Study Guide Questions Exam #1 PDF
Document Details
Uploaded by CelebratedCosine
Columbia University School of Nursing
Tags
Summary
This document discusses biological parameters and the use of race in medicine. It highlights how "race" is not a biological concept, while also stressing how social categories like race can cause disparities in disease incidence.
Full Transcript
Study Guide Questions Exam #1 1) What is “normal” in terms of biological parameters? What are some examples of sources of variation on “normal.” Sources of variation on “normal” Genetics Age...
Study Guide Questions Exam #1 1) What is “normal” in terms of biological parameters? What are some examples of sources of variation on “normal.” Sources of variation on “normal” Genetics Age ○ HR for 3 y/o is tachycardic for an adult Gender (Sex) ○ Hormone level – testosterone, [estrogen, progesterone] ○ Testosterone = higher RBC count Situational ○ Living at sea level (lower RBC count) vs high altitude (more RBC count) Time ○ Hormone levels Testosterone levels highest in morning Female hormone levels diff based on ovulation cycle Laboratory conditions ○ Every lab has their own reference values based on their tests There is no single value for any biological parameter that is normal. There is a distribution of normal within a population. 2) How has “race” been used in medicine as a source of variation in biological parameters? Why is this problematic? Race: historically used as source of variation in normal values Problematic because the way race is defined does not tie it to something biological Race is self-identified with very broad categories (African American, non-Hispanic, Hispanic) Does not translate to what people think it does ○ BELIEF: People THINK race = ancestry-related genes → r/t variation in biological parameters & disease Ancestry-related genes correspond to only 0.1% of genes differences between ppl ○ Ancestry-related genes represent only minuscule part of genome ○ REALITY: race ≠ ancestry-related genes Race = social category Race is only used as a very poor substitute for ancestry-related genes Medicine ○ Repeatedly weaponized throughout history to justify & rationalize enslavement of black people ○ Still used to obfuscate incidents of racial injustice ○ Used race as sorting tool w/ profound impacts on diagnostics & treatments of disease Inaccurate, not true, and perpetuates idea that individuals in different racial categories are biologically different ○ When in fact, people from different racial categories are biologically the same ○ Reinforces racial stereotypes ○ Leads to bad medicine ○ Implicit bias ○ Use of harmful standards of care that have gone unexamined When we find differences in disease incidence and health outcomes, it is a difference in social determinants (from oppression) → it shows disparities and NOT differences in genetics 1