22 Questions
What is one reason researchers evaluate published papers on a specific topic?
To make a systematic review
When should researchers evaluate research papers?
Before planning the research, during implementation, and before discussing the results
What is the role of health professionals in research evaluation?
To critically assess the value of new published research
Who needs to evaluate research results and their implications?
Both researchers and policy makers
Why is research evaluation important?
To inform decision-making and practice
What is the purpose of assessing the scientific output of candidates?
To assess their suitability for academic posts
What is one of the purposes of evaluating research?
To evaluate the return on investment by investors
What should a good methods section provide?
Sufficient detail to allow other investigators to replicate the study
What is an important aspect of sample selection?
Ensuring the sample is representative of the population studied
What should be considered when designing a research study?
Both the research question and resources available
What is the minimum power required for a sample size to be considered adequate?
80%
What is the advantage of random assignment over systematic assignment?
It is more advantageous
What should be done when comparing two samples?
Select one sample to be identical to the other in every way, except the one to be studied
What is an important aspect of the title and abstract of a research paper?
They should give an indication of the novelty and relevance of the paper
What is an important factor to consider when evaluating the credibility of a research article?
The author's expertise in the field
What does a high citation count indicate about a research article?
The article is highly influential in the field
What should a bibliography or references section include?
Scholarly sources that are authorized by individuals with authority in the field
What is an important consideration when evaluating the methodology of a research study?
The study's control of confounding variables
What should a discussion and conclusion section of a research article include?
A discussion of the study's limitations and generalizability
What is an important ethical consideration in research?
The protection of human subjects
Why is it important to evaluate the relevance of sources in a bibliography or references section?
To ensure the sources are relevant to the topic
What is an important aspect of evaluating a research article?
The article's relevance to the topic
Study Notes
Importance of Evaluating Research
- Research needs to be evaluated by investors to assess the return on their investment
- Evaluating research is crucial to discard what is not effective and potentially harmful, promote what is effective but underutilized, and postpone decisions when evidence is lacking
Assessing Research Papers
- The title and abstract of a paper should indicate its novelty and relevance
- The research question should be clear, with terms clearly defined
- Attention should be given to errors in logic regarding causation, relationship, or association
- The methods section should be the first part of the paper to assess, as it determines whether the science is good or bad
- A good methods section should provide sufficient detail to allow other investigators to replicate the study and confirm the results
Sample Selection and Measurements
- The sample should be representative of the population studied and have an adequate sample size with sufficient power (at least 80%)
- Representativeness depends on selection and assignment, with random assignment being more advantageous than systematic assignment
- If two samples are compared, they must be selected to be identical for every relevant variable, except the one being studied
Research Design and Evaluation
- Research design should be appropriate to the research question, considering resources of time, money, and number of researchers
- Evaluation of research should be done before planning, during implementation, and before discussing results and communicating them
Critical Evaluation of Research
- Researchers, policymakers, and health professionals need to critically evaluate research to assess its value and practical application
- Authors' credentials, including their expertise and citations, are important indicators of the article's credibility
- The bibliography should list scholarly sources that are relevant, up-to-date, and authorized by experts in the field
Additional Items for Critical Evaluation
- Control of confounding variables
- Discussion and conclusion, including limitations of the study and generalizability
- Ethics, including adherence to ethical standards
- References, including their relevance and credibility
Learn how to evaluate research and assess research papers by understanding the importance of evaluation, how to identify novelty and relevance in a paper, and how to define research questions clearly.
Make Your Own Quizzes and Flashcards
Convert your notes into interactive study material.
Get started for free
