Presentation of Self and Role Theory in Sociology

Podcast

Play an AI-generated podcast conversation about this lesson

Questions and Answers

According to Goffman's theory, what is the main difference between the frontstage and backstage?

The frontstage is where individuals behave genuinely, and the backstage is where they act superficially.

The frontstage involves public behavior aligned with social expectations, while the backstage is a private space for preparation. (correct)

The frontstage is where individuals are free from societal norms, and backstage is where they adhere to norms.

The frontstage is a physical location, while the backstage is a mental state.

Which of the following best describes 'role conflict' as defined by role theory?

The confusion experienced when one is unsure of their social role.

The difficulty an individual faces in effectively fulfilling a single role.

The competing demands arising from different social roles held by an individual. (correct)

The pressure exerted by society to conform to the expected behavior in any role.

In the context of policing, which of the following is characteristic of the 'police service' model?

Prioritizing community engagement, communication, and problem-solving. (correct)

Maintaining sharp moral distinctions and a 'us vs. them' mentality.

Emphasis on militaristic approaches and strict adherence to rules.

Focus on crime-fighting and law enforcement above all else.

Which of the following is a main challenge regarding diversity in policing recruitment according to the text?

Mistrust, perceived discrimination, and systemic barriers. Signup and view all the answers

According to the theories given, what percentage of police time is typically spent on law enforcement?

10-15% Signup and view all the answers

What is a key critique of police training programs, as highlighted in the provided information?

Preference for pedagogy over andragogy in training structures. Signup and view all the answers

According to the provided content, which of the following is an accurate description of the origins of policing in Canada?

It evolved from night watch systems inspired by Robert Peel's principles. Signup and view all the answers

What constitutes 'role strain', as opposed to 'role conflict'?

The difficulty in fulfilling the obligations of a single role effectively. Signup and view all the answers

What was a primary outcome of the Confederation in 1867 regarding policing?

A division of policing responsibilities between federal and provincial levels. Signup and view all the answers

According to Chappell & Lanza-Kaduce (2010), what is a potential negative consequence of the paramilitary structure of police academies?

The hinderance of the development of critical thinking and adaptability. Signup and view all the answers

What do Wozniak et al. (2023) identify as a common way police recruits publicly justify their career choice?

Using socially acceptable and altruistic terms, such as helping others. Signup and view all the answers

Which of the following best describes the 'Us vs. Them' mentality in the context of police academy socialization as described by Chappell & Lanza-Kaduce?

It fosters a sense of unity amongst the recruits but can alienate them from the public. Signup and view all the answers

According to Wozniak et al's research, what might be a potential underlying career driver masked by recruits' publicly oriented motives?

Job security or a desire for excitement Signup and view all the answers

What do Chappell & Lanza-Kaduce suggest needs to be balanced with tactical training in police academies?

Soft skills such as empathy and ethics. Signup and view all the answers

How do societal perceptions of policing affect police recruits, according to Wozniak et al.?

They influence how recruits express their goals and values. Signup and view all the answers

In the context of police academy training, what does the term 'socialization' refer to?

The process of internalizing the values and norms of the police force. Signup and view all the answers

Which of the following reflects a critique of the paramilitary structure of the police training as discussed in the text?

It can encourage a rigid approach in dealing with police work. Signup and view all the answers

What does Wozniak et al. suggest regarding the need of police forces relating directly to recruit motives?

To align organizational culture and training to recruits' motivations. Signup and view all the answers

Study Notes

Presentation of Self (Goffman, 1959)

Life is a performance, individuals manage behavior to fit situational norms.
Frontstage: Public performance aligning with expected norms.
Backstage: Private moments, free from expectations; preparation occurs here.
Congruence: Appearance and manner align with role, maintaining legitimacy.
Policing Application: Officers manage presentation for public trust and legitimacy.

Role Theory (Merton, 1957; Stryker, 1980; 1994)

Social positions have normative expectations guiding behavior.
Salience Hierarchy: Prioritizes roles based on personal identity & commitment.
Role Conflict: Competing demands between different roles.
Role Strain: Challenges in fulfilling a single role effectively.
Police Roles:
- Law Enforcement: Traditional crime-fighting (10-15% of police time).
- Order Maintenance: Managing public order, often underestimated; critical.
- Social Worker: Helping those in need, challenging to measure.
- Knowledge Worker: Managing info & analytics.

Policing Philosophies

Police "Service" Model: Focus on communication, community engagement, problem-solving, and crime prevention; ethics, diversity, and higher education emphasized.
Police "Force" Model: Emphasis on crime-fighting and law enforcement; sharp moral distinctions, militaristic approach.

Recruitment and Training

Recruitment Motivations: Helping people, career security, crime-fighting, excitement.
Recruitment Challenges: Diversity, perceptions of bias.
Diversity in Policing: Representation of women, visible minorities, and Indigenous peoples lags behind national populations. Barriers include mistrust, perceived discrimination, and systemic issues.
Training Critiques: Overemphasis on tactical, physical skills over soft skills (communication, ethics); emphasis on pedagogy over andragogy; questions about training predicting field performance.

Historical and Organizational Context of Canadian Policing

Origins: Night watch systems (1650s) evolved to structured policing, influenced by Robert Peel's principles (1829).
Development: Confederation (1867) led to divisions in policing responsibilities; RCMP formed (1920) merging the NWMP and Dominion Police.
Modern Era: Growing complexity, specialization, integration of technology (CAD, predictive analytics).

Chappell & Lanza-Kaduce (2010): Police Academy Socialization

Focus: Police recruit socialization in paramilitary settings.
Key Points: Paramilitary structure emphasizes hierarchy, discipline, order; training promotes obedience; "us vs. them" mentality; socialization process transforms recruits to internalize police values; training heavily focuses on physical fitness, tactical skills, procedural knowledge; limited emphasis on communication, problem-solving, or community engagement;
Critiques: Paramilitary structure might hinder critical thinking, adaptability, and marginalize service-oriented policing; potential for rigid, authoritarian approach to policing.
Implications: Concerns about training aligning with community policing needs; reforms to balance tactical training with soft skills (empathy, ethics).

Wozniak et al. (2023): Police Recruit Narratives

Focus: Recruit motivations using narrative analysis; public-oriented vocabulary of motives.
Key Points: Common reasons for recruitment include helping others, maintaining safety, and fulfillment; crime-fighting/excitement are secondary; recruits frame motivations in socially acceptable, altruistic terms emphasizing service over personal gain, legitimizing choice to self and public; shaped by societal perceptions; public discourse influences how recruits articulate goals;
Critiques: Publicly-oriented motives might mask underlying drivers like job security or excitement; potential disconnect between initial motivations and on-the-job realities.
Implications: Importance of aligning training and organizational culture with recruits' motivations; need for transparency addressing public expectations.

Study Tips for Test Preparation

Key Comparisons: Chappell & Lanza-Kaduce (structural/social aspects of academy training) vs. Wozniak et al. (personal narratives & public-facing motives).
Main Themes: Socialization (internalizing norms) and public perception (framing motivations aligning with societal values).

Studying That Suits You

Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.

Description

Explore Erving Goffman's concept of self-presentation and the complexities of role theory as discussed by Merton and Stryker. This quiz covers the dynamics of public versus private behavior and the varied roles within social contexts, particularly in policing. Test your understanding of how societal expectations shape individual actions and role performance.