Podcast
Questions and Answers
What is the primary irony associated with state crimes?
What is the primary irony associated with state crimes?
- States often punish their own citizens for crimes they themselves commit.
- States often deny their own involvement in criminal acts.
- State crimes are always committed in secret making them difficult to identify.
- The state is responsible for upholding the law but sometimes breaks it. (correct)
According to Green and Ward (2004), what is the defining characteristic of state crimes?
According to Green and Ward (2004), what is the defining characteristic of state crimes?
- Activities that are not defined as criminal by any state law.
- Illegal or deviant activities by state agencies to further state policies. (correct)
- Acts that are illegal under international law.
- Violations of human rights conventions.
Which of the following is NOT typically considered a state crime?
Which of the following is NOT typically considered a state crime?
- Petty theft by a government employee. (correct)
- Torture and acts of genocide.
- War crimes and assassinations.
- Violations of human rights.
Why is defining state crimes as problematic?
Why is defining state crimes as problematic?
What is meant by 'a transgressive approach' to understanding state crime?
What is meant by 'a transgressive approach' to understanding state crime?
Which of the following best describes the concept of 'techniques of neutralization' used in the context of state crime?
Which of the following best describes the concept of 'techniques of neutralization' used in the context of state crime?
According to Green and Ward (2012), what are the two main aspects involved in state crime?
According to Green and Ward (2012), what are the two main aspects involved in state crime?
Which of these statements best exemplifies that states can 'disguise, decriminalize and justify' their crimes?
Which of these statements best exemplifies that states can 'disguise, decriminalize and justify' their crimes?
What is the key distinction between state crimes and the actions of rogue state employees?
What is the key distinction between state crimes and the actions of rogue state employees?
What is considered a fundamental basis for human rights?
What is considered a fundamental basis for human rights?
Which document establishes a legal framework for defining and enforcing universal human rights?
Which document establishes a legal framework for defining and enforcing universal human rights?
O'Byrne argues that states are increasingly assessed by what?
O'Byrne argues that states are increasingly assessed by what?
What do Schwendinger and Schwendinger, and Green and Ward include in their wider definition of human rights?
What do Schwendinger and Schwendinger, and Green and Ward include in their wider definition of human rights?
Which of the following is NOT considered a state crime, according to the text?
Which of the following is NOT considered a state crime, according to the text?
Which regime was responsible for the mass murder of up to 3 million people from forced labour, malnutrition, poor medical care and executions?
Which regime was responsible for the mass murder of up to 3 million people from forced labour, malnutrition, poor medical care and executions?
Which country was found guilty of using 'white noise' to torture IRA suspects?
Which country was found guilty of using 'white noise' to torture IRA suspects?
What did the US Senate report find that the CIA had frequently and illegally used as an interrogation technique after 9/11?
What did the US Senate report find that the CIA had frequently and illegally used as an interrogation technique after 9/11?
Approximately how many Jews were murdered in gas chambers at Auschwitz during the Nazi regime?
Approximately how many Jews were murdered in gas chambers at Auschwitz during the Nazi regime?
What is the main characteristic of state corruption as defined in the text?
What is the main characteristic of state corruption as defined in the text?
Which of the following describes a war crime as per the text?
Which of the following describes a war crime as per the text?
Which former leader was brought to trial for war crimes, including forced deportation and murder?
Which former leader was brought to trial for war crimes, including forced deportation and murder?
What defines genocide, as mentioned in the text?
What defines genocide, as mentioned in the text?
What does state-sponsored terrorism refer to, according to the text?
What does state-sponsored terrorism refer to, according to the text?
What was a key finding of the De Silva report regarding the murder of a Belfast lawyer in 1989?
What was a key finding of the De Silva report regarding the murder of a Belfast lawyer in 1989?
According to Green and Ward's integrated theory, what is a key component in explaining state crime?
According to Green and Ward's integrated theory, what is a key component in explaining state crime?
According to Kelman and Hamilton's 'crimes of obedience' model, what is a key way violent states encourage conformity among those carrying out human rights abuses?
According to Kelman and Hamilton's 'crimes of obedience' model, what is a key way violent states encourage conformity among those carrying out human rights abuses?
What does the concept of 'dehumanization' refer to in the context of state crime?
What does the concept of 'dehumanization' refer to in the context of state crime?
What is the significance of 'routinization' in the context of state violence?
What is the significance of 'routinization' in the context of state violence?
What are 'enclaves of barbarism' according to de Swann?
What are 'enclaves of barbarism' according to de Swann?
According to Bauman, how did the Nazi regime make the Holocaust possible?
According to Bauman, how did the Nazi regime make the Holocaust possible?
What does the application of 'techniques of neutralization' refer to, in the context of state crime?
What does the application of 'techniques of neutralization' refer to, in the context of state crime?
According to Cohen, which of the following is a significant barrier to researching state crime?
According to Cohen, which of the following is a significant barrier to researching state crime?
Why is researching state crime particularly difficult compared to traditional sociological research on crime?
Why is researching state crime particularly difficult compared to traditional sociological research on crime?
Which data sources are researchers often reliant upon when investigating state crime?
Which data sources are researchers often reliant upon when investigating state crime?
What is a common bias in media coverage of state crime, according to the content?
What is a common bias in media coverage of state crime, according to the content?
What concept did Cohen apply from Sykes and Matza to explain how states deny human rights abuses?
What concept did Cohen apply from Sykes and Matza to explain how states deny human rights abuses?
What does the concept of a 'dark figure' refer to in the context of state crime?
What does the concept of a 'dark figure' refer to in the context of state crime?
In what way did the application of modern science and technology affect the process of the Nazi genocide of Jews as mentioned in the text?
In what way did the application of modern science and technology affect the process of the Nazi genocide of Jews as mentioned in the text?
Flashcards
State Crimes
State Crimes
Illegal or deviant activities committed by state agencies to advance state policies.
State Power to Avoid Criminalization
State Power to Avoid Criminalization
The state, as the law-making body, can define its own actions as not criminal, even if they violate international norms.
State Crimes as Human Rights Violations
State Crimes as Human Rights Violations
Acts that violate human rights, even if not explicitly defined as crimes by law.
Techniques of Neutralization
Techniques of Neutralization
Signup and view all the flashcards
Transgressive Approach
Transgressive Approach
Signup and view all the flashcards
State Organizational Deviance
State Organizational Deviance
Signup and view all the flashcards
State Power to Justify Violations
State Power to Justify Violations
Signup and view all the flashcards
Human Rights Conventions
Human Rights Conventions
Signup and view all the flashcards
Human Rights
Human Rights
Signup and view all the flashcards
UN Universal Declaration of Human Rights
UN Universal Declaration of Human Rights
Signup and view all the flashcards
State Evaluation Based on Human Rights
State Evaluation Based on Human Rights
Signup and view all the flashcards
Human Rights as Social and Economic Rights
Human Rights as Social and Economic Rights
Signup and view all the flashcards
State Crimes as Social Harm
State Crimes as Social Harm
Signup and view all the flashcards
Torture and Illegal Punishment of Citizens
Torture and Illegal Punishment of Citizens
Signup and view all the flashcards
Genocide
Genocide
Signup and view all the flashcards
Corruption
Corruption
Signup and view all the flashcards
Assassination or 'Targeted Killing'
Assassination or 'Targeted Killing'
Signup and view all the flashcards
War Crimes
War Crimes
Signup and view all the flashcards
State-Sponsored Terrorism
State-Sponsored Terrorism
Signup and view all the flashcards
The Holocaust
The Holocaust
Signup and view all the flashcards
Auschwitz Concentration Camp
Auschwitz Concentration Camp
Signup and view all the flashcards
Acts of Rogue Individuals
Acts of Rogue Individuals
Signup and view all the flashcards
Integrated Theory of State Crime
Integrated Theory of State Crime
Signup and view all the flashcards
Crimes of Obedience Model
Crimes of Obedience Model
Signup and view all the flashcards
Authorization (Crimes of Obedience)
Authorization (Crimes of Obedience)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Dehumanization (Crimes of Obedience)
Dehumanization (Crimes of Obedience)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Routinization (Crimes of Obedience)
Routinization (Crimes of Obedience)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Enclaves of Barbarism
Enclaves of Barbarism
Signup and view all the flashcards
Techniques of Neutralization (State Crime)
Techniques of Neutralization (State Crime)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Dark Figure of Crime (State Crime)
Dark Figure of Crime (State Crime)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Rule of Law
Rule of Law
Signup and view all the flashcards
Integrated Theory of State Crime
Integrated Theory of State Crime
Signup and view all the flashcards
Crimes of Obedience Model
Crimes of Obedience Model
Signup and view all the flashcards
Authorization (Crimes of Obedience)
Authorization (Crimes of Obedience)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Dehumanization (Crimes of Obedience)
Dehumanization (Crimes of Obedience)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Routinization (Crimes of Obedience)
Routinization (Crimes of Obedience)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Study Notes
State Crimes
- State crimes are illegal or deviant activities perpetrated by, or with the complicity of, state agencies, furthering state policies.
- Examples include torture, illegal treatment/imprisonment/punishment, corrupt policing, corruption, war crimes, assassination, genocide, state-sponsored terrorism, and human rights violations.
Defining State Crimes – Problems
- Defining state crime is problematic because the state is the source of law and defines crime.
- States can avoid defining their actions as crimes, even when violating international law (e.g., Nazi Germany).
- States can disguise, decriminalize, or justify offenses by redefining them.
State Crime as Human Rights Violations
- A more transgressive approach defines state crime as violations of human rights.
- Green and Ward define state crime as "state organizational deviance involving the violation of human rights."
- This definition encompasses actions not necessarily criminal under law but harmful to human rights.
- It distinguishes state crimes from actions by individual rogue agents.
Human Rights
- Human rights are entitlements to fair and just treatment, stemming from common humanity.
- The UN Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948) established a legal framework, creating global norms.
- States are increasingly assessed based on human rights preservation.
- Human rights include basic social/economic rights (security, subsistence) and civil/political rights (life, liberty).
Examples of State Crimes
- Torture/Illegal Treatment: Gaddafi regime, Khmer Rouge, UK in 1970s, US at Guantanamo Bay, CIA post-9/11.
- Corruption: Mubarak in Egypt (allegedly embezzled billions).
- Assassination/Targeted Killings: Al-Mabhouh, Litvinenko.
- War Crimes: Israel-Palestine conflict, former Yugoslavia.
- Genocide: Nazi Germany, Sudan's Darfur, Rwanda.
- State-Sponsored Terrorism: Iran, US support of rebels.
Explaining State Crimes
- Integrated Theory: State crime has similar motivations, opportunities, and control failures to other crimes.
- The Crimes of Obedience Model (Kelman & Hamilton):
- Authorization: State actors act with official support.
- Dehumanization: Marginalization of a group, leading to atrocities being perceived as acceptable. (e.g., Jews in Nazi Germany, terrorists today).
- Routinization: Organizing actions into routine tasks, making moral considerations unnecessary. (e.g., using scientific techniques to eliminate a group as if removing pests, the Holocaust as an administrative task).
Techniques of Neutralization
- States use techniques of neutralization to excuse their actions.
- This involves relabeling crimes, excusing actions (e.g., for national security), or blaming victims.
Researching State Crimes – Challenges
- Difficulty in determining the true extent of state crime due to government denial and justification, and manipulation of information.
- Powerful states use resources to control information and cover-up.
- Research is often reliant on secondary data (e.g., media reports) that may focus on developing nations and ignore Western democracies.
- Strong official resistance, threats, and denial of funding/access can hinder research.
- Researchers in authoritarian regimes face risks of imprisonment, torture, or death.
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.