Podcast
Questions and Answers
What is a primary methodological problem related to subliminal stimuli?
What is a primary methodological problem related to subliminal stimuli?
- Response bias may affect whether a subject thinks they have seen the stimulus. (correct)
- Participants always show high levels of motivation in tasks.
- Clear identification of stimuli is always achieved.
- Subjects may claim they have seen a stimulus when they haven't.
How could participant motivation impact subliminal stimulus identification?
How could participant motivation impact subliminal stimulus identification?
- Higher motivation always guarantees accurate identification.
- Participants are more likely to detect subliminal stimuli when bored.
- Motivated participants cannot recognize subliminal stimuli.
- Lack of motivation may lead to decreased performance in difficult tasks. (correct)
In the context of subliminal stimuli, what is a significant issue with response bias?
In the context of subliminal stimuli, what is a significant issue with response bias?
- It indicates subjects are highly motivated to identify stimuli.
- Subjects report higher certainty than they actually possess.
- It ensures subjects identify all stimuli accurately.
- It can lead to false negatives where stimuli may be seen but unreported. (correct)
What do Newell & Shanks discuss regarding unconscious influences?
What do Newell & Shanks discuss regarding unconscious influences?
Which resource is recommended for exam revision on the topic of attention?
Which resource is recommended for exam revision on the topic of attention?
What is a condition that makes change blindness more likely?
What is a condition that makes change blindness more likely?
How does change blindness differ from inattentional blindness?
How does change blindness differ from inattentional blindness?
What does not contribute to change blindness according to the information provided?
What does not contribute to change blindness according to the information provided?
Which term describes stimuli that are not consciously perceived?
Which term describes stimuli that are not consciously perceived?
Which example illustrates inattentional blindness effectively?
Which example illustrates inattentional blindness effectively?
What element of change blindness allows us to perceive stimuli but not remember them?
What element of change blindness allows us to perceive stimuli but not remember them?
What experimental technique did James Vicary claim to have used for subliminal advertising?
What experimental technique did James Vicary claim to have used for subliminal advertising?
What is the primary focus in studies involving change blindness and their implications?
What is the primary focus in studies involving change blindness and their implications?
What percentage of participants noticed the gorilla in the Simons & Chabris study?
What percentage of participants noticed the gorilla in the Simons & Chabris study?
In the study involving a unicycling clown, which group had the highest percentage of participants noticing the clown?
In the study involving a unicycling clown, which group had the highest percentage of participants noticing the clown?
Which of the following statements about inattentional blindness is correct?
Which of the following statements about inattentional blindness is correct?
What difficulty is associated with measuring subliminal perception?
What difficulty is associated with measuring subliminal perception?
What was a significant concern regarding the research conducted by James Vicary?
What was a significant concern regarding the research conducted by James Vicary?
Which example illustrates real-world inattentional blindness?
Which example illustrates real-world inattentional blindness?
What type of misconduct is associated with Diederik Stapel?
What type of misconduct is associated with Diederik Stapel?
In the research by Hyman et al. regarding the clown, what was the percentage of cell phone users who noticed anything unusual?
In the research by Hyman et al. regarding the clown, what was the percentage of cell phone users who noticed anything unusual?
After what year is it likely that Diederik Stapel began manipulating data?
After what year is it likely that Diederik Stapel began manipulating data?
What is one of the primary findings from the studies on inattentional blindness?
What is one of the primary findings from the studies on inattentional blindness?
What should one be cautious of in academic research according to the content?
What should one be cautious of in academic research according to the content?
Change blindness differs from inattentional blindness in that it primarily relates to:
Change blindness differs from inattentional blindness in that it primarily relates to:
What was the primary finding from Karremans et al. (2006) regarding subliminal priming?
What was the primary finding from Karremans et al. (2006) regarding subliminal priming?
In the experiments by Karremans et al. (2006), how long were the prime words presented?
In the experiments by Karremans et al. (2006), how long were the prime words presented?
What was a limitation noted about the findings from Karremans et al. (2006)?
What was a limitation noted about the findings from Karremans et al. (2006)?
Which of the following statements best describes the prevalence of outright data manipulation in academia?
Which of the following statements best describes the prevalence of outright data manipulation in academia?
Flashcards
Change blindness
Change blindness
The failure to notice a change in a visual scene, even when the change is obvious once it's pointed out. It highlights the limitations of our visual attention.
Flicker Paradigm
Flicker Paradigm
A method of testing change blindness where two slightly different images are shown in rapid succession, separated by a brief blank screen. The observer's task is to spot the change.
Gradual change blindness
Gradual change blindness
A type of change blindness where a change occurs slowly over time, making it harder to detect. Think of a slowly changing clock.
The Door Study
The Door Study
Signup and view all the flashcards
Inattentional blindness
Inattentional blindness
Signup and view all the flashcards
Early selection
Early selection
Signup and view all the flashcards
Late selection
Late selection
Signup and view all the flashcards
Priming
Priming
Signup and view all the flashcards
Gorilla in our midst experiment
Gorilla in our midst experiment
Signup and view all the flashcards
The unicycling clown experiment
The unicycling clown experiment
Signup and view all the flashcards
Inattentional vs. Change Blindness
Inattentional vs. Change Blindness
Signup and view all the flashcards
Subliminal perception
Subliminal perception
Signup and view all the flashcards
Challenges of measuring subliminal perception
Challenges of measuring subliminal perception
Signup and view all the flashcards
Subliminal messages in advertising
Subliminal messages in advertising
Signup and view all the flashcards
Response Bias in Subliminal Perception
Response Bias in Subliminal Perception
Signup and view all the flashcards
Motivation in Subliminal Perception Research
Motivation in Subliminal Perception Research
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is 'Behavioural and Brain Sciences' format?
What is 'Behavioural and Brain Sciences' format?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Early Selection Theory
Early Selection Theory
Signup and view all the flashcards
Late Selection Theory
Late Selection Theory
Signup and view all the flashcards
Subliminal Advertising
Subliminal Advertising
Signup and view all the flashcards
Vicary's Coke Experiment
Vicary's Coke Experiment
Signup and view all the flashcards
Diederik Stapel
Diederik Stapel
Signup and view all the flashcards
Data Manipulation
Data Manipulation
Signup and view all the flashcards
Karremans et al. (2006) Study
Karremans et al. (2006) Study
Signup and view all the flashcards
Replication
Replication
Signup and view all the flashcards
Conceptual Replication
Conceptual Replication
Signup and view all the flashcards
Implausibly High Effect Sizes
Implausibly High Effect Sizes
Signup and view all the flashcards
Study Notes
Cognitive Psychology 1: Limits of Attention
- Attention is capacity limited and selective.
- Unattended/irrelevant information is usually not processed.
- Evidence suggests unattended information can sometimes influence attention.
Today's Lecture: Learning Objectives
- Describe change blindness and inattentional blindness.
- Explain the similarities and differences between change and inattentional blindness.
- Understand the difficulties in measuring subliminal perception.
Inattentional Blindness
- Simons & Chabris (1999), Simons (2010) - Research on inattentional blindness.
'Gorillas in our midst'
- Simons & Chabris (1999) study: Participants were shown a video of two teams passing a basketball. A person in a gorilla suit walked through the teams.
- A significant percentage of participants failed to notice the gorilla. White team passing: 42%, black team passing: 83%.
The Unicycling Clown
- Hyman et al (2010) - Participants crossed a square at Western Washington University and passed a unicycling clown.
- After crossing the square they were asked if they noticed anything unusual and if they noticed the clown.
- Different groups (cell phone users, single persons, music player users and pairs) had varying results.
- Music players: 32% noticed something unusual, 61% noticed the clown.
- Cell phones: 8% noticed something unusual, 25% noticed the clown.
"Real-World" Examples of Inattentional Blindness
- Chabris & Simons (2010): A person commented that they did not notice the bicyclist, which appeared to suddenly appear.
- Drew, Vo, & Wolfe (2013): Expert radiologists may miss anomalies in CT scans, even when looking directly at them.
Change Blindness
- The difficulty in detecting changes in a scene/image.
- Examples: 'Whodunnit' and examples on slides 10 and 11 (airplane/farmhouse image)
- "Door" study (the procedure of briefly switching out images) and the associated conditions.
Limits to Change Blindness
- Certain conditions increase change blindness.
- Empty frames between images, temporary occlusions, and slow changes are some examples.
- Simons & Rensink (2005) is a good overview.
Change Blindness and Inattentional Blindness
- Common thread: Both types of blindness arise due to lack of attention.
- Early selection: The stimulus never gets processed.
- Late selection: The stimulus is perceived but might not be remembered.
Change Blindness vs. Inattentional Blindness
- Change blindness: Comparing two images / pictures / movies in terms of specific items.
- Inattentional blindness: Something unexpected or unusual is presented during a task; participants did not explicitly look at that specific thing.
Subliminal Influences on Behaviour
- Subliminal: Below the threshold of awareness.
- Prime: Very briefly presented stimulus, usually masked.
- Limen is a threshold.
The Case of James Vicary
- Claimed to use subliminal advertising to boost sales of Coke and popcorn.
- Data from interviews were suspect.
The Case of Diederik Stapel
- Renowned Dutch professor fabricated data in over fifty publications.
- Was suspended in 2011.
- Fraud in academic research already started in 2004.
Fraud in Academia
- Outright data manipulation/fabrication is often rare.
- Recognize "too good to be true" results or implausibly high effect sizes.
Recent Claims of Successful Subliminal Priming
- Karremans et al (2006): Subliminal priming with "Lipton Ice" increased the choice of that specific drink.
- Difficulty replicating the original studies.
Methodological Problems
- Difficult to prove subliminal stimuli are actually below a threshold.
- Response bias: Participants might partly see the stimulus/prime but deny seeing it.
- Motivation for the task: Prime identification tasks can demotivate participants.
Exam Revision
- Review lecture slides.
- Review Eysenck & Keane (8th edition), Chapters 4 and 5.
- Focus on key facts and concepts; avoid unnecessary detail.
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.
Related Documents
Description
Explore the fascinating limits of attention in cognitive psychology through key concepts like change blindness and inattentional blindness. This quiz will delve into research findings, including the famous 'Gorillas in our midst' study by Simons & Chabris. Test your understanding of how attention shapes perception and the implications of these phenomena.