6 Questions
Explain the difference between majority and plurality voting systems and provide an example of each.
The majority voting system requires a candidate to receive more than 50% of the votes to win. An example is the two-round system used in France. The plurality voting system, on the other hand, only requires a candidate to receive more votes than any other candidate, without the need for a majority. An example is the electoral college system used in the United States presidential elections.
Describe the Borda count method and provide an example of how it is applied in a voting scenario.
The Borda count method is a preferential voting system where voters rank candidates in order of preference, and points are assigned to each ranking. The candidate with the highest total points wins. An example of its application is in ranking candidates in a beauty pageant, where judges assign points to each contestant based on their ranking.
Compare and contrast the computation process for majority and plurality voting systems with the Borda count method.
The computation process for majority and plurality voting systems involves counting the number of votes for each candidate and determining if a candidate has received a majority or plurality of votes. In the Borda count method, the computation involves assigning points to each candidate based on their ranking and then summing up the points to determine the winner. The Borda count method requires more complex computation compared to majority and plurality voting systems.
Match the following voting system with their primary characteristics:
Majority Voting System = Candidate with more than half of the votes wins Plurality Voting System = Candidate with the most votes wins Borda Count Method = Candidates are ranked and assigned points based on their rankings Computation in Voting = Utilizes mathematical calculations to determine the winner
Match the following scenarios with the appropriate voting system:
Election with multiple candidates = Plurality Voting System Selecting the best option from a list of choices = Borda Count Method Decision-making process requiring a clear mandate = Majority Voting System Utilizing weighted preferences in voting = Computation in Voting
Match the following voting systems with their potential drawbacks:
Majority Voting System = Possible exclusion of minority preferences Plurality Voting System = Winner may not have majority support Borda Count Method = Vulnerable to strategic manipulation Computation in Voting = Complexity in implementation and understanding
Study Notes
Voting Systems
Majority vs. Plurality Voting Systems
- In a majority voting system, a candidate must receive more than 50% of the votes to win.
- In a plurality voting system, the candidate with the most votes wins, even if they don't receive more than 50% of the votes.
- Example of majority voting system: a mayor election where the winner must receive 51% of the votes.
- Example of plurality voting system: a US presidential election where the winner is the candidate with the most votes, even if they don't receive 50% of the votes.
Borda Count Method
- The Borda count method is a voting system in which voters rank candidates in order of preference.
- Each candidate receives a certain number of points based on their ranking (e.g. 1st place = 3 points, 2nd place = 2 points, 3rd place = 1 point).
- The candidate with the most points wins.
- Example: in a 3-candidate election, voter A ranks candidates as A>B>C, voter B ranks as B>C>A, and voter C ranks as C>A>B. Candidate A receives 3 points from voter A, 1 point from voter B, and 2 points from voter C, for a total of 6 points. Candidate B receives 2 points from voter A, 3 points from voter B, and 1 point from voter C, for a total of 6 points. Candidate C receives 1 point from voter A, 2 points from voter B, and 3 points from voter C, for a total of 6 points. In this case, there is a tie, and a tiebreaker may be needed.
Comparison of Voting Systems
- In majority and plurality voting systems, voters select one candidate, and the winner is determined based on the number of votes received.
- In the Borda count method, voters rank candidates, and the winner is determined based on the points received.
- The computation process for majority and plurality voting systems is based on the number of votes, while the Borda count method is based on the ranking of candidates.
Matching Voting Systems with Primary Characteristics
- Plurality voting system: winner does not need to receive more than 50% of the votes
- Majority voting system: winner must receive more than 50% of the votes
- Borda count method: voters rank candidates in order of preference
Matching Scenarios with Voting Systems
- A single winner election where the winner must receive more than 50% of the votes: majority voting system
- A presidential election where the winner is the candidate with the most votes: plurality voting system
- A committee election where voters rank candidates in order of preference: Borda count method
Matching Voting Systems with Potential Drawbacks
- Plurality voting system: can lead to a winner with less than 50% of the votes
- Majority voting system: can lead to a runoff election if no candidate receives more than 50% of the votes
- Borda count method: can be complex and time-consuming to calculate the winner
1. In a local election, candidate A receives 40% of the vote, candidate B receives 35%, and candidate C receives 25%. Which voting system would declare candidate A the winner?
Make Your Own Quizzes and Flashcards
Convert your notes into interactive study material.
Get started for free
