Podcast Beta
Questions and Answers
Define a rule.
Behavioral guidelines that teach us lessons about the real world.
Define a law.
Rules that have been passed by and will be enforced by the government.
Which of the following is a similarity between a rule and a law? (Select all that apply)
Which of the following is a difference between a rule and a law? (Select all that apply)
Signup and view all the answers
Provide an example where a rule we follow as children prepares us for a law when we are older.
Signup and view all the answers
What is the positive law approach to understanding law?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the natural law approach to understanding law?
Signup and view all the answers
Identify a key idea from Utilitarianism.
Signup and view all the answers
Identify a key idea from Libertarianism.
Signup and view all the answers
How does legal formalism differ from legal realism?
Signup and view all the answers
Study Notes
Legal Foundations Overview
- Rules: Behavioral guidelines that prepare individuals for real-world scenarios.
- Laws: Rules established by the government, enforceable by police and courts.
Similarities and Differences: Rules vs. Laws
-
Similarities:
- Both teach right from wrong.
- Both apply to everyone within their respective contexts.
-
Differences:
- Laws are enforced by the police and the judicial system, while rules are enforced by parents or teachers.
- Laws must be voted on and accepted, whereas rules may vary and do not necessarily involve formal acceptance.
Rule to Law Example
-
Example: Looking both ways before crossing the street.
- Taught by parents as a safety guideline
- Formalized as a traffic law to promote safety and prevent accidents.
Natural Law vs. Positive Law
-
Natural Law:
- Comprises universal moral and ethical principles inherently understood by humans.
- Example: The belief that murder is inherently wrong.
-
Positive Law:
- Suggests society must create laws to maintain order, independent of morality.
- Emphasizes that laws must be followed simply because they are laws established by the government.
Influence of Perspectives on Law
- Understanding law incorporates both ethical principles (natural law) and practical frameworks (positive law) for societal order and justice.
Early Philosophers of Law: Utilitarianism vs. Libertarianism
-
Utilitarianism:
- Advocates for actions that produce the greatest good for the majority.
- Focuses on maximizing collective happiness and pleasure.
- Quantity of pleasure is prioritized over the nature of pleasures.
-
Libertarianism:
- Emphasizes the importance of individual rights over collective rights.
- Suggests certain pleasures are qualitatively superior and should be prioritized.
- Rules should be established to lead to the best outcomes for society.
Application of Theories to Tax Law
- Utilitarian View: Supports tax laws for redistributive purposes, arguing they reduce inequality and enhance overall happiness.
- Libertarian View: Would analyze how the law aligns with general rules promoting the greatest good and if it respects individual rights.
Contemporary Legal Theories
- Legal Formalism: Involves strict adherence to established rules; judges interpret the law without external influence.
- Legal Realism: Suggests laws can be interpreted and shaped by judges, making them influential in case outcomes.
- Canadian Approach: Canada leans towards legal realism, allowing judges to consider broader contexts in their rulings.
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.
Related Documents
Description
Explore the key concepts of rules and laws in this quiz. Understand their definitions, similarities, and differences to better comprehend the legal framework. This review package prepares you for discussions on legal foundations.
