Podcast
Questions and Answers
What was a key recommendation of the Acworth Committee regarding Railway Finances?
What was a key recommendation of the Acworth Committee regarding Railway Finances?
- Finance Department should maintain control over railway budgets.
- The railway budget should be overseen by the Finance Member of the Council.
- The railways should prepare a separate budget and manage their own finances. (correct)
- Railways should rely on the Government for financial audits.
What decision was made by the Government of India regarding the separation of Railway Finances?
What decision was made by the Government of India regarding the separation of Railway Finances?
- A Convention resolution was laid before Legislative Assembly. (correct)
- It was rejected entirely without consideration.
- Separation was achieved through an Act of Parliament.
- They decided to enhance the control of the Finance Department.
Which year did the Legislative Assembly vote on the Convention resolution proposed by the Government regarding Railway Finances?
Which year did the Legislative Assembly vote on the Convention resolution proposed by the Government regarding Railway Finances?
- 1920
- 1924 (correct)
- 1929
- 2017
What significant change occurred in 2017 concerning Railway Finances?
What significant change occurred in 2017 concerning Railway Finances?
When was the Financial Commissioner for Railways appointed?
When was the Financial Commissioner for Railways appointed?
What was the scope of the financial administration before the appointment of the Financial Commissioner for Railways?
What was the scope of the financial administration before the appointment of the Financial Commissioner for Railways?
What document governs the presentation of a separate Demand for Grants for the Ministry of Railways?
What document governs the presentation of a separate Demand for Grants for the Ministry of Railways?
In which stage was the separation of accounting and auditing functions completed on the Railways?
In which stage was the separation of accounting and auditing functions completed on the Railways?
Who was responsible for the accounting work of the railways prior to the appointment of the Financial Commissioner?
Who was responsible for the accounting work of the railways prior to the appointment of the Financial Commissioner?
What is the primary responsibility of the Financial Adviser & Chief Accounts Officer regarding the General Manager?
What is the primary responsibility of the Financial Adviser & Chief Accounts Officer regarding the General Manager?
Which of the following best describes the current role of the Finance Officer?
Which of the following best describes the current role of the Finance Officer?
What does the Finance Branch primarily assist the Railway Administration with?
What does the Finance Branch primarily assist the Railway Administration with?
How has the role of the Financial Adviser & Chief Accounts Officer evolved over time?
How has the role of the Financial Adviser & Chief Accounts Officer evolved over time?
Which of the following aspects does the Financial Adviser & Chief Accounts Officer NOT have special responsibility for?
Which of the following aspects does the Financial Adviser & Chief Accounts Officer NOT have special responsibility for?
In what way is the work of the Finance Branch seen as comparable to that of a Management Accountant?
In what way is the work of the Finance Branch seen as comparable to that of a Management Accountant?
What significant change occurred to the post of Accountant General, Railways?
What significant change occurred to the post of Accountant General, Railways?
What significant emphasis is placed on the Financial Adviser & Chief Accounts Officer's role after the delegation of the Accounts Department?
What significant emphasis is placed on the Financial Adviser & Chief Accounts Officer's role after the delegation of the Accounts Department?
Who was the Chief Accounts Officer answerable to after the separation of functions at the Railway level?
Who was the Chief Accounts Officer answerable to after the separation of functions at the Railway level?
Which statement regarding the financial implications in railway operations is correct?
Which statement regarding the financial implications in railway operations is correct?
What is NOT part of the Finance Branch's functions?
What is NOT part of the Finance Branch's functions?
Which committee recommended the organizational changes in the Railway Accounts Department?
Which committee recommended the organizational changes in the Railway Accounts Department?
What was the new title given to the Chief Accounts Officer after organizational changes?
What was the new title given to the Chief Accounts Officer after organizational changes?
What allowed the Financial Adviser & Chief Accounts Officer to access the Financial Commissioner?
What allowed the Financial Adviser & Chief Accounts Officer to access the Financial Commissioner?
When was the arrangement made permanent for all Government Railways?
When was the arrangement made permanent for all Government Railways?
What was instituted under the Financial Adviser & Chief Accounts Officer?
What was instituted under the Financial Adviser & Chief Accounts Officer?
Which railway was the Finance Branch scheme first initiated as an experimental measure?
Which railway was the Finance Branch scheme first initiated as an experimental measure?
What primary purpose did the organizational changes serve?
What primary purpose did the organizational changes serve?
How were the organizational changes viewed initially?
How were the organizational changes viewed initially?
What is one of the main responsibilities of the Financial Adviser & Chief Accounts Officer?
What is one of the main responsibilities of the Financial Adviser & Chief Accounts Officer?
Who assists the Financial Adviser & Chief Accounts Officer at the Headquarters office?
Who assists the Financial Adviser & Chief Accounts Officer at the Headquarters office?
What is the main function of the Deputy Financial Adviser in relation to the budget?
What is the main function of the Deputy Financial Adviser in relation to the budget?
Which of the following statements represents a scenario where a proposal may require reference to the Railway Board?
Which of the following statements represents a scenario where a proposal may require reference to the Railway Board?
At which level are the financial functions combined with internal check functions?
At which level are the financial functions combined with internal check functions?
How many separate Railway Administrations were operating in India at the dawn of the 20th Century?
How many separate Railway Administrations were operating in India at the dawn of the 20th Century?
What was the main role of the Railway Branch of the Public Works Department?
What was the main role of the Railway Branch of the Public Works Department?
Who was appointed as Special Commissioner for Indian Railways in 1901?
Who was appointed as Special Commissioner for Indian Railways in 1901?
What did Sir Thomas Robertson recommend for the administration of Indian Railways?
What did Sir Thomas Robertson recommend for the administration of Indian Railways?
What was the total length of Railway lines operated by the Railway Administrations in India?
What was the total length of Railway lines operated by the Railway Administrations in India?
Which entities were responsible for operating four of the thirty-three Railway Administrations?
Which entities were responsible for operating four of the thirty-three Railway Administrations?
Who assisted the head of the Railway Branch in its administrative functions?
Who assisted the head of the Railway Branch in its administrative functions?
What is the primary responsibility of the Financial Adviser & Chief Accounts Officer concerning the budget?
What is the primary responsibility of the Financial Adviser & Chief Accounts Officer concerning the budget?
Under what circumstance must a proposal be referred to the Railway Board?
Under what circumstance must a proposal be referred to the Railway Board?
Which role does the Deputy Financial Adviser primarily hold within the financial framework?
Which role does the Deputy Financial Adviser primarily hold within the financial framework?
How are financial scrutiny functions organized at the Unit level?
How are financial scrutiny functions organized at the Unit level?
What aspect is essential for the success of the Finance Branch?
What aspect is essential for the success of the Finance Branch?
What is one of the key responsibilities of the Financial Adviser & Chief Accounts Officer regarding disagreements with the General Manager?
What is one of the key responsibilities of the Financial Adviser & Chief Accounts Officer regarding disagreements with the General Manager?
Which of the following best describes the evolution of the role of the Finance Officer in the Railway Administration?
Which of the following best describes the evolution of the role of the Finance Officer in the Railway Administration?
What broad functions does the Finance Branch serve within the Railway Administration?
What broad functions does the Finance Branch serve within the Railway Administration?
How does the Financial Adviser & Chief Accounts Officer's responsibility extend beyond accounting propriety?
How does the Financial Adviser & Chief Accounts Officer's responsibility extend beyond accounting propriety?
What role does the Finance Branch play in relation to decision-making within the Railway Administration?
What role does the Finance Branch play in relation to decision-making within the Railway Administration?
What is a critical aspect of the Finance Branch's functions in a business model?
What is a critical aspect of the Finance Branch's functions in a business model?
Why is the stipulation regarding the Financial Adviser & Chief Accounts Officer still considered valid?
Why is the stipulation regarding the Financial Adviser & Chief Accounts Officer still considered valid?
Which of the following does NOT fall under the responsibilities of the Finance Branch?
Which of the following does NOT fall under the responsibilities of the Finance Branch?
In the context of financial management, what does the term 'management participation' imply for the Finance Officer?
In the context of financial management, what does the term 'management participation' imply for the Finance Officer?
Which statement reflects the primary function of the Financial Adviser & Chief Accounts Officer within the Railway system?
Which statement reflects the primary function of the Financial Adviser & Chief Accounts Officer within the Railway system?
What was a significant inconsistency noted by the Government of India regarding the Acworth Committee's recommendation?
What was a significant inconsistency noted by the Government of India regarding the Acworth Committee's recommendation?
In which year did the Legislative Assembly vote on the Convention resolution concerning Railway Finances?
In which year did the Legislative Assembly vote on the Convention resolution concerning Railway Finances?
What was the role of the Financial Commissioner appointed in April 1923?
What was the role of the Financial Commissioner appointed in April 1923?
What stage was characterized by the completion of separation of accounting and auditing functions within the Railways?
What stage was characterized by the completion of separation of accounting and auditing functions within the Railways?
Which year marked the merger of the Railway Budget with the Union Budget?
Which year marked the merger of the Railway Budget with the Union Budget?
What primary function was retained by the Ministry of Railways after its budgets were included in the Union Budget?
What primary function was retained by the Ministry of Railways after its budgets were included in the Union Budget?
What document was utilized for the presentation of a single Appropriation Bill for the Ministry of Railways?
What document was utilized for the presentation of a single Appropriation Bill for the Ministry of Railways?
Which financial stage involved the administrative controller of the Auditor General prior to the appointment of the Financial Commissioner?
Which financial stage involved the administrative controller of the Auditor General prior to the appointment of the Financial Commissioner?
What was the purpose of the Acworth Committee's recommendation on Railway Finances?
What was the purpose of the Acworth Committee's recommendation on Railway Finances?
What role was introduced to ensure coordination between the General Manager and the Chief Accounts Officer?
What role was introduced to ensure coordination between the General Manager and the Chief Accounts Officer?
Which committee recommended the administrative control change over the Railway Accounts Department?
Which committee recommended the administrative control change over the Railway Accounts Department?
Which two State Railways were initially chosen for experimenting with the new arrangements in 1938?
Which two State Railways were initially chosen for experimenting with the new arrangements in 1938?
At what organizational stage was the Finance Branch established under the Financial Adviser & Chief Accounts Officer?
At what organizational stage was the Finance Branch established under the Financial Adviser & Chief Accounts Officer?
What was the primary objective of placing the Railway Accounts Department under the General Manager?
What was the primary objective of placing the Railway Accounts Department under the General Manager?
What significant change did the Financial Adviser & Chief Accounts Officer bring to the management of Railway finances?
What significant change did the Financial Adviser & Chief Accounts Officer bring to the management of Railway finances?
What was a prerequisite for the Financial Adviser & Chief Accounts Officer to coordinate with the Financial Commissioner?
What was a prerequisite for the Financial Adviser & Chief Accounts Officer to coordinate with the Financial Commissioner?
Which stage marked the complete separation of accounting and auditing functions on the Railways?
Which stage marked the complete separation of accounting and auditing functions on the Railways?
What was the initial approach to the reorganization of the Railway Accounts Department in 1938?
What was the initial approach to the reorganization of the Railway Accounts Department in 1938?
What was the main structure of oversight for the Non-Government Railways in India at the dawn of the 20th Century?
What was the main structure of oversight for the Non-Government Railways in India at the dawn of the 20th Century?
What was the recommended composition of the Railway Board according to Sir Thomas Robertson's report?
What was the recommended composition of the Railway Board according to Sir Thomas Robertson's report?
How many separate Railway Administrations were active in India during the early 1900s?
How many separate Railway Administrations were active in India during the early 1900s?
What was the primary responsibility of the Secretary of State for India in relation to the Indian Railways in 1901?
What was the primary responsibility of the Secretary of State for India in relation to the Indian Railways in 1901?
What role did the Accountant General of the Public Works Department play in the Railway system?
What role did the Accountant General of the Public Works Department play in the Railway system?
What was a significant aspect of the regulatory framework for the Railways during the early 20th Century?
What was a significant aspect of the regulatory framework for the Railways during the early 20th Century?
Which recommendations were made by Sir Thomas Robertson regarding the qualifications of members of the Railway Board?
Which recommendations were made by Sir Thomas Robertson regarding the qualifications of members of the Railway Board?
Flashcards
Early Railway Administration India
Early Railway Administration India
At the start of the 20th century, India had 33 separate railway administrations, split between government, princely states, and private companies.
Early Railway Control
Early Railway Control
Non-government railways were overseen by the Indian government's Railway Branch of the Public Works Department.
Sir Thomas Robertson's Role
Sir Thomas Robertson's Role
Sir Thomas Robertson conducted an inquiry into Indian railway administration and recommended a Railway Board.
Railway Board Composition
Railway Board Composition
Signup and view all the flashcards
Government Supervision
Government Supervision
Signup and view all the flashcards
Indian Railway Organization
Indian Railway Organization
Signup and view all the flashcards
Railway Accounting
Railway Accounting
Signup and view all the flashcards
Acworth Committee Recommendation
Acworth Committee Recommendation
Signup and view all the flashcards
Railway Finance Separation (1924)
Railway Finance Separation (1924)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Railway Budget Merged (2017)
Railway Budget Merged (2017)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Stage I of Railway Finance
Stage I of Railway Finance
Signup and view all the flashcards
Stage II of Railway Finance
Stage II of Railway Finance
Signup and view all the flashcards
Stage III of Railway Finance
Stage III of Railway Finance
Signup and view all the flashcards
Financial Commissioner for Railways
Financial Commissioner for Railways
Signup and view all the flashcards
Convention Resolution (1924)
Convention Resolution (1924)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Government of India Act of 1919
Government of India Act of 1919
Signup and view all the flashcards
Financial Adviser & Chief Accounts Officer Role
Financial Adviser & Chief Accounts Officer Role
Signup and view all the flashcards
Budgetary Control
Budgetary Control
Signup and view all the flashcards
Mutual Confidence & Consultation
Mutual Confidence & Consultation
Signup and view all the flashcards
Financial Scrutiny at Unit Level
Financial Scrutiny at Unit Level
Signup and view all the flashcards
Financial Scrutiny - General Manager's Authority
Financial Scrutiny - General Manager's Authority
Signup and view all the flashcards
Controller of Railway Accounts
Controller of Railway Accounts
Signup and view all the flashcards
Director of Railway Audit
Director of Railway Audit
Signup and view all the flashcards
Chief Accounts Officer
Chief Accounts Officer
Signup and view all the flashcards
Chief Auditor
Chief Auditor
Signup and view all the flashcards
Indian Railway Accounts Service
Indian Railway Accounts Service
Signup and view all the flashcards
Financial Adviser & Chief Accounts Officer
Financial Adviser & Chief Accounts Officer
Signup and view all the flashcards
Financial Adviser and Chief Accounts Officer
Financial Adviser and Chief Accounts Officer
Signup and view all the flashcards
Wedgwood Committee (Indian Railway Enquiry Committee, 1937)
Wedgwood Committee (Indian Railway Enquiry Committee, 1937)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Finance Branch
Finance Branch
Signup and view all the flashcards
Experimental Measure
Experimental Measure
Signup and view all the flashcards
Financial Advice in Railway Administration
Financial Advice in Railway Administration
Signup and view all the flashcards
FACAO's Role in Tendering Advice
FACAO's Role in Tendering Advice
Signup and view all the flashcards
Financial Prudence & Propriety in Railways
Financial Prudence & Propriety in Railways
Signup and view all the flashcards
Finance Branch's Functions in Railway Management
Finance Branch's Functions in Railway Management
Signup and view all the flashcards
Evolution of the Finance Officer's Role
Evolution of the Finance Officer's Role
Signup and view all the flashcards
Financial Implications in Rail Transportation
Financial Implications in Rail Transportation
Signup and view all the flashcards
Finance Branch: Management Accountant's Role
Finance Branch: Management Accountant's Role
Signup and view all the flashcards
Rational Planning and Decision Making
Rational Planning and Decision Making
Signup and view all the flashcards
Control Over Railway Operations
Control Over Railway Operations
Signup and view all the flashcards
Financial Responsibility Across Railway Areas
Financial Responsibility Across Railway Areas
Signup and view all the flashcards
Sir Thomas Robertson's Inquiry
Sir Thomas Robertson's Inquiry
Signup and view all the flashcards
Railway Finances & the Government
Railway Finances & the Government
Signup and view all the flashcards
Acworth Committee & Separate Finances
Acworth Committee & Separate Finances
Signup and view all the flashcards
Evolution of Financial Control
Evolution of Financial Control
Signup and view all the flashcards
Financial Implications in Railway Decisions
Financial Implications in Railway Decisions
Signup and view all the flashcards
Wedgwood Committee (1937)
Wedgwood Committee (1937)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Accountant General, Railways Replaced
Accountant General, Railways Replaced
Signup and view all the flashcards
Separation at Railway Level
Separation at Railway Level
Signup and view all the flashcards
Wedgwood Committee's Recommendation
Wedgwood Committee's Recommendation
Signup and view all the flashcards
Chief Accounts Officer's New Role
Chief Accounts Officer's New Role
Signup and view all the flashcards
Financial Adviser & Chief Accounts Officer's Access
Financial Adviser & Chief Accounts Officer's Access
Signup and view all the flashcards
Financial Adviser & Chief Accounts Officer's Responsibilities
Financial Adviser & Chief Accounts Officer's Responsibilities
Signup and view all the flashcards
Finance Branch's Purpose
Finance Branch's Purpose
Signup and view all the flashcards
Financial Adviser & Chief Accounts Officer (FACAO)
Financial Adviser & Chief Accounts Officer (FACAO)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Why is the FACAO's role important?
Why is the FACAO's role important?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What happens when the FACAO disagrees with the General Manager?
What happens when the FACAO disagrees with the General Manager?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is the Finance Branch's primary function?
What is the Finance Branch's primary function?
Signup and view all the flashcards
How does the Finance Branch assist the Railway Administration?
How does the Finance Branch assist the Railway Administration?
Signup and view all the flashcards
How has the Finance Officer's role changed?
How has the Finance Officer's role changed?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Why are financial considerations important in rail transportation?
Why are financial considerations important in rail transportation?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is the analogy between the Finance Branch and a Management Accountant?
What is the analogy between the Finance Branch and a Management Accountant?
Signup and view all the flashcards
How does the Finance Branch contribute to rational planning and decision-making?
How does the Finance Branch contribute to rational planning and decision-making?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is the Finance Branch's role in controlling railway operations?
What is the Finance Branch's role in controlling railway operations?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Study Notes
Financial Organization Historical Background
-
Evolution of financial organization on railroads in India
- Early 20th century, 33 separate railway administrations existed
- Operated 41,000 route kilometers
- 4 government-owned, 5 Indian state-owned, 24 private companies
- Private companies under government supervision and control
- Public Works Department (PWD) handled regulation
- Railway Branch of PWD headed by an ICS officer, part of Viceroy and Governor General's council, assisted by staff
- Staff included: secretaries, deputy secretaries, under-secretaries, assistant secretaries
-
1901: Sir Thomas Robertson appointed as a Special Commissioner to investigate and report on Indian Railways' administration and functioning.
-
Recommendations: Railway Board consisting of a President, 2 Commissioners (with Railway experience) to be assisted by a secretary, and other personnel.
-
1905 (early): Railway Branch of PWD abolished, Railway systems transferred to a Railway Board (Chairman & 2 members).
-
Railway Board under the Department of Commerce and Industry.
-
1908 (later): Railway Board reorganization, distinct from Commerce & Industry, under the same member of the Viceroy and Governor General's Executive Council.
-
Chairman's position changed to President with direct access to the Viceroy/Governor-General.
-
Accounts and civil audit establishments merged under the Finance Member of the Government of India.
-
1923: The Financial Commissioner for Railways appointed by Secretary of State.
- Objective: economy in public expenditure, co-ordination with general financial policy.
-
1921: Acworth Committee's recommendations on Railway Finances
-
1924: Separation Convention, separation of railways financial details from general government finances.
-
Recommendation that specific railway finance be controlled and monitored by railway finance independent of general government finances.
-
Railway Budget merged into Union Budget (2017)
-
Financial Organization Stages on Railways (5 stages)
- Stage 1: Prior to financial commissioner, finance under PWD/finance.
- Stage 2: Appointment of the Financial Commissioner(1923)
- Stage 3: Separation of accounting/auditing functions (1929)
- Stage 4: Place of Railway accounts department under General Manager (1937)
- Stage 5: Finance Branch under Financial Advisor (1947)
-
Financial Organization structure
- Accountant General
- Financial Commissioner
- Chief Accounts Officer
-
Financial functions & responsibilities
- Assist the Railway Administration in financial implications -Financial Prudence and financial propriety -Scrutinizing proposals
-
Financial oversight delegated
- Railway Board/President
- General Manager
- Officers
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.
Related Documents
Description
Explore the historical evolution of financial organization in the Indian railroads during the early 20th century. This quiz covers the transition from multiple railway administrations to the establishment of a centralized Railway Board and the regulatory role of the Public Works Department. Test your knowledge on key events and figures that shaped the financial governance of Indian Railways.