Questions and Answers
What does the computer analogy suggest about our genes and language?
Our genes provide biological hardware but not the software needed for language.
Syntax is believed to have emerged before independent symbols in the evolution of language.
False
Which disciplines are mentioned as relevant to the investigation of the evolution of language?
The systems used by animals for communication do not satisfy all the design features of __________ languages.
Signup and view all the answers
Which of the following theories suggest the origins of language is linked to gestures?
Signup and view all the answers
What does the theory 'looky-look' argue?
Signup and view all the answers
Specific Language Impairment (SLI) is solely associated with language and the FOXP2 gene.
Signup and view all the answers
Match the following theories of language origins with their descriptions:
Signup and view all the answers
What distinguishes human language from animal communication systems?
Signup and view all the answers
Which of the following accounts for the diversity of languages according to the Judean–Christian tradition?
Signup and view all the answers
Feral children can learn language fully after being raised with minimal human contact.
Signup and view all the answers
What was the first word produced by the infants segregated by Psammetichus?
Signup and view all the answers
Which theory suggests that human language began with the mimicry of natural sounds?
Signup and view all the answers
According to the 'ding-dong' theory, language originated from:
Signup and view all the answers
What challenge does the 'noddy' theory face?
Signup and view all the answers
Who proposed the grooming hypothesis in the emergence of language?
Signup and view all the answers
What is a possible candidate gene associated with language according to the 'just genes' theory?
Signup and view all the answers
Researchers believe that human language evolved as a biologically encoded trait.
Signup and view all the answers
What crucial aspect of language evolution does Michael Tomasello emphasize?
Signup and view all the answers
Study Notes
Human Language vs. Animal Communication
- Human language differs from animal communication primarily in degree, not kind.
- Cognitive mechanisms for speech may have predated human language.
- Qualitative differences in language evolution likely stem from quantitative differences over time.
Origins and Evolution of Human Language
- Many cultures have myths explaining language origins, often attributing it to divine sources.
- Historical examples include Adam naming creatures, the Tower of Babel, and various deities responsible for language in different cultures.
- Scientific exploration of language origins relies on indirect evidence due to the absence of historical records prior to writing.
Case Studies of Language Acquisition
- Feral children, like Genie, show the impact of isolation on language acquisition, gaining vocabulary but struggling with complex syntax.
- Historical anecdotes include the Egyptian Pharaoh Psammetichus's experiment with two infants believed to reveal the original human language.
Theories on Language Origins (19th Century)
- La-La Theory: Suggests language derived from song-like communication.
- Bow-Wow Theory: Proposes language began as mimicking natural sounds.
- Ding-Dong Theory: Asserts natural connections exist between sounds and meanings.
- Pooh-Pooh Theory: Attributes language to natural cries of emotion.
- Yo-Heave-Ho Theory: Suggests vocalizations made during physical exertion led to early language.
Limitations of Historical Theories
- Historical theories fail to adequately explain complex elements like syntax and morphology.
- Some theories lack clarity on the transition from simple sounds to intricate language structures.
Reassessment of Language Origins
- Linguistic Society of Paris imposed a ban on language origin papers, viewed as speculative.
- Interdisciplinary approaches are now encouraged, including insights from genetics and neurobiology.
- Recent speculations about origins consider cultural influences rather than biological adaptations.
The Gestural Origin Hypothesis
- Posits that early communication was gestural, which later evolved into vocal forms.
- Bipedalism and changes in vocal anatomy may have facilitated this transition.
- Suggests a shift in communication focus from visual gestures to vocal expressions due to environmental advantages.
The Grooming Hypothesis
- Proposed by Robin Dunbar, linking social bonding and language as a means of group cohesion.
- Speech allows for social interaction in larger groups, functioning like grooming done in other primates.
Genetic Predisposition for Language
- Genetic adaptations facilitate language acquisition, contradicting the tabula rasa view.
- Two perspectives:
- Just Genes Theory: Language arose from a single genetic mutation (Chomsky's "Oops!" theory).
- Language evolved as a biological adaptation through natural selection (Pinker’s "chatting-up" theory).
- FOXP2 gene linked to language development but is not exclusively responsible for language abilities.
Language and Social Cognition
- Recent theories suggest language complexity arose culturally, informed by social dynamics.
- The ability to share attention and recognize intentional agents may have been essential for language development.
Concluding Remarks on Language Evolution
- Current consensus views genes as providing hardware for language acquisition rather than encoding it.
- Cultural contexts are seen as pivotal in the emergence of language and subsequent grammatical developments.
- Comparative studies of non-human communication systems can yield insights into human language evolution.
- Emphasis on an interdisciplinary approach incorporating genetics, psychology, and other fields contributes to understanding language origins.### Animal Communication and Language Learning
- Many species have been taught human language, particularly apes, demonstrating some structural similarities to human language but lacking key features like duality of patterning and reflexivity.
- Studies show natural communication systems in animals do not decisively support or oppose theories on the evolution of human language.
Origins and Theories of Human Language
- Speculations about language origins can be traced back through mythology, with numerous 19th-century theories including:
- 'Bow-wow': Language arose from natural sounds.
- 'Ding-dong': Language developed from innate metaphoric associations.
- 'Pooh-pooh': Language emerged from emotional exclamations.
- 'Yo-heave-ho': Language originated from communal work chants.
- 'La-la': Language evolved from play and musical sounds.
- Modern theories introduce more complex ideas, such as:
- 'Noddy': Language stems from gestures.
- 'Yackety-yack': Language emerged to facilitate social gossip as a substitute for grooming.
- 'Just genes': Language is genetically encoded.
- 'Chatting-up': Language evolved through natural selection.
- 'Oops': Language arose from random genetic mutation.
Genetics and Language
- Specific Language Impairment (SLI) is linked to the FOXP2 gene, historically regarded as the 'language gene,' but is not exclusive to language.
- Recent theories highlight cultural aspects in the emergence of human language, where biological evolution provided a language-ready brain that flourished in social contexts.
- The 'looky-look' theory posits that joint attention was crucial in the development of language.
Further Reading and Studies
- Comprehensive reviews on animal communication can be found in the works of Bright (1984) and Morton and Page (1992).
- Honeybee communication has been notably described in Karl von Frisch’s 1973 Nobel lecture.
- Bird vocalizations and monkey communications have been explored in various studies, showcasing the complexity of animal interactions.
- Key researchers in ape language learning include Hayes, Gardner, Premack, and Savage-Rumbaugh. Their works cover significant attempts to teach language to chimpanzees.
- The 'Clever Hans' effect illustrates misinterpretations in animal communication studies.
- Language acquisition case studies, such as Genie, demonstrate the critical aspects of language development and learning.
Evolution of Human Language
- The field of language evolution has seen many ideas, from Lenneberg’s classic works to newer insights from Fitch and Tomasello, reflecting the shifting understanding of how language relates to cognition and social structures.
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.
Description
Explore the fascinating differences and similarities between human language and animal communication. This quiz also delves into the origins and evolution of language across different cultures, alongside case studies that illustrate language acquisition in unique circumstances. Test your knowledge of these crucial concepts in linguistics.
