Podcast
Questions and Answers
Descartes classifies our essence as 'thinking things' and asserts that our knowledge can be derived from pure ______ alone.
Descartes classifies our essence as 'thinking things' and asserts that our knowledge can be derived from pure ______ alone.
reason
Hume believes that understanding ______ is essential to comprehending our thinking as human beings.
Hume believes that understanding ______ is essential to comprehending our thinking as human beings.
people
Hume wanted to undermine the foundations of ______ and eliminate 'bad' metaphysics.
Hume wanted to undermine the foundations of ______ and eliminate 'bad' metaphysics.
metaphysics
Hume sought an accurate scrutiny of human understanding and the faculties of human ______.
Hume sought an accurate scrutiny of human understanding and the faculties of human ______.
Hume classifies the perceptions of the mind into ideas versus ______.
Hume classifies the perceptions of the mind into ideas versus ______.
Impressions are based on direct experience while ideas are a mental ______.
Impressions are based on direct experience while ideas are a mental ______.
Impressions have a stronger force because they are felt ______.
Impressions have a stronger force because they are felt ______.
The origin of all ideas is ______.
The origin of all ideas is ______.
Empiricism states that all knowledge derives from ______.
Empiricism states that all knowledge derives from ______.
Relations of ideas are a priori and are ______ of content.
Relations of ideas are a priori and are ______ of content.
Matters of fact refer to statements that say something about the ______.
Matters of fact refer to statements that say something about the ______.
Immediate matters of fact involve direct ______ confirmation.
Immediate matters of fact involve direct ______ confirmation.
Reasoning for non-immediate facts is built upon the foundation of ______ and effect.
Reasoning for non-immediate facts is built upon the foundation of ______ and effect.
According to Hume, we can't use ______ to establish cause and effect.
According to Hume, we can't use ______ to establish cause and effect.
Hume's problem of induction assumes that nature will remain ______.
Hume's problem of induction assumes that nature will remain ______.
The idea that the future will ______ the past is not absolute.
The idea that the future will ______ the past is not absolute.
Assumptions about nature require a belief that there wouldn't be a ______ within nature.
Assumptions about nature require a belief that there wouldn't be a ______ within nature.
If we were purely ______, humanity would cease to exist.
If we were purely ______, humanity would cease to exist.
Hume claims that all knowledge is confirmed through ______ data.
Hume claims that all knowledge is confirmed through ______ data.
Hume's claims do not support ______.
Hume's claims do not support ______.
Hume believed that without belief in ______, society would not be able to operate.
Hume believed that without belief in ______, society would not be able to operate.
Flashcards
Descartes' Essence of Humanity
Descartes' Essence of Humanity
Descartes believes our fundamental nature is defined by our ability to think. He argues that our knowledge stems solely from pure reason.
Hume's Critique of Descartes
Hume's Critique of Descartes
Hume disagrees with Descartes' focus solely on reason. He argues that our thinking is a part of a broader human experience and that reason alone is insufficient to understand our whole being.
Hume's Rejection of Metaphysics
Hume's Rejection of Metaphysics
Hume criticizes metaphysics, the study of reality beyond physical experience, as untestable and beyond the limits of human understanding.
Hume's Goal: Understanding Human Understanding
Hume's Goal: Understanding Human Understanding
Signup and view all the flashcards
Hume's Classification of Mental Perceptions
Hume's Classification of Mental Perceptions
Signup and view all the flashcards
Hume's Claim on Causality
Hume's Claim on Causality
Signup and view all the flashcards
Problem of Induction
Problem of Induction
Signup and view all the flashcards
Nature's Consistency
Nature's Consistency
Signup and view all the flashcards
Invalid Assumption
Invalid Assumption
Signup and view all the flashcards
Begging the Question
Begging the Question
Signup and view all the flashcards
Unprovable Causal Chain
Unprovable Causal Chain
Signup and view all the flashcards
Humanity and Causality
Humanity and Causality
Signup and view all the flashcards
Empirical Data and Knowledge
Empirical Data and Knowledge
Signup and view all the flashcards
Impressions
Impressions
Signup and view all the flashcards
Ideas
Ideas
Signup and view all the flashcards
Objects of Reason
Objects of Reason
Signup and view all the flashcards
Matters of Fact
Matters of Fact
Signup and view all the flashcards
Immediate Matters of Fact
Immediate Matters of Fact
Signup and view all the flashcards
Non-Immediate Matters of Fact
Non-Immediate Matters of Fact
Signup and view all the flashcards
Cause and Effect
Cause and Effect
Signup and view all the flashcards
Knowledge of Cause and Effect
Knowledge of Cause and Effect
Signup and view all the flashcards
Study Notes
Hume vs. Descartes
- Descartes defines essence as "thinking things," deriving knowledge solely from reason.
- Hume broadens the concept of thinking, linking it to understanding human beings, arguing that thinking isn't separate from us as people.
- Hume criticizes Descartes' approach to metaphysics, arguing it's beyond our capabilities and untestable.
- Hume's goal is to undermine the foundations of metaphysics.
- He aims to accurately scrutinize human understanding, determining the boundaries of human knowledge by understanding our mental geography.
- He classifies mental perceptions as impressions and ideas.
Impressions/Ideas
- Impressions: represent direct experience, strong, firsthand sensations.
- Examples include strong feelings and direct sensory experience.
- Ideas: are mental representations, weaker, like memories; recreations of experiences in the mind.
- Examples include a faded memory and recreations from sensory experiences.
Objects of Reason
- Relations of Ideas: concern concepts, like math, and are derived by logic.
- Matters of Fact: relate to the empirical world, describing events. Matters of fact are contingent, and experience is their basis. They are based on cause and effect which themselves are not self-evidently true; we learn them through experience. They are more useful than relations of ideas.
Types of Matters of Fact
- Immediate: directly experienced; evidence from sensory data.
- Non-immediate: no direct sensory confirmation; based on past experience, and the idea that nature is consistent.
Cause and Effect
- Hume argues causality isn't based on reason but constant conjunction.
- We observe events consistently appearing together, forming our understanding of cause and effect. Reason is not involved in the initial perception.
- Hume's argument is about how we gain knowledge of cause and effect. It's based on experience of constant conjunction, not reason.
Problem of Induction
- Nature's consistency is assumed by past experience and is a key assumption behind inductive reasoning.
- Hume argues we can't prove nature will always behave the same way because future events are not a priori (knowable based on reason/thought alone).
- Predicting the future based on past experience is an assumption rather than a reasoned truth.
- Our belief in the uniformity of nature is based on past experience; this is a matter of fact, which is contingent knowledge.
Central Argument
- Hume argues that an unprovable causal chain doesn't matter to human existence—we rely on past experiences in order to build our future based on an assumption that the future will be similar to the past.
- Our knowledge is based on empirical data, limiting what can be known.
- Accepting causality is necessary for human society to exist.
- Empiricism, or knowledge gained from experience, is crucial for knowing things in the world.
- Metaphysics is unsupported by Hume's approach.
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.
Related Documents
Description
Explore the philosophical debate between Hume and Descartes regarding the nature of knowledge and human understanding. The quiz delves into Hume's criticism of Descartes' metaphysics and the classification of mental perceptions into impressions and ideas. Test your grasp of these foundational concepts in philosophy.
