Podcast
Questions and Answers
What is a key characteristic of a liberal welfare state?
What is a key characteristic of a liberal welfare state?
What is a common issue with the conservative welfare state?
What is a common issue with the conservative welfare state?
Why might a supranational welfare state not be viable in the European context?
Why might a supranational welfare state not be viable in the European context?
What is a potential issue with risk pooling in a homogeneous group?
What is a potential issue with risk pooling in a homogeneous group?
Signup and view all the answers
What is a characteristic of two-sided solidarity?
What is a characteristic of two-sided solidarity?
Signup and view all the answers
What may happen if there is an imbalance between one-sided and two-sided solidarity in a welfare state?
What may happen if there is an imbalance between one-sided and two-sided solidarity in a welfare state?
Signup and view all the answers
Why might international risk pooling be beneficial?
Why might international risk pooling be beneficial?
Signup and view all the answers
What is a potential issue with informal, communal solidarity?
What is a potential issue with informal, communal solidarity?
Signup and view all the answers
Why might the conservative welfare state appeal to the middle-class?
Why might the conservative welfare state appeal to the middle-class?
Signup and view all the answers
What is a characteristic of a liberal welfare state in terms of taxation?
What is a characteristic of a liberal welfare state in terms of taxation?
Signup and view all the answers
Study Notes
Liberal Welfare State
- Limits welfare to one-sided solidarity, covering only basic needs, resulting in low costs
- Provides less protection to the least-advantaged citizens
- Two-sided solidarity is organized outside of the welfare state, through private companies in the free market
Characteristics
- Draws a strict line between those who receive welfare and those who contribute to it
- Prevents costly circulation of funds between the same people
- Appeals to affective motives, such as community spirit or altruism, but not self-interest
- Problematic in countries with no strong affective motives, as people may not want to help without receiving anything in return
Challenges
- Processes of individualization and globalization may weaken affective motives
- Creates in-group and out-group dynamics, with the contributors and the poor
- Outsiders are kept out as much as possible
- The problem of adverse selection: only those who need specific support will want others to contribute to it
Conservative Welfare State
- Supports external misfortune insurances, such as sickness and disability
- Based on both one-sided and two-sided solidarity
- Provides high standard of public services to the middle classes and decent support to the least advantaged
- High taxes make it questionable if these states are sustainable long-term
Scandinavian Model
- Higher community spirit due to higher homogeneity
- Personal contact fosters affective ties and facilitates control of individual behavior
- Prevents opportunistic behavior and abuse
- Risks and benefits are more similar, thus no disproportionate benefit
- Everyone has the same chance to benefit from solidarity
Possible Issues
- Nullified solidarity between groups
- People with above-average risks can have difficulties accessing groups
- Insufficient risk spread (everyone experiences a downturn at the same time in the same industry, so no one can pay the unemployment benefits)
- Unclear optimal scale of organization
Supranational Welfare State
- Considered viable by very few people in the European context
- Large differences between current national welfare states
- Pre-conditions of two-sided solidarity are not met
- No direct payments from the EU to citizens
- Economic risks, such as unemployment, are not presented equally in Europe
- Most people do not consider themselves primarily European and trust fellow countrymen more
International Risk Pooling
- Can be beneficial and provide a more stable support
- Based on pure enlightened self-interest
- Already done by international corporations to avert risk
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.
Description
This quiz explores the characteristics of a liberal welfare state, including the limitations of one-sided solidarity and the role of private insurance companies in providing protection to citizens.
