Podcast
Questions and Answers
Which of the following best describes ethical objectivism?
Which of the following best describes ethical objectivism?
- Moral principles are derived from personal experiences and upbringing.
- Moral truths are relative to cultural norms and vary between societies.
- Moral beliefs are solely based on individual feelings and emotions.
- There are objective facts in ethics that determine what is right or wrong. (correct)
What is the primary goal of a moral theory?
What is the primary goal of a moral theory?
To explain what makes actions right or wrong.
Which of the following is NOT a typical reason for wanting a moral theory?
Which of the following is NOT a typical reason for wanting a moral theory?
- To determine the applicability of moral principles.
- To resolve controversial ethical dilemmas.
- To understand exceptions to moral rules.
- To justify personal biases and prejudices. (correct)
The statement 'Whatever God commands us to do is right' is unambiguous and has only one possible interpretation.
The statement 'Whatever God commands us to do is right' is unambiguous and has only one possible interpretation.
Which theory suggests that certain actions are right because God commands them?
Which theory suggests that certain actions are right because God commands them?
Which theory suggests that religion is necessary to help us determine what is right and what is wrong?
Which theory suggests that religion is necessary to help us determine what is right and what is wrong?
State one major objection philosophers raise against Divine Command Theory.
State one major objection philosophers raise against Divine Command Theory.
The three reasons why religion is necessary for morality are: religion is necessary to motivate people to do what is ______, religion is necessary to help us determine what is right and what is wrong and without religion people wouldn’t know how to handle situations in the right or wrong way.
The three reasons why religion is necessary for morality are: religion is necessary to motivate people to do what is ______, religion is necessary to help us determine what is right and what is wrong and without religion people wouldn’t know how to handle situations in the right or wrong way.
A group of people are stranded on a lifeboat that is overcrowded and will sink unless someone is thrown off. According to the 'Respect for Persons' principle, why would throwing someone off the boat be criticized?
A group of people are stranded on a lifeboat that is overcrowded and will sink unless someone is thrown off. According to the 'Respect for Persons' principle, why would throwing someone off the boat be criticized?
According to Aristotle, cultivating virtues is unimportant because it primarily benefits the individual and does not significantly impact the well-being of others.
According to Aristotle, cultivating virtues is unimportant because it primarily benefits the individual and does not significantly impact the well-being of others.
According to Rachels' interpretation of Radical Virtue Ethics, what determines if an action is right?
According to Rachels' interpretation of Radical Virtue Ethics, what determines if an action is right?
According to Brian Tracy, the most important virtue is ______, and it can be learned through study, practice, and instruction.
According to Brian Tracy, the most important virtue is ______, and it can be learned through study, practice, and instruction.
Match the concept with its description, according to Kantian ethics:
Match the concept with its description, according to Kantian ethics:
According to hedonistic utilitarianism, what is the fundamental criterion for determining the rightness of an action?
According to hedonistic utilitarianism, what is the fundamental criterion for determining the rightness of an action?
Hedonistic utilitarianism considers both pleasure and happiness as intrinsically good.
Hedonistic utilitarianism considers both pleasure and happiness as intrinsically good.
Besides pleasure and pain, name one other central feature of hedonistic utilitarianism.
Besides pleasure and pain, name one other central feature of hedonistic utilitarianism.
According to hedonistic utilitarianism, the morality of an action is determined by assessing its overall ________.
According to hedonistic utilitarianism, the morality of an action is determined by assessing its overall ________.
Match the moral senses with their descriptions:
Match the moral senses with their descriptions:
How does one decide whether an action is morally right according to hedonistic utilitarianism?
How does one decide whether an action is morally right according to hedonistic utilitarianism?
Utilitarians believe that the actual consequences of an action are more important than the probable consequences when determining the action's morality.
Utilitarians believe that the actual consequences of an action are more important than the probable consequences when determining the action's morality.
Why do utilitarians focus on the ‘probable’ consequences rather than the 'actual' consequences of actions?
Why do utilitarians focus on the ‘probable’ consequences rather than the 'actual' consequences of actions?
Utilitarians assess commonly accepted moral rules based on their ability to ________ utility.
Utilitarians assess commonly accepted moral rules based on their ability to ________ utility.
According to hedonistic utilitarianism, why might an action with bad consequences be considered 'right'?
According to hedonistic utilitarianism, why might an action with bad consequences be considered 'right'?
Hedonistic utilitarianism advocates for treating non-human animals with less consideration than humans.
Hedonistic utilitarianism advocates for treating non-human animals with less consideration than humans.
According to Mill, is religion a necessary component for developing morals?
According to Mill, is religion a necessary component for developing morals?
One virtue of hedonistic utilitarianism is that it provides a ________ to determine the rightness and wrongness of actions.
One virtue of hedonistic utilitarianism is that it provides a ________ to determine the rightness and wrongness of actions.
Which of the scenarios would a hedonistic utilitarian consider an unacceptable consequence?
Which of the scenarios would a hedonistic utilitarian consider an unacceptable consequence?
Hedonistic utilitarianism easily accommodates back-looking reactions to actions.
Hedonistic utilitarianism easily accommodates back-looking reactions to actions.
Individual relativism posits that an action is right for a person if they believe it is right, regardless of whether others agree.
Individual relativism posits that an action is right for a person if they believe it is right, regardless of whether others agree.
Which of the following is a central tenet of individual relativism?
Which of the following is a central tenet of individual relativism?
According to Kant, under what condition is happiness not considered a good thing?
According to Kant, under what condition is happiness not considered a good thing?
Give an example that illustrates an objection to individual relativism due to its counterintuitive results.
Give an example that illustrates an objection to individual relativism due to its counterintuitive results.
According to Kant, an action that conforms to duty is always morally good.
According to Kant, an action that conforms to duty is always morally good.
Explain in your own words, what Kant means by 'good will'.
Explain in your own words, what Kant means by 'good will'.
According to individual relativism, one could never be mistaken in one's moral ______.
According to individual relativism, one could never be mistaken in one's moral ______.
A __________ imperative commands you to do something to get something else, while a __________ imperative is a universal, exceptionless command that applies to all rational agents.
A __________ imperative commands you to do something to get something else, while a __________ imperative is a universal, exceptionless command that applies to all rational agents.
Match each ethical theory with its description:
Match each ethical theory with its description:
What fundamentally distinguishes descriptive relativism from ethical relativism?
What fundamentally distinguishes descriptive relativism from ethical relativism?
Which of the following best describes Kant's 'Universal Law' formulation of the categorical imperative?
Which of the following best describes Kant's 'Universal Law' formulation of the categorical imperative?
Kant believed that making promises you don't intend to keep is morally acceptable if it benefits the majority.
Kant believed that making promises you don't intend to keep is morally acceptable if it benefits the majority.
Ethical relativism implies that if a society believes cannibalism is morally acceptable, then it is morally acceptable for that society.
Ethical relativism implies that if a society believes cannibalism is morally acceptable, then it is morally acceptable for that society.
Explain why the 'Universal Law' formulation of the categorical imperative is considered subjective.
Explain why the 'Universal Law' formulation of the categorical imperative is considered subjective.
According to ethical relativism, which of the following actions could be considered 'right'?
According to ethical relativism, which of the following actions could be considered 'right'?
Which scenario best illustrates the criticism that Kant's categorical imperative cannot adequately handle conflicting maxims?
Which scenario best illustrates the criticism that Kant's categorical imperative cannot adequately handle conflicting maxims?
Provide one major objection to ethical relativism concerning obviously wrong actions.
Provide one major objection to ethical relativism concerning obviously wrong actions.
The "Respect for Persons" formulation of Kant's categorical imperative states that we should always treat persons as __________ in themselves and never merely as __________.
The "Respect for Persons" formulation of Kant's categorical imperative states that we should always treat persons as __________ in themselves and never merely as __________.
A significant issue with ethical relativism is the problem of determining the relevant ______ group.
A significant issue with ethical relativism is the problem of determining the relevant ______ group.
According to Kant's 'Respect for Persons' formulation, it is morally permissible to use someone for your own benefit as long as they are aware of it.
According to Kant's 'Respect for Persons' formulation, it is morally permissible to use someone for your own benefit as long as they are aware of it.
Why is ethical relativism still widely accepted despite its problems?
Why is ethical relativism still widely accepted despite its problems?
Briefly differentiate between perfect duties and imperfect duties, according to Kant.
Briefly differentiate between perfect duties and imperfect duties, according to Kant.
Ethical relativism is popular because it's free from confusion and provides definitive moral answers.
Ethical relativism is popular because it's free from confusion and provides definitive moral answers.
Which of the following situations poses a criticism of the 'Respect for Persons' formulation, suggesting it can require behavior at odds with treating persons with respect?
Which of the following situations poses a criticism of the 'Respect for Persons' formulation, suggesting it can require behavior at odds with treating persons with respect?
Give an example where moral principles are universally accepted but differ in action due to different non-moral beliefs.
Give an example where moral principles are universally accepted but differ in action due to different non-moral beliefs.
The ethical approach which states the right action has the vest consequences is called ______.
The ethical approach which states the right action has the vest consequences is called ______.
Actions that bring about the best consequences are considered __________
Actions that bring about the best consequences are considered __________
Which describes utilitarianism?
Which describes utilitarianism?
Explain what it means for an action to be subjectively right.
Explain what it means for an action to be subjectively right.
According to the content, objectively right actions are determined by the information given to you internally.
According to the content, objectively right actions are determined by the information given to you internally.
According to Radical Virtue Ethics, what determines if an action is right?
According to Radical Virtue Ethics, what determines if an action is right?
According to Brian Tracy, integrity is the least important virtue.
According to Brian Tracy, integrity is the least important virtue.
According to Brian Tracy, what question should one ask for the development of character?
According to Brian Tracy, what question should one ask for the development of character?
According to Kant, only a person with a good _____ is good without qualification.
According to Kant, only a person with a good _____ is good without qualification.
Match the following Kantian concepts with their descriptions:
Match the following Kantian concepts with their descriptions:
According to Kant, why is happiness not good without qualification?
According to Kant, why is happiness not good without qualification?
For Kant, an action done in accordance with duty is always morally good.
For Kant, an action done in accordance with duty is always morally good.
What is the key difference between acting in accordance with duty and acting from duty, according to Kant?
What is the key difference between acting in accordance with duty and acting from duty, according to Kant?
Kant's Universal Law formulation states: Act only according to that maxim whereby you can at the same time will that it should become a _____ _____.
Kant's Universal Law formulation states: Act only according to that maxim whereby you can at the same time will that it should become a _____ _____.
Which of the followiong is an example of a pleasure that Immanuel Kant would say is not good?
Which of the followiong is an example of a pleasure that Immanuel Kant would say is not good?
A perfect duty can be fulfilled in multiple ways.
A perfect duty can be fulfilled in multiple ways.
What kind of actions does the 'Respect for Persons' formulation prohibit us from doing?
What kind of actions does the 'Respect for Persons' formulation prohibit us from doing?
A hypothetical imperative commands you to do something to achieve a specific _____.
A hypothetical imperative commands you to do something to achieve a specific _____.
Which criticism of Kant's Universal Law formulation suggests that it can lead to unacceptable consequences due to its subjective nature?
Which criticism of Kant's Universal Law formulation suggests that it can lead to unacceptable consequences due to its subjective nature?
According to Kant, it is always morally permissible to make a promise you don't intend to keep if it benefits you.
According to Kant, it is always morally permissible to make a promise you don't intend to keep if it benefits you.
List 3 features of hedonistic utilitarianism
List 3 features of hedonistic utilitarianism
How, according to hedonistic utilitarianism, does one decide whether it is right?
How, according to hedonistic utilitarianism, does one decide whether it is right?
Explaining in detail why utilitarians think we should appeal to the problem consequence rather than actual consequence of actions when determining what we should do
Explaining in detail why utilitarians think we should appeal to the problem consequence rather than actual consequence of actions when determining what we should do
Explain the hedonistic utilitarian attitude toward the commonly accepted moral rules, such as those prohibiting killing, injuring, and lying to others. To what extent would a utilitarian accept such rules?
Explain the hedonistic utilitarian attitude toward the commonly accepted moral rules, such as those prohibiting killing, injuring, and lying to others. To what extent would a utilitarian accept such rules?
Does Mill think that religious beliefs are necessary to ensure moral behavior? How does Mill see the relationship between religion and utilitarianism?
Does Mill think that religious beliefs are necessary to ensure moral behavior? How does Mill see the relationship between religion and utilitarianism?
What are some of the main virtues of hedonistic utilitarianism? Explain each virtue
What are some of the main virtues of hedonistic utilitarianism? Explain each virtue
Flashcards
Ethical Objectivism
Ethical Objectivism
The belief that there are objective facts about right and wrong in ethics.
Moral Theory
Moral Theory
A framework that explains what actions are right or wrong based on moral data.
Four Reasons for Moral Theory
Four Reasons for Moral Theory
- Resolves controversies 2. Addresses applicability 3. Handles exceptions 4. Clarifies conflicts.
Divine Command Theory
Divine Command Theory
Signup and view all the flashcards
Infallible Guide Theory
Infallible Guide Theory
Signup and view all the flashcards
Ontically Necessary
Ontically Necessary
Signup and view all the flashcards
Epistemically Necessary
Epistemically Necessary
Signup and view all the flashcards
Objections to Divine Command Theory
Objections to Divine Command Theory
Signup and view all the flashcards
Hedonistic Utilitarianism
Hedonistic Utilitarianism
Signup and view all the flashcards
Intrinsic Good
Intrinsic Good
Signup and view all the flashcards
Intrinsic Bad
Intrinsic Bad
Signup and view all the flashcards
Moral Rightness
Moral Rightness
Signup and view all the flashcards
Decision Criteria
Decision Criteria
Signup and view all the flashcards
Probable Consequence
Probable Consequence
Signup and view all the flashcards
Moral Rules Acceptance
Moral Rules Acceptance
Signup and view all the flashcards
Treatment of Animals
Treatment of Animals
Signup and view all the flashcards
Moral Standards Variability
Moral Standards Variability
Signup and view all the flashcards
Unacceptable Consequences
Unacceptable Consequences
Signup and view all the flashcards
Objections to Hedonistic Utilitarianism
Objections to Hedonistic Utilitarianism
Signup and view all the flashcards
Moral Behavior and Religion
Moral Behavior and Religion
Signup and view all the flashcards
Social Reform Potential
Social Reform Potential
Signup and view all the flashcards
Expectation of Moral Rules
Expectation of Moral Rules
Signup and view all the flashcards
Net Utility Concept
Net Utility Concept
Signup and view all the flashcards
Individual Relativism
Individual Relativism
Signup and view all the flashcards
Objection to Individual Relativism
Objection to Individual Relativism
Signup and view all the flashcards
Descriptive Relativism
Descriptive Relativism
Signup and view all the flashcards
Ethical Relativism
Ethical Relativism
Signup and view all the flashcards
Difference between Descriptive and Ethical Relativism
Difference between Descriptive and Ethical Relativism
Signup and view all the flashcards
Objection to Ethical Relativism
Objection to Ethical Relativism
Signup and view all the flashcards
Ethical Absolutism
Ethical Absolutism
Signup and view all the flashcards
Ethnocentrism
Ethnocentrism
Signup and view all the flashcards
Cultural Relativism
Cultural Relativism
Signup and view all the flashcards
Consequentialist Ethics
Consequentialist Ethics
Signup and view all the flashcards
Utilitarianism
Utilitarianism
Signup and view all the flashcards
Criticism of Ethical Relativism
Criticism of Ethical Relativism
Signup and view all the flashcards
Confusion around Ethical Relativism
Confusion around Ethical Relativism
Signup and view all the flashcards
Universal Moral Principles
Universal Moral Principles
Signup and view all the flashcards
Virtue
Virtue
Signup and view all the flashcards
Vice
Vice
Signup and view all the flashcards
Radical Virtue Ethics
Radical Virtue Ethics
Signup and view all the flashcards
Most Important Virtue
Most Important Virtue
Signup and view all the flashcards
Learning Values and Virtues
Learning Values and Virtues
Signup and view all the flashcards
Consequentialism
Consequentialism
Signup and view all the flashcards
Subjectively Right
Subjectively Right
Signup and view all the flashcards
Objectively Right
Objectively Right
Signup and view all the flashcards
Kant's Good Will
Kant's Good Will
Signup and view all the flashcards
Morally Good Actions
Morally Good Actions
Signup and view all the flashcards
Hypothetical Imperative
Hypothetical Imperative
Signup and view all the flashcards
Categorical Imperative
Categorical Imperative
Signup and view all the flashcards
Universal Law Formula
Universal Law Formula
Signup and view all the flashcards
Respect for Persons
Respect for Persons
Signup and view all the flashcards
Perfect Duties
Perfect Duties
Signup and view all the flashcards
Imperfect Duties
Imperfect Duties
Signup and view all the flashcards
Conflicting Maxims
Conflicting Maxims
Signup and view all the flashcards
Kant's Criticism of Categorical Imperative
Kant's Criticism of Categorical Imperative
Signup and view all the flashcards
Virtue Ethics
Virtue Ethics
Signup and view all the flashcards
Integrity
Integrity
Signup and view all the flashcards
Good Will
Good Will
Signup and view all the flashcards
Merely Right Actions
Merely Right Actions
Signup and view all the flashcards
Kantian Ethics
Kantian Ethics
Signup and view all the flashcards
Conflict of Duties
Conflict of Duties
Signup and view all the flashcards
Study Notes
Review Questions for PHIL 103
-
Moral Theories:
- Moral theories explain moral data, detailing right/wrong actions.
- Four reasons for wanting a moral theory: resolving controversial cases, applying principles, explaining exceptions, and resolving conflicts.
- Ethical objectivism posits objective moral facts.
-
Divine Command Theory (DCT) and Infallible Guide Theory:
- DCT: An action is right if God commands it; actions are right because God commands them. (Ontically necessary)
- Infallible Guide Theory: God commands actions because they are right; actions are right independently of God's command. (Epistemically necessary)
- Objections to DCT: Actions commanded by God could be wrong.
- Infallible Guide Theory isn't an ethical theory because it doesn't explain why actions are right/wrong independently.
-
Religion and Morality:
- Three reasons religion is claimed necessary for morality: Motivation, guidance on right/wrong, establishing right/wrong.
-
Individual Relativism:
- Individual relativism: Moral standards vary person-to-person, justifying all belief systems.
- Objection: Inability to be mistaken.
- Objection(2): Never having reason for revision.
- Example: Person A believes lying is acceptable, Person B believes it is not. Both are morally correct according to Individual Relativism.
-
Descriptive vs. Ethical Relativism:
- Descriptive relativism: Different moral standards exist across social groups--It's a factual description of cultural variations in morality.
- Ethical relativism: Correct moral standards vary by society; an action is right if society accepts it.
- Difference: Descriptive relativism doesn't imply right/wrong; ethical relativism does.
-
Objections to Ethical Relativism:
- Obvious wrong acts can be right in certain groups.
- Identifying the relevant society.
- Dismissing minority opinions.
- Inability to criticize other cultures
-
Acceptance of Ethical Relativism:
- Confusion between ethical relativism and descriptive relativism.
- Confusion with ethical nihilism.
- Confusion with ethnocentrism
-
Universal Moral Principles:
- Moral principles often underlie varying actions.
- Example: Different societies have similar moral principles about caring for parents—though specific actions differ based on cultural norms.
Consequentialism and Utilitarianism
-
Consequentialism: Right action is the one with the best consequences.
-
Utilitarianism: Right action maximizes utility (pleasure/happiness) for all affected.
-
Hedonistic Utilitarianism:
- Formal criterion: Act X is right for Person S if, from all relevant actions available to S, act X maximizes pleasure and minimizes pain for all affected.
- Intrinsic good: Pleasure. Intrinsic bad: Pain.
- Monistic, secular, can drive social change, explains moral rules.
-
Moral Rules (Utilitarian View):
- Utilitarians accept rules if they maximize utility. Murder or lying may be acceptable if circumstances justify maximizing overall pleasure.
-
Utilitarian Approach to Problematic Consequences:
- Utilitarians consider likely consequences, not just actual to measure expected net utility.
-
Animal Treatment (Utilitarianism):
- Utilitarians believe non-human animals should be treated equally, minimizing pain for all sentient beings.
-
Religion & Mill:
- Mill doesn't see religion as essential for morality – Moral actions derive from Utility consideration alone.
-
Hedonistic Utilitarianism Virtues:
- Provides criterion for action rightness/wrongness.
- Explains/provides exceptions to moral rules when needed.
-
Hedonistic Utilitarianism Objections/Responses:
- Measuring pain/pleasure.
- Accepting obviously wrong acts.
- Conflicts with justice, inability to accommodate past acts.
- Utilitarian response: Exact measurements are not essential.
- Sometimes, sacrificing justice may maximize overall utility.
Deontology (Kantian Ethics)
-
Kantian Disagreement with Hedonistic Utilitarianism:
- Not all pleasures are good (i.e. torturing a child).
-
Kant on Happiness: Happiness isn't inherently good, but is good when deserved.
-
Good Will: Doing the right thing simply because it is right, motivated by duty.
-
Merely Right vs. Morally Good Actions:
- Merely right action: Action complies with duty, but not from duty itself.
- Morally good action: Action from duty, intention matters.
-
Acting from Duty:
- Intentional action based solely on duty.
-
Hypothetical vs. Categorical Imperatives:
- Hypothetical: "If you want X, do Y."
- Categorical: Universal, applies across the board.
-
Universal Law Formulation:
- Act only on principles you want universalized.
-
Criticism of Universal Law Formulation:
- Subjectivity. (Not generalizable across all)
- Conflicts (Two duties conflicting)
-
Respect for Persons Formulation:
- Treat humans as ends, not merely means.
-
Perfect vs. Imperfect Duties:
- Perfect: Specific, fully fulfilling (e.g., keeping promises)
- Imperfect: General, multiple ways of fulfilling (e.g., helping others)
-
Criticisms of Respect for Persons Formulation:
- Potential conflicts with treating individuals with respect. (Example boat scenario)
-
Virtue Ethics: Virtue is a stable trait and crucial for moral flourishing (Aristotle)
- Formal criterion: Actions of a perfectly virtuous person in a given circumstance.
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.