Responses to Criticism of Intelligent Design Theory

Study Notes

Intelligent design theorists argue that imperfect designs may be due to multiple motives of the designer, but this approach makes it untestable and therefore unscientific.
Paley's response to criticism of imperfections in design was that they may be due to unknown causes.

Evolution responds to an organism's needs through tinkering, modifying existing structures through natural selection, rather than optimal design.
The human jaw and birth canal are examples of imperfections, resulting in difficulties during childbirth.
Evolution explains these imperfections as a consequence of the enlargement of the human brain.

The distribution of animals in different continents and islands can be explained by the theory of evolution, which states that species can only exist and evolve in areas colonized by their ancestors.
The absence of certain species from hospitable environments can be explained by the theory of evolution.

Molecular biology provides the most detailed and convincing evidence for biological evolution.
The application of molecular biology techniques to evolutionary problems has made it possible to explore issues such as genetic variation and genetic change during the formation of new species.
Comparisons of amino acid sequences of corresponding proteins in different species have provided quantitatively precise measures of the divergence among species evolved from common ancestors.

The neutrality theory proposes that many changes in DNA and protein sequences are adaptively neutral, having little or no effect on an organism's fitness.
The neutrality theory suggests that there should be a "molecular clock" of evolution, where the degree of divergence between species provides a reliable estimate of the time since the species diverged.

Some economists, such as F.A. Hayek, have applied the Darwinian process to the economy, suggesting that individual preferences and ingenuity drive economic change and progress.

The theory of evolution has been seen as incompatible with religious beliefs, particularly those of Christianity.
Evolution is seen as contradicting a literal interpretation of the biblical book of Genesis and the belief in humans as "created in the image of God".
Some religious scholars have acknowledged the irony that evolution has removed the need to explain the world's imperfections as outcomes of God's design.

Podcast