vid 1

Introduction to Non-Extractive Entrepreneurship

• This course focuses on entrepreneurship that avoids financial extraction, a process of taking wealth from a business beyond salaries and pensions.
• Goal: Understand how financial extraction impacts business and develop a more ethical business model.
• Focus: Deconstructing the current business system to create one that benefits society and the environment.
• Idealists: Empower entrepreneurs who want to use business to create positive change.
• Challenging Assumptions: Questioning traditional entrepreneurial assumptions about growth and equity.
• System Change: Encourage deconstructing and reassembling the current system for ethical and sustainable outcomes.
• Actionable Tools: Provide practical tools and techniques to drive positive change in business.
• Optimistic Approach: Focus on empowering individuals to transform the current system.
• Course Structure: Sections include instructor introduction, aligning personal values with business, analyzing the flaws of the current business model, examining limitations of the Silicon Valley model, exploring alternatives to traditional models, understanding post-growth entrepreneurship, examining alternative financing models, and building a new business paradigm.

The Instructor's Background

• Melanie is a computer scientist, cyber security expert, entrepreneur, and founder.
• Radically Open Security: Founded a not-for-profit focused on ethical hacking and security audits.
• Foundation Ownership: Sold the company to a foundation for a symbolic amount, prioritizing social impact.
• Fiscal Fundraising Institution: Uses specific Dutch tax structure for maximizing charitable donations.
• Profit Donation: Donates 90% of profits to nlnet foundation, supporting open-source initiatives.
• Success Despite Skepticism: Demonstrated that a not-for-profit model can be successful, growing to 50 employees and donating over €750,000.
• Validation: Awarded EU Women Innovation Prize, recognized for innovative and socially responsible businesses.
• Steward Ownership: Advocates a business model where profit rights are separated from voting rights, prioritising social goals.
• Non-Profit Ventures: Founded a non-profit incubator for non-extractive startups, supporting social enterprises.
• Entrepreneurship as Activism: Challenges the view of business as solely a wealth-building tool, highlighting its potential for social change.
• Business as Art and Spirituality: Explores business as a creative vehicle, breaking conventional business norms.

Examining the Status Quo: Financial Extraction

• Financial Extraction: Unnecessary removal of wealth from businesses beyond salaries and pensions.
• Forms of Financial Extraction: Dividends, excessive CEO compensation, equity sales above market value, and bonuses.
• Growth Imperative: The continuous need for growth, often fueled by financial extraction.
• The Story of the 11th Round: A parable illustrating the connection between financial extraction and growth.
• Original Sin: Financial extraction considered a fundamental flaw, similar to usury.
• Layers of Financial Extraction:
  • Micro: Personal debt (student loans, mortgages, credit cards) leads to financial dependence.
  • Meso: Corporate debt and excessive equity sales siphon business profits.
  • Macro: International development loans can result in debt slavery and loss of national autonomy.
• Confessions of an Economic Hitman: Explores the use of development loans for global control.

Beyond GDP: Rethinking Economic Growth

• GDP (Gross Domestic Product): Traditional measure of economic growth, often prioritised over other indicators.
• Questioning GDP: Course challenges the sole reliance on GDP growth as a measure of prosperity, promoting alternatives.
• Post-Growth Economics: A movement questioning the constant need for growth.
• Degrowth Movement: A more radical approach advocating for economic reduction to achieve sustainability and societal well-being.
• Thriving Without Growth: Investigating societal well-being without continuous economic expansion.
• Degrowth: Less is More: The idea that flourishing is possible with reduced material consumption.
• Prosperity Without Growth: Tim Jackson's work analyzing how societal advancement is compatible with limited growth.
• Donut Economics: An alternative model proposed by Kate Rayworth, prioritizing social well-being alongside environmental limits.
• The Donut Model: Visualizes a sustainable economy, where basic needs and ecological limits are respected.

Silicon Valley Model and its Challenges

• Silicon Valley Model: Entails venture capital, rapid growth, and an exit strategy (acquisition or IPO).
• Capital: Venture capital, seed rounds, convertible loans, and debt financing are seen as essential but their necessity is questioned.
• The Myth of Needing Venture Capital: Businesses existed and thrived before the advent of venture capital.
• Loss of Autonomy: Reliance on venture capital often places entrepreneurs under investors' governance.
• The Hype of Venture Capital: VCs' pervasive presence sometimes marginalizes alternative financing options.
• The Google Story: Illustrates the potential downsides of relying on venture capital.
• The Unintended Consequences of Silicon Valley: Questions the model's social consequences (inequality, gentrification).

Scaling in Silicon Valley

• Scaling often refers to increased revenue, but this might not indicate profitability.
• Venture Capital's Acceleration: Venture capital may not consistently advance profitability, hindering it in some cases.
• High Burn Rate: Funding can lead to increased spending and rapid resource depletion, limiting runway.
• Limited Capital Advantages: Starting with limited capital fosters lean operations and efficiency, focusing on value proposition.
• Minimum Viable Product (MVP): Building a basic model to test market demand.
• Customer Acquisition's Power: Customer acquisition often generates compounding growth.
• Product/Market Disconnect: Rapid scaling can lead to prioritising technological advancement over market needs.
• Lean Startup Methodology: An iterative process focused on validated learning, avoiding product/market mismatches.

Exits in Silicon Valley

• Exits: Company sales often seen as a measure of success, but can cause disruptions.
• Detrimental Impacts: Can lead to staff departures, cultural shifts, and organizational dysfunction.
• Casino Environment: Emphasis on exits prioritises a select few successes over numerous failures.
• Focus on IPOs: Prioritising massive financial gain from IPOs over building lasting businesses.

Valuations and the Financialization of Startups

• Inflated Valuations: Early-stage company valuations can be significantly inflated, especially before profitability.
• Illusion of Success: Small investments can artificially inflate valuations, creating a deceptive picture of success.
• Pump and Dump Schemes: companies may raise valuations and then sell shares quickly before profitability.
• SoftBank's Influence: Investment firms have inflated valuations via investment in companies.
• Uneven Playing Field: Venture-backed companies may outcompete other businesses with limited funding.
• Distortion of Industries: Prioritization of financial gain over product and service value.

Modern Monetary Theory (MMT) and the Concept of Equity as a Sovereign Currency

• Sovereign Currencies and Government Spending: Governments with sovereign currencies can manage finances without budgetary constraints.
• Business Equity and Social Agreement: Unlimited shares are possible as long as society agrees on their value.
• Fluid Nature of Valuations: Subjectivity of valuations affected by social factors and influential figures.
• Shareholder Dilution: Unlimited creation of shares can lead to founders diluting existing investors.

Speculation and the "Whirlpool of Speculation"

• Speculation in Various Markets: "Whirlpool" exists across markets (stocks, crypto, etc).
• Greater Fool Theory: Individuals buy assets based on the hope of future gains, regardless of true value.
• Distorted Economic Progress: Speculative bubbles can overshadow genuine enterprise.