Podcast
Questions and Answers
Which perspective aligns with Foucault and Szasz's argument regarding mental illness?
Which perspective aligns with Foucault and Szasz's argument regarding mental illness?
- Mental illness is a stable, objective reality grounded in psychopathology.
- Mental illness is solely a result of individual biological or genetic predispositions.
- Cultural and societal factors play a significant role in defining and understanding mental illness. (correct)
- Psychiatric symptoms remain constant across different historical periods.
In prehistoric societies, what was the prevailing understanding of mental and physical suffering?
In prehistoric societies, what was the prevailing understanding of mental and physical suffering?
- Mental and physical suffering were intertwined with magic, religion, and medicine. (correct)
- Mental suffering was primarily attributed to neurological disorders.
- Mental and physical suffering were clearly distinguished and treated separately.
- Physical suffering was seen as a consequence of moral failings, while mental suffering was biologically based.
How did ancient Egyptian and Mesopotamian civilizations primarily explain mental afflictions?
How did ancient Egyptian and Mesopotamian civilizations primarily explain mental afflictions?
- As a result of psychological trauma, needing therapeutic practices.
- As a manifestation of divine displeasure, necessitating atonement.
- Through demonic possession requiring incantations and religious rituals. (correct)
- Through the imbalance of bodily humors, requiring medical intervention.
What distinguished the Hebrew and Israelite understanding of mental illness from that of other ancient civilizations?
What distinguished the Hebrew and Israelite understanding of mental illness from that of other ancient civilizations?
How did Hippocrates challenge the prevailing views on the origins of mental illness in ancient Greece?
How did Hippocrates challenge the prevailing views on the origins of mental illness in ancient Greece?
What concept did the ancient Greeks emphasize in their theatrical portrayals of individuals driven to insanity?
What concept did the ancient Greeks emphasize in their theatrical portrayals of individuals driven to insanity?
What was a common element in the understanding and treatment of ailments, including epilepsy, in ancient civilizations before the Classical Era?
What was a common element in the understanding and treatment of ailments, including epilepsy, in ancient civilizations before the Classical Era?
How did the understanding of epilepsy in ancient times reflect the prevailing cultural and religious beliefs?
How did the understanding of epilepsy in ancient times reflect the prevailing cultural and religious beliefs?
Which of the following best characterizes the shift in understanding mental disorders from the Middle Ages to the Renaissance?
Which of the following best characterizes the shift in understanding mental disorders from the Middle Ages to the Renaissance?
How did Johann Weyer challenge the prevailing views on mental disorders during the Renaissance?
How did Johann Weyer challenge the prevailing views on mental disorders during the Renaissance?
What was the significance of Felix Platter's 'Praxis Medica' in the history of psychiatry?
What was the significance of Felix Platter's 'Praxis Medica' in the history of psychiatry?
Which statement best describes the core principle of the moral treatment movement?
Which statement best describes the core principle of the moral treatment movement?
How did William Tuke contribute to the advancement of mental health care?
How did William Tuke contribute to the advancement of mental health care?
Benjamin Rush, considered the 'Father of American Psychiatry,' primarily attributed mental illness to what cause?
Benjamin Rush, considered the 'Father of American Psychiatry,' primarily attributed mental illness to what cause?
How did Chiarugi's perspective on mental illness differ from prevailing views of his time?
How did Chiarugi's perspective on mental illness differ from prevailing views of his time?
According to Pinel's classification, which of the following was NOT considered a type of insanity?
According to Pinel's classification, which of the following was NOT considered a type of insanity?
Which statement best reflects Hippocrates' view on the origin of epilepsy, as presented?
Which statement best reflects Hippocrates' view on the origin of epilepsy, as presented?
How did Aristotle's perspective on mental illness differ from Plato's, based on the information provided?
How did Aristotle's perspective on mental illness differ from Plato's, based on the information provided?
Which of the following statements accurately describes the impact of Emperor Constantine's sanctioning of Christianity on beliefs about mental illness?
Which of the following statements accurately describes the impact of Emperor Constantine's sanctioning of Christianity on beliefs about mental illness?
How did Galen's approach to understanding mental disorders differ from the broader diagnostic classifications used by Hippocrates?
How did Galen's approach to understanding mental disorders differ from the broader diagnostic classifications used by Hippocrates?
Which of the following statements accurately relates the four humors to personality or mood, according to humoral theory?
Which of the following statements accurately relates the four humors to personality or mood, according to humoral theory?
Which statement accurately reflects how Hippocrates approached the treatment of mental illness, according to the information provided?
Which statement accurately reflects how Hippocrates approached the treatment of mental illness, according to the information provided?
How did Aretaeus of Cappadocia contribute to the understanding of mood disorders?
How did Aretaeus of Cappadocia contribute to the understanding of mood disorders?
What was the prevailing attitude toward madness during the Classical period, based on the information provided?
What was the prevailing attitude toward madness during the Classical period, based on the information provided?
Which of the following best describes Charcot's contribution to the field of neurology during the Modern Period?
Which of the following best describes Charcot's contribution to the field of neurology during the Modern Period?
Emil Kraepelin's classification system, a landmark development, was primarily based on which of the following?
Emil Kraepelin's classification system, a landmark development, was primarily based on which of the following?
What was a primary motivation for developing the initial version of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual (DSM)?
What was a primary motivation for developing the initial version of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual (DSM)?
Which of the following accurately represents a key change introduced in DSM-III compared to DSM-I and DSM-II?
Which of the following accurately represents a key change introduced in DSM-III compared to DSM-I and DSM-II?
The development of DSM-IV involved a 'three-stage empirical process.' Which of the following was NOT one of the stages?
The development of DSM-IV involved a 'three-stage empirical process.' Which of the following was NOT one of the stages?
What was the primary impetus behind the creation of the DSM-IV-TR, the text revision of DSM-IV?
What was the primary impetus behind the creation of the DSM-IV-TR, the text revision of DSM-IV?
Dorothea Dix is best known for her work in which area?
Dorothea Dix is best known for her work in which area?
According to Emil Kraepelin's dichotomy, which of the following disorders was considered to have a good prognosis?
According to Emil Kraepelin's dichotomy, which of the following disorders was considered to have a good prognosis?
Flashcards
Foucault & Szasz
Foucault & Szasz
Argued mental illness is a cultural construct, not a natural fact.
Roth & Kroll
Roth & Kroll
Argued psychiatric symptoms' stability shows mental illness is a real psychopathological entity.
Trepanned Skulls
Trepanned Skulls
Surgical procedure on the skull dating back to 5000 BC.
Prehistoric View of Madness
Prehistoric View of Madness
Signup and view all the flashcards
Egyptian/Mesopotamian View
Egyptian/Mesopotamian View
Signup and view all the flashcards
Indian View of Mental Illness
Indian View of Mental Illness
Signup and view all the flashcards
Hebrew/Israelite View
Hebrew/Israelite View
Signup and view all the flashcards
Greek/Roman View
Greek/Roman View
Signup and view all the flashcards
Sacred Disease
Sacred Disease
Signup and view all the flashcards
Humoralism
Humoralism
Signup and view all the flashcards
Humoral Imbalance
Humoral Imbalance
Signup and view all the flashcards
Hippocrates' Mental Illness Classification
Hippocrates' Mental Illness Classification
Signup and view all the flashcards
Hippocrates' Treatment Approach
Hippocrates' Treatment Approach
Signup and view all the flashcards
Humoral Equilibrium
Humoral Equilibrium
Signup and view all the flashcards
Plato's View of Mental Illness
Plato's View of Mental Illness
Signup and view all the flashcards
Aretaeus & Bipolar Disorder
Aretaeus & Bipolar Disorder
Signup and view all the flashcards
Middle Ages
Middle Ages
Signup and view all the flashcards
Muslim World's Middle Ages View
Muslim World's Middle Ages View
Signup and view all the flashcards
Christian Europe's Middle Ages View
Christian Europe's Middle Ages View
Signup and view all the flashcards
Renaissance Humanism
Renaissance Humanism
Signup and view all the flashcards
Johann Weyer
Johann Weyer
Signup and view all the flashcards
Modern Period (17th-19th Century) Psychiatric Progress
Modern Period (17th-19th Century) Psychiatric Progress
Signup and view all the flashcards
Moral Treatment Movement
Moral Treatment Movement
Signup and view all the flashcards
Pinel's Categories of Insanity
Pinel's Categories of Insanity
Signup and view all the flashcards
Jean-Martin Charcot
Jean-Martin Charcot
Signup and view all the flashcards
Dorothea Dix
Dorothea Dix
Signup and view all the flashcards
Emil Kraepelin
Emil Kraepelin
Signup and view all the flashcards
Sigmund Freud
Sigmund Freud
Signup and view all the flashcards
1918 Statistical Manual
1918 Statistical Manual
Signup and view all the flashcards
DSM-I (1952)
DSM-I (1952)
Signup and view all the flashcards
DSM-III (1980)
DSM-III (1980)
Signup and view all the flashcards
DSM-IV (1994)
DSM-IV (1994)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Study Notes
- Mental illness must be understood as a cultural construct, not a natural fact, according to Foucault and Szasz.
- Sir Martin Roth and Jerome Kroll have argued that the long-term stability of psychiatric symptoms indicates mental illness is a real psychopathological entity.
- The evolution of psychiatry is related to the evolution of civilization.
Prehistoric Period
- Little evidence exists from this time due to a lack of written records.
- Archeologists have discovered trepanned skulls dating back to at least 5000 BC.
- Madness was considered a matter of fate or punishment, dealt with by witch doctors.
- Mental and physical suffering were not distinguished, and medicine, magic, and religion were intertwined.
Ancient Civilizations
- Egyptian and Mesopotamian views attributed mental affliction to demonic possession.
- Incantation was used as treatment, dominated by magic and religion, aiming to reconcile the suffering with the transcendental world.
- In ancient India, angry demons were thought to inhabit the body, causing mental illness.
- Imbalances of bodily fluids were seen as a cause, treated with animistic and exorcistic practices.
- Hebrew and Israelite beliefs connected One God with mental illness, stemming from problems in the relationship between man and God.
- Curing disease was considered an attribute of the Divine.
Ancient Times
- Epilepsy was viewed as an example of mental illness in ancient civilizations.
- Babylonians considered demons attacking the person as the cause.
- Hindu cultures associated the goddess Graphi.
- Greece regarded visions as brought by the Gods and demonic possession as a cause.
The Classical Era
- Elemental conflicts caused mental illness according authors like Homer, Sophocles and Euripides.
- An imbalance in the four humors of the body were also a considered a cause.
The Playwrights
- People driven to insanity by the gods, crushed by destiny, or driven to madness by self-infliction.
- Agony could lead to wisdom.
Hippocrates (460 BC - 370 BC)
- Gods were not held responsible, and medicine was naturalized.
- Epilepsy was not more divine or sacred than other diseases, but had a natural cause.
Humoralism
- Black bile was associated with melancholia, located in the spleen.
- Yellow bile was connected to a choleric temperament, causing one to be easily angered, located in the liver.
- Blood was associated with unstable mood shifts, located in the heart.
- Phlegm was linked to a phlegmatic disposition, associated with being calm, located in the brain.
Hippocrates
- Mental illness comes from an imbalance of the four humours.
- Appropriate treatment depended on which bodily fluid or humour had caused the problem.
- Disease can be cured by using elements opposite to the four fundamental qualities: heat, dryness, moisture, and cold.
- Hippocrates developed the first classification for mental illnesses
The Influence of Hippocrates
- Hippocratic physicians recognized a number of mental illnesses that still exist or are similar to modern conditions
- One of the conditions were classified as mania, melancholy, paranoia, and epilepsy.
Humoralism
- Healthiness is defined by equilibrium. Sickness is defined by the extremes of mania and melancholia.
- Bipolar was a concept ingrained in the minds of educated people.
Plato & Aristotle
- Plato believed their were 2 types of mental illness: One type divinely inspired which gives the person prophetic powers. The other type caused by physical disease.
- Aristotle abandoned the divine explanation of mental illness, attributing it to physical problems..
Return of the Supernatural
- Emperor Constantine officially sanctioned Christianity in the Roman Empire in the 4th C BC..
- This legitimized supernatural beliefs and promoted faith and love and belief in the will of God over reason.
- Holy madness was distinguished from mental illness.
- This had implications for treatments, including religious houses.
Galen (129-200AD)
- The site of the rational soul is the brain.
- Sever emotional disturbance might indicate a lesion in the brain.
- Adopting a single symptom approach rather than broad diagnostic categories.
- Seeking an intergrating force to link mind and body.
- Personality types are based on humours.
Aretaeus of Cappadocia
- Contempary of Galen, Aretaeus is credited with identifying what would later be bipolar disorder.
- Classical period = Madness was rationalized.
Middle Ages (5th to 15th century)
- In the Muslim world, mental disorder was thought be related to a loss of reason.
- People who were mentally disordered were thought of as worthy of humane treatment
- The first psychiatric hospital was founded in Baghdad in 705.
- In Christian Europe, demons came back and diabolic possession.
- Exorcism was treatment for this, including purges, bloodletting, and whipping.
Renaissance (14th to 17th century)
- During this time there was a large humanistic movement, which included the revival of Greek learning.
- The individuality of man served the strivings of man through intellect.
- There was a rejection of withcraft and a push for realism.
- Johann Weyer wrote "On the Illusions of the Demons and on Spells and Poisons" in (1563)
- Weyer criticized Christian witch hurthing and investigated cases of "witchcraft" which became psychiatric descriptions of different mental disorders.
Modern Period (17th to 19th century)
- Reason was emphasized
- The first medical textbook on psychiatry (Felix Platter's Praxix Medica) was published in 1602.
- In the 18th century there was greater classification of mental symptoms.
- There was a skyrocketing of numbers of mental hospitals in Europe in the 19th century.
- The moral treatment movement developed towards the end of the 18th century
- William Tuke (England) (1732-1822) and Hannah Mills (1790) pioneered humane treatment by creating the York Retreat.
- Benjamin Rush (United States) (1745-1813) linked disease to moral therapy.
- Chiarugi (Italy) (1759-1820) said bodily stated influenced the mind via the activites of the senses and the nervous system at large.
- He was known as someone who beieved the mentally ill should be respected as people.
- Pinel (France) (1745-1826) categorized mental illnesses as madness which was a breakdown of internal, rational discipline.
- In 1978 he published an authoritative calssification of diseases called "Nosographie philosophique ou méthode de l'analyse appliquée à la médecine”.
Charcot
- Charcot (1825 – 1893) France was the founder of modern neurology.
- Charcot was a clinical proffesor of the nervous system at the Salpetriere.
- Charcot said that Hysteria was a neurological disorder caused by hereditary problems in the nervious system.
Late 19th to 20th Century
- Dorothy Dix (1802-1887), started the mental of hygene movement which funded 32 state hospitals.
- This was also the 1st generation of American mental asylums.
- Emil Kraepelin (1855-1926) was known for classifying based on symptomatology, which lead to 15 catagories disorder
- This caused organic manic-depressive psychosis (good prognosis) versus dementia praecox (incurable).
- Sigmaud Frued (185--1939), creates a psychoanalytical model which causes non-psychotic disorders.
History of the DSM
- In 1918, the first standardized psychiatric calssification system was created: Statistical Manual fot the use of Institutions for the insane in the US.
- This was needed for an official calssification sustem.
- This also aided the cllection of statistical information.
DSM-I
- DSM-I was released int 1952.
- It was part of the American Physchiatric Association Committee on Nomenclature and Statistics.
- This created descriptions of disgnosistic categories and clinical utility.
- This also reflected psychoanalytical theories.
- There was unclear diagnostic catagories.
DSM-II
- DSM-II was released in 1968.
- It was very similiar to DSM-1
DSM-III
- DSM-III was released in 1980
- It was known for its explicet diagnostice catagories, multiaxial system, and theoretically netual
- It had inconsistencitsand ambiguities.
- 1987: DSM-III-R changed catagories and resolved inconsistencies.
DSM-IV
- DSM-IV was released in 1994.
- It had a three stage emperical process, which had literature reviews, reanalysis of data
- It was simplified by extensive issue-focused field trials
Goals
- All the versions aimed to correct errors
- Ensure information is up-to-date
- Make necessary changes
DSM 5
- DSM-5 was published on May 18, 2013.
- The development of the new edition began with a conference in 1999
- A task force was formed in 2007 which developed and field tested new classifications
- It was not greatly different from DSM IV
- Various authorities have criticized the fifthd edition
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.