation
Signup and view all the flashcards
Social control
Social control
Signup and view all the flashcards
Economic control
Economic control
Signup and view all the flashcards
Large-scale industry
Large-scale industry
Signup and view all the flashcards
Planned capitalist production
Planned capitalist production
Signup and view all the flashcards
Merchants' economic control
Merchants' economic control
Signup and view all the flashcards
Merchants
Merchants
Signup and view all the flashcards
Gemeinschaft
Gemeinschaft
Signup and view all the flashcards
Gesellschaft
Gesellschaft
Signup and view all the flashcards
Transformation of Legal Systems
Transformation of Legal Systems
Signup and view all the flashcards
Contractual Basis of Gesellschaft
Contractual Basis of Gesellschaft
Signup and view all the flashcards
Rational and Authoritative Will in Legal Systems
Rational and Authoritative Will in Legal Systems
Signup and view all the flashcards
Shift from belief in invisible beings to science
Shift from belief in invisible beings to science
Signup and view all the flashcards
Religion's role in a scientific society
Religion's role in a scientific society
Signup and view all the flashcards
Science's connection to culture
Science's connection to culture
Signup and view all the flashcards
Religion's connection to morality
Religion's connection to morality
Signup and view all the flashcards
Gesellschaft characteristics in a nation
Gesellschaft characteristics in a nation
Signup and view all the flashcards
Upper strata influence in Gesellschaft
Upper strata influence in Gesellschaft
Signup and view all the flashcards
Lower strata adaptation in Gesellschaft
Lower strata adaptation in Gesellschaft
Signup and view all the flashcards
Gemeinschaft to Gesellschaft transition
Gemeinschaft to Gesellschaft transition
Signup and view all the flashcards
Convention in Gesellschaft
Convention in Gesellschaft
Signup and view all the flashcards
Role of the State in Gesellschaft
Role of the State in Gesellschaft
Signup and view all the flashcards
Capitalist Influence in Gesellschaft
Capitalist Influence in Gesellschaft
Signup and view all the flashcards
Social Control in Gesellschaft
Social Control in Gesellschaft
Signup and view all the flashcards
Individual Will in Gesellschaft
Individual Will in Gesellschaft
Signup and view all the flashcards
Rational & Authoritative Will in Legal Systems
Rational & Authoritative Will in Legal Systems
Signup and view all the flashcards
Study Notes
Ferdinand Tönnies
- Tönnies (1855-1936) was a German sociologist born into a wealthy farming family.
- His brother's trade with English merchants exposed him to English capitalism.
- He taught at the University of Kiel until removed by the Nazis for his social-democratic views.
- Less influential than Weber and Durkheim, he's considered a foundational sociologist.
- Tönnies distinguished between Gemeinschaft (community) and Gesellschaft (society).
- Gemeinschaft is based on families, villages, agriculture, and local culture.
- Gesellschaft is based on large social units, complex trade, and industry.
- He developed the concept of Wesenwille, essential/instinctive will, tied to Gemeinschaft and Kurwille, deliberate will, in Gesellschaft.
- Influenced by English thinkers such as Hobbes, Maine, and Spencer.
- While he did criticize Gesellschaft, he did not sentimentalize Gemeinschaft, but saw the shift between the two as a normal social process.
- His work provides ideal types of social formations, not necessarily perfect models but for comparison.
- Gemeinschaft and Gesellschaft aren't polar opposites but positioned at different points on a spectrum.
- Social life can possess characteristics of both ideal types.
Order, Law, and Mores
- Social order emerges from consensus (folkways, mores, and religion) or rational agreement (legislation and public opinion).
- First instance is a common body of law based on norms of families and land ownership.
- This form of order is rooted in the code of folkways and mores and religious ideals.
- The alternative, rational order, reflects legal systems based on convention, politics, and public opinion.
- A distinction exists between ideal law (mores) and positive law, which must be accepted to become legitimate.
The People (Folk) and the State
- People form Gemeinschaft by creating their homes and communities, with families at the foundation.
- From them emerge individuals with power (princes, etc.) as long as their actions are guided by the common will of the people.
- Economic power, exemplified by merchants, becomes vital in forming Gesellschaft.
- The people form society (Gesellschaft) based on economic activity, which in turn shapes the structure of the state.
Types of Real Community Life
- Examples of community life are the house, village, and town, which are seen as more lasting and established.
- Towns are the most advanced form of community, although family values persist.
- Cities are the most complex social structures in Gesellschaft, but richer elites influence the character and life of the city.
- The state becomes distanced from the customs and values of a community.
The Real State
-
In Gesellschaft, public opinion affects the state, as the state's power is used for the common good.
-
There can be a tendency for the state to use its power in ways that contradict public interests (e.g. suppression of dissent).
-
The state can also strive to reform or even destroy itself by pursuing the opposite values it was formed from.
-
Tönnies observed increasing class divisions and struggles in the modern context, a conflict between individual interest and public well-being.
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.