Podcast
Questions and Answers
What is the primary motivation of warlords and criminals in their political struggles?
What is the primary motivation of warlords and criminals in their political struggles?
- To secure economic and commercial privileges (correct)
- To instigate social reforms
- To uphold socio-political agendas
- To establish military dominance
How do terrorists primarily differ in their approach compared to guerrilla movements?
How do terrorists primarily differ in their approach compared to guerrilla movements?
- They use physical violence only.
- They pursue economic gains exclusively.
- They aim at political power and territory.
- They focus more on psychological techniques. (correct)
What role do mercenaries and marauders primarily play in armed conflicts?
What role do mercenaries and marauders primarily play in armed conflicts?
- They engage mainly in physical violence for intimidation. (correct)
- They prioritize ideological motivations.
- They serve largely political interests.
- They focus on community defense.
Which statement best captures the ambivalence of militias and warlords regarding violence?
Which statement best captures the ambivalence of militias and warlords regarding violence?
What distinguishes guerrilla movements from warlords and criminals in terms of motivations?
What distinguishes guerrilla movements from warlords and criminals in terms of motivations?
What is a characteristic of armed non-state actors?
What is a characteristic of armed non-state actors?
What is one potential strategy to reduce the capacities of armed non-state actors as 'spoilers'?
What is one potential strategy to reduce the capacities of armed non-state actors as 'spoilers'?
Which group is specifically identified as pursuing political, social-revolutionary, or ethno-nationalistic agendas?
Which group is specifically identified as pursuing political, social-revolutionary, or ethno-nationalistic agendas?
How can state officials be involved with armed non-state actors?
How can state officials be involved with armed non-state actors?
What effect do armed non-state actors have on security governance in fragile states?
What effect do armed non-state actors have on security governance in fragile states?
How might rebels or guerrilla fighters portray themselves to gain protection under international law?
How might rebels or guerrilla fighters portray themselves to gain protection under international law?
What is a primary factor differentiating various types of armed non-state actors?
What is a primary factor differentiating various types of armed non-state actors?
In what context is understanding armed non-state actors particularly important?
In what context is understanding armed non-state actors particularly important?
Which type of non-state actor typically seeks to change the existing government or political system?
Which type of non-state actor typically seeks to change the existing government or political system?
What motivation commonly drives warlords and criminals in their actions?
What motivation commonly drives warlords and criminals in their actions?
Which group primarily behaves opportunistically, serving both status quo forces and challenging them?
Which group primarily behaves opportunistically, serving both status quo forces and challenging them?
Terrorists generally have which type of aspirations concerning territory?
Terrorists generally have which type of aspirations concerning territory?
What type of violence do rebels and guerrilla movements primarily engage in?
What type of violence do rebels and guerrilla movements primarily engage in?
Militia organizations may be assigned special tasks other than territorial control. Which of the following is an example of such a task?
Militia organizations may be assigned special tasks other than territorial control. Which of the following is an example of such a task?
Which of these actors is more likely to operate within a defined territory?
Which of these actors is more likely to operate within a defined territory?
What distinguishes militias from mercenaries regarding their primary purpose?
What distinguishes militias from mercenaries regarding their primary purpose?
What is a common result of collective learning among armed non-state actors?
What is a common result of collective learning among armed non-state actors?
Which strategy involves offering material incentives to armed non-state actors?
Which strategy involves offering material incentives to armed non-state actors?
What is a potential benefit of granting amnesty to non-state actors?
What is a potential benefit of granting amnesty to non-state actors?
What is the aim of the containment and marginalisation strategy?
What is the aim of the containment and marginalisation strategy?
Which group is most likely to respond positively to bribery as a strategy?
Which group is most likely to respond positively to bribery as a strategy?
What is a necessary condition for effective containment and marginalisation?
What is a necessary condition for effective containment and marginalisation?
In what context might amnesty be more appealing to certain armed groups?
In what context might amnesty be more appealing to certain armed groups?
Which strategy is regarded as politically and normatively questionable?
Which strategy is regarded as politically and normatively questionable?
What is one potential negative outcome of fragmenting armed groups into more moderate forces and hardliners?
What is one potential negative outcome of fragmenting armed groups into more moderate forces and hardliners?
What is a common method used in coercion by international actors?
What is a common method used in coercion by international actors?
What must the international community be prepared for when implementing coercive measures?
What must the international community be prepared for when implementing coercive measures?
Why is it challenging for the international community to provide long-term support for state-building processes?
Why is it challenging for the international community to provide long-term support for state-building processes?
What are some instruments of coercive measures used by international actors?
What are some instruments of coercive measures used by international actors?
What does the term 'political capital' refer to in the context of addressing armed non-state actors?
What does the term 'political capital' refer to in the context of addressing armed non-state actors?
In what way can involvement in a political process help in addressing armed groups?
In what way can involvement in a political process help in addressing armed groups?
What is a reason that limits the mobilization of resources for addressing armed non-state actors?
What is a reason that limits the mobilization of resources for addressing armed non-state actors?
Who was the Brazilian author known for his influence on guerrilla tactics?
Who was the Brazilian author known for his influence on guerrilla tactics?
Which group was founded by Carlos Marighela?
Which group was founded by Carlos Marighela?
Which of the following regions is NOT mentioned as having clan-based societies?
Which of the following regions is NOT mentioned as having clan-based societies?
What type of groups does the content specifically exclude?
What type of groups does the content specifically exclude?
The pro-Indonesian group 'Besi Merah Putih' operated in which region?
The pro-Indonesian group 'Besi Merah Putih' operated in which region?
Which term describes local power structures in tribal societies that are often linked to conflict?
Which term describes local power structures in tribal societies that are often linked to conflict?
What group is known for violent actions against Kurdish populations?
What group is known for violent actions against Kurdish populations?
In which country are the Tuaregs predominantly located?
In which country are the Tuaregs predominantly located?
Flashcards
Armed Non-State Actors
Armed Non-State Actors
Armed groups who actively engage in violence to achieve their goals, but are independent from formal state institutions like the military or police.
Fragile Statehood
Fragile Statehood
A state characterized by weak institutions, a lack of control over its territory, and a failure to provide basic services to its citizens.
Security Governance
Security Governance
The ways in which security is managed and enforced within a state, particularly in relation to non-state actors, particularly in the context of fragile states.
Warlords and Criminals (Economic Motivations)
Warlords and Criminals (Economic Motivations)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Rebels/Guerrilla fighters
Rebels/Guerrilla fighters
Signup and view all the flashcards
Guerrillas and Militias (Political Motives)
Guerrillas and Militias (Political Motives)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Spoilers
Spoilers
Signup and view all the flashcards
Marauders and Criminals (Violence as Intimidation)
Marauders and Criminals (Violence as Intimidation)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Capacity for Violence
Capacity for Violence
Signup and view all the flashcards
Typology of Armed Non-State Actors
Typology of Armed Non-State Actors
Signup and view all the flashcards
Clan Chiefs and Mercenaries (Physical Violence)
Clan Chiefs and Mercenaries (Physical Violence)
Signup and view all the flashcards
State Support for Armed Non-State Actors
State Support for Armed Non-State Actors
Signup and view all the flashcards
Militias and Warlords (Flexible Violence)
Militias and Warlords (Flexible Violence)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Change orientation
Change orientation
Signup and view all the flashcards
Status quo orientation
Status quo orientation
Signup and view all the flashcards
Territorial ambitions
Territorial ambitions
Signup and view all the flashcards
Non-territorial ambitions
Non-territorial ambitions
Signup and view all the flashcards
Physical violence
Physical violence
Signup and view all the flashcards
Psychological violence
Psychological violence
Signup and view all the flashcards
Rebel and guerrilla movements
Rebel and guerrilla movements
Signup and view all the flashcards
Mercenaries
Mercenaries
Signup and view all the flashcards
Socialisation of Non-State Actors
Socialisation of Non-State Actors
Signup and view all the flashcards
Collective Learning of Armed Actors
Collective Learning of Armed Actors
Signup and view all the flashcards
Bribery in Peacebuilding
Bribery in Peacebuilding
Signup and view all the flashcards
Amnesty in Fragile States
Amnesty in Fragile States
Signup and view all the flashcards
Containment & Marginalization
Containment & Marginalization
Signup and view all the flashcards
Containing Armed Actors
Containing Armed Actors
Signup and view all the flashcards
Peacebuilding Consensus
Peacebuilding Consensus
Signup and view all the flashcards
Ignoring Violent Provocations
Ignoring Violent Provocations
Signup and view all the flashcards
Fragile State
Fragile State
Signup and view all the flashcards
Rebel Group
Rebel Group
Signup and view all the flashcards
Warlord or Criminal Group
Warlord or Criminal Group
Signup and view all the flashcards
Local Militias
Local Militias
Signup and view all the flashcards
Local Armed Groups
Local Armed Groups
Signup and view all the flashcards
Enforcing Splits and Internal Rivalry
Enforcing Splits and Internal Rivalry
Signup and view all the flashcards
Coercion
Coercion
Signup and view all the flashcards
Military/Police Operations
Military/Police Operations
Signup and view all the flashcards
Deployment of International Troops
Deployment of International Troops
Signup and view all the flashcards
International Sanctions
International Sanctions
Signup and view all the flashcards
Focus on Emergencies and Crises
Focus on Emergencies and Crises
Signup and view all the flashcards
Limited Resources
Limited Resources
Signup and view all the flashcards
Political Commitment
Political Commitment
Signup and view all the flashcards
Study Notes
Fragile Statehood, Armed Non-State Actors and Security Governance
- The state has a dual function: maintaining domestic order within its territory and creating a global order.
- Ineffective, weak, failing, or failed states (fragile statehood) undermine both functions and cause problems nationally, regionally, and globally.
- Fragile statehood is primarily a problem for governance within a state, and also for regional and global governance.
- Until the early 2000s, fragile statehood was mainly of concern to development experts and agencies, only becoming a significant security issue after 9/11.
- The concept of fragile statehood is now a major concern for security issues including issues such as the spread of AIDS and other epidemics, disaster prevention, poverty, resource distribution, and conflicts.
- The UN report, 2004, identified 6 issues directly related to fragile statehood: economic, social, and ecological threats, interstate conflicts, intrastate conflicts, nuclear/radiological/biological/chemical weapons proliferation, terrorism, and transnational organized crime.
- The US and EU have recognised failing and failed states as security threats.
- Fragile states provide enabling factors, or catalysts for potential threats, and are obstructions to solving global security issues.
A Typology of Armed Non-State Actors
- Armed non-state actors are those willing and able to use violence outside of formal state institutions.
- Rebels/Guerrilla Fighters: fight for regime change, territorial secession, or end of occupation. Methods are typically non-confrontational guerrilla warfare in rural/mountainous areas. Support often comes from foreign governments.
- Militias/Paramilitaries: local authorities, often created/funded by the state to combat other groups. Employ violence and may engage in human rights abuses.
- Clan Chiefs/Big Men: traditional leaders of a tribe, clan, ethnic, or religious group. Control a territory; control a local area.
- Warlords: Local strongmen who control territory during/after conflict. Gain power through private armies and resource control. Often seek to formalize their rule.
- Terrorists: Use violence to achieve political goals, ideologically motivated, and widely dispersed.
- Criminals: Organized groups engaging in illegal activity, often influencing politics to protect interests.
- Mercenaries/Private Security Companies (PSCs): Volunteers, often with specific expertise, paid to fight in conflicts.
- Marauders: Demobilized combatants engaging in looting, pillaging, and terrorizing civilians. Often have low organizational cohesion.
Dealing with Armed Non-State Actors
- Strategies for managing armed non-state actors include:
- Negotiation: Facilitators/mediators encourage de-escalation and compromise.
- Socialisation: Instilling shared norms and rules for armed actors to follow.
- Bribery: Offering incentives to stop violence.
- Amnesty: Offering pardon for past actions to encourage surrender.
- Containment: Isolating actors from followers/supporters.
- Enforcing Splits: Creating divisions within groups.
- Coercion: using force to end violence (threat or actual intervention).
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.