Podcast
Questions and Answers
What was one of the common aims of competition law regarding economic performance?
What was one of the common aims of competition law regarding economic performance?
Which event is mentioned as having shaken faith in the free market economy in the mid-20th century?
Which event is mentioned as having shaken faith in the free market economy in the mid-20th century?
How does competition law aim to secure small- and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs)?
How does competition law aim to secure small- and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs)?
What is highlighted as a current challenge within competition law?
What is highlighted as a current challenge within competition law?
Signup and view all the answers
One objective of competition law is to support fair distribution of wealth. What has been a historically focused area under this objective?
One objective of competition law is to support fair distribution of wealth. What has been a historically focused area under this objective?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the primary aim of EU competition law?
What is the primary aim of EU competition law?
Signup and view all the answers
What is a cartel defined as in EU competition law?
What is a cartel defined as in EU competition law?
Signup and view all the answers
Which article of the TFEU explicitly prohibits anti-competitive agreements?
Which article of the TFEU explicitly prohibits anti-competitive agreements?
Signup and view all the answers
What element must be present for EU competition law to be applicable?
What element must be present for EU competition law to be applicable?
Signup and view all the answers
How does the leniency program under EU competition law function?
How does the leniency program under EU competition law function?
Signup and view all the answers
What is a significant impact of cartels on market competition?
What is a significant impact of cartels on market competition?
Signup and view all the answers
Which two bodies are responsible for the parallel enforcement of EU competition law?
Which two bodies are responsible for the parallel enforcement of EU competition law?
Signup and view all the answers
Which of the following describes the internal market in the context of EU competition law?
Which of the following describes the internal market in the context of EU competition law?
Signup and view all the answers
What was one of the main goals of the Sherman Act of 1890?
What was one of the main goals of the Sherman Act of 1890?
Signup and view all the answers
What significant social impact did the emergence of large trusts have in the late 19th century?
What significant social impact did the emergence of large trusts have in the late 19th century?
Signup and view all the answers
Which of the following was a response to the pressure small businesses faced from larger enterprises?
Which of the following was a response to the pressure small businesses faced from larger enterprises?
Signup and view all the answers
What economic advantage did trusts provide that pressured smaller firms?
What economic advantage did trusts provide that pressured smaller firms?
Signup and view all the answers
What type of legislative changes did the Sherman Act introduce regarding trade?
What type of legislative changes did the Sherman Act introduce regarding trade?
Signup and view all the answers
What was one outcome of the political power held by trusts during this period?
What was one outcome of the political power held by trusts during this period?
Signup and view all the answers
What was a direct result of the competition faced by smaller businesses from trusts?
What was a direct result of the competition faced by smaller businesses from trusts?
Signup and view all the answers
How did the Sherman Act empower the federal government?
How did the Sherman Act empower the federal government?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the primary aim of Article 101(1) regarding agreements between parties?
What is the primary aim of Article 101(1) regarding agreements between parties?
Signup and view all the answers
Which statement accurately reflects the assessment of agreements under Article 101(1)?
Which statement accurately reflects the assessment of agreements under Article 101(1)?
Signup and view all the answers
Under Article 101(1), how is the relevance of the market defined?
Under Article 101(1), how is the relevance of the market defined?
Signup and view all the answers
What must be established to determine if an agreement has the object of restricting competition?
What must be established to determine if an agreement has the object of restricting competition?
Signup and view all the answers
In which case is the subjective intention of the parties deemed irrelevant in assessing competition restriction?
In which case is the subjective intention of the parties deemed irrelevant in assessing competition restriction?
Signup and view all the answers
Which of the following is NOT considered a classical infringement under Article 101(1)?
Which of the following is NOT considered a classical infringement under Article 101(1)?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the significance of the conjunction 'or' in relation to the requirements of Article 101(1)?
What is the significance of the conjunction 'or' in relation to the requirements of Article 101(1)?
Signup and view all the answers
What potential impact must be demonstrated in assessing whether an agreement distorts competition?
What potential impact must be demonstrated in assessing whether an agreement distorts competition?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the main objective of prohibiting concerted practices under Art. 101(1) TFEU?
What is the main objective of prohibiting concerted practices under Art. 101(1) TFEU?
Signup and view all the answers
Which of the following is NOT a requirement to establish a concerted practice?
Which of the following is NOT a requirement to establish a concerted practice?
Signup and view all the answers
What leads to a rebuttable presumption of a concerted practice?
What leads to a rebuttable presumption of a concerted practice?
Signup and view all the answers
What does 'substitution of competition by cooperation' imply in the context of concerted practices?
What does 'substitution of competition by cooperation' imply in the context of concerted practices?
Signup and view all the answers
Which component does NOT form part of the legal test for concerted practices?
Which component does NOT form part of the legal test for concerted practices?
Signup and view all the answers
How are concerted practices classified in relation to other forms of collusion under Art. 101 TFEU?
How are concerted practices classified in relation to other forms of collusion under Art. 101 TFEU?
Signup and view all the answers
Which of the following statements best describes the concept of 'contact' in concerted practices?
Which of the following statements best describes the concept of 'contact' in concerted practices?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the significance of the Anic Case C-49/92 (1999) in relation to concerted practices?
What is the significance of the Anic Case C-49/92 (1999) in relation to concerted practices?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the maximum market share for agreements between competitors under the de minimis doctrine?
What is the maximum market share for agreements between competitors under the de minimis doctrine?
Signup and view all the answers
Which of the following is NOT considered a hardcore restriction under the de minimis doctrine?
Which of the following is NOT considered a hardcore restriction under the de minimis doctrine?
Signup and view all the answers
The de minimis doctrine applies to which type of restrictions?
The de minimis doctrine applies to which type of restrictions?
Signup and view all the answers
Which category of agreement is affected by the presumption of non-affectation?
Which category of agreement is affected by the presumption of non-affectation?
Signup and view all the answers
What must be true for an agreement to qualify for the safe harbor under the de minimis doctrine?
What must be true for an agreement to qualify for the safe harbor under the de minimis doctrine?
Signup and view all the answers
Which of the following is an example of a hardcore restriction?
Which of the following is an example of a hardcore restriction?
Signup and view all the answers
What does the concept of 'restrict competition' imply in the context of the de minimis doctrine?
What does the concept of 'restrict competition' imply in the context of the de minimis doctrine?
Signup and view all the answers
Study Notes
Competition Law I - Anticompetitive Agreements
- Competition is crucial for prosperity, benefiting consumers but challenging for producers/sellers
- Competition laws are designed to safeguard consumer welfare by addressing potential risks like price-fixing cartels and powerful companies abusing their power
- Competition enforcers monitor proposed mergers to prevent undermining effective competition.
- Competition enforcers must carefully consider the level of intervention to avoid distorting the natural dynamics of competition, as per Ariel Ezrachi.
Overview & Objectives of Lecture
- The lecture will cover the fundamental ideas of competition, competition law in the EU, and anti-competitive agreements, focusing on Article 101 of the TFEU.
Foundations and Context of Modern Competition Law
- Modern competition law's roots lie in North America, specifically post-US Civil War communications and transportation advancements.
- These advancements linked previously separate markets, leading to larger enterprises operating across wider locations.
- The late 19th century saw large enterprises (known as Trusts) emerge, often displacing smaller firms, leading to cost reductions and lower prices passed on to consumers, putting pressure on small businesses.
- Trusts held substantial economic and political power, changing social structures and impacting community control.
- The emergence of trusts and large enterprises in the late 19th century prompted the implementation of laws like the Sherman Act.
Sherman Act (1890)
- A pivotal piece of legislation aimed at curbing large monopolies and trusts in various industries.
- The Act aimed to enhance rivalry among businesses.
- The Act sought to ensure small businesses' opportunity to compete.
- It prohibited unreasonable restraints of trade that prevented competition among businesses.
- The Act empowered the federal government with the authority to investigate trusts and companies suspected of violating the Act.
Evolution of Modern Competition Law
- Faith in free economies was shaken after The Great Depression.
- Post-WWII, the free market emerged as the organising principle of western economies, including Europe (Rome Treaty).
- The Fall of the Soviet Union marked the triumph of free-market capitalism.
- The 2007 financial crisis eroded confidence in free markets, compounded by globalization and austerity measures.
- Present challenges encompass growing inequalities, populism, protectionism, and economic activity from technological giants in the digital economy.
Aims of Competition Law
- Improve economic performance, through:
- Promoting growth.
- Increasing productivity.
- Stimulating innovation.
- Support fair distribution of wealth through:
- Reducing poverty.
- Addressing historical disadvantage for certain groups.
- Protect the integrity of the political process.
- Secure positions for small- and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs).
Practicing Competition Law
- Offers global career opportunities.
- Demands a global understanding of principles and interconnectedness.
Basic Principles of Competition
- Perfect Competition: Customers and suppliers are fully informed and rational. The market is simple, products are homogenous, and invisible hand competition is prominent.
- Oligopoly: Imperfect competition dominated by a few large competitors. There is often limited competition, potentially involving tacit collusion to prevent the market from becoming more competitive and thus protecting themselves.
- Monopoly: Domination by a single firm. This company has high market concentration (BoE). There is no competition in the market, leading to an inability for prices or other conditions to be appropriately set by competition.
Market Power
- The ability of a firm to profitably sustain its price above the competitive level without losing market share.
- This depends on the market in question and its competitors.
Relevant Market
- Product Market: Products considered substitutes by consumers and/or suppliers.
- Geographic Market: Area in which relevant products are marketed, sharing similar conditions.
- Temporal Market: Timeframe for products and services to be considered in the market (if applicable).
Market Share
- Used to categorize companies and quantify their relative market dominance in the appropriate market.
- Allows to understand the potential competitive restraints.
- Also considers barriers to entry for outside companies.
- Evaluates potential buyer power.
Harms of Market Power
- Joint market power after anticompetitive agreements
- Single dominant/monopolist firm
- Mergers of two or more firms
Anti-Competitive Agreements in EU (Art 101 TFEU)
- A common form of anti-competitive agreements is cartels, which are illegal in many jurisdictions, including the EU.
- Cartels seek to fix prices, limit production, or share markets among independent competitor companies to prevent each other from competing.
- Cartels reduce incentives for innovation, by removing competitive pressure, and may involve collusions amongst producers or distributors.
- The leniency program encourages companies to reveal their illegal dealings with other competitors in exchange for immunity or a reduction in fines from the commission.
- Settlements for fine reductions are possible.
Article 101 TFEU - The Scheme
- Article 101(1): Prohibits undertakings' collusive activities which appreciably distort competition between member states. The burden of proof lies with the European Commission or whoever alleges an infringement.
- Article 101(2): Provides for the nullity of the undertaking's conduct + enforcement (public and private) when anti-competitive conduct is discovered and proven.
- Article 101(3): Excludes agreements with exceptions for individual purposes where the undertaking must demonstrate any benefit is greater than its harmful effects.
Article 101 TFEU - The Elements
- Undertakings/ Associations of undertakings.
- Agreements/ decisions of associations of undertakings/ concerted practices.
- Anti-competitive object or effect.
- Effect on trade.
Undertaking, Association of Undertakings
- An undertaking is any entity engaged in an economic activity regardless of legal form or financing type.
- Associations of undertakings can be subject to Article 101 TFEU, even if they don't engage in economic activities themselves, if they coordinate the market behaviour of members.
Agreements, Decisions, Concerted Practices
- Any form of collusion that leads to a distortion or restriction of competition between independent undertakings is prohibited.
- Article 101 TFEU lists 3 categories: agreements, decisions, and concerted practices.
- These categories are not exclusive and frequently overlap.
Object or Effect of Preventing, Restricting, or Distorting Competition
- The EU regulates behaviour which restricts competition through the object or effect of such conduct.
- This can be evaluated by examining objective intentions, aims, and context.
- Agreement or concerted practice restrictions which could affect trade between member states, even if the parties have no explicitly collusive agreement.
- Subjective intents of parties are not relevant when examining whether an agreement or practice restricts competition.
Restriction by Object
- Deals with situations where the agreement's inherent nature creates a potential for anti-competitive effects.
- Agreements with the explicit goal of undermining competition are automatically prohibited, regardless of effect on trade between member states.
- Hardcore Restrictions are per se anti-competitive, such as agreements on price fixing, market sharing, resale price maintenance or export restrictions.
Restriction by Effect
- Focuses on the agreement's observed impact on competition.
- Requires a market analysis to determine relevant geographic and product markets; consideration of the agreement within its actual context.
- The analysis also examines potential limitations and foreclosure effects on access to market.
- Requires a comparison between factual situation and hypothetical scenario where the agreement did not take place.
- Relevant material factors that contribute to a potential negative effect (such as severity of protection clauses) are also considered.
Effect on Trade Between Member States
- Trade between EU member states must be affected by the agreement in an appreciable manner to qualify as a violation of Article 101.
- Agreements to be a violation, must have a minimum threshold of cross-border economic activity affected.
- There is a presumption against an effect on trade between EU member states when aggregate market shares and turnover are below certain values.
De Minimis Doctrine
- Offers a safety net for minor agreements between businesses that the Commission deems have no substantial effect on competition within the given parameters.
- Applies if market shares are under set thresholds (10% for competitors, 15% for non-competitors within the group).
- Exceptions include hardcore restrictions which are always viewed as having a significant effect.
EU Competition Law - Overview
- EU competition law aims at preventing distortions in the internal market, ensuring free competition and protecting consumers.
- It encompasses a system encompassing competition policy, which aims to ensure fair and effective competition, protect consumers and the structure and structure of the market.
- It's linked to EU's general law on free movement.
- The European Commission and national competition authorities (NCAs) enforce these laws.
Lecture Recap
- The lecture covered competition, competition law, market power, anti-competitive agreements, Article 101 of the TFEU.
- Key concepts like undertakings, agreements, decisions, concerted practices, object/effect of restrictions, market share, trade between member states, and the specific de minimis doctrine.
References
- A comprehensive list of articles, books, and other materials cited in the presentation is provided.
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.
Related Documents
Description
This quiz explores the fundamental principles of competition law, especially focusing on anti-competitive agreements as outlined in Article 101 of the TFEU. It delves into the significance of competition for consumer welfare and the role of competition enforcers in monitoring mergers. Additionally, it touches on the historical context of modern competition law and its development in North America.
