Podcast
Questions and Answers
Which feature of human language, as described by Hockett, is LEAST evident in the communication system of vervet monkeys?
Which feature of human language, as described by Hockett, is LEAST evident in the communication system of vervet monkeys?
- Arbitrariness, where there is no inherent connection between a signal and its meaning.
- Semanticity, where signals have a specific and consistent association with meaning.
- Specialization, where the communication system is designed for specific purposes and contexts.
- Displacement, where communication can refer to things remote in time or space. (correct)
A researcher observes a new primate species using distinct vocalizations for different food sources but never combining these calls. Which Hockett's design feature is most likely absent?
A researcher observes a new primate species using distinct vocalizations for different food sources but never combining these calls. Which Hockett's design feature is most likely absent?
- Semanticity
- Productivity (correct)
- Vocalization
- Arbitrariness
How does the communication of bees differ from that of primates, particularly concerning inventiveness and open-ended communication?
How does the communication of bees differ from that of primates, particularly concerning inventiveness and open-ended communication?
- Bee communication lacks semanticity.
- Primate communication showcases features that allow for inventiveness, whereas bee communication is limited to specific purposes.
- Primate communication shows a limited repertoire and a lack of inventiveness. (correct)
- Bees exhibit a broader range of vocal sounds compared to primates, facilitating more complex messaging.
What is a key difference between vervet monkey alarm calls and human language regarding Hockett's design features?
What is a key difference between vervet monkey alarm calls and human language regarding Hockett's design features?
If scientists were to discover a primate species that combines existing vocalizations to create new meanings, which design feature of language would this species demonstrate?
If scientists were to discover a primate species that combines existing vocalizations to create new meanings, which design feature of language would this species demonstrate?
Newborn vervet monkeys instinctively produce alarm calls, but they refine their usage over time. What does this suggest about the calls?
Newborn vervet monkeys instinctively produce alarm calls, but they refine their usage over time. What does this suggest about the calls?
What is the significance of vervet monkeys having different alarm calls for leopards, eagles, and snakes?
What is the significance of vervet monkeys having different alarm calls for leopards, eagles, and snakes?
If a primate species uses a specific call to indicate 'food' and another to indicate 'danger', which feature of Hockett's design is being demonstrated?
If a primate species uses a specific call to indicate 'food' and another to indicate 'danger', which feature of Hockett's design is being demonstrated?
What is the significance of human-reared apes mastering Hockett's design features of language?
What is the significance of human-reared apes mastering Hockett's design features of language?
Why is it crucial to avoid overinterpreting a chimpanzee's use of signs for objects like 'banana'?
Why is it crucial to avoid overinterpreting a chimpanzee's use of signs for objects like 'banana'?
What is the main point of comparing a chimpanzee learning signs to a pigeon pecking colored keys?
What is the main point of comparing a chimpanzee learning signs to a pigeon pecking colored keys?
What is the meaning of 'suspending the presumption of a certain kind of intelligence'?
What is the meaning of 'suspending the presumption of a certain kind of intelligence'?
What is a critical question researchers must ask when studying animal language?
What is a critical question researchers must ask when studying animal language?
What does it mean to 'mind the gap between behavior and knowledge' in animal language research?
What does it mean to 'mind the gap between behavior and knowledge' in animal language research?
Which factor most significantly contributes to the difference in communication skills between wild apes and human-reared apes?
Which factor most significantly contributes to the difference in communication skills between wild apes and human-reared apes?
Why should researchers avoid jumping to conclusions about a Chimpanzee's cognitive abilities simply because their actions resemble human behavior?
Why should researchers avoid jumping to conclusions about a Chimpanzee's cognitive abilities simply because their actions resemble human behavior?
What was the main concern raised by Savage-Rumbaugh and her colleagues regarding ape language research?
What was the main concern raised by Savage-Rumbaugh and her colleagues regarding ape language research?
According to the passage, what criteria must be met to demonstrate that an ape is using a sign referentially?
According to the passage, what criteria must be met to demonstrate that an ape is using a sign referentially?
Why is it important to consider all instances in which an ape uses a particular sign, not just the successful ones?
Why is it important to consider all instances in which an ape uses a particular sign, not just the successful ones?
How might researchers inadvertently influence an ape's signing behavior?
How might researchers inadvertently influence an ape's signing behavior?
What type of testing environment is needed to fairly evaluate an ape's knowledge of signs?
What type of testing environment is needed to fairly evaluate an ape's knowledge of signs?
What broader implication did Savage-Rumbaugh's methodological considerations have?
What broader implication did Savage-Rumbaugh's methodological considerations have?
What does the term 'hominids' refer to according to the passage?
What does the term 'hominids' refer to according to the passage?
Considering the concerns raised in the passage, which experimental design would be LEAST effective in determining if an ape understands the meaning of a symbol?
Considering the concerns raised in the passage, which experimental design would be LEAST effective in determining if an ape understands the meaning of a symbol?
What fundamental difference does the text highlight between humans and chimpanzees regarding fairness?
What fundamental difference does the text highlight between humans and chimpanzees regarding fairness?
What characterizes the primary difference between a human's daily experience and that of a chimpanzee?
What characterizes the primary difference between a human's daily experience and that of a chimpanzee?
In the shopping scenario, which of the following does NOT illustrate an aspect of 'institutional reality'?
In the shopping scenario, which of the following does NOT illustrate an aspect of 'institutional reality'?
What does the example of queuing in a store checkout line demonstrate about human behavior?
What does the example of queuing in a store checkout line demonstrate about human behavior?
Which of the following is the LEAST likely reaction a chimpanzee would have in the described shopping scenario?
Which of the following is the LEAST likely reaction a chimpanzee would have in the described shopping scenario?
Which of the following scenarios best demonstrates the human capacity for understanding 'institutional reality,' as distinct from a chimpanzee's perspective?
Which of the following scenarios best demonstrates the human capacity for understanding 'institutional reality,' as distinct from a chimpanzee's perspective?
How would a chimpanzee MOST likely interpret the act of exchanging money for goods in a store?
How would a chimpanzee MOST likely interpret the act of exchanging money for goods in a store?
What does the text suggest about the role of 'institutional realities' in shaping human behavior?
What does the text suggest about the role of 'institutional realities' in shaping human behavior?
According to research on joint attention and language development, which type of pointing is most closely associated with the emergence of language skills in children?
According to research on joint attention and language development, which type of pointing is most closely associated with the emergence of language skills in children?
In the study by Morales et al. (2000), how was joint attention responsiveness measured in infants?
In the study by Morales et al. (2000), how was joint attention responsiveness measured in infants?
What was the key finding of the Morales et al. (2000) study regarding joint attention and vocabulary size?
What was the key finding of the Morales et al. (2000) study regarding joint attention and vocabulary size?
How does the communication style of apes with humans differ from that of human children, according to the information provided?
How does the communication style of apes with humans differ from that of human children, according to the information provided?
Based on the research, what is a potential implication of the difference between imperative and declarative pointing for linguistic sophistication?
Based on the research, what is a potential implication of the difference between imperative and declarative pointing for linguistic sophistication?
In the 'Researchers at Work 2.1' section, what was the hypothesis being tested regarding joint attention?
In the 'Researchers at Work 2.1' section, what was the hypothesis being tested regarding joint attention?
In the description of Test A, how did the researchers control for potential biases when testing joint attention responsiveness in older babies?
In the description of Test A, how did the researchers control for potential biases when testing joint attention responsiveness in older babies?
What specifically did the adult do during Test A to try and engage the child in joint attention?
What specifically did the adult do during Test A to try and engage the child in joint attention?
In the described study, what is the main purpose of the researcher returning her gaze to the child between trials (C)?
In the described study, what is the main purpose of the researcher returning her gaze to the child between trials (C)?
Why were the coders who assessed the children's direction of gaze kept unaware of the children's vocabulary assessment results?
Why were the coders who assessed the children's direction of gaze kept unaware of the children's vocabulary assessment results?
The study uses the MacArthur Communicative Development Inventory (MCDI). What information does the MCDI provide?
The study uses the MacArthur Communicative Development Inventory (MCDI). What information does the MCDI provide?
According to the results, joint attention skills between which ages were most predictive of later vocabulary size?
According to the results, joint attention skills between which ages were most predictive of later vocabulary size?
The authors mention that the correlation found in their study does not prove causation. Which of the following best describes a possible 'third variable' that could explain both joint attention skills and vocabulary size?
The authors mention that the correlation found in their study does not prove causation. Which of the following best describes a possible 'third variable' that could explain both joint attention skills and vocabulary size?
What type of statistical test is most likely used to confirm the association between joint attention skills and vocabulary size?
What type of statistical test is most likely used to confirm the association between joint attention skills and vocabulary size?
In designing a follow-up study to establish a more causal link between joint attention and word learning, which experimental design would be most effective?
In designing a follow-up study to establish a more causal link between joint attention and word learning, which experimental design would be most effective?
Assuming the relationship between joint attention and vocabulary is causal, what theoretical implication would this have for early childhood education?
Assuming the relationship between joint attention and vocabulary is causal, what theoretical implication would this have for early childhood education?
Flashcards
Human-reared Apes & Language
Human-reared Apes & Language
Apes raised by humans show advanced language skills compared to those in the wild, suggesting innate capacity.
Avoiding Overinterpretation
Avoiding Overinterpretation
Carefully avoid overinterpreting animal behavior by attributing complex cognitive abilities without sufficient evidence.
Human-like Language Use
Human-like Language Use
The ability to use language in the same way as humans involves symbolic understanding and intentional communication.
Objective Animal Research
Objective Animal Research
Signup and view all the flashcards
Pigeon Behavior
Pigeon Behavior
Signup and view all the flashcards
Simpler explanation of behavior
Simpler explanation of behavior
Signup and view all the flashcards
Chimps Vs Pigeons
Chimps Vs Pigeons
Signup and view all the flashcards
Sue Savage-Rumbaugh
Sue Savage-Rumbaugh
Signup and view all the flashcards
Learnability
Learnability
Signup and view all the flashcards
Primate Communication
Primate Communication
Signup and view all the flashcards
Semanticity
Semanticity
Signup and view all the flashcards
Arbitrariness
Arbitrariness
Signup and view all the flashcards
Displacement
Displacement
Signup and view all the flashcards
Duality of Patterning
Duality of Patterning
Signup and view all the flashcards
Productivity (in language)
Productivity (in language)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Vervet Monkey Calls
Vervet Monkey Calls
Signup and view all the flashcards
Overattribution
Overattribution
Signup and view all the flashcards
Referential sign use
Referential sign use
Signup and view all the flashcards
Flexible sign production
Flexible sign production
Signup and view all the flashcards
Comprehensive Sign Analysis
Comprehensive Sign Analysis
Signup and view all the flashcards
Inadvertent cueing
Inadvertent cueing
Signup and view all the flashcards
Rigorous testing Situations
Rigorous testing Situations
Signup and view all the flashcards
Hominids
Hominids
Signup and view all the flashcards
Methodological flaws
Methodological flaws
Signup and view all the flashcards
Joint Attention
Joint Attention
Signup and view all the flashcards
Responding to Direct Attention
Responding to Direct Attention
Signup and view all the flashcards
Joint Attention & Language Link
Joint Attention & Language Link
Signup and view all the flashcards
Declarative Pointing
Declarative Pointing
Signup and view all the flashcards
Imperative Pointing
Imperative Pointing
Signup and view all the flashcards
Commenting in Communication
Commenting in Communication
Signup and view all the flashcards
Directing in Communication
Directing in Communication
Signup and view all the flashcards
Joint Attention & Vocabulary Size
Joint Attention & Vocabulary Size
Signup and view all the flashcards
Chimpanzee Altruism
Chimpanzee Altruism
Signup and view all the flashcards
Human vs. Chimpanzee Reality
Human vs. Chimpanzee Reality
Signup and view all the flashcards
Institutional Reality of Shopping
Institutional Reality of Shopping
Signup and view all the flashcards
Shopper's Rights and Obligations
Shopper's Rights and Obligations
Signup and view all the flashcards
Government's Role in Food Safety
Government's Role in Food Safety
Signup and view all the flashcards
Trust in Monetary Systems
Trust in Monetary Systems
Signup and view all the flashcards
Social Norms and Public Behavior
Social Norms and Public Behavior
Signup and view all the flashcards
Impact of Institutional Realities
Impact of Institutional Realities
Signup and view all the flashcards
Vocabulary Checklist (MCDI)
Vocabulary Checklist (MCDI)
Signup and view all the flashcards
PPVT & EVT
PPVT & EVT
Signup and view all the flashcards
Joint Attention and Vocabulary
Joint Attention and Vocabulary
Signup and view all the flashcards
Correlation
Correlation
Signup and view all the flashcards
Third Causal Variable
Third Causal Variable
Signup and view all the flashcards
Causal Role Study
Causal Role Study
Signup and view all the flashcards
Gaze Following
Gaze Following
Signup and view all the flashcards
Study Notes
Origins of Human Language
- Humans are the only species which possess and utilize language, distinguishing from other animals that communicate in more limited ways.
- Unique human activities such as gossiping, seminars, interviews, board meetings, poems, treaties, marriage ceremonies, and criminal trials revolve around language and talking.
- Language is nearly unique to humans, though humans also participate in other unique activities.
- Language is differentiated from other uniquely human activities because all humans do it, past and present, even though not all humans design bridges.
- Genes contribute to language acquisition, with one perspective that language is an innate instinct, while another see it as a by-product of cognitive abilities.
- Steven Pinker's 1994 book, The Language Instinct, supports the nativist view, suggesting genes endow language capacity and general structure.
- An opposing anti-nativist view suggests language isn't an instinct but comes from the impressive cognitive abilities of humans as superlearners.
- Daniel Everett's Language: The Cultural Tool suggests human beings invented language to solve problems like efficiently transmitting information.
- Language is universal like arrows in hunter-gatherer societies, driven by problem-solving competence rather than specific genes.
- Diverse fields of language sciences are yet unable to resolve the debate.
- Questions remain about the definition of language, involved learning, physical and mental machinery. The role of genes in language remains uncertain.
- The Linguistic Society of Paris forbade origin-of-language papers at its conferences in 1866.
Why Us?
- Human language differs from animal communication, such as the honeybees' dance language, by humans making symbolic representations.
- Karl von Frisch identified and described the dance language of honeybees.
- A worker bee communicates nectar location with a waggle dance.
- The bee's dance communicates the nectar source's direction, distance, and quality.
- Direction is indicated by the bee's movement in line with vertical top of hive indicates direction to sun, and angle is relative
- Distance is indicated by length of bee's dance
- Quality of of of nectar source is indicated by vigor
- Different bee species have variations in this dance, each with their own dialect. Bees introduced do not adopt dialect of new hive. Bees can learn each other's dialects
- Honeybee dance language has similarities to human language because it uses body movements to represent things in the real world. It also relies on symbolic representation to ground meanings.
- Human language uses sounds made in the mouth as symbolic units like "eat fruit."
Human Language vs Bee Language
- Bee dances communicate specific information while human language has arbitrary associations.
- Bee dances function like drawing maps with bodies, human language with words.
- Bee dances are limited to one topic of food or water, while human language handles endless topics.
- Human language encompasses making requests, promises, sympathy, and directions. Human language also involves a complexity of structure bees' dance language does not.
- Charles Hockett listed "design features" as common to all human languages, like vocal-auditory channel, broadcast transmission, rapid fading, and interchangeability.
Primate Vocalizations
- Primate communication has a limited repertoire with specific purposes.
- Vervet monkeys have distinct alarm calls for different predators, but their calls lack displacement, duality of patterning and productivity.
- Vervet calls exhibit semanticity and arbitrariness. Their calls are genetically wired and instinctively linked to predator categories. The sounds are fixed from birth and are culturally transmitted, so that eagle alarm is not made in reaction to a pigeon.
- Genetic programming for language is more flexible in humans, enabling versatile language learning, and the nativist position suggests common structural ingredients in all languages.
- Primates show greater flexibility in interpreting signals than producing them
- Vervets do not seem to be born with an understanding of the alarms but learn over time with experiences.
Can Language Be Taught to Apes?
- Non-human primates lack language-like vocalization in the wild, so non-nativists evaluate ape learning with human interaction
- Apes raised in a language-rich environment with other humans could master hundreds of words and symbols.
- Apes can use symbols to request objects, comment on environment, refer to objects not present, and even lie. They’ve also shown suggesting of Hockett's ‘productivity’.
- Comprehension skills are much quicker for apes that production of the language-like units
- Apes struggle to use vocal sounds to represent meaning. Apes cannot articulate different-sounding words.
- Apes can build up a large vocabulary using signed language for spoken languages and adopt visual symbols arranged in systematic structures.
Hockett's Design Features
- Vocal-auditory channel: language is produced in vocal tract and transmitted as sound.
- Broadcast Transmission and directional reception: language can be heard coming from one direction.
- rapid Fading: sounds produced by speech quickly
- Interchangeability: user of a language can send and receive the same message
- Total feedback: Senders of message can hear message
- Specialization: production of sound in language other than to communicate
- Semanticity: There are aspects and the units of language
- Arbitrariness: meaningful associations
- Discreteness: units of language are separate and not part of whole
- Displacement: language an be used to communicate things not present in time
- Productivity: can say things not been said before
- Traditional transmission: specific language is adopted to exposure of other users
- Duality of Patterning: words combined with sounds in patterns
- Prevarication: used to make false statements
- Reflexiveness: language to describe itself
- Learnability: use of language to learn to use a different language
Evolution of Communication
- Genetically, the most common view is that humans have some innate capabilities for language that evolved as adaptations
- Evolutionary adaptations transmit traits that gives individuals advantages, with the advantageous gene spreading
- The piano-playing analogy questions why only humans use language if apes' language capabilities evolved before divergence.
Social Cognition
- Humans are inclined to share information while other primates have not been able to discover the benefits of doing so. Social behavior is more important to humans.
- Chimps are less altruistic/caring than humans
- To navigate the human world we need a certain social aptitude that chimps do not. Language, law, money - require buy in
- Socially-oriented motivation
- Humans have the capacity for joint attention: more are more individuals are paying attention to the same thing
- Joint attention skills are evident in extremely young humans. Toward the en of te first year, babies direct people's attention and use elaborate vocalizations.
- Humans have a sense of "commenting with humans."
Language Structure
- Language has the properties of both symbols and combination.
- Combination requires two levels:
- Words: using relatively few sounds to communicate, but they cannot communicate complex ideas.
- Sentences: requires combining meaningful elements like sounds, but requires agreed upon rules of syntax so meanings are clear.
The Structure of Language
- The question of recursivity and syntax goes past vocabulary and word choice in generating meaning from the elements that are used.
- "Nesting" of related clauses or other linguistic units within each other
The Evolution of Speech
- The ability to speak was the third factor in being contribute to human language.
- Speech requires a finely tuned delivery system through which the linguistic signal is transmitted.
- Human distinctiveness stems from both symbols/structure of words. Humans use speech, other primates do not.
- Apes can barely utter more than four indistinct words no matter how hard they try.
- Human speech production involves pushing air through lungs, control lips,and coordinate these parts at millisecond timing.
- Chimpanzee's larynx is not as low as human's. Chimpanzee cannot pronounce vowels in bead or boo.
- Having correct anatomy involves the ability to learn any skills for equipment.
- It does not make you a guitar player if someone gives you a guitar
The Vocalization of Primates
- Most primates have a relatively fixed and largely innate set of vocalizations that is not largely affected by the environment. This does not occur in babies who change their voices over time.
- Vocal imitation has birds and aquatic animals
- Several researchers have argued that not all vocalizations made by humans or other animals are rooted through the neural pathway.
- It needs to be in a way that is related to arousal, emotion, and motivation. The sounds that are made largely in born for the most part.
- Human animals can make a vocal call through a cognitive pathway involving auditory before can be reliably. Different from other primates
- Hockett was wrong. Human languages are universally spoken as truth. Speech has been default for transmit language.
Hockett's Design Features of Human Language
- Language is produced in the vocal channel and transmitted as sound and is through auditory channels.
- There is broad cast transmission or direction reception. Language can be heard from many directions, coming from one particular
- A user of language can send and receive the same message. Language can be deliberate to make false statements
- There is rapid fading and the sounds produced by language has the ability to be transmitted quickly.
- The user and sender can hear internalized messages
- The production of sounds
- Users can use it to describe or refer to itself and can learn use in a different language.
The Evolution of Gestures
- Humans have evolved perfectly with anatomy and the nervous system. Adaptations have been made for linguistic communication and humans are not dependent on it through speech in any modality.
- The hypothesis shows the earliest forms of human language and the ancestors communication comes down to gestures. Apes bad communicate any of speech from any semblance
The Innateness of Language
- Primates do use spontaneous gestures. This is the interesting flexible vocals. Vocal sounds are limited to very specific context and the Ape see is able to use gestures.
- Gestures can be adapted in varying settings like words. Gesture has made a plausible communication towards the primate line. Vocalizations have been unlike humans
The Study of Language
- People who are deaf can be separated from hearing communities. Children can invent sign and gestures with the help and the instruction of their parents
- If deaf people are separated, the communication can be system systematically. If you can't hear it, you're separated to become innovative or complicated.
- In addition to being born with the capacity to learn, language children can be born to invent languages and similarities or together
- But who are relatively raised to the otherwise are socially have made it be useful analogies. It's not easy to make it Some things would and maybe wouldn’t be depending on the circumstances but all that have a shared system that helps a group of sign be made more in order to gain something about their language The Nicaraguan kids so basic on the language. It's altered to what was best more creative. and some efficiency is gained with certain aspects by being restructured and reorganized.
- The efficiency is gained by those that is known as Pantomiming. If he'd just get still production in a series and certain order.
Evolutionary Linguistics
- Senghas researchers suggested 2 ingredients on how shared home sign needs to process past its humble beginings: the comminuty by language, a progession of exposure.
- The greatest is the greatest competence is had with new learners having the structure that put all there
Language and Genetics
- There are a high amount of linguistic input. The window of of during when should see a see the to to be a foreign speaker like their nature. Easy to see in imigrant in their newly.
- But what do they show They also need to show them show them.
Evolution
- Many nativists have seen that a sensitive period of language supports the view that has an intermitted specified with vigorous capacity
- The the sensitive period of language comes to get the sounds right with hours of practice The researchers see parts of the language. But that has the language is easy from
- Theories are also more compatible for people that speak
- In these cases, they often are good in areas like tests, which may make one understand With how much of how did that, and what do you do with have with They that what
- So how is our language related have
The Evolution of Language - Genetics
- Since 1950s, Down Syndrome was identified as linked genetics. It is known that ability and to make functions or or or or or a glitch, has a certain point These important to know to learn there be system has a a as If language is from ability have should what on And hand as was would that that module not a a know to is is is is there? Well with genetic a language of have with genetic and and and with genetic would
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.