Podcast
Questions and Answers
What distinguishes an interventional study from an observational study?
What distinguishes an interventional study from an observational study?
Which statement correctly describes case-control studies?
Which statement correctly describes case-control studies?
Why are observational studies considered less compelling than randomized controlled trials?
Why are observational studies considered less compelling than randomized controlled trials?
What was a significant outcome demonstrated by the case-control study conducted by Sir Richard Doll?
What was a significant outcome demonstrated by the case-control study conducted by Sir Richard Doll?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the primary goal of the Nurses’ Health Study initiated in 1976?
What is the primary goal of the Nurses’ Health Study initiated in 1976?
Signup and view all the answers
Which characteristic is essential for defining a cohort in a cohort study?
Which characteristic is essential for defining a cohort in a cohort study?
Signup and view all the answers
In which type of study do investigators primarily observe associations rather than causal relationships?
In which type of study do investigators primarily observe associations rather than causal relationships?
Signup and view all the answers
What is a significant limitation of cohort studies mentioned in the content?
What is a significant limitation of cohort studies mentioned in the content?
Signup and view all the answers
What aspect of cohort studies helps reduce recall error?
What aspect of cohort studies helps reduce recall error?
Signup and view all the answers
What is one reason cohort studies are often undertaken?
What is one reason cohort studies are often undertaken?
Signup and view all the answers
What was the primary focus of the cancer prevention clinical trials mentioned?
What was the primary focus of the cancer prevention clinical trials mentioned?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the primary aim of cancer prevention clinical trials?
What is the primary aim of cancer prevention clinical trials?
Signup and view all the answers
Which dietary factor was included in both Phase I and Phase II trials targeting prostate cancer?
Which dietary factor was included in both Phase I and Phase II trials targeting prostate cancer?
Signup and view all the answers
What outcome did the study by Clark et al. achieve regarding colorectal cancer incidence?
What outcome did the study by Clark et al. achieve regarding colorectal cancer incidence?
Signup and view all the answers
Which phase of cancer prevention trials is primarily concerned with determining the optimal dose?
Which phase of cancer prevention trials is primarily concerned with determining the optimal dose?
Signup and view all the answers
Which trial had the largest number of patients and involved Tamoxifen/raloxifene for breast cancer?
Which trial had the largest number of patients and involved Tamoxifen/raloxifene for breast cancer?
Signup and view all the answers
What have epidemiologic studies indicated about lifestyle factors and cancer risk?
What have epidemiologic studies indicated about lifestyle factors and cancer risk?
Signup and view all the answers
What was the primary result reported in the Baron et al. study regarding adenoma incidence?
What was the primary result reported in the Baron et al. study regarding adenoma incidence?
Signup and view all the answers
What percentage of cancer deaths in men is linked to overweight and obesity according to recent studies?
What percentage of cancer deaths in men is linked to overweight and obesity according to recent studies?
Signup and view all the answers
Which type of trial allows patients to access experimental therapies prior to final FDA approval?
Which type of trial allows patients to access experimental therapies prior to final FDA approval?
Signup and view all the answers
Study Notes
Additional Types of Clinical Research in Oncology
- Clinical trials are classified by the researchers' approach.
- Observational studies involve observing subjects and measuring outcomes without managing the experiment. An example is the Nurses' Health Study.
- Interventional studies involve giving subjects a medicine or intervention and comparing them to control groups. Researchers then measure how subjects' health changes.
Study Designs
- Evidence-based medicine uses observational studies and randomized controlled trials to derive conclusions.
- Cohort studies and case-control studies are examples of observational studies.
- Observational studies identify correlations between treatments and health status.
Case-control studies
- Case-control studies compare subjects with a condition to similar subjects without the condition.
- They are inexpensive and often used in individual or small teams of researchers.
- Their retrospective and non-randomized nature limits conclusions.
- Case-control studies were instrumental in demonstrating the link between tobacco smoking and lung cancer, although they cannot prove causation.
Cohort Studies
- A cohort is a group of people with a shared characteristic or experience.
- The comparison group may be the general population or a similar cohort with less exposure.
- Cohort studies investigate a suspected association between cause and disease.
- A major advantage of cohort studies is that the cohort is identified before the appearance of the disease.
- Longitudinal data collection over time reduces recall error.
- Cohort studies are costly and time-consuming as they require longitudinal observations and data collection at regular intervals.
The Nurses' Health Study
- The Nurses' Health Study (NHS) is an observational cohort study that aims to avoid biases in retrospective studies and evaluate oral contraceptives.
- The study began in 1976 and enrolled over 121,700 women aged 30 to 55 to investigate the long-term health consequences of oral contraceptives.
- The study has collected data on various lifestyle factors and stored specimens (blood, DNA, tumor samples) during its 29-year span.
- It is used to progress understanding of cancer causes and prevention possibilities.
The Nurses' Health Study (cont.)
- The NHS is the initial large-scale prospective study of women that has updated exposure assessment for various factors.
- It analyzes overall risks and benefits of lifestyle factors, chronic conditions, and mortality in relation to various cancers.
- The study found a link between alcohol intake and increased breast cancer risk.
- It also found that long-term multivitamin containing folate use is associated with a reduced risk of colon cancer.
- The NHS has also linked estrogen and testosterone levels to a boosted breast cancer risk in postmenopausal women.
Timeline - Evolution of the Nurses' Health Study
- The Nurses' Health Study began with a questionnaire mailed to participants in 1976.
- The study has continued collecting data and samples since that time.
Implications for prevention from the Women's Health Study
- Lifestyle choices can prevent around 50% of cancers.
- Key lifestyle choices for cancer risk reduction include not smoking, being physically active, maintaining a healthy weight, eating a healthy diet, taking a multivitamin, and avoiding long-term hormone therapy.
The Women's Health Study
- The Women's Health Study is a source of knowledge on estrogen-associated risk factors for breast cancer.
- The timing of first birth affects breast cancer risk. Subsequent births closer to the first birth are associated with lower subsequent breast cancer risk.
- Estimated cumulative risks of breast cancer have been determined for different patient profiles.
- Factors like benign breast disease, family history of breast cancer, and estrogen plus progestin therapies increase breast cancer risk.
Interventional Trials
- These are classified by their purpose and include prevention, screening, diagnostic, and treatment trials.
- Prevention trials aim to prevent diseases (or relapses) and include medications or lifestyle modifications.
- Screening trials aim to detect diseases through tests and methodologies.
- Diagnostic trials aim to find better tests/procedures to diagnose diseases.
- Treatment trials aim to test experimental treatments, new drug combinations, surgery, or radiation therapy.
Prevention trials
- Cancer prevention is the ideal method for reducing society's burden of cancer.
- Cancer prevention clinical trials have been ongoing for the past 30 years, incorporating investigation of natural and synthetic cancer-prevention agents.
Prevention trials (cont.)
- Phase I clinical trials are used to establish dose ranges for drugs.
- Phase II clinical trials are used to test efficacy in small high-risk groups for specific cancers.
- Phase III trials are randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled studies used to test efficacy in large populations.
- Agents in Phase III trials that prove successful in Phase I and II testing are the most promising for large-scale prevention trials.
Prevention trials (cont.)
- Epidemiological evidence suggests lifestyle factors (smoking, nutrition, overweight, obesity) account for a huge percentage of cancer risk.
- Understanding the effect of positive lifestyle changes is guiding the National Cancer Institute to design and run cancer prevention trials.
Selected NCI Phase I, II, and III Chemoprevention Trials
- The table provides a list of dietary factors (e.g., Soy Isoflavones, Lycopene), the target organs (e.g., Prostate, Breast), and the number of patients involved in trials.
Screening trials
- Randomized screening trials are the best method to assess screening efficacy.
- The use of mammography screenings has been widely adopted for women 50 to 69.
- Lung cancer trials did not encourage general adoption of screening programs.
- Prostate screening using PSA blood testing has increased prostate cancer incidence but not definitively reduced mortality.
Basic criteria for screening
- Criteria for an effective screening test include defining the disorder and effectiveness of remedies, simple and safe testing, known distributions of test values, cost-effectiveness, availability, and equitable access.
Design of a randomized screening trial
- An example study design used to evaluate the sensitivity of a screening test for cervical cancer.
A meta-analysis of randomized and nonrandomized controlled trials
- A meta-analysis from a review of controlled trials evaluating hemoccult screening.
- Results from controlled studies indicate no clear benefit in screening using fecal occult blood tests.
Prevalence of disease
- Examples of the prevalence of a disease given a specific test sensitivity and specificity.
Invasive procedures for benign lesions detected by CT screening
- A listing of studies and the proportions of patients that had invasive procedures when benign lesions were detected by CT screening.
Risk of cancer from diagnostic x-rays
- Estimates of attributable risk and cases per year in the United Kingdom, Germany, the US, and Japan from diagnostic X-rays.
Quality of life trials
- Quality of life trials focus on symptom relief, involving patient-reported outcomes in contrast to tumor response or survival.
- Challenges include having strong rationales for HRQOL assessment, developing comprehensive models outlining symptom relations, and improving quality-of-life measurement methods.
Flow of participants after randomization
- Description of a study examining the flow of participants enrolled in a study involving a treatment group versus placebo. (Example data from the study)
Mean (SE) scores on health related quality of life
- Results of analyses relating health related quality of life measures for women to treatment groups in a clinical trial.
What is already known on this topic
- Summary of existing knowledge on the effects of hormone replacement therapy on various aspects of health-related quality of life for women.
Involvement of minorities in cancer research
- Participation of racial/ethnic minorities in cancer trials is crucial for equitable healthcare.
- Inclusion of women and minorities has been required in clinical trials since 1993.
- A low percentage of minorities participate in NCI-funded trials.
Involvement of minorities in cancer research (cont.)
- The need for more racial and ethnic diversity in clinical trial populations is emphasized.
- Factors like mistrust of research, costs, perceived harms, demographics, transportation, lack of education, time, and fear/family are barriers to participation in trials.
Barriers to clinical trial awareness & clinical trial opportunity
- Number of studies reporting on participant barriers to clinical trial enrollment, awareness, and opportunity.
Application of evidence to conceptual framework
- Description of a concept framework used to explain the effects of socioeconomic status on clinical trial participation.
Minority-Based Community Clinical Oncology Program
- Tracking the accrual trends of the Minority-Based Community Clinical Oncology Program (MBCCOP) to illustrate the clinical trials targeting minorities.
Minority percentage of participation
- Graphic showing the percentage of minorities who participated in various clinical trials over time.
CCOP and MBCCOP accruals to STAR and SELECT
- Data on the number of accruals from all study sites involving minority participations in the STAR and SELECT trials.
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.
Related Documents
Description
Test your knowledge on the distinctions and methodologies of interventional and observational studies. Dive into case-control and cohort studies, and evaluate their strengths and limitations as discussed in public health research. This quiz will help deepen your understanding of cancer prevention clinical trials and the Nurses’ Health Study.
