Podcast
Questions and Answers
What does Section 35 of the Constitution Act, 1982 recognize?
What does Section 35 of the Constitution Act, 1982 recognize?
- The rights of private industry in treaty negotiations
- The historical grievances of all Canadian settlers
- The existing Aboriginal and treaty rights of Aboriginal peoples in Canada (correct)
- The rights of non-Aboriginal citizens to land claims
What is the purpose of the initial document filed in a lawsuit?
What is the purpose of the initial document filed in a lawsuit?
- To finalize a settlement between the parties
- To outline key points the plaintiff needs to prove at trial (correct)
- To provide the defendant with a list of witnesses
- To present evidence to the court
Which groups are defined as Aboriginal people under Section 35?
Which groups are defined as Aboriginal people under Section 35?
- Native Americans, Inuit, and Anglo-Canadians
- Indigenous, Inuit, and First Nations
- Indian, Inuit, and Metis (correct)
- Anglo-Saxons, Metis, and Inuit
What does it mean if a defendant fails to respond to the claim within the allowed time?
What does it mean if a defendant fails to respond to the claim within the allowed time?
Who has the duty to consult and accommodate Aboriginal Peoples?
Who has the duty to consult and accommodate Aboriginal Peoples?
What is included in the statement of defense prepared by the defendant?
What is included in the statement of defense prepared by the defendant?
What must be proven for the duty to consult to arise?
What must be proven for the duty to consult to arise?
Which of the following is NOT a common method of alternative dispute resolution (ADR)?
Which of the following is NOT a common method of alternative dispute resolution (ADR)?
What can a defendant do if they believe the plaintiff also caused the incident in question?
What can a defendant do if they believe the plaintiff also caused the incident in question?
Which statement accurately reflects the role of the defense attorney in the pleadings stage?
Which statement accurately reflects the role of the defense attorney in the pleadings stage?
What is a primary benefit of negotiation as an alternative dispute resolution method?
What is a primary benefit of negotiation as an alternative dispute resolution method?
Which of the following statements is true regarding the duty to consult business interests?
Which of the following statements is true regarding the duty to consult business interests?
At what stage can negotiation be employed to resolve a dispute?
At what stage can negotiation be employed to resolve a dispute?
What is the time period in which a party must initiate an appeal after a trial decision?
What is the time period in which a party must initiate an appeal after a trial decision?
What is one of the disadvantages of starting an appeal?
What is one of the disadvantages of starting an appeal?
Which party represents the one making the appeal?
Which party represents the one making the appeal?
After the court of appeal rules, what must an unsuccessful party do to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada?
After the court of appeal rules, what must an unsuccessful party do to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada?
What type of issues can lead to a successful appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada?
What type of issues can lead to a successful appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada?
In which situation should a business refrain from negotiating?
In which situation should a business refrain from negotiating?
What is a major advantage of mediation?
What is a major advantage of mediation?
Who typically acts as a mediator?
Who typically acts as a mediator?
What is the primary role of a mediator in a negotiation?
What is the primary role of a mediator in a negotiation?
Mediation is often required in certain circumstances. What is one condition where mediation is mandatory?
Mediation is often required in certain circumstances. What is one condition where mediation is mandatory?
What is one important characteristic of mediation?
What is one important characteristic of mediation?
What percentage of cases in mediation typically settle before reaching trial?
What percentage of cases in mediation typically settle before reaching trial?
Why might businesses choose mediation over traditional litigation?
Why might businesses choose mediation over traditional litigation?
What is the primary role of the plaintiff in a litigation process?
What is the primary role of the plaintiff in a litigation process?
What are some consequences of starting litigation?
What are some consequences of starting litigation?
Why is there a limitation period for initiating legal actions?
Why is there a limitation period for initiating legal actions?
What is the limitation period in Ontario for initiating a lawsuit?
What is the limitation period in Ontario for initiating a lawsuit?
Which provincial limitation period is unique compared to others mentioned?
Which provincial limitation period is unique compared to others mentioned?
What can be a major drawback of litigation?
What can be a major drawback of litigation?
What is a key factor that dictates how litigation will proceed?
What is a key factor that dictates how litigation will proceed?
What is a common misconception about litigation outcomes?
What is a common misconception about litigation outcomes?
Study Notes
Duty to Consult Aboriginal Peoples
- Section 35 of the Constitution Act, 1982 affirms existing Aboriginal and treaty rights in Canada.
- Aboriginal peoples include Indian, Inuit, and Métis groups.
- Treaty rights arise from agreements made between Canada and Aboriginal peoples.
- The federal and provincial crowns have a duty to consult and accommodate Aboriginal interests when decisions may affect their rights.
- Businesses are not legally responsible for the crown's failure to consult but can face liability for negligence, breach of contract, or fraud in dealings with Indigenous communities.
Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR)
- ADR provides non-litigious methods for resolving disputes, including negotiation, mediation, and arbitration.
- Negotiation is a common method, emphasizing dialogue to find mutually agreeable solutions while preserving relationships.
Mediation
- Mediation involves a neutral mediator aiding parties in reaching settlements, providing a quicker, less expensive, and confidential alternative to litigation.
- Helps maintain relationships and creates tailored resolutions for both parties.
- Mandatory mediation programs exist in some jurisdictions, such as Ontario.
- Effective in about 90% of cases before trial, with mediators not imposing solutions but facilitating discussion and tension reduction.
Litigation Process
- Litigation is the formal legal process initiated by a plaintiff against a defendant when other methods fail.
- Risks include harm to relationships, publicity, and unpredictability.
- Specific procedural rules must be followed which dictate documentation and trial processes.
- Limitation periods vary by province, generally 2 years from discovery for initiating actions (e.g., Ontario, New Brunswick).
- Alberta has a 2-year limitation with a 10-year ultimate limit.
- Proper timing encourages prompt claims to avoid diluting evidence and provides defendants assurance against indefinite litigation.
Claim and Defense
- Initial claims are filed with relevant court offices, outlining the basis and demand for a remedy.
- If not responded to within the allowed timeframe, defendants admit the claim.
- Defendants can file defenses stating differing causation or circumstances and may counterclaim against plaintiffs for their claims.
Appeal Process
- Appeals can be initiated by parties dissatisfied with trial decisions within 30 days.
- Appeals focus on arguing the trial's legal misapplication, not re-evaluating factual determinations.
- Appeals are usually heard by panels of three judges, and no new evidence is introduced.
- Further appeals to the Supreme Court of Canada require leave and must pertain to significant legal issues or public importance.
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.
Description
This quiz explores the legal responsibilities of the Crown in consulting Aboriginal peoples as per Section 35 of the Constitution Act, 1982, and delves into the principles of Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR). Understand the significance of treaty rights, methods of resolving disputes, and the role of mediation. Enhance your knowledge of Indigenous rights and conflict resolution strategies.
