Podcast
Questions and Answers
What are the three categories of criminal offences?
What are the three categories of criminal offences?
Summary, Indictable, and Triable Either Way.
What is the maximum time an arrested individual can be detained without charge in England?
What is the maximum time an arrested individual can be detained without charge in England?
96 hours.
What body decides whether to prosecute after charges are laid by police?
What body decides whether to prosecute after charges are laid by police?
The Crown Prosecution Service (CPS).
What is a 'CAUTION' in the context of criminal proceedings?
What is a 'CAUTION' in the context of criminal proceedings?
In which courts are summary offences tried?
In which courts are summary offences tried?
Can the prosecution occur without a victim's complaint?
Can the prosecution occur without a victim's complaint?
What types of offences fall under 'Indictable' offences?
What types of offences fall under 'Indictable' offences?
Which act allows for a penalty notice to be issued to individuals over 18?
Which act allows for a penalty notice to be issued to individuals over 18?
What types of offences are classified as 'triable either way'?
What types of offences are classified as 'triable either way'?
What happens if a defendant pleads guilty in a triable either way offence?
What happens if a defendant pleads guilty in a triable either way offence?
How does the court decide whether a case is suitable for summary trial?
How does the court decide whether a case is suitable for summary trial?
What is bail in the context of court proceedings?
What is bail in the context of court proceedings?
What types of serious offences are exclusively tried in the Crown Court?
What types of serious offences are exclusively tried in the Crown Court?
What is the significance of the term 'indictable' in criminal law?
What is the significance of the term 'indictable' in criminal law?
What is the primary role of the jury in murder and manslaughter cases?
What is the primary role of the jury in murder and manslaughter cases?
What determines whether a case can be handled in a Magistrates' Court?
What determines whether a case can be handled in a Magistrates' Court?
In youth courts, what is required if a defendant is under 16 years old?
In youth courts, what is required if a defendant is under 16 years old?
What are the consequences if a defendant pleads not guilty in a triable either way case?
What are the consequences if a defendant pleads not guilty in a triable either way case?
What are the powers of sentencing for the Crown compared to Magistrates?
What are the powers of sentencing for the Crown compared to Magistrates?
What is the timeframe for a defendant to appeal from the Magistrates' Court?
What is the timeframe for a defendant to appeal from the Magistrates' Court?
Can the prosecution appeal from the Magistrates to the Crown Court?
Can the prosecution appeal from the Magistrates to the Crown Court?
What must the appeal from the Magistrates to the High Court focus on?
What must the appeal from the Magistrates to the High Court focus on?
What happens during an appeal against conviction in the Magistrates' Court?
What happens during an appeal against conviction in the Magistrates' Court?
What is required for a defendant to appeal to the Court of Appeal from Crown Court?
What is required for a defendant to appeal to the Court of Appeal from Crown Court?
What is one condition that may be imposed on a defendant granted conditional bail?
What is one condition that may be imposed on a defendant granted conditional bail?
Under what circumstances can a defendant be denied bail according to the Bail Act 1976?
Under what circumstances can a defendant be denied bail according to the Bail Act 1976?
What type of cases does the Magistrates' Court primarily handle?
What type of cases does the Magistrates' Court primarily handle?
Who has the authority to sentence in the Magistrates' Court?
Who has the authority to sentence in the Magistrates' Court?
What type of juristic powers does the Crown Court hold?
What type of juristic powers does the Crown Court hold?
What is the maximum sentence a Magistrate can impose for a single offence?
What is the maximum sentence a Magistrate can impose for a single offence?
How has the power of magistrates regarding fines changed after 2015?
How has the power of magistrates regarding fines changed after 2015?
What type of judge commonly hears cases in the Crown Court?
What type of judge commonly hears cases in the Crown Court?
What is a suspended sentence and under what conditions can it lead to imprisonment?
What is a suspended sentence and under what conditions can it lead to imprisonment?
What is the time frame within which a leave application must be made for an appeal decided by a single judge?
What is the time frame within which a leave application must be made for an appeal decided by a single judge?
What is a Detention and Training Order, and who is eligible for it?
What is a Detention and Training Order, and who is eligible for it?
How does the seriousness of the crime influence sentencing decisions?
How does the seriousness of the crime influence sentencing decisions?
Under what condition can the Court of Appeal grant a retrial when appealing against conviction?
Under what condition can the Court of Appeal grant a retrial when appealing against conviction?
What is the effect of a guilty plea on sentencing length, according to the Criminal Justice Act 2003?
What is the effect of a guilty plea on sentencing length, according to the Criminal Justice Act 2003?
What allows the prosecution to appeal rulings that terminate a trial?
What allows the prosecution to appeal rulings that terminate a trial?
What role do mitigating circumstances play in sentencing?
What role do mitigating circumstances play in sentencing?
What role does the Criminal Cases Review Commission play in relation to cases under s.9 of the Criminal Appeal Act 1995?
What role does the Criminal Cases Review Commission play in relation to cases under s.9 of the Criminal Appeal Act 1995?
What is an example of a non-punitive sentence that can be applied for the least serious offences?
What is an example of a non-punitive sentence that can be applied for the least serious offences?
What is an ancillary order and give an example?
What is an ancillary order and give an example?
What guidelines assist the courts in determining sentences for specific offenses?
What guidelines assist the courts in determining sentences for specific offenses?
What type of sentence is referred to as 'custodial' and under what circumstances is it typically imposed?
What type of sentence is referred to as 'custodial' and under what circumstances is it typically imposed?
What is the purpose of a community sentence and name one component of it?
What is the purpose of a community sentence and name one component of it?
What happens if an offender commits another crime while on a suspended sentence?
What happens if an offender commits another crime while on a suspended sentence?
What distinguishes a determinate sentence from an indeterminate sentence?
What distinguishes a determinate sentence from an indeterminate sentence?
Flashcards
Triable Either Way Offences
Triable Either Way Offences
Criminal offences that can be tried in either the Magistrates' Court (summary trial) or the Crown Court (indictable trial).
Allocation
Allocation
The process of the court deciding whether a 'triable either way' offence should be tried summarily or indictably.
Insufficient Sentencing Powers
Insufficient Sentencing Powers
Sentencing powers of the Magistrates' Court may be insufficient for a particular 'triable either way' offence.
Presumption of Innocence
Presumption of Innocence
Signup and view all the flashcards
Bail
Bail
Signup and view all the flashcards
Custody
Custody
Signup and view all the flashcards
Bail Decision
Bail Decision
Signup and view all the flashcards
Balance of Factors in Bail Decisions
Balance of Factors in Bail Decisions
Signup and view all the flashcards
Conditional Bail
Conditional Bail
Signup and view all the flashcards
Surety
Surety
Signup and view all the flashcards
Fitness to Plead Examination
Fitness to Plead Examination
Signup and view all the flashcards
Magistrates' Court
Magistrates' Court
Signup and view all the flashcards
Summary Trial
Summary Trial
Signup and view all the flashcards
Indictable Trial
Indictable Trial
Signup and view all the flashcards
Crown Court
Crown Court
Signup and view all the flashcards
Summary Offences
Summary Offences
Signup and view all the flashcards
Indictable Offences
Indictable Offences
Signup and view all the flashcards
Decision to Prosecute
Decision to Prosecute
Signup and view all the flashcards
Plea Bargaining
Plea Bargaining
Signup and view all the flashcards
Alternatives to Prosecution
Alternatives to Prosecution
Signup and view all the flashcards
Initial Appeal: Magistrates to Crown Court
Initial Appeal: Magistrates to Crown Court
Signup and view all the flashcards
Case Stated: Magistrates to High Court D.C. KBD
Case Stated: Magistrates to High Court D.C. KBD
Signup and view all the flashcards
Initial Appeal: Crown to Court of Appeal
Initial Appeal: Crown to Court of Appeal
Signup and view all the flashcards
Jury Role in Criminal Trials
Jury Role in Criminal Trials
Signup and view all the flashcards
Sentencing Powers of the Crown Court
Sentencing Powers of the Crown Court
Signup and view all the flashcards
Jurisdiction of Special Magistrates' Courts
Jurisdiction of Special Magistrates' Courts
Signup and view all the flashcards
Appeal Rights: Magistrates to High Court D.C. KBD
Appeal Rights: Magistrates to High Court D.C. KBD
Signup and view all the flashcards
Prosecution Appeal Rights: Magistrates to Crown Court
Prosecution Appeal Rights: Magistrates to Crown Court
Signup and view all the flashcards
Prosecution Appeal
Prosecution Appeal
Signup and view all the flashcards
COA Review of Crown Decisions
COA Review of Crown Decisions
Signup and view all the flashcards
Custodial Sentence
Custodial Sentence
Signup and view all the flashcards
Unpaid Work Sentence
Unpaid Work Sentence
Signup and view all the flashcards
Fine Sentence
Fine Sentence
Signup and view all the flashcards
Conditional Discharge
Conditional Discharge
Signup and view all the flashcards
Determinate Sentence
Determinate Sentence
Signup and view all the flashcards
Indeterminate Sentence
Indeterminate Sentence
Signup and view all the flashcards
Suspended Sentence
Suspended Sentence
Signup and view all the flashcards
Detention and Training Order
Detention and Training Order
Signup and view all the flashcards
Ancillary Orders
Ancillary Orders
Signup and view all the flashcards
Guilty Plea Reduction
Guilty Plea Reduction
Signup and view all the flashcards
Sentencing Factors
Sentencing Factors
Signup and view all the flashcards
Sentencing Guidelines
Sentencing Guidelines
Signup and view all the flashcards
Sentencing Children and Young Persons
Sentencing Children and Young Persons
Signup and view all the flashcards
Sentencing Guidelines for Specific Offenses
Sentencing Guidelines for Specific Offenses
Signup and view all the flashcards
Study Notes
English Legal Method I - Fall 2024-2025
- Course taught by Belkıs Şahinoğlu
- Course dates are Fall 2024 - 2025
Post-Midterm Timetable
- 09.12.24: Criminal Court Structure
- 16.12.24: Precedent
- 23.12.24: Tutorial
- 30.12.24: Statutory Interpretation
- 06.01.25: Review
- 13.01.25: Final Exam
Criminal Court Structure: Contents
- Categories of criminal offenses: Summary, Indictable, Triable Either Way
- Courts: Criminal Jurisdiction of Magistrates, Crown (first Instance)
- Appeal Routes
- Types of sentence and determination
- Plea Bargaining
Procedure Pre-Prosecution
- Starts with complaint/investigation, arrest under legislation, common law, or warrant.
- Arrested individuals must be brought to police station within 24 hours for charging or release.
- Further investigation: Police can extend detention for 12 hours. If over 36 hours, court approval is required. Maximum detention is 96 hours.
- Northern Cyprus: Arrested individuals must be charged within 24 hours or brought to court for further detention. Court can extend in 8 day increments up to a maximum of 3 months
- Until 1986: Police made the decision to prosecute. Now, the CPS makes the decision.
- Prosecution can happen irrespective of a victim's complaint.
- Note differences in Turkey and Northern Cyprus regarding the necessity of victim complaints in certain cases (sexual assault, sexual harassment, theft, property damage).
Instead of Prosecution...
- Relevant Acts: Crime and Disorder Act 1998, Criminal Justice Act 2003, and Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Act 2012
- Alternative to criminal charges: Bad character reference
- Penalty Notice (18+ - fine), for example, shoplifting
Deciding on the Crime for Prosecution...
- This section doesn't provide specific information regarding the topic
Categories of Criminal Offences - Summary
- Relatively trivial offenses, tried in Magistrates' Courts (330 courts) in the relevant district where the offense occurred.
- Examples: Highway/traffic offences (speeding, dangerous driving), assault, cruelty to animals, criminal damage (under £5,000), being drunk and disorderly, driving while disqualified, labor issues (employment of children)
Categories of Criminal Offences - Indictable
- Serious offences tried in the Crown Court.
- Examples: Murder (attempted murder, conspiracy to commit), manslaughter, rape, shooting, maiming/burning by explosion, robbery, burglary, arson endangering life, kidnapping
Categories of Criminal Offences - Triable Either Way
- More serious, but not inherently indictable. Can be tried as summary or indictable
- Examples: Theft (not robbery or burglary), drug offences, aggravated vehicle taking, aggravated dangerous driving, ABH, aggravated common assault, criminal damage, abduction, cruelty to a child, controlling/causing prostitution for gain or administering noxious substance to cause harm.
Triable Either Way Offences...how do we decide?
- Magistrates' deliberation, plea (guilty/not guilty), allocation; suitability of summary trial
- The severity of the offenses affects the decision as to which court handles the trial
- Sentencing and powers of Magistrates
- Magistrates' power to sentence is insufficient; referral to the Crown Court for sentencing.
Advantages/Disadvantages of Selecting Summary/Indictable
- This part of the presentation isn't covering advantages and disadvantages
Bail - What is it?
- After the decision to prosecute, and if the defendant pleads not guilty, judicial determination is made to either remand the defendant in custody or grant bail.
- Bail is release from custody while the case is being dealt with.
- Balance is sought between the presumption of innocence and liberty vs. ensuring the defendant attends trial.
- Conditional bail conditions can include: keeping away from certain places or people, payment of a bond, reporting, no driving, electronic tagging
Exceptions to Granting Bail
- No bail for murder prosecutions (s.4 Bail Act 1976) unless there's reason to believe the defendant will: fail to surrender, commit an offense on bail, interfere with witnesses, commit another indictable/triable either-way offense while on bail, or pose a risk of harm.
Progression of Criminal Cases
- Prosecution, Examination, Cross-examination, Re-examination, Defense
- This part focuses on the order of presentation
The Court Jurisdictions – Magistrates' Court
- Original jurisdiction only
- Tries: Summary, Sentence/try Triable either way selected as summary trial
- Referrals: Transfers some cases to Crown Court (limited powers), sends indictable/triable-either-way cases to Crown Court for trial
Who hears cases in the Magistrates' Court?
- 2 or 3 Magistrates
- District Judge
Sentencing Powers of the Magistrates
- Limited sentencing powers, maximum six months for a singular offense, maximum 12 months for multiple offenses, community sentence options, combinations of fines and community sentences.
- Fines up to £5,000. After 2015, fines are unlimited in magistrates' courts. Indictments involving more significant sentences are passed to Crown Court.
The Court Jurisdictions - Crown Court
- Original and Appellate Jurisdiction
- Tries: Indictable, Triable Either Way (selected as indictable by Magistrates or Defendant)
- Referrals: Defendants pleading guilty sent from Magistrates' court for sentencing, hears appeals from Magistrates (summary offenses).
Who hears cases in the Crown?
- Circuit Judge (lesser offenses)
- High Court Judge (more serious offenses - Murder, Manslaughter)
- Cases heard by judge and jury
- Role of Jury: decides facts and guilt
- Role of Judge: sentencing
Youth Courts
- Special Magistrates Courts for defendants under 18
- Exceptions: Homicide (including death by dangerous/intoxicated driving), certain offenses carrying potential for 14+ years imprisonment.
- 3 Magistrates or a District Judge
- No jury
- Less formal procedures
- Wide range of sentences
The Appeal Structure
- Summary and Indictment appeals, different procedures for both
- Appeals from Magistrates to Crown Court: defendant can appeal sentence or conviction, or appeal both
- No permission required for appeal; appeal within 21 days
Initial Appeal – Summary -Mag to Crown Court
- Defendant may appeal to the Crown Court from the Magistrates court.
- Appeals cover conviction/sentence or both. Separately, sentence only.
- Appeals don't require court permission.
- Appeals must occur within 21 days of judgment.
Quasi Appellate Jurisdiction of the Crown
- Criminal Review Commission
- Criminal Procedure rules
Initial Appeal – Summary – Mag to the High Court D.C. KBD
- Alternative appeals from Magistrates to High Court, defendant only.
- On a point of law
- As “Case Stated” = no retrial
Initial Appeal – Indictment – Crown to the COA Criminal Division
- Defendant can appeal if there was a conviction or sentence.
- Leave from the COA or trial Court is required.
- Leave determination depends on a singular judge.
Initial Appeal - Indictment – Crown to the COA Criminal Division (Prosecution)
- Prosecution ability to appeal ruling affecting trial termination under Criminal Justice Act 2003.
- Quasi-appellate jurisdiction of the COA
- Examples like s.9 Criminal Appeal Act 1995, s. 36 Criminal Justice Act 1972, s. 36 Criminal Justice Act 1988.
Further Appeal
- Summary: Magistrates→Crown Court→Supreme Court
- Indictment: Crown Court→Supreme Court through COA
- Leave needed in certain circumstances
Summary and Indictment Flowchart
- Summary offenses go from Magistrate to Crown Court, then Supreme Court
- Indictable offenses go from Crown Court to COA to Supreme Court.
The Criminal Cases Review Commission
- Reviews Magistrates' and Crown Court decisions to appeal.
- Areas of appeal include: lenient sentences, points of law
Sentences
- Discharge (least serious offences), Fine (less serious offences), Community Sentence (unpaid work, curfew, restricted places, mental health program, reparation orders, rehabilitation orders), Prison (custodial sentence)
Suspended Sentence
- Prison sentence between 14 days to 2 years, not immediate incarceration
- Conditionally imposed requirements e.g. curfew, treatment, specific places
- Failure to meet conditions = serving original sentence
- If the defendant has another crime committed = original sentence plus new sentence
Detention and Training Order (12- 17 Years)
- 4 months-2 years custody. First half in custody; then the rest of the time is supervision
- More serious cases with extended custody & special supervision like electronic tags.
- Murder has set minimum time for custody followed by lifelong supervision
Ancillary Orders
- Compensation, drinking bans, disqualification from driving, exclusion orders
Which Sentence?
- Factors regarding crime severity
- Circumstance and legal provisions
- Impact on Victim
- Blame worthiness
- Criminal record(if applicable)
- Guilty plea and timing
- Mitigated circumstances, family considerations
- Potential for a different sentence
Sentencing Guidelines
- Sentencing Council guidelines for children and young persons, community and custodial guidelines, robbery, theft, fraud, bribery, health and safety
- Guidelines from COA and Sentencing Council
Plea Bargaining?
- s. 144 Criminal Justice Act 2003
- Guidelines exist to aid sentencing determination and encourage early guilty pleas
- Benefits include victim impact reduction, victim/witness testimony savings, and cost savings
Reduction in Sentence
- Gradual reduction from ⅓ to 1/10 possible based on pleading time
- Reductions based on initial stages leading up to final plea
- Reductions possible from Custodial sentence (prison) to Community Sentence to fines
- Sentence reductions from 10 to 5
- The lower sentencing power and the time the case was in Magistrates Court led to sentence reduction
How reductions are applied
- Reduction based on type and length of sentencing given
- Reductions based on guilty pleas, trial procedure, type of offenses
- Trial reductions based on plea time and offense
Flowcharts
- Series of flowcharts showing the judicial procedures and options based on guilty or not guilty pleas for both summary and indictable offenses
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.
Related Documents
Description
Test your knowledge on the categories of criminal offences, detention regulations, and court proceedings in England. This quiz covers various aspects of criminal law, including types of offences and the role of the jury. Challenge yourself and see how well you understand the intricacies of the legal system!