Podcast
Questions and Answers
Why was Robert Meyer arrested in 1920?
Why was Robert Meyer arrested in 1920?
- He promoted German culture in public schools.
- He refused to teach English to his students.
- He did not pass the teacher certification exam.
- He violated a Nebraska law by teaching German to a 10-year-old boy. (correct)
How did the Nebraska Supreme Court justify its ruling against Meyer?
How did the Nebraska Supreme Court justify its ruling against Meyer?
- By emphasizing the importance of teaching English.
- By citing a lack of constitutional protection for teaching.
- By stating foreign languages harmed children's cognitive abilities.
- By claiming the German language embodied German national character and values. (correct)
What was the decision of the United States Supreme Court regarding Meyer's case?
What was the decision of the United States Supreme Court regarding Meyer's case?
- They upheld his conviction.
- They required Meyer to only teach English.
- They overturned Meyer's conviction and declared the language laws unconstitutional. (correct)
- They declared teaching foreign languages unconstitutional.
Which of the following did the US Supreme Court state in its ruling?
Which of the following did the US Supreme Court state in its ruling?
Why did Nebraska and other states pass laws against teaching foreign languages?
Why did Nebraska and other states pass laws against teaching foreign languages?
What did the Siman Act prohibit?
What did the Siman Act prohibit?
Which languages were allowed to be taught under the Siman Act?
Which languages were allowed to be taught under the Siman Act?
What historical event influenced the passage of language laws like the Siman Act?
What historical event influenced the passage of language laws like the Siman Act?
What did the US Supreme Court state about the German language in its ruling?
What did the US Supreme Court state about the German language in its ruling?
What psycholinguistic question does Meyer's case raise?
What psycholinguistic question does Meyer's case raise?
What claim did Wilhelm von Humboldt make about language in 1836?
What claim did Wilhelm von Humboldt make about language in 1836?
The relationship of language, thought, and culture is central to psycholinguistics.
The relationship of language, thought, and culture is central to psycholinguistics.
The Siman Act allowed the teaching of foreign languages to children under 13 years old.
The Siman Act allowed the teaching of foreign languages to children under 13 years old.
Nebraska's language laws primarily targeted Latin and Greek.
Nebraska's language laws primarily targeted Latin and Greek.
Meyer's case was initially rejected by the Nebraska Supreme Court.
Meyer's case was initially rejected by the Nebraska Supreme Court.
The US Supreme Court supported the idea that a language represents the national character and values of a people.
The US Supreme Court supported the idea that a language represents the national character and values of a people.
The Nebraska language law was a reaction to anti-German sentiment after World War I.
The Nebraska language law was a reaction to anti-German sentiment after World War I.
The US Supreme Court ruled that teaching foreign languages is unconstitutional.
The US Supreme Court ruled that teaching foreign languages is unconstitutional.
The US Supreme Court's ruling highlighted that knowledge of a foreign language does not necessarily convey cultural values.
The US Supreme Court's ruling highlighted that knowledge of a foreign language does not necessarily convey cultural values.
Meyer was arrested for teaching Bible stories in German to children over 13 years old.
Meyer was arrested for teaching Bible stories in German to children over 13 years old.
The Siman Act was passed to prevent the teaching of foreign languages in the wake of anti-German sentiment after World War I.
The Siman Act was passed to prevent the teaching of foreign languages in the wake of anti-German sentiment after World War I.
The Nebraska Supreme Court supported Meyer's appeal.
The Nebraska Supreme Court supported Meyer's appeal.
The US Supreme Court declared that knowledge of a foreign language does not necessarily convey cultural values.
The US Supreme Court declared that knowledge of a foreign language does not necessarily convey cultural values.
All 50 US states passed similar laws to the Siman Act after World War I.
All 50 US states passed similar laws to the Siman Act after World War I.
According to the US Supreme Court, knowing a foreign language cannot reasonably be regarded as harmful.
According to the US Supreme Court, knowing a foreign language cannot reasonably be regarded as harmful.
Latin and Greek were exempt from Nebraska's foreign language restrictions.
Latin and Greek were exempt from Nebraska's foreign language restrictions.
Meyer's case was ultimately ruled unconstitutional based on both constitutional and psycholinguistic grounds.
Meyer's case was ultimately ruled unconstitutional based on both constitutional and psycholinguistic grounds.
What is the difficulty in determining a safe
second language?
What is the difficulty in determining a safe
second language?
Which example illustrates the complexity of determining 'safe' and 'harmful' second languages?
Which example illustrates the complexity of determining 'safe' and 'harmful' second languages?
What are the four principal formulations regarding the relationship between language, thought, and culture?
What are the four principal formulations regarding the relationship between language, thought, and culture?
According to Theory 1, what is essential for thought?
According to Theory 1, what is essential for thought?
What does Theory 2 propose about language and thought?
What does Theory 2 propose about language and thought?
What does Theory 3 suggest about the relationship between language and perception?
What does Theory 3 suggest about the relationship between language and perception?
According to Theory 4, what does language shape?
According to Theory 4, what does language shape?
What complicates determining whether a second language is 'safe' or 'harmful'?
What complicates determining whether a second language is 'safe' or 'harmful'?
Which example illustrates the complexity of labeling a second language as 'safe' or 'harmful'?
Which example illustrates the complexity of labeling a second language as 'safe' or 'harmful'?
What does Theory 1 suggest about the relationship between thought and speech?
What does Theory 1 suggest about the relationship between thought and speech?
What is the main claim of Theory 3?
What is the main claim of Theory 3?
What does Theory 4 argue about the role of language?
What does Theory 4 argue about the role of language?
A second language can be considered harmful if it conflicts with societal morals and values.
A second language can be considered harmful if it conflicts with societal morals and values.
Political associations of languages, such as Communism or democracy, complicate the determination of 'safe' second languages.
Political associations of languages, such as Communism or democracy, complicate the determination of 'safe' second languages.
Theory 1 claims that thought is impossible without written language.
Theory 1 claims that thought is impossible without written language.
Theory 3 suggests that learning a language determines how we perceive the physical world.
Theory 3 suggests that learning a language determines how we perceive the physical world.
According to Theory 4, learning a language influences our understanding of the world and culture.
According to Theory 4, learning a language influences our understanding of the world and culture.
Theories 1 and 2 both emphasize that language is essential for thought but differ in the role of speech.
Theories 1 and 2 both emphasize that language is essential for thought but differ in the role of speech.
The text raises the question of whether a second language can conflict with societal morals and values.
The text raises the question of whether a second language can conflict with societal morals and values.
Political and cultural associations of a language make it easy to determine whether it is 'safe’ or ‘harmful.'
Political and cultural associations of a language make it easy to determine whether it is 'safe’ or ‘harmful.'
Theory 1 claims that speech is essential for developing thought.
Theory 1 claims that speech is essential for developing thought.
Flashcards
Meyer Case
Meyer Case
Robert Meyer was arrested for teaching German, violating Nebraska law.
US Supreme Court Ruling
US Supreme Court Ruling
The Court overturned Meyer's conviction, declaring language laws unconstitutional.
Significance of Language in Culture
Significance of Language in Culture
Language embodies the national character and cultural values of a people.
Siman Act
Siman Act
Signup and view all the flashcards
Thought and Language Dependency
Thought and Language Dependency
Signup and view all the flashcards
Wilhelm von Humboldt's Claim
Wilhelm von Humboldt's Claim
Signup and view all the flashcards
Bilingual Education Debate
Bilingual Education Debate
Signup and view all the flashcards
Theory 1 Overview
Theory 1 Overview
Signup and view all the flashcards
Child Comprehension vs. Production
Child Comprehension vs. Production
Signup and view all the flashcards
Non-verbal Thought
Non-verbal Thought
Signup and view all the flashcards
Theory 2 Significance
Theory 2 Significance
Signup and view all the flashcards
Deaf Individuals and Thought
Deaf Individuals and Thought
Signup and view all the flashcards
Theory 3's Focus
Theory 3's Focus
Signup and view all the flashcards
Color Vocabulary Research
Color Vocabulary Research
Signup and view all the flashcards
Inuit Snow Vocabulary
Inuit Snow Vocabulary
Signup and view all the flashcards
Theory 4 Overview
Theory 4 Overview
Signup and view all the flashcards
Multilingual Worldviews
Multilingual Worldviews
Signup and view all the flashcards
Erroneous Belief About Language Analysis
Erroneous Belief About Language Analysis
Signup and view all the flashcards
Hopi Language
Hopi Language
Signup and view all the flashcards
Relationship Between Thought and Language
Relationship Between Thought and Language
Signup and view all the flashcards
John Locke's View
John Locke's View
Signup and view all the flashcards
Social Interaction and Language
Social Interaction and Language
Signup and view all the flashcards
Cognitive Flexibility in Multilinguals
Cognitive Flexibility in Multilinguals
Signup and view all the flashcards
Evidence Against Linguistic Determinism
Evidence Against Linguistic Determinism
Signup and view all the flashcards
Impact of Vocabulary on Thought
Impact of Vocabulary on Thought
Signup and view all the flashcards
Cultural Shifts and Language Grammar
Cultural Shifts and Language Grammar
Signup and view all the flashcards
Complexity of Languages
Complexity of Languages
Signup and view all the flashcards
Meaning Acquisition of Words
Meaning Acquisition of Words
Signup and view all the flashcards
Primitive vs. Modern Languages
Primitive vs. Modern Languages
Signup and view all the flashcards
Study Notes
Summary of Quiz Chapter 9
- Robert Meyer was arrested in 1920 for violating a Nebraska law by teaching German to a 10-year-old boy.
- The Nebraska Supreme Court justified its ruling by claiming German embodied German national character and values, citing a lack of constitutional protection for teaching German.
- The US Supreme Court overturned Meyer's conviction, stating language laws were unconstitutional as knowledge of a foreign language couldn't be considered harmful.
- The US Supreme Court stated knowledge of German couldn't reasonably be considered harmful.
- Nebraska and other states passed laws against teaching foreign languages to reduce the influence of German culture.
- The Siman Act prohibited teaching foreign languages to children under 13 years old.
- The Siman Act was influenced by anti-German sentiment.
- The relationship between language, thought, and culture is central to psycholinguistics. Wilhelm von Humboldt argued in 1836 that language reflects the spirit and national character of a people.
- Four principal formulations regarding the relationship between language, thought, and culture exist.
- Theory 1 suggests thought depends on speech. Behaviorists like Liberman's Motor Theory of Speech Perception supported this.
- Theory 2 suggests language is essential for developing thought. Sapir, Whorf, and Vygotsky spearheaded this theory.
- Theory 3 suggests language shapes perception.
- Theory 4 suggests language influences cultural and social beliefs and world views.
- The importance of speech in thinking came up frequently.
- There are varied perspectives and discussions about the relationship between language, thought, and culture, and how these theories have been understood and developed.
Theory 1 (Speech is Essential for Thought)
- Proponents: Behaviorists like Liberman.
- Central claim: Thought is derived from speech production.
- Criticism: Evidence that speech comprehension often precedes speech production in children, demonstrating the independence of thought from speech production. Cases of individuals like Stephen Hawking and Christopher Reeve are presented as evidence against this theory. Their thought and cognitive abilities survived despite severely impaired speech.
Theory 2 (Language is Essential for Thought)
- Proponents: Sapir, Whorf, Vygotsky.
- Central claim: Language is vital for thought development.
- Objections: Case of deaf individuals, who can think even without sign language. The trilingual family study suggests unified thought regardless of language use.
Theory 3 (Language Shapes Perception)
- Central claim: Language molds our perception of the world. A person's language determines their view of the world.
- Critique: Some research found that language did not affect perception, that it just affects how people communicate their perceptions.
Theory 4 (Language Shapes Cultural Worldview)
- Central claim: Language greatly influences cultural and social perspectives.
- Objections: People with similar ideas despite using different languages, as seen in the example of Communism.
- Theory 4 suggests that language influences cultural and social beliefs.
- Critiques: The idea that people with similar ideas will still use differing languages. This is especially relevant in societies with diverse groups.
Key Entities
- Robert Meyer
- Nebraska law
- US Supreme Court
- Siman Act
- Wilhelm von Humboldt
- Sapir, Whorf, Vygotsky
- Alvin Liberman
- Stephen Hawking and Christopher Reeve
- Helen Keller
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.