Podcast
Questions and Answers
What is the role of courts in the Irish legal system?
What is the role of courts in the Irish legal system?
The courts interpret laws, determine whether they have been violated, and enforce penalties or awards for damages.
Describe the difference between a legal principle and a legal rule.
Describe the difference between a legal principle and a legal rule.
A legal principle is the underlying idea of the law, while a legal rule is the specific law that puts that principle into practice.
List and explain two functions of the law in Irish society.
List and explain two functions of the law in Irish society.
The law sets out rules of behavior in society and acts as a deterrent to crime.
What are the essential elements of a legal system as outlined in Irish law?
What are the essential elements of a legal system as outlined in Irish law?
Signup and view all the answers
What distinguishes criminal law cases from civil law cases in the Irish legal system?
What distinguishes criminal law cases from civil law cases in the Irish legal system?
Signup and view all the answers
What distinguishes a public wrong in criminal law from a private wrong in civil law?
What distinguishes a public wrong in criminal law from a private wrong in civil law?
Signup and view all the answers
Who carries the burden of proof in a criminal case, and what is the standard of proof required?
Who carries the burden of proof in a criminal case, and what is the standard of proof required?
Signup and view all the answers
Explain the presumption of innocence and its significance in criminal law.
Explain the presumption of innocence and its significance in criminal law.
Signup and view all the answers
How do criminal proceedings differ in terms of initiation compared to civil proceedings?
How do criminal proceedings differ in terms of initiation compared to civil proceedings?
Signup and view all the answers
In what circumstances are serious criminal cases heard, and who decides the verdict?
In what circumstances are serious criminal cases heard, and who decides the verdict?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the difference between substantive law and procedural law in the context of Irish law?
What is the difference between substantive law and procedural law in the context of Irish law?
Signup and view all the answers
Can you provide two examples of public law and two examples of private law?
Can you provide two examples of public law and two examples of private law?
Signup and view all the answers
What role do injunctions and specific performance play in Irish law?
What role do injunctions and specific performance play in Irish law?
Signup and view all the answers
How does the concept of rescission contribute to the Law of Contract?
How does the concept of rescission contribute to the Law of Contract?
Signup and view all the answers
Explain the significance of the case DPP v. Best in the context of Irish law principles.
Explain the significance of the case DPP v. Best in the context of Irish law principles.
Signup and view all the answers
What is the verdict in a criminal case in Ireland, and what are the implications of being found not guilty?
What is the verdict in a criminal case in Ireland, and what are the implications of being found not guilty?
Signup and view all the answers
In civil law, who carries the burden of proof, and how is the case assessed?
In civil law, who carries the burden of proof, and how is the case assessed?
Signup and view all the answers
What distinguishes a civil wrong from a criminal wrong in Irish law?
What distinguishes a civil wrong from a criminal wrong in Irish law?
Signup and view all the answers
What are the typical remedies available in civil law, and which is the most common?
What are the typical remedies available in civil law, and which is the most common?
Signup and view all the answers
How can a single event lead to liability in both criminal and civil law?
How can a single event lead to liability in both criminal and civil law?
Signup and view all the answers
What role does the state play in initiating criminal cases compared to civil cases?
What role does the state play in initiating criminal cases compared to civil cases?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the standard of proof required in criminal cases, and how does it differ from civil cases?
What is the standard of proof required in criminal cases, and how does it differ from civil cases?
Signup and view all the answers
Name one alternative to court resolution in civil law.
Name one alternative to court resolution in civil law.
Signup and view all the answers
What is meant by the phrase 'costs follow the event' in civil cases?
What is meant by the phrase 'costs follow the event' in civil cases?
Signup and view all the answers
Give an example of a criminal offense and its corresponding civil action.
Give an example of a criminal offense and its corresponding civil action.
Signup and view all the answers
What is meant by 'legal personality' in the context of Irish law?
What is meant by 'legal personality' in the context of Irish law?
Signup and view all the answers
How does the concept of Rule of Law impact government authority in Ireland?
How does the concept of Rule of Law impact government authority in Ireland?
Signup and view all the answers
Describe the separation of powers as it exists in the Irish legal system.
Describe the separation of powers as it exists in the Irish legal system.
Signup and view all the answers
What is the significance of the Good Friday Agreement in the context of Irish law?
What is the significance of the Good Friday Agreement in the context of Irish law?
Signup and view all the answers
What does it mean when a crime is regarded as a 'public wrong' in Irish law?
What does it mean when a crime is regarded as a 'public wrong' in Irish law?
Signup and view all the answers
Explain the concepts of 'burden of proof' and 'standard of proof' in legal proceedings.
Explain the concepts of 'burden of proof' and 'standard of proof' in legal proceedings.
Signup and view all the answers
Outline the historical development of the Irish legal system from Brehon Law to modern times.
Outline the historical development of the Irish legal system from Brehon Law to modern times.
Signup and view all the answers
What role does the Oireachtas play in the legislative process of Irish law?
What role does the Oireachtas play in the legislative process of Irish law?
Signup and view all the answers
Study Notes
Irish Legal System
- Law is a set of rules imposed by the state, regulating conduct within that state
- Courts interpret these rules, determine if they've been broken, and award compensation (or pass sentence)
- This maintains a standard of behaviour for the common good
- Systems of principles, rules, and procedures regulate individuals in society
Key Principles of Irish Law
- Legal principle: the idea behind the law
- Legal rule: the law that puts the principle into practice
- Legal procedure: rules relating to court process and evidence
- Jurisdiction: the geographical area where a law applies
Characteristics of the Law
- Acts as a guide for behaviour
- Is regulated through institutions
- Is compulsory in nature
Functions of the Law
- Sets out rules of behaviour in society
- Acts as a deterrent to crime
- Punishes wrongdoers
- Provides a mechanism for those wronged to recover compensation
- Provides a means of enforcing legal rights and obligations
Essential Elements of a Legal System
- Rules forbidding certain behaviour
- Rules for compensating people wronged for damages caused
- Rules regulating and enforcing agreements/relationships between people
- A system of courts to enforce the above
- A body to make new laws for new situations or amend existing ones
Criminal Law
- Deals with conduct prohibited by the state (criminal offences)
- Punishable by sanctions
- A crime is considered a wrong against the state, not the victim
- The victim is a witness, but the state decides to prosecute
- Names of cases often reflect this, for example, DPP v Ryan
Criminal Law v Civil Law
- Criminal: Prosecution v Defendant. Proceedings initiated by the state (Gardai or DPP). Cases heard in criminal courts (minor vs. serious cases).
- Civil: Plaintiff v Defendant (plaintiff brings the case). Plaintiff has the burden of proof - must demonstrate, likely than not, that the defendant's actions were wrong. Cases heard in civil courts (juries are not commonly used).
Criminal Law – Presumption of Innocence
- The accused is innocent until proven guilty
- The state carries the burden of proof
- The defendant does not need to prove their innocence
- Presumption in favor of bail
- Case reporting reflects the presumption of innocence
Criminal Law - Standard of Proof
- Guilt must be established beyond a reasonable doubt (a very high standard)
- Evidence must meet this standard
- Important to ensure that innocent people are not convicted
Criminal Law - Verdict & Sentencing
- Verdict in a criminal case is either guilty or not guilty
- Not guilty: defendant released, no criminal record
- Guilty: defendant receives a sentence by a judge, may be held in custody until sentencing, a criminal record may be kept depending on specifics.
- Maximum sentences are defined by law for each offense.
- Minimum/mandatory sentences are rare in Ireland, judges generally have discretion in calculating the sentence.
Civil Law
- Addresses private wrongs (disputes between individuals), with or without legal entities involved
- The state does not bring the case on behalf of the injured party.
- The injured party (plaintiff) brings the case, against the defendant.
- Case names usually include the names of the parties e.g., Donoghue v Stevenson.
- Plaintiff carries the burden of proof to demonstrate their case.
- Civil cases must be established on a balance of probabilities
- Damages is the most common remedy.
- Other remedies include court injunctions, declarations, rescission, or specific performance
- Costs generally follow the event, successful party can seek to be compensated
Civil Law - Courts & Decision
- Cases heard in civil courts, by a judge
- Juries are rarely used in civil cases
- The court's decision is that the defendant was either liable or not liable
- If found liable, the court determines an appropriate remedy to compensate the losses to the other party
Dual Liability
- A single event can lead to both criminal and civil liability
- Example: driving under the influence of alcohol leading to injury—criminal prosecution and civil damages claim for injuries.
Key Differences between Criminal and Civil Law (Summary Table)
Feature | Criminal Law | Civil Law |
---|---|---|
Aims | Deter crime, punish wrongdoers | Compensate for loss, enforce rights, obligations |
Parties | DPP/State (prosecution) vs. Accused | Plaintiff (person bringing case) vs. Defendant (person sued) |
Standard of Proof | Beyond a reasonable doubt | On the balance of probabilities |
Courts | District Court, Circuit Criminal Court, etc. | District Court, Circuit Court, High Court, Court of Appeal |
Remedies | Fine, imprisonment | Damages, injunctions, court orders |
Divisions of Law
- Substantive Law: primary rules governing conduct (e.g., Criminal Law, Contract Law).
- Procedural Law: secondary rules governing implementation of substantive law (e.g., Law of Evidence, Criminal Procedure).
Public and Private Law
- Public Law: involves the state (e.g., Criminal Law, Immigration Law, etc.)
- Private Law: disputes between individuals/private entities (e.g., Law of Tort, Contract Law, etc.)
Development of the Irish Legal System
- Brehon Law
- Common Law (introduction of English Law)
- 20th-century development (e.g., Independence, Constitution, court system, EU membership, Belfast Agreement)
Legal Personality
- The capacity of an individual or entity to be recognized as a person under the law.
- Natural persons (human beings)
- Artificial persons (legal entities like companies)
- Significance relates to areas like company law and separate legal personality.
The Rule of Law
- The state is bound by law.
- Limited government power
- Government acts according to pre-established rules
- Entitlement to fair notice of laws that govern actions
- The principle of separation of powers (different branches of government).
Separation of Powers
- Division of government powers into legislative, executive, and judicial branches, each branch overseeing the other branches' actions and maintaining power balance.
Discussion Questions (as found in provided documents):
- Define law, including key characteristics.
- Outline differences between civil and criminal law. Give examples.
- Explain the concept of separation of powers.
- Explain public wrong concept in the context of a crime.
- Explain burden of proof and standard of proof.
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.
Related Documents
Description
This quiz will explore the key principles, characteristics, and functions of the Irish legal system. Understand how laws are structured, interpreted, and enforced in Ireland to maintain societal order and justice.