5 Questions
What is the ontological status of theoretical entities according to the author?
The author argues that the entities referred to by scientific theories are not just convenient fictions, but have a real existence.
What are some views that the author believes are incongruous with the scientific attitude?
The author finds it incongruous to believe that the entities referred to by scientific theories are just convenient fictions, or that talk about them can be translated into talk about sense contents or everyday physical objects.
Who are some physicists mentioned in the text who hold instrumentalist views?
Bohr and Heisenberg are mentioned as physicists who hold instrumentalist views.
What does Professor Ernest Nagel conclude about the opposition between realist and instrumentalist views?
Professor Ernest Nagel concludes that the opposition between realist and instrumentalist views of theories is a conflict over preferred modes of speech.
According to the author, what is the main conflict between realist and instrumentalist views?
The main conflict between realist and instrumentalist views is the question of which mode of speech is preferred when talking about theories.
The Ontological Status of Theoretical Entities Quiz: Test your knowledge on the philosophical debate surrounding the existence and nature of entities referred to in scientific theories. Explore theories and arguments regarding whether these entities are merely convenient fictions or have a distinct ontological status. Dive into the discourse on translating such talk into sense contents or physical objects. Challenge your understanding and explore the implications of this ongoing philosophical discussion.
Make Your Own Quizzes and Flashcards
Convert your notes into interactive study material.
Get started for free
