The Dilemma of Raffi

Dilema Raffi

• Definition: The "Dilema Raffi" refers to a philosophical and ethical problem involving decision-making under conditions of uncertainty, often presented as a choice in which competing moral principles clash.

• Origin: The dilemma is named after a hypothetical character, Raffi, used to illustrate complex moral choices.

• Key Components:

  • Conflicting Values: Features two or more values or obligations that cannot all be fulfilled simultaneously.
  • Choices: Typically involves a situation where the decision will have significant consequences for individuals involved.

• Common Scenarios:

  • Utilitarian vs. Deontological Ethics:
    • Utilitarian approach seeks the greatest good for the greatest number.
    • Deontological approach emphasizes the importance of following moral rules or duties.
  • Personal vs. Societal Responsibility: Situations where personal loyalty may conflict with societal obligations or norms.

• Examples:

  • Choosing whether to save one person who is close to you or a group of strangers in danger.
  • Deciding whether to report a friend's illegal activity, which could help society but harm the friendship.

• Analysis Techniques:

  • Cost-Benefit Analysis: Weighing possible outcomes for each decision alternative.
  • Moral Reasoning: Evaluating decisions based on ethical theories like virtue ethics, consequentialism, etc.

• Implications:

  • Highlights the complexities of moral decision-making.
  • Encourages critical thinking about ethics and personal values.
  • Used in discussions on ethics in business, healthcare, and law.

Dilema Raffi

• The Dilemma Raffi is a hypothetical situation used to explore ethical issues in decision making.
• The dilemma focuses on choices with conflicting moral principles.
• The dilemma highlights the struggle between utilitarian and deontological ethics, often leading to conflicting values and obligations.
• The dilemma commonly involves personal vs. societal moral responsibility.
• Examples of the Dilemma Raffi include choosing between saving a loved one or saving a group of strangers, and whether to report a friend's crime.
• Dilema Raffi helps promote critical thinking and moral reasoning, and is often analyzed using cost-benefit analysis.
• The dilemma is often applied to real-world situations, like ethical dilemmas in business, healthcare, and law.