Podcast
Questions and Answers
A nation-state is experiencing challenges in precisely determining its maritime zones due to a highly irregular coastline with multiple islands and deep bays. Which legal precedent, related to establishing baselines, might offer guidance in resolving this specific issue?
A nation-state is experiencing challenges in precisely determining its maritime zones due to a highly irregular coastline with multiple islands and deep bays. Which legal precedent, related to establishing baselines, might offer guidance in resolving this specific issue?
- The guidelines for managing pollution within the contiguous zone.
- The principle of 'innocent passage' as defined under UNCLOS.
- The regulations governing Exclusive Economic Zones (EEZs) for resource management.
- The 'persistent objector' rule established in the Anglo-Norwegian Fisheries Case. (correct)
A foreign cargo ship is transiting through a nation's territorial sea. Under UNCLOS, the ship's passage is considered 'innocent' EXCEPT when it is...
A foreign cargo ship is transiting through a nation's territorial sea. Under UNCLOS, the ship's passage is considered 'innocent' EXCEPT when it is...
- displaying its national flag and identification clearly.
- using designated sea lanes established by the coastal state.
- conducting hydrographic surveys without explicit authorization. (correct)
- making reasonable progress through the territorial sea.
A coastal state discovers illegal fishing activities by a foreign vessel within its Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ). According to the Law of the Sea, what actions are permitted?
A coastal state discovers illegal fishing activities by a foreign vessel within its Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ). According to the Law of the Sea, what actions are permitted?
- The coastal state may exercise rights related to natural resources, including fishing activities, within the EEZ. (correct)
- The coastal state can only issue a warning but cannot seize the vessel.
- The coastal state can only monitor the vessel but cannot interfere with its activities.
- The coastal state must seek approval from the United Nations before taking any action.
A nation wishes to lay a submarine communications cable across the Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ) of another country. What conditions apply under the Law of the Sea?
A nation wishes to lay a submarine communications cable across the Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ) of another country. What conditions apply under the Law of the Sea?
A foreign warship is navigating through the territorial sea of a coastal state. According to UNCLOS, which of the following actions would automatically violate the principle of 'innocent passage'?
A foreign warship is navigating through the territorial sea of a coastal state. According to UNCLOS, which of the following actions would automatically violate the principle of 'innocent passage'?
A vessel commits a customs violation within a state's contiguous zone. What enforcement actions can the coastal state legally undertake?
A vessel commits a customs violation within a state's contiguous zone. What enforcement actions can the coastal state legally undertake?
Which of the following best describes the legal status of internal waters under the Law of the Sea?
Which of the following best describes the legal status of internal waters under the Law of the Sea?
What is the primary function of baselines in the context of maritime law?
What is the primary function of baselines in the context of maritime law?
What is a key requirement for a land territory or island to claim territorial waters and an Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ) under the Law of the Sea?
What is a key requirement for a land territory or island to claim territorial waters and an Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ) under the Law of the Sea?
Which of the following is NOT a right granted by sovereign control of a land territory or island?
Which of the following is NOT a right granted by sovereign control of a land territory or island?
China's claim to the South China Sea is based on what historical argument?
China's claim to the South China Sea is based on what historical argument?
What principle of UNCLOS does China's 'Law on the Territorial Sea' (1992) potentially contradict?
What principle of UNCLOS does China's 'Law on the Territorial Sea' (1992) potentially contradict?
What was the significance of the UN arbitration ruling in July 2016 regarding the South China Sea?
What was the significance of the UN arbitration ruling in July 2016 regarding the South China Sea?
What was the direct consequence of the Philippines filing a UN arbitration case against China in January 2013?
What was the direct consequence of the Philippines filing a UN arbitration case against China in January 2013?
The US立场s in the South China Sea dispute have primarily focused on:
The US立场s in the South China Sea dispute have primarily focused on:
What is the primary purpose of ASEAN and China negotiating a 'code of conduct' for the South China Sea?
What is the primary purpose of ASEAN and China negotiating a 'code of conduct' for the South China Sea?
What action did the Philippines take in 2011 to assert its claim to the South China Sea?
What action did the Philippines take in 2011 to assert its claim to the South China Sea?
Why is the South China Sea considered a 'priority theater' in the US national defense strategy?
Why is the South China Sea considered a 'priority theater' in the US national defense strategy?
Under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (LOSC), what recourse is available if conciliation fails to resolve a dispute over maritime zones?
Under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (LOSC), what recourse is available if conciliation fails to resolve a dispute over maritime zones?
A coastal state intends to exploit resources on its continental shelf beyond 200 nautical miles. According to the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (LOSC), which activity falls under its sovereign rights?
A coastal state intends to exploit resources on its continental shelf beyond 200 nautical miles. According to the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (LOSC), which activity falls under its sovereign rights?
What is the primary goal of the 'High Seas Treaty' adopted in June 2023?
What is the primary goal of the 'High Seas Treaty' adopted in June 2023?
In the context of maritime boundary disputes, what did the ICJ rule in the North Sea Continental Shelf Cases regarding the equidistance principle?
In the context of maritime boundary disputes, what did the ICJ rule in the North Sea Continental Shelf Cases regarding the equidistance principle?
If a vessel is engaged in piracy on the high seas, which entity has the authority to exercise jurisdiction over it?
If a vessel is engaged in piracy on the high seas, which entity has the authority to exercise jurisdiction over it?
What is the legal implication of a state ratifying the 'High Seas Treaty'?
What is the legal implication of a state ratifying the 'High Seas Treaty'?
In maritime boundary delimitation, what does the concept of 'equitable principles' emphasize?
In maritime boundary delimitation, what does the concept of 'equitable principles' emphasize?
According to the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (LOSC), what is the 'flag state' responsible for?
According to the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (LOSC), what is the 'flag state' responsible for?
What is the first step for resolving disputes related to the interpretation or application of the Law of the Sea Convention (LOSC)?
What is the first step for resolving disputes related to the interpretation or application of the Law of the Sea Convention (LOSC)?
How did the ICJ's ruling in the North Sea Continental Shelf Cases influence subsequent maritime delimitation agreements?
How did the ICJ's ruling in the North Sea Continental Shelf Cases influence subsequent maritime delimitation agreements?
Flashcards
UNCLOS
UNCLOS
An international agreement governing the use of the world's oceans.
Internal Waters
Internal Waters
Waters treated as part of a state's land territory, with full territorial sovereignty.
Baselines (Law of the Sea)
Baselines (Law of the Sea)
Lines that separate a state's internal waters from external waters and from which maritime zones are measured.
Territorial Sea
Territorial Sea
Signup and view all the flashcards
Innocent Passage
Innocent Passage
Signup and view all the flashcards
Contiguous Zone
Contiguous Zone
Signup and view all the flashcards
Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ)
Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Navigational Freedoms in EEZ
Navigational Freedoms in EEZ
Signup and view all the flashcards
Continental Shelf
Continental Shelf
Signup and view all the flashcards
High Seas
High Seas
Signup and view all the flashcards
Flag State
Flag State
Signup and view all the flashcards
Pirate Vessel Jurisdiction
Pirate Vessel Jurisdiction
Signup and view all the flashcards
"High Seas Treaty"
"High Seas Treaty"
Signup and view all the flashcards
Conciliation Procedure (LOSC)
Conciliation Procedure (LOSC)
Signup and view all the flashcards
ITLOS
ITLOS
Signup and view all the flashcards
Equidistance Principle
Equidistance Principle
Signup and view all the flashcards
"Equitable" Boundary Principle
"Equitable" Boundary Principle
Signup and view all the flashcards
North Sea Continental Shelf Case Ruling
North Sea Continental Shelf Case Ruling
Signup and view all the flashcards
Definition of Island (UNCLOS)
Definition of Island (UNCLOS)
Signup and view all the flashcards
South China Sea (SCS)
South China Sea (SCS)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Nine-dashed Line
Nine-dashed Line
Signup and view all the flashcards
UNCLOS (Law of the Sea)
UNCLOS (Law of the Sea)
Signup and view all the flashcards
China's Territorial Sea Law (1992)
China's Territorial Sea Law (1992)
Signup and view all the flashcards
West Philippine Sea
West Philippine Sea
Signup and view all the flashcards
China Artificial Islands
China Artificial Islands
Signup and view all the flashcards
Freedom of Navigation (FON) Missions
Freedom of Navigation (FON) Missions
Signup and view all the flashcards
Study Notes
- Here are your study notes
UN Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS)
- Negotiations started in 1973
- Adopted in December 1982
- Went into effect in November 1994
- Key treaty governing the law of the sea
Importance of UNCLOS
- Addresses key issues like state sovereignty, territorial boundaries, and state interests
Types of Waters
- Internal waters: treated as part of a state's land territory with full territorial sovereignty
Baselines
- Separate a state's internal waters from external waters
- Used to measure maritime zones
- Normal baseline traces the coast
- Issues arise with islands, bays, etc.
- 1951 Anglo-Norwegian Fisheries Case example regarding customary law and "persistent objector" rule
Territorial Sea
- Extends 12 nautical miles from baselines
- Sovereignty is limited
- Foreign vessels have "innocent passage," including foreign military vessels
Innocent Passage
- Passage considers "innocent" if it's not prejudicial to the peace, good order, or security of the state
- Passage must be continuous and expeditious
State Duties
- States have duties to foreign vessels in their territorial sea
- Foreign vessels not engaged in innocent passage may be excluded
Contiguous Zone
- Extends 24 nautical miles from baselines
- Coastal state may exercise control to prevent crime in its territory or territorial sea, and to punish crimes committed there
Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ)
- Extends 200 nautical miles from baselines
- States have rights related to natural resources within the EEZ, including fishing activities
EEZ Rights
- States have rights over mining and pollution management
- Foreign vessels have navigational freedoms
- Other states can lay submarine cables and pipelines in the EEZ
Continental Shelf
- Coastal state has sovereign rights over natural resources (soil and seabed)
- A state can claim a continental shelf extending beyond 200 nautical miles
High Seas
- Open to all states
Flag State
- "Flag state" exercises jurisdiction over its vessels on high seas.
Piracy
- All states may exercise jurisdiction over pirate vessels
- UNSC resolutions from 2010-2022
- New "high seas treaty" to protect marine life adopted in June 2023
Comprehensive Treaty
- First comprehensive treaty in this area aiming for 30% protection by 2030
- Process started in 2004
- Open for signature Sept 2023; currently has 107 signatures and 15 ratifications/accessions
Maritime Zones
- LOSC has compromissory clauses for dispute resolutions
- Conciliation procedure under section 1 involves a panel making non-binding recommendations
Dispute Resolution
- If settlement is impossible under section 1, either party may resort to compulsory dispute settlement provisions in section 2, which LOSC has
- Agreements are resolved by one of 4 legally binding procedures: ITLOS, ICJ, general arbitral tribunal, or arbitral tribunal with specialists
Overlapping Claims
- Many claims to sea areas and continental shelf exist
- Customary law tends to favor a median line between 2 states, but this is complicated with more states
Equidistance Principle
- States/tribunals are often unwilling to automatically apply the equidistance principle, so it must be "equitable"
North Sea Continental Shelf Case
- Germany wasn't part of the Convention on the Continental Shelf
- Denmark and the Netherlands argued equidistance was customary international law
- Applying equidistance gave Germany a smaller portion
ICJ Ruling
- Concluded equidistance wasn't customary international law, so Germany wasn't legally bound
- Observed equidistance may lead to inequity; delimitation must be agreed upon by states using equitable principles
No Solution
- Delimitation must be effected by agreement in accordance with international law, Article 38 of the Statute of the ICJ, to achieve an equitable solution
Negotiation
- A solution was negotiated based on ICJ ruling
- Germany got a larger portion of the continental shelf using the "equitable" principle
Importance of Land Territory and Islands
- Can generate a continental shelf and an EEZ covering hundreds of square miles
- Fishing and natural resources are sovereign rights
- Other states' actions are limited to "innocent passage" in territorial waters
- Definition of island: must sustain human life and economic activity to create territorial waters, EEZ
Islands in South China Sea (SCS)
- Claimed by China, Vietnam, Philippines, Malaysia, and Brunei, impacting fishing, mining, trade, and military functions
China's Claim
- China claims sovereignty over everything within "Nine-dashed Line"
Historic Rights
- China claims ownership since the Xia dynasty (921st-16th centuries BCE)
- Vietnam disputes, claiming ownership since the 17th century
Proximity
- The Philippines claims based on geographical proximity
- Malaysia and Brunei claim territory falls within their EEZ as defined by LOSC
History of SCS Dispute
- 1974: China seizes Paracel Islands from Vietnam
- February 1992: China's "Law on the Territorial Sea" requires foreign military ships to get permission to enter China
UNCLOS in the SCS
- 1994: UNCLOS enters into force (China accedes in 1996) and defines maritime boundaries
- China has a reservation on innocent passage
Continental Shelves
- May 2009: Malaysia and Vietnam file to extend their continental shelves beyond 200 nm
- In response, China makes "nine-dash line" claim
US Involvement
- July 23, 2010: US affirms interests in open access to Asia's maritime commons
- Early-mid 2011: Philippines and Vietnam highlight "harassment" of their ships surveying and oil exploration
- China begins naval "incursions" into their waters
Philippines and China
- October 2011: Philippines renames SCS as the West Philippine Sea and the US supports
- April 8, 2012: Scarborough Shoal Incident (2-month standoff)
Vietnam and China
- June 2012: Vietnam claims jurisdiction over Spratly and Paracel islands, demanding notification from foreign naval ships passing through
- China responds by establishing Sansha City
UN Arbitration
- January 2013: Philippines files UN Arbitration over China's claims in the SCS
- 2013: China begins dredging to build artificial islands around reefs
Dredging Operations
- 2014: Dredging operation underway
- October 2015: US sails within 12 nautical miles of artificial islands, engaging in FON missions
Tribunals
- July 2016: UN tribunal rules against China
- Rejected China's historic rights, said China violated international law, and said these are not "islands" legally, falling in Philippines EEZ
No Enforcement
- China has not abided by the decision
- September 2018: USS Decatur travelled within 12 nautical miles of Chinese claimed reefs,
- US accuses Chinese ship of forcing it off course
Tensions
- August 2019: US sails an aircraft carrier in Manila, Philippines moving closer to China
- US declares Chinese Claims 'unlawful'
- Today there are increasingly violent tensions between Philippines and China
- The US has a mutual defense treaty with the Philippines, but it's questionable whether the US will honor it
- ASEAN-China are negotiating a "code of conduct” agreements for SCS
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.