Podcast
Questions and Answers
What is one challenge associated with enforcing economic sanctions in International Environmental Agreements?
What is one challenge associated with enforcing economic sanctions in International Environmental Agreements?
- They always increase the number of signatories.
- They are easy to design and implement.
- Credible threats are difficult to design. (correct)
- They do not affect non-signatories.
Why are emissions considered hardly a credible threat in the context of International Environmental Agreements?
Why are emissions considered hardly a credible threat in the context of International Environmental Agreements?
- Countries benefit from self-damaging policies.
- Emissions are always economically beneficial.
- Countries are likely to adopt sustainable practices.
- Countries are unlikely to sustain self-damaging policies. (correct)
What potential effect might carrying out sanctions have on the coalition of current signatories?
What potential effect might carrying out sanctions have on the coalition of current signatories?
- It may reduce the incentive to join the coalition. (correct)
- It could increase non-signatory participation.
- It would lead to more voluntary signatories.
- It could eliminate the need for future sanctions.
What is one reason why the threat of economic sanctions is employed in International Environmental Agreements?
What is one reason why the threat of economic sanctions is employed in International Environmental Agreements?
How might credible threats impact the design of International Environmental Agreements?
How might credible threats impact the design of International Environmental Agreements?
What is the first stage of the non-cooperative game theory in the context of International Environmental Agreements?
What is the first stage of the non-cooperative game theory in the context of International Environmental Agreements?
How do countries approach the outcome of the emission game during the coalition game?
How do countries approach the outcome of the emission game during the coalition game?
What is the primary purpose of International Environmental Agreements (IEAs)?
What is the primary purpose of International Environmental Agreements (IEAs)?
In the emission game, how do countries that sign the agreement behave?
In the emission game, how do countries that sign the agreement behave?
What significant rule is determined during the coalition game?
What significant rule is determined during the coalition game?
What is the first stage of the IEA framework according to non-cooperative game theory?
What is the first stage of the IEA framework according to non-cooperative game theory?
What assumption is made regarding the decision-making process of countries in both stages?
What assumption is made regarding the decision-making process of countries in both stages?
Which of the following describes a challenge in the formation of IEAs?
Which of the following describes a challenge in the formation of IEAs?
What is the primary focus of the theoretical framework of International Environmental Agreements?
What is the primary focus of the theoretical framework of International Environmental Agreements?
What common issue do binding agreements in IEAs help to overcome?
What common issue do binding agreements in IEAs help to overcome?
How do countries that sign an IEA behave during the emission game?
How do countries that sign an IEA behave during the emission game?
Which game theory concept is utilized to analyze countries' decisions regarding signing agreements?
Which game theory concept is utilized to analyze countries' decisions regarding signing agreements?
What determines the resulting payoff for countries that sign the agreement in the emission game?
What determines the resulting payoff for countries that sign the agreement in the emission game?
According to Kolstad and Toman, what is the paradox concerning International Agreements?
According to Kolstad and Toman, what is the paradox concerning International Agreements?
In the theoretical framework of IEAs, how is burden-sharing determined?
In the theoretical framework of IEAs, how is burden-sharing determined?
What assumption is made about the countries' decisions in the stages of the IEA framework?
What assumption is made about the countries' decisions in the stages of the IEA framework?
What condition must be satisfied for a coalition to be considered profitable?
What condition must be satisfied for a coalition to be considered profitable?
Under what circumstance is a coalition considered stable?
Under what circumstance is a coalition considered stable?
Which type of game does the theory more closely resemble?
Which type of game does the theory more closely resemble?
What is a characteristic of a Pareto optimal coalition?
What is a characteristic of a Pareto optimal coalition?
What influences the size of the group of signatories in the game?
What influences the size of the group of signatories in the game?
In the context of the coalition game, what indicates a profitable coalition?
In the context of the coalition game, what indicates a profitable coalition?
Which statement is true about a coalition that is both profitable and stable?
Which statement is true about a coalition that is both profitable and stable?
What is a potential outcome of the two-stage game described?
What is a potential outcome of the two-stage game described?
What is the main purpose of transfers in International Environmental Agreements?
What is the main purpose of transfers in International Environmental Agreements?
Which of the following is NOT a method explored to enhance coalition size in environmental agreements?
Which of the following is NOT a method explored to enhance coalition size in environmental agreements?
What commitment is required from countries implementing transfer programs to non-signatories?
What commitment is required from countries implementing transfer programs to non-signatories?
What characterizes the equilibrium coalition in international environmental agreements?
What characterizes the equilibrium coalition in international environmental agreements?
Who conducted research showing the necessity of commitment for transfer programs in agreements?
Who conducted research showing the necessity of commitment for transfer programs in agreements?
What is a potential drawback of countries agreeing to transfer programs?
What is a potential drawback of countries agreeing to transfer programs?
What is the primary challenge identified in extending the size of environmental coalitions?
What is the primary challenge identified in extending the size of environmental coalitions?
Which of the following factors can potentially encourage countries to join an environmental agreement?
Which of the following factors can potentially encourage countries to join an environmental agreement?
What is a fundamental characteristic of International Environmental Agreements (IEAs)?
What is a fundamental characteristic of International Environmental Agreements (IEAs)?
What problem do binding agreements in IEAs help to overcome?
What problem do binding agreements in IEAs help to overcome?
According to Kolstad and Toman, what is the apparent contradiction regarding IEAs?
According to Kolstad and Toman, what is the apparent contradiction regarding IEAs?
What type of good is a healthy environment classified as in the context of IEAs?
What type of good is a healthy environment classified as in the context of IEAs?
What is one of the main research questions regarding the design of IEAs?
What is one of the main research questions regarding the design of IEAs?
Which statement best reflects the role of participation in IEAs?
Which statement best reflects the role of participation in IEAs?
What is a common misconception about IEAs as derived from the literature?
What is a common misconception about IEAs as derived from the literature?
Which factor is incorrectly assumed to determine the efficiency of IEAs?
Which factor is incorrectly assumed to determine the efficiency of IEAs?
Flashcards
What are International Environmental Agreements (IEAs)?
What are International Environmental Agreements (IEAs)?
An agreement between nations to address global environmental problems. They aim to protect a collective good, such as a healthy environment.
What is the free-riding problem?
What is the free-riding problem?
A situation where individuals benefit from a resource without contributing to its upkeep. IEAs aim to counter this by encouraging participation and shared responsibility.
Why is a healthy environment considered a global public good?
Why is a healthy environment considered a global public good?
A public good is non-excludable (accessible to everyone) and non-rival (use by one person doesn't reduce its availability for others). A healthy environment benefits everyone, but individual countries may be tempted to free-ride.
What is the Paradox of International Agreements?
What is the Paradox of International Agreements?
Signup and view all the flashcards
How do IEAs help overcome the free-riding problem?
How do IEAs help overcome the free-riding problem?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Why are IEAs considered a natural solution for addressing global environmental problems?
Why are IEAs considered a natural solution for addressing global environmental problems?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What are the research questions in the theory of IEAs?
What are the research questions in the theory of IEAs?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is the theory of International Environmental Agreements?
What is the theory of International Environmental Agreements?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is an IEA?
What is an IEA?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is the standard tool used to model IEAs?
What is the standard tool used to model IEAs?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Describe the first stage of the IEA model.
Describe the first stage of the IEA model.
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is burden-sharing in IEAs?
What is burden-sharing in IEAs?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Describe the second stage of the IEA model.
Describe the second stage of the IEA model.
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is the assumption made about timing in the IEA model?
What is the assumption made about timing in the IEA model?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Non-cooperative Game Theory
Non-cooperative Game Theory
Signup and view all the flashcards
Coalition Formation
Coalition Formation
Signup and view all the flashcards
Burden-Sharing Rule
Burden-Sharing Rule
Signup and view all the flashcards
Simultaneous Emission Game
Simultaneous Emission Game
Signup and view all the flashcards
Backward Induction
Backward Induction
Signup and view all the flashcards
Single Player Emission Game
Single Player Emission Game
Signup and view all the flashcards
IEA Framework
IEA Framework
Signup and view all the flashcards
Nash Emission Game
Nash Emission Game
Signup and view all the flashcards
Coalition in International Environmental Agreements
Coalition in International Environmental Agreements
Signup and view all the flashcards
Profitable Coalition
Profitable Coalition
Signup and view all the flashcards
Stable Coalition
Stable Coalition
Signup and view all the flashcards
Pareto Optimal Coalition
Pareto Optimal Coalition
Signup and view all the flashcards
Partial Cooperation in Environmental Agreements
Partial Cooperation in Environmental Agreements
Signup and view all the flashcards
Strategic Interaction in Environmental Agreements
Strategic Interaction in Environmental Agreements
Signup and view all the flashcards
The "Chicken Game" in Environmental Agreements
The "Chicken Game" in Environmental Agreements
Signup and view all the flashcards
Prisoner's Dilemma in Environmental Agreements
Prisoner's Dilemma in Environmental Agreements
Signup and view all the flashcards
International Environmental Agreements (IEAs)
International Environmental Agreements (IEAs)
Signup and view all the flashcards
Theory of International Environmental Agreements
Theory of International Environmental Agreements
Signup and view all the flashcards
Theoretical Framework for IEAs
Theoretical Framework for IEAs
Signup and view all the flashcards
Main Results of IEA Research
Main Results of IEA Research
Signup and view all the flashcards
Expanding IEA Coalitions
Expanding IEA Coalitions
Signup and view all the flashcards
Transfers in IEAs
Transfers in IEAs
Signup and view all the flashcards
Issue Linkages in IEAs
Issue Linkages in IEAs
Signup and view all the flashcards
Threats in IEAs
Threats in IEAs
Signup and view all the flashcards
How are economic sanctions used in IEAs?
How are economic sanctions used in IEAs?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is the "free-riding" problem in IEAs?
What is the "free-riding" problem in IEAs?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Why do IEAs exist despite the free-riding challenge?
Why do IEAs exist despite the free-riding challenge?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What are the challenges of using threats in IEAs?
What are the challenges of using threats in IEAs?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Study Notes
Intergenerational Fairness Lecture Notes
- International Environmental Agreements (IEAs) are seen as a way to address climate change.
- A healthy environment is considered a global public good.
- Participation in IEAs is a public good.
- Binding agreements are used to overcome free-riding.
- Research questions include how IEAs work, various agreement types, and optimal IEA design.
- Kolstad and Toman (2005) described the "Paradox of International Agreements," noting that although IEAs are common, economic theory suggests they should not be effective as observed.
Theoretical Framework
- The standard tool for analyzing IEAs is non-cooperative game theory of coalition formation.
- This involves two stages:
- The coalition game where countries decide whether or not to join the agreement, defining a burden-sharing rule.
- The emission game where participating countries act as a single player and share the outcome according to their burden-sharing rule.
- All countries simultaneously make decisions in both stages.
Theoretical Framework: Emission Game
- During the coalition game, countries forecast the play and outcome of the emission game.
- Countries use backward induction to determine the best strategy for the emission game in each coalition scenario.
- Exact payoff structures for coalition and non-coalition members are not required.
- The key assumption is that each country's payoff grows with the coalition's size (number of participants).
Theoretical Framework: Coalition Game (1)
- All countries are identical and can only sign one agreement; proposing a different agreement after joining is forbidden.
- Countries not in a coalition act as singletons.
- When a country leaves a coalition (S), other members are assumed to remain within the coalition.
Theoretical Framework: Coalition Game (2)
- A coalition (S) is considered profitable if each country within it gains by joining (versus no coalition).
- A coalition is stable if no member gains by leaving, and no outside member benefits by joining.
- A profitable and stable coalition is also Pareto-optimal; no other profitable and stable coalition exists that improves everyone's situation.
Partial Cooperation
- The IEA scenario isn't a prisoner's dilemma but more like a "chicken game."
- The equilibrium involves a profitable and stable, but partial, coalition.
- Two groups of countries exist at equilibrium: signatories and defectors.
- The size of the signatory group depends on strategic interactions (reaction functions).
Small Coalitions: Other Policies?
- The equilibrium coalition is typically composed of a small number of signatories.
- Research explores ways to expand coalition size beyond emission controls.
- Policy areas include transfers, issue linkages, and/or threats.
IEAs with Transfers
- Transfers are often proposed to compensate countries that lose from signing an agreement.
- Transfers can expand initially stable but small coalitions.
- Implementing transfer programs necessitates cooperation from all countries involved, as seen in previous studies.
IEAs with Issue Linkages
- Linking environmental negotiations to other economic issues (e.g., trade, technology) is beneficial.
- This can reduce limitations from asymmetries and increase stable coalition size by strategically using linked benefits.
IEAs with Threats
-
Using economic sanctions (e.g., trade) to punish non-signatories can raise the number of participants.
-
Credibly designed threats are difficult to establish, as emissions are usually not a sufficient threat.
-
Imposing sanctions to draw in more members may reduce the commitment from already participating countries instead.
-
Lastly, the lecturer expresses gratitude to the audience.
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.