Shoe print Analysis

Choose a study mode

Play Quiz
Study Flashcards
Spaced Repetition
Chat to Lesson

Podcast

Play an AI-generated podcast conversation about this lesson
Download our mobile app to listen on the go
Get App

Questions and Answers

Which type of shoe impression is typically invisible to the naked eye and requires dusting to be visualized?

  • Visible
  • Patent
  • Plastic
  • Latent (correct)

How can the depth of a shoe print primarily assist investigators at a crime scene?

  • Determining the shoe brand
  • Identifying socio-economic indicators
  • Estimating the suspect's height
  • Estimating the suspect's approximate weight (correct)

What is the main difference between class and individual evidence in shoeprints?

  • Class evidence is related to the shoe size, while individual evidence is related to the shoe brand.
  • Class evidence is always visible, while individual evidence is latent.
  • Class evidence links a shoe to a group, while individual evidence links it to a specific shoe worn by a person. (correct)
  • Class evidence can link a shoe to a specific person, while individual evidence links it to a group.

Two people can own the same shoe, in the exact same size, but the wear pattern will be different. What causes this difference?

<p>The way each person walks and characteristics that effect shoe wear (D)</p> Signup and view all the answers

Which of the following factors can affect an individual's shoe wear pattern?

<p>Whether they walk on their toes, heels, or flat-footed (A)</p> Signup and view all the answers

Why is it important to take photographs directly overhead when photographing shoe impressions?

<p>To ensure an accurate representation of the impression's dimensions (B)</p> Signup and view all the answers

When creating a cast of a shoe impression, why is it recommended to pour the mixture onto a piece of cardboard first rather than directly onto the print?

<p>To avoid damaging the fine details of the impression (D)</p> Signup and view all the answers

When examining tire tracks, what does the 'track width' refer to?

<p>Distance between the center of each tire to the opposite tire (B)</p> Signup and view all the answers

In the case study of Russell Williams, what evidence led police to suspect him in Jessica Lloyd's disappearance?

<p>Tire tracks from his vehicle matching those found at the crime scene (A)</p> Signup and view all the answers

Why do investigators document the tire and shoe impressions of first responders at a crime scene?

<p>To distinguish between evidence left by the suspect and that left by first responders (D)</p> Signup and view all the answers

Explain how shoe wear patterns can assist in identifying a suspect, even when multiple people own the same type of shoe.

<p>Each person walks differently, causing unique wear patterns on the shoe's sole. These individual wear patterns, influenced by factors like gait, weight distribution, and walking surface, differentiate shoes of the same make and size.</p> Signup and view all the answers

Describe the differences between class and individual characteristics of shoe prints and how they are used in forensic investigations.

<p>Class characteristics narrow down the type of shoe, linking it to a group, while individual characteristics are unique damages or wear patterns that can link a shoe print to a specific shoe.</p> Signup and view all the answers

What are the three types of photographs that should be taken when documenting shoeprint evidence, and why is each important?

<p>Overview (shows the context of the print), midrange (shows the location and surroundings), and close-ups (captures fine details). Each serves a different purpose in documenting, preserving, and analyzing the evidence.</p> Signup and view all the answers

What are the names of the commercial databases used for shoe prints?

<p>Threadmark, solemate</p> Signup and view all the answers

Outline the steps for creating a cast of a tire impression, including key considerations for snow impressions.

<p>Photograph, frame the impression, mix dental stone, pour mixture on cardboard, let it dry, and remove. For snow, spray with snow wax or dental stone in dry form before adding liquid.</p> Signup and view all the answers

During bite mark photography, why is it important to use long-wave UV light rather than short-wave UV light?

<p>Short-wave UV light can degrade DNA evidence. (B)</p> Signup and view all the answers

In cases involving bite marks on food items, what is the recommended procedure for preserving this evidence?

<p>Take photographs and then immediately cast the bite mark, as the food may dry out. (D)</p> Signup and view all the answers

How did dental records play a crucial role in confirming the identity of Josef Mengele?

<p>Comparing dental records with the exhumed body provided a match, later confirmed by DNA. (C)</p> Signup and view all the answers

What is the primary role of enamel in human teeth, and how does it contribute to forensic odontology?

<p>Enamel is the hardest tissue, enabling teeth to withstand extreme conditions, making them useful for identification in events like fires. (C)</p> Signup and view all the answers

What is the significance of 'Megan's Law,' which stemmed from the case of Megan Kanka, in the context of forensic science?

<p>It mandates the registration of all sex offenders in a database. (C)</p> Signup and view all the answers

In forensic odontology, what does comparing 'antemortem' and 'postmortem' dental records involve, and why is this comparison crucial?

<p>Comparing dental records taken during life with those recorded after death to identify human remains. (C)</p> Signup and view all the answers

What are the limitations of using teeth to determine characteristics such as age, gender, and race/ethnicity without dental records?

<p>While teeth accurately show age, they cannot reliably determine gender or race/ethnicity. (D)</p> Signup and view all the answers

A forensic odontologist is called to a scene where skeletal remains have been discovered. Besides identification, in what other capacity can the odontologist assist the investigation?

<p>Providing insights into potential abuse or trauma through dental evidence. (D)</p> Signup and view all the answers

In the Universal Numbering System used in dentistry, what is the significance of assigning a specific number to each tooth?

<p>It standardizes dental record keeping for easier comparison and identification. (B)</p> Signup and view all the answers

Why is bite mark evidence considered controversial in forensic science, despite its historical use in criminal cases?

<p>Experts often disagree on the interpretation of bite mark matches, and there have been cases of wrongful convictions based on this evidence. (B)</p> Signup and view all the answers

Summarize the role of a forensic odontologist in identifying human remains, incorporating the concept of 'antemortem' and 'postmortem' records.

<p>A forensic odontologist compares dental records, specifically antemortem (taken before death) and postmortem (taken after death) records, to identify human remains. They look for matches in fillings, tooth shape, and other dental characteristics to confirm identity.</p> Signup and view all the answers

A body is discovered but is unidentifiable because of tissue decomposition. What dental characteristics may still be used to assist in making an identification?

<p>Fillings, missing teeth and the patterns they create, unusual dental work, the overall shape and alignment of teeth, and root canal work are all still useful when trying to identify a body.</p> Signup and view all the answers

Name the part of the tooth that is above the gum line, at the gum line, and below.

<p>crown, neck, root</p> Signup and view all the answers

What part of the tooth must you have in order to sequence DNA?

<p>pulp</p> Signup and view all the answers

Name the two bones that hold teeth, and where they are located on the skull.

<p>Maxilla and Mandible</p> Signup and view all the answers

What are the types of gait?

<p>Walking, Running, Jogging, Skipping, Sprinting (B)</p> Signup and view all the answers

What are the two materials commonly used to make impression casts?

<p>Plaster of Paris and Dental Stone</p> Signup and view all the answers

Flashcards

What are patent impressions?

Visible 2D shoe impressions left through soil, dust, paint, or blood.

What are latent impressions?

Shoe impressions hidden to the eye, often found on polished floors and requiring dusting to become visible.

What are plastic impressions?

Visible 3D shoe impressions left in materials like snow, mud, soil, or wet concrete.

What is class shoe evidence?

Links a shoe to a group of shoes, like associating a shoe imprint with a size 9 Nike Air Jordans.

Signup and view all the flashcards

What is individual shoe evidence?

Links a shoe to a specific shoe worn by a specific person, like identifying a Nike Air Jordans with a rock and tear.

Signup and view all the flashcards

What is wear pattern?

The unique pattern of wear on a shoe, influenced by how a person walks and interacts with surfaces.

Signup and view all the flashcards

What is gait?

The distinctive manner of movement, including walk, skip, jog, run, and sprint, which can provide information at crime scenes.

Signup and view all the flashcards

Why photograph shoe impressions?

Photographs taken to document shoe print evidence, including overview, midrange, and closeups with scales and evidence markers.

Signup and view all the flashcards

How to locate latent shoe prints?

Spray BlueStar, dust with fingerprint powder, or use electrostatic dusting to reveal shoe prints.

Signup and view all the flashcards

What is tire tread?

Patterns of rubber that touches roads, including ribs/ridges, grooves, sipes, and dimples, all designed to handle varying conditions.

Signup and view all the flashcards

What can shoe size tell you?

The size of a person's foot, which can also give an approximate height.

Signup and view all the flashcards

What can shoeprint depth suggest?

Approximate weight of a person.

Signup and view all the flashcards

What can shoe brand indicate?

Socio-economic status, potential occupations and/or level of wealth.

Signup and view all the flashcards

How to make a cast impression

Photograph the impression, spray with hairspray, frame the impression, mix and pour dental stone, let dry, then carefully remove the cast.

Signup and view all the flashcards

What is a tire track?

Tracks made by each tire when a vehicle travels.

Signup and view all the flashcards

Odontology definition

The study of teeth anatomy, growth, and associated diseases.

Signup and view all the flashcards

Forensic Odontologist

Dentists specializing in identifying human remains through teeth and bite marks.

Signup and view all the flashcards

Forensic Odontology

Examination of dental evidence in criminal justice.

Signup and view all the flashcards

Teeth Enamel

Enamel's hardness allows teeth to withstand high stressors.

Signup and view all the flashcards

Jaws for teeth

Maxilla (upper) and Mandible (lower).

Signup and view all the flashcards

Parts of a tooth

Crown, Neck, and Root.

Signup and view all the flashcards

Permanent teeth

The adult set; approximately 32 teeth.

Signup and view all the flashcards

Antemortem Records

Records taken during life.

Signup and view all the flashcards

Postmortem records

Records recorded after death.

Signup and view all the flashcards

Bitemarks

Marks left behind by teeth, commonly found on the chest or arms.

Signup and view all the flashcards

Deciduous Teeth

Primary teeth from milk buds, temporary.

Signup and view all the flashcards

Forensic Odontologist Job

Dentists identifying remains/bitemarks, often part-time.

Signup and view all the flashcards

Bite Mark Photography

Photograph overall, closeup with/without ABFO scale, long-wave UV, infrared.

Signup and view all the flashcards

Process Bite Marks

If in food, photograph, cast. Swab inside/outside for DNA. Medical examiner if deceased.

Signup and view all the flashcards

Dental Records

Universal system to keep the teeth of a person's records consistent

Signup and view all the flashcards

Study Notes

  • Forensic Odontology is the examination of dental evidence in the criminal justice system
  • Forensic Odontologists use knowledge of teeth to identify victims of mass disasters, identify skeletal remains, help police in criminal investigations, and verify signs of abuse

History of Bite Mark Analysis

  • Agrippina the Younger had her rival sentenced to death and demanded her head as proof
  • Agrippina identified her rival Lollia by a gap in her front teeth
  • In 1692, Reverend Burroughs was accused of witchcraft in Salem, Massachusetts for biting his victims
  • A judge allowed a comparison of his bite marks with other villagers and determined he was a match
  • Reverend Burroughs was hanged but later exonerated

Recent History of Bite Mark Analysis

  • In 1948, pathologist Keith Simpson testified on the bite marks on victim Phyllis Gorringe
  • Her husband, Robert, was convicted of her murder
  • In 1954, a person broke into a grocery store in Aspermont, Texas, and ate some of the cheese
  • Jimmy Doyle was arrested and asked to bite into cheese
  • A dentist and forensic examiner both stated the bite was a match to the crime scene cheese bite
  • Jimmy Doyle was convicted and it was upheld upon appeal

Case Study: Megan Kanka

  • Megan Kanka was murdered by her neighbor, Jesse Timmendequas, on July 29, 1984
  • Jesse had been convicted twice of child abuse
  • When police questioned him the next day, he confessed and led police to her body at a park
  • Bite marks on his hand matched Megan's teeth
  • Jesse Timmendequas received the death penalty in New Jersey
  • Megan's Law was enacted in New Jersey, which makes all sex offenders register in a database

Forensic Odontologist

  • Forensic Odontologists are dentists who specialize in identifying human remains with teeth and matching bite marks
  • Most work as a dentist full-time and do cases as a side business

Job Duties

  • Identify human remains from their teeth
  • Match bite marks on victims to suspects

Educational Requirements

  • Licensed dentist with a bachelor's degree
  • Pass the Dental Admissions Test (DAT)
  • Complete four years of dentistry school, pass licensing exam
  • The average salary is $150,000 per year

Human Teeth

  • Every human body ages in a similar manner with a semi-standardized pattern of teeth
  • Each human has an individual set of teeth
  • Seniors may lose teeth and use dentures
  • Teeth are made of enamel, the hardest tissue in the human body
  • Enamel and its hardness allow teeth to withstand high stressors like extremely high temperature, water desiccation, or fire

Anatomy of Teeth

  • The purpose of teeth is to mechanically grind teeth into smaller pieces to aid in digestion
  • Teeth are contained within the bones of the upper jaw (maxilla) and lower jaw (mandible)
  • A tooth has three parts: crown, neck, and root
    • The crown is the tooth above the gumline
    • The neck is where crown and tooth meet at the gumline
    • The root is the tooth embedded below the gumlines

Teeth Composition

  • Teeth are composed of several different materials: dentin, pulp, enamel, and cementum
    • Dentin is connective tissue that has calcified and shapes teeth
    • Pulp is connective tissue with nerves and blood vessels
    • DNA can be harvested from pulp for matching purposes
    • Enamel is a protective layer on the crown which protects dentin
    • Cementum covers dentin in the root where it attaches to the bone of the jaw

Deciduous Teeth

  • Deciduous teeth are primary teeth that sprout from milk buds and are temporary
  • Humans have 20 deciduous (baby) teeth which fall out to make room for permanent teeth
  • Teeth begin to appear at 6 months of age and all should have emerged by age 3
  • Forensic odontologists can determine an age range based on the number of deciduous teeth still present
  • Between the ages of 7-21 years, every deciduous tooth should have been replaced with permanent (adult) teeth

Permanent Teeth

  • Permanent teeth are the adult, or second set
  • There are approximately 32 teeth in an adult's mouth
  • There are four types of permanent teeth: molars, premolars, canine, and incisors
    • Molars are for chewing and grinding
    • Premolars are for chewing and grinding
    • Canine is for tearing
    • Incisors are for biting

Dental Records

  • Forensic Odontologists compare antemortem records and postmortem records
    • Antemortem records are records taken during life
    • Postmortem records are records recorded after death
  • Dental records use the Universal System
    • Teeth are given a specific number; primary teeth are given a specific capital letter
    • Any dental work done on the surface is noted
  • In Texas, dental records can be submitted to the Texas Missing Person's Clearinghouse for missing children and adults

Identifying Remains from Teeth

  • Forensic odontologists compare dental records with the victim's remains
  • Investigators check the dental records for alterations like fillings, caps, bridgework, and dentures
  • They compare the teeth's size and shape, gaps and cracks, alignment, missing or extra teeth, and wears and stains

Case Study: Josef Mengele

  • Josef Mengele born was March 16, 1911, in Germany
  • As a doctor in Nazi Germany, he worked at Auschwitz concentration camp and conducted horrific medical experiments on twins
  • After the fall of Nazi Germany, he fled to Argentina in 1949, then Paraguay in 1959, and Brazil in 1960
    • He stayed free with the help of a network of former Nazis in South America
  • On February 7, 1979, Josef drowned while swimming after experiencing a stroke
  • The Allies had an active warrant for his arrest and exhumed his body on May 31, 1985- his dental records matched
  • In 1992, DNA results confirmed the body was Josef Mengele

Characteristics from Teeth

  • Teeth have limitations in determining characteristics without dental records:
    • Age can be more accurately determined if the person is younger than 25 years
    • Over 25 years teeth do not change so identifying age is less accurate
    • Gender and race or ethnicity cannot be positively determined
    • However, based on dentistry practices around the world and chemical analysis of minerals in water, a dentist can determine which area of the world the person lived in some cases

Bite Marks

  • Bite marks are marks left behind by teeth
  • Bite marks have limited evidentiary value when they are found in human skin as it swells and bruises
  • Bite marks are commonly found in family violence assaults, sexual assaults, and child abuse cases
    • Especially on the chest, neck, and arms
  • Bite marks on the arms and hands can be defensive wounds
  • Bite marks may be found on the suspect, which were made by the victim

Photographing Bite Marks

  • Bite marks may quickly fade so it is important to immediately photograph them
  • The procedure for photographing bite marks is to:
    • Take overall photo of the bite mark on the body part for establishing shots
    • Take a closeup photo showing the bite mark
    • Take a closeup photo with ABFO scale
    • Take long-wave UV light closeup photo (short-wave UV light will degrade DNA)
    • Take Infrared closeup photo of bite mark

Processing Bite Marks

  • If the bite mark is in a food item, take photographs then cast it immediately as the food may dry out
  • Swab the inside and outside of the bite mark for possible DNA
  • For living humans: if the bite is bleeding, get medical attention first
  • For deceased individuals: talk with the medical examiner if the cast would be better done during the autopsy

Case Study: Ted Bundy

  • Ted Bundy was a notorious serial killer who murdered from Washington to Florida
  • On January 15, 1978, Ted Bundy broke into the Chi Omega sorority house in Tallahassee, Florida
    • He attacked 4 women, murdering two of them
  • Lisa Levy was murdered after he bit her left buttock and chest
  • During the trial, forensic odontologists Souviron and Lowell matched his teeth to the bite marks
  • Ted Bundy was executed in 1989 in Florida

Caution on Bite Mark Analysis

  • Bite mark evidence is very controversial as experts disagree on "matches"
  • Several persons have been convicted and later exonerated based on faulty matches of bite marks
  • The Texas Commission on Forensic Science has condemned bite mark evidence because:
    • Human bite marks are not unique
    • Human bite marks are not accurately transferred to the skin
    • Patterns cannot be attributed to one person

Case Study: Ray Crone

  • Ray Crone was born on January 19, 1957, in Pennsylvania
  • On December 29, 1991, Kim Ancona was found murdered in the male restroom at the bar she worked
    • She had been stabbed with bite marks on her chest
  • Ray Crone became a prime suspect as he was to help her close the bar that night as the last person alone with her
    • Police asked for a bite mark impression from him
  • Experts testified it was match to the crime scene bites and he was sentenced to life in prison
  • In 2002, he was exonerated after DNA from the bite mark was compared and was a match to another convicted killer

Studying That Suits You

Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.

Quiz Team

Related Documents

More Like This

Enquête criminelle et empreintes de pas
45 questions
Shoe & Tire Impression Evidence
10 questions
Use Quizgecko on...
Browser
Browser