Podcast
Questions and Answers
Is the commandment of כיבוד אב ואם considered a בין אדם לחבירו or בין אדם למקום according to Ramban?
Is the commandment of כיבוד אב ואם considered a בין אדם לחבירו or בין אדם למקום according to Ramban?
It is considered בין אדם למקום as it relates to one's relationship with Hashem.
According to Chayei Adam, why is paying back debt to parents considered a בין אדם לחבירו?
According to Chayei Adam, why is paying back debt to parents considered a בין אדם לחבירו?
Because we owe our existence to our parents and could not survive without them.
What is the nפקא מינה regarding asking for Machila related to כיבוד אב ואם?
What is the nפקא מינה regarding asking for Machila related to כיבוד אב ואם?
If it is בין אדם למקום, one must ask Hashem for forgiveness; if it is בין אדם לחבירו, one must ask the parents directly.
What act did Dama Ben Nesinah perform to honor his father that led to his reward?
What act did Dama Ben Nesinah perform to honor his father that led to his reward?
According to R’ Chaim Shmuelev, what should a person do to honor their parents?
According to R’ Chaim Shmuelev, what should a person do to honor their parents?
What does the Machilta teach regarding honoring both Hashem and one's parents?
What does the Machilta teach regarding honoring both Hashem and one's parents?
According to the Ramah, how should one serve their parents?
According to the Ramah, how should one serve their parents?
What obligation does a child have when their parent asks them to do something while they are studying?
What obligation does a child have when their parent asks them to do something while they are studying?
What actions did R’ Shlomo Zalman Auerbach recommend regarding learning and honoring parents?
What actions did R’ Shlomo Zalman Auerbach recommend regarding learning and honoring parents?
According to the Kitzur, what is considered the biggest honor one can give their parents?
According to the Kitzur, what is considered the biggest honor one can give their parents?
What phrase should be used when quoting deceased parents before twelve months have passed?
What phrase should be used when quoting deceased parents before twelve months have passed?
Is it permissible to sit in your father's place in shul or at home?
Is it permissible to sit in your father's place in shul or at home?
What should one do when their parents come into the room, according to halacha?
What should one do when their parents come into the room, according to halacha?
How should one address their parents when referring to them in a formal manner?
How should one address their parents when referring to them in a formal manner?
What is one expected to do when one finds it challenging to care for an emotionally unwell parent?
What is one expected to do when one finds it challenging to care for an emotionally unwell parent?
What action can one take if a parent has caused them emotional embarrassment and loss?
What action can one take if a parent has caused them emotional embarrassment and loss?
What is the appropriate response if someone disagrees with their parent's opinion?
What is the appropriate response if someone disagrees with their parent's opinion?
What obligation does a child have regarding their parent's physical setting, such as a chair or desk?
What obligation does a child have regarding their parent's physical setting, such as a chair or desk?
When is a child allowed to wake their father while he is sleeping?
When is a child allowed to wake their father while he is sleeping?
What should a child do if they need to disagree publicly with their father's interpretation of Torah?
What should a child do if they need to disagree publicly with their father's interpretation of Torah?
What should one do if their parent is mochel on their honor?
What should one do if their parent is mochel on their honor?
What importance is given to saying 'קדיש' for a deceased parent?
What importance is given to saying 'קדיש' for a deceased parent?
According to R’ Elyashiv, what is a contributing factor to a lack of respect in the current generation?
According to R’ Elyashiv, what is a contributing factor to a lack of respect in the current generation?
What is the punishment for cursing one's parents according to Halacha?
What is the punishment for cursing one's parents according to Halacha?
According to Halacha Chuf Ches, what is the consequence if a child hits a parent and causes a wound?
According to Halacha Chuf Ches, what is the consequence if a child hits a parent and causes a wound?
If a father commands a son to violate a Torah law, what should the son do?
If a father commands a son to violate a Torah law, what should the son do?
What does the Ramban state about the nature of Kibbud Av V'Em (honoring parents)?
What does the Ramban state about the nature of Kibbud Av V'Em (honoring parents)?
In what situation does a child not need to follow parental wishes regarding marriage according to Netziv?
In what situation does a child not need to follow parental wishes regarding marriage according to Netziv?
What is the distinction made by Chayei Adam regarding debts owed to parents?
What is the distinction made by Chayei Adam regarding debts owed to parents?
What is the consequence, as stated by Birchei Yosef, of not assisting a parent with a harmful request?
What is the consequence, as stated by Birchei Yosef, of not assisting a parent with a harmful request?
How should a child handle a situation if a parent is unclear about how to honor them?
How should a child handle a situation if a parent is unclear about how to honor them?
What does R’ Elchanan suggest about a father's permission to a child regarding respect?
What does R’ Elchanan suggest about a father's permission to a child regarding respect?
What is the Halacha regarding a father with a physical ailment whose child is asked to assist?
What is the Halacha regarding a father with a physical ailment whose child is asked to assist?
What should a child do if their parents ask them to violate a halacha?
What should a child do if their parents ask them to violate a halacha?
In the situation where both parents and child are financially struggling, what is the child’s obligation to provide support?
In the situation where both parents and child are financially struggling, what is the child’s obligation to provide support?
How should a child handle a situation where they have a mitzvah to perform while their parents ask for help?
How should a child handle a situation where they have a mitzvah to perform while their parents ask for help?
What is the importance of waking a parent for a child's profit?
What is the importance of waking a parent for a child's profit?
What is the obligation regarding a step-parent's honor compared to biological parents?
What is the obligation regarding a step-parent's honor compared to biological parents?
What does the halacha state about the behavior of parents towards their children in terms of respect?
What does the halacha state about the behavior of parents towards their children in terms of respect?
What should a child do if their parents want them to marry someone they do not wish to?
What should a child do if their parents want them to marry someone they do not wish to?
What obligation do children have if they have siblings of different financial statuses?
What obligation do children have if they have siblings of different financial statuses?
How should a child approach taking on a stringency (חומרא) against their parents’ wishes?
How should a child approach taking on a stringency (חומרא) against their parents’ wishes?
What is the mitzvah status of a Mamzer in relation to Kibbud Av V'Aim?
What is the mitzvah status of a Mamzer in relation to Kibbud Av V'Aim?
In a case where a child moves away for better schooling, what can they tell their parents?
In a case where a child moves away for better schooling, what can they tell their parents?
What is the consideration if a child's actions cause the parents pain?
What is the consideration if a child's actions cause the parents pain?
What is the status of honoring grandparents in the absence of a parent's life?
What is the status of honoring grandparents in the absence of a parent's life?
Flashcards
Is כיבוד אב ואם בין אדם לחבירו or בין אדם למקום?
Is כיבוד אב ואם בין אדם לחבירו or בין אדם למקום?
The act of honoring one's parents is a mitzvah that is considered between a person and God because the first commandment on the first Tablet refers to God, and all the commandments on the first Tablet mention God’s name.
What does Chayei Adam say about כיבוד אב ואם?
What does Chayei Adam say about כיבוד אב ואם?
The mitzvah of honoring your parents stems from the obligation to repay the debt you owe them for your existence and survival.
What are the key aspects of honoring your parents?
What are the key aspects of honoring your parents?
Honoring parents involves treating them with respect and kindness, anticipating their needs, and fulfilling their requests with a cheerful and positive attitude.
What should a child do if a parent asks them to do something when they're learning?
What should a child do if a parent asks them to do something when they're learning?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Why is it important to not cause pain to your parents?
Why is it important to not cause pain to your parents?
Signup and view all the flashcards
How should you view your parents?
How should you view your parents?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Should a child wait for their parents to ask before fulfilling their needs?
Should a child wait for their parents to ask before fulfilling their needs?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What lesson is taught in the story of Dama Ben Nesinah?
What lesson is taught in the story of Dama Ben Nesinah?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Who should wake up a parent?
Who should wake up a parent?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Can a child wake up their parent for profit?
Can a child wake up their parent for profit?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What if a parent tells you to break a Jewish law?
What if a parent tells you to break a Jewish law?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What if a parent asks for something while you're doing a Mitzvah?
What if a parent asks for something while you're doing a Mitzvah?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What if parents tell you to stop speaking to someone?
What if parents tell you to stop speaking to someone?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What if a parent requests something during your mitzvah?
What if a parent requests something during your mitzvah?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Should you always obey your parents?
Should you always obey your parents?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Can a child override their parent's wishes about marriage?
Can a child override their parent's wishes about marriage?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Does the mitzvah of honoring parents apply to both men and women?
Does the mitzvah of honoring parents apply to both men and women?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Can a child move cities for religious study?
Can a child move cities for religious study?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Who are you obligated to honor?
Who are you obligated to honor?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What should a child avoid doing to their parents?
What should a child avoid doing to their parents?
Signup and view all the flashcards
How should parents respond to their children's mistakes?
How should parents respond to their children's mistakes?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Do parents have the right to physically discipline?
Do parents have the right to physically discipline?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Can a father serve his son?
Can a father serve his son?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is the punishment for cursing parents?
What is the punishment for cursing parents?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is the punishment for hitting your parents?
What is the punishment for hitting your parents?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What should you do if your father has a cut?
What should you do if your father has a cut?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Do you have to obey your parents if they ask you to break a Torah law?
Do you have to obey your parents if they ask you to break a Torah law?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What if a parent asks you to do something harmful to yourself?
What if a parent asks you to do something harmful to yourself?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Is honoring parents a mitzvah between a person and God or a person and another person?
Is honoring parents a mitzvah between a person and God or a person and another person?
Signup and view all the flashcards
According to Chayei Adam, is honoring parents a mitzvah between a person and God or a person and another person?
According to Chayei Adam, is honoring parents a mitzvah between a person and God or a person and another person?
Signup and view all the flashcards
How does Ramban explain the parent's right to receive respect?
How does Ramban explain the parent's right to receive respect?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Does a parent's forgiveness erase the mitzvah of honoring them?
Does a parent's forgiveness erase the mitzvah of honoring them?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Honoring Parents: Being a תלמיד חכם
Honoring Parents: Being a תלמיד חכם
Signup and view all the flashcards
Respecting Deceased Parents
Respecting Deceased Parents
Signup and view all the flashcards
Kaddish for Deceased Parents
Kaddish for Deceased Parents
Signup and view all the flashcards
Standing for Parents
Standing for Parents
Signup and view all the flashcards
Sitting in the Parents' Place
Sitting in the Parents' Place
Signup and view all the flashcards
Disagreement with Parents
Disagreement with Parents
Signup and view all the flashcards
Disagreement with Parents on Torah Matters
Disagreement with Parents on Torah Matters
Signup and view all the flashcards
Addressing Parents and Parents-in-Law
Addressing Parents and Parents-in-Law
Signup and view all the flashcards
Using Honorific Titles for Parents
Using Honorific Titles for Parents
Signup and view all the flashcards
Caring for Emotionally Ill Parents
Caring for Emotionally Ill Parents
Signup and view all the flashcards
Restraining Parents
Restraining Parents
Signup and view all the flashcards
Financial Obligations to Parents
Financial Obligations to Parents
Signup and view all the flashcards
Lack of Respect in Current Generation
Lack of Respect in Current Generation
Signup and view all the flashcards
Sitting at the Head of the Table
Sitting at the Head of the Table
Signup and view all the flashcards
Sleeping on Parent's Bed
Sleeping on Parent's Bed
Signup and view all the flashcards
Honoring Parents is Like Honoring the Shechinah
Honoring Parents is Like Honoring the Shechinah
Signup and view all the flashcards
Study Notes
כיבוד אב ואם: בין אדם לחבירו or בין אדם למקום?
- Ramban argues כיבוד אב ואם is a מצוה between oneself and God (בין אדם למקום), as the first tablet of the commandments solely relates to this category.
- All מצוות on the first tablet explicitly mention God ('ה').
- Chayei Adam posits that honoring parents is a debt repayment (בין אדם לחבירו) due to their life-sustaining support.
- Asking for forgiveness (מחילה) depends on the relationship; if with God, ask God for forgiveness, and if with parents, ask them.
Key Principles of כיבוד אב ואם
- The magnitude of respecting parents is immense (tremendous proportions).
- Challenges of not contradicting parents.
- Examples demonstrate respect's vital importance.
- Positive reinforcement of parental respect.
- The Zohar emphasizes refraining from causing pain to parents.
- Parents are considered the greatest people on earth, and one must recognize their unique qualities.
- Treat parents with remarkable respect and consideration (as a king).
- Includes fulfilling all their needs, anticipating needs, and doing tasks with a positive attitude (like a slave to their master, or like assisting their teacher).
- The difficulty of balancing learning and parental needs.
- Different opinions regarding prioritizing learning or responding to parental requests.
Honoring Parents: Specific Scenarios
- Respectful communication with parents.
- Honoring parents even after their death; specific prayers and actions.
- Standing for parents twice daily as an expression of respect; a "greater" act of respect (standing for them) than standing for God.
- Proper seating arrangements for parents (not taking the elder's chair or table position); and general seating guidelines.
- Permission to rest or lie on parental beds.
- Respectful disagreements with parents; respectful clarification, or questions (not direct confrontation).
- Disagreement on Torah matters.
- Addressing parents by title when addressing by name.
- Dealing with a parent's emotional well-being.
- Parental guidance that demands a violation of a Halacha.
Practical Applications & Exceptions
- Parental embarrassment/child's loss situations.
- Liability or responsibility for parental actions.
- Situations where parents can be supported financially or in other ways.
- Parental requests that cause harm, inconvenience, or violate Halacha.
- Marital obligations versus honoring parents.
- Handling issues with step-parents (separate obligations, honoring until death of parent, respect according to Halacha).
- Honor for siblings; separate, different obligations.
- Grandparent and great-grandparent recognition.
- Serving parents who are Talmudists.
Prohibited Actions
- Cursing parents (Severe punishment).
- Physically harming parents (severe liability).
- Failure to assist a sick parent (various levels of non-assistance as per the situation).
Additional Considerations
- Seeking guidance from knowledgeable authorities (rabbinic scholars) for complicated issues.
- Parental permissiveness versus child obedience to specific actions.
- Marriage decisions or yeshiva choices.
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.
Description
Explore the nuances of honoring parents according to Jewish teachings. This quiz delves into the arguments from Ramban and Chayei Adam on whether respect for parents is a divine obligation or a societal debt. Test your understanding of the key principles surrounding כיבוד אב ואם and its implications for personal relationships.