Podcast
Questions and Answers
What is the primary objection Mill addresses regarding the focus on pleasure in morality?
What is the primary objection Mill addresses regarding the focus on pleasure in morality?
- It overlooks the role of intellectual pleasure.
- It does not consider the moral implications of actions.
- It may promote hedonism as a lifestyle.
- It could value all forms of pleasure equally. (correct)
Which statement reflects Mill's view on higher pleasures?
Which statement reflects Mill's view on higher pleasures?
- Higher pleasures are more valuable due to human intellectual and emotional capacities. (correct)
- Higher pleasures are merely more abundant than lower pleasures.
- All pleasures can be ranked based solely on duration.
- Higher pleasures can be measured without reference to human experiences.
What distinguishes Mill's concept of pleasure from the principles of asceticism?
What distinguishes Mill's concept of pleasure from the principles of asceticism?
- Mill emphasizes the importance of higher pleasures over mere sensory experiences. (correct)
- Mill argues that lower pleasures are more beneficial.
- Asceticism advocates for the pursuit of all pleasures equally.
- Asceticism places value on sensory pleasures.
How does Mill propose measuring the quality of pleasures?
How does Mill propose measuring the quality of pleasures?
What is the fundamental difference between qualitative and quantitative pleasure according to Mill?
What is the fundamental difference between qualitative and quantitative pleasure according to Mill?
What does the principle of asceticism advocate in contrast to utilitarianism?
What does the principle of asceticism advocate in contrast to utilitarianism?
What is the primary focus of the principle of sympathy and antipathy?
What is the primary focus of the principle of sympathy and antipathy?
In Bentham's hedonic calculus, which property addresses how long the expected pleasure will last?
In Bentham's hedonic calculus, which property addresses how long the expected pleasure will last?
Which of the following does Bentham NOT consider as one of the properties to measure pleasure and pain?
Which of the following does Bentham NOT consider as one of the properties to measure pleasure and pain?
What distinguishes Mill's higher pleasures from Bentham's approach to pleasure?
What distinguishes Mill's higher pleasures from Bentham's approach to pleasure?
In utilitarian ethical theory, which statement about the ultimate good is accurate?
In utilitarian ethical theory, which statement about the ultimate good is accurate?
Which of the following factors in Bentham's calculus relates to how likely an expected pleasure is not to be followed by pain?
Which of the following factors in Bentham's calculus relates to how likely an expected pleasure is not to be followed by pain?
How does the concept of extent relate to utilitarianism according to Bentham?
How does the concept of extent relate to utilitarianism according to Bentham?
Which objection relates to the issue of taking pleasure in harmful actions such as murder?
Which objection relates to the issue of taking pleasure in harmful actions such as murder?
What is the concern raised by the quality objection regarding Mill's hedonism?
What is the concern raised by the quality objection regarding Mill's hedonism?
Which objection highlights the complexities of moral responsibilities beyond mere actions?
Which objection highlights the complexities of moral responsibilities beyond mere actions?
What is a potential problem with utilitarianism as indicated by counterintuitive implications?
What is a potential problem with utilitarianism as indicated by counterintuitive implications?
What is the distinction made in Mill's higher pleasures compared to Bentham's hedonic calculus?
What is the distinction made in Mill's higher pleasures compared to Bentham's hedonic calculus?
Which principle suggests that strictly adhering to rules will ultimately produce the greatest happiness?
Which principle suggests that strictly adhering to rules will ultimately produce the greatest happiness?
What criticism might be made against utilitarianism concerning the idea of supererogation?
What criticism might be made against utilitarianism concerning the idea of supererogation?
Which objection targets the feasibility of achieving consensus regarding subjective pleasures?
Which objection targets the feasibility of achieving consensus regarding subjective pleasures?
Study Notes
Utilitarianism
- Utilitarianism: A moral philosophy that emphasizes maximizing pleasure and minimizing pain for the greatest number of people.
- Two key figures: Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill.
- Bentham: The principle of utility = maximize pleasure, everyone counts as one and no one more than one, pleasures of sentient creatures are the ultimate goods.
- Mill: Argued that some types of pleasures are higher than others, and those higher pleasures come from using human's higher faculties: intellectual, emotional, moral, and imaginative.
- Mill believes that higher pleasures are not comparable to lower pleasures in quantity, but in quality of that experience.
- Preference test: Determine the quality of pleasure by asking competent judges: "what all, almost all, or a majority decides is the higher pleasure?"
- Non-rational beings may be content or satisfied with lower pleasures.
- Bentham's arguments presented as an argument by elimination: Eliminates other moral principles by showing that they are unsatisfactory.
Bentham's Hedonic Calculus
- Bentham presents seven factors for calculating the amount of pleasure or pain an action will produce:
- Intensity
- Duration
- Certainty
- Remoteness
- Fecundity
- Purity
- Extent
Objections to Utilitarianism
- Evil Pleasures Objection: This objection states that a murderer derives pleasure from killing, and utilitarianism would seem to justify it if it maximizes the pleasure of the killer.
- Quality Objection: Does Mill's hedonism correctly account for the quality of pleasure? Can people actually distinguish between different kinds of pleasure, or is it just a matter of consensus or diversity?
- Irrelevance Objection: This objection argues that utilitarianism is unable to provide a theory of the right, because it only focuses on maximizing happiness, not on right action.
- Over-demandingness Objection: Utilitarianism demands too much of us, it requires constantly striving to maximize happiness for everyone.
- Supererogation Objection: This objection argues that utilitarianism does not allow for supererogatory actions (actions beyond what is required by duty), because any action not maximizing happiness is considered morally wrong.
- Negative Responsibility Objection: This objection states that we are responsible for the actions we take, as well as for the consequences of our inaction.
- Agent-centered Responsibility Objection: This objection argues that utilitarianism does not adequately account for our special obligations to other agents, such as to our family, friends, and community.
- Counterintuitive Implications Objection: This objection highlights that utilitarianism can lead to morally unjust conclusions in some situations.
Replies and Fixes to Utilitarianism
- Act Utilitarianism vs. Rule Utilitarianism: Rule utilitarianism emphasizes following rules that will ultimately maximize happiness, whereas act utilitarianism focuses on calculating the consequences of each individual action.
- This is a potential fix for the over-demandingness objection, since following rules may be less demanding than calculating the consequences of each action.
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.
Related Documents
Description
Explore the fundamental principles of utilitarianism, a moral philosophy focused on maximizing pleasure and minimizing pain for the greatest number. Delve into the insights of key figures Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill, and understand their differing views on the quality of pleasures.
