Podcast
Questions and Answers
Human classification into racial groups has never been based on visual differences.
Human classification into racial groups has never been based on visual differences.
False (B)
The concept of race often assumes that differences are superficial, non-essential, and easily altered.
The concept of race often assumes that differences are superficial, non-essential, and easily altered.
False (B)
The race business relies on identifying people through observable traits.
The race business relies on identifying people through observable traits.
True (A)
The idea of race does not assume a link between external differences and complex internal differences.
The idea of race does not assume a link between external differences and complex internal differences.
The assumption that race is a biological construct suggests it has a basis in reality.
The assumption that race is a biological construct suggests it has a basis in reality.
Genetics research confirms the existence of genetic markers unique to each race.
Genetics research confirms the existence of genetic markers unique to each race.
There exist genetic markers that can definitively define 'Race'.
There exist genetic markers that can definitively define 'Race'.
In a DNA workshop, students compared races and blood types.
In a DNA workshop, students compared races and blood types.
The DNA workshop involved extracting DNA from cells to compare genetic similarities and differences.
The DNA workshop involved extracting DNA from cells to compare genetic similarities and differences.
At the start of the workshop, students' thoughts on genetic similarity were unbiased.
At the start of the workshop, students' thoughts on genetic similarity were unbiased.
Realizing that race is a biological myth requires a major shift in perspective.
Realizing that race is a biological myth requires a major shift in perspective.
Race, from a biological perspective, is based on tangible, measurable traits.
Race, from a biological perspective, is based on tangible, measurable traits.
Visual differences are typically not used to classify people into racial groups.
Visual differences are typically not used to classify people into racial groups.
The 'race business' focuses on internal, non-observable traits.
The 'race business' focuses on internal, non-observable traits.
Genetics research supports the idea that unique genetic markers define 'Race'.
Genetics research supports the idea that unique genetic markers define 'Race'.
The students started the DNA workshop with no initial assumptions about genetic similarities.
The students started the DNA workshop with no initial assumptions about genetic similarities.
The shift in perspective involves understanding that race is fundamentally a biological concept.
The shift in perspective involves understanding that race is fundamentally a biological concept.
The DNA workshop primarily ignored skin color when comparing genetic differences.
The DNA workshop primarily ignored skin color when comparing genetic differences.
The classification of humans into racial groups never predates the rise of modern genetics.
The classification of humans into racial groups never predates the rise of modern genetics.
The concept of race denies any association between observable external characteristics and more complex internal traits.
The concept of race denies any association between observable external characteristics and more complex internal traits.
Richard Lewontin's research in the 1960s aimed to understand the distribution of genetic variation across groups identified as races.
Richard Lewontin's research in the 1960s aimed to understand the distribution of genetic variation across groups identified as races.
Lewontin utilized technology known as spectral analysis to examine genetic variations in different organisms.
Lewontin utilized technology known as spectral analysis to examine genetic variations in different organisms.
Lewontin's studies found that approximately 45% of all genetic variation exists between any two individuals within a local population.
Lewontin's studies found that approximately 45% of all genetic variation exists between any two individuals within a local population.
There is significantly less genetic diversity within a single racial group compared to the genetic diversity found between different racial groups.
There is significantly less genetic diversity within a single racial group compared to the genetic diversity found between different racial groups.
Accumulations of certain genes in specific geographic locations are better explained by racial differences than by geographic factors.
Accumulations of certain genes in specific geographic locations are better explained by racial differences than by geographic factors.
Patterns of human genetic variation are primarily due to the species' ancient origins and static patterns of mating.
Patterns of human genetic variation are primarily due to the species' ancient origins and static patterns of mating.
According to the 'Out of Asia' theory, the human lineage originated in Asia before migrating to other continents.
According to the 'Out of Asia' theory, the human lineage originated in Asia before migrating to other continents.
Initial human migrations from Africa, including Homo sapiens, occurred approximately two million years ago.
Initial human migrations from Africa, including Homo sapiens, occurred approximately two million years ago.
The first migrations out of Africa by early hominids led directly to the current global distribution of modern humans.
The first migrations out of Africa by early hominids led directly to the current global distribution of modern humans.
All modern humans are descendants of a second major migration of Homo erectus out of Africa less than 100,000 years ago.
All modern humans are descendants of a second major migration of Homo erectus out of Africa less than 100,000 years ago.
Extensive genetic mixing through migration has allowed genes to move and re-assort over thousands of years.
Extensive genetic mixing through migration has allowed genes to move and re-assort over thousands of years.
Only large-scale migrations contribute to genetic diversity; the movement of smaller groups has minimal impact.
Only large-scale migrations contribute to genetic diversity; the movement of smaller groups has minimal impact.
Human populations have been isolated for a sufficient period to allow for the evolution into distinct subspecies.
Human populations have been isolated for a sufficient period to allow for the evolution into distinct subspecies.
Limited genetic variation between human populations primarily affects essential physiological functions.
Limited genetic variation between human populations primarily affects essential physiological functions.
Despite visible differences, humans share substantial genetic similarities, indicating a common recent ancestry.
Despite visible differences, humans share substantial genetic similarities, indicating a common recent ancestry.
The ethical implications of gathering blood samples for Lewontin's study were never questioned since the study was so important for science.
The ethical implications of gathering blood samples for Lewontin's study were never questioned since the study was so important for science.
Lewontin's findings have neither been validated nor refuted by subsequent genetic studies.
Lewontin's findings have neither been validated nor refuted by subsequent genetic studies.
Human populations have been geographically isolated on different continents for millions of years.
Human populations have been geographically isolated on different continents for millions of years.
Geography does not accurately explain observed accumulations of specific genes.
Geography does not accurately explain observed accumulations of specific genes.
Lewontin's methodology involved a novel technology applicable to any organism, revolutionizing the study of genetic variance.
Lewontin's methodology involved a novel technology applicable to any organism, revolutionizing the study of genetic variance.
The existence of slavery and dispossession alongside the ideal of equality in America was a harmonious circumstance.
The existence of slavery and dispossession alongside the ideal of equality in America was a harmonious circumstance.
The 'story of race' was created to challenge unequal treatment based on skin color and origin.
The 'story of race' was created to challenge unequal treatment based on skin color and origin.
Race is solely about physical appearance and has no deeper meaning.
Race is solely about physical appearance and has no deeper meaning.
The concept of race remains static and unchanging over time.
The concept of race remains static and unchanging over time.
The concept of race narrative has held little influence within America.
The concept of race narrative has held little influence within America.
Thomas Jefferson, a slaveholder, played no role in drafting the Declaration of Independence.
Thomas Jefferson, a slaveholder, played no role in drafting the Declaration of Independence.
Jefferson's 'Notes on the State of Virginia' expresses similar views on all inhabitants of America, Europe, and Africa.
Jefferson's 'Notes on the State of Virginia' expresses similar views on all inhabitants of America, Europe, and Africa.
Jefferson speculated on differences between racial groups.
Jefferson speculated on differences between racial groups.
Jefferson is considered a person who rejected racial theories in the United States.
Jefferson is considered a person who rejected racial theories in the United States.
Jefferson's theories served to critique the institution of slavery.
Jefferson's theories served to critique the institution of slavery.
'Notes' challenged slavery as the Founding Fathers faced scrutiny.
'Notes' challenged slavery as the Founding Fathers faced scrutiny.
The Founding Fathers found it very easy to promote liberty, freedom, and democracy while maintaining a system of slavery.
The Founding Fathers found it very easy to promote liberty, freedom, and democracy while maintaining a system of slavery.
The idea developed that inalienable rights universally applied to every person.
The idea developed that inalienable rights universally applied to every person.
America's inception is important for understanding nationality and immigration.
America's inception is important for understanding nationality and immigration.
Early Americans fully rejected that all men are created equal.
Early Americans fully rejected that all men are created equal.
To maintain American nationality, nobody was excluded from the idea of the human family.
To maintain American nationality, nobody was excluded from the idea of the human family.
The contradiction between espousing equality while practicing slavery led to no significant impact on American identity.
The contradiction between espousing equality while practicing slavery led to no significant impact on American identity.
The concept of race was constructed as a justification for political and economic objectives.
The concept of race was constructed as a justification for political and economic objectives.
The Declaration of Independence, which proclaims human equality, was penned by a slaveholder.
The Declaration of Independence, which proclaims human equality, was penned by a slaveholder.
The problem was how to limit liberty, freedom, and democracy while ending slavery and exploitation of non-white people.
The problem was how to limit liberty, freedom, and democracy while ending slavery and exploitation of non-white people.
The revolutionary ideal that 'all men are created equal' was conceived in the U.S. despite the simultaneous practices of slavery and land dispossession.
The revolutionary ideal that 'all men are created equal' was conceived in the U.S. despite the simultaneous practices of slavery and land dispossession.
The concept of race is primarily determined by inherent physical attributes, remaining static over time.
The concept of race is primarily determined by inherent physical attributes, remaining static over time.
The narrative of race was developed swiftly, solidifying within a single generation to address immediate economic needs.
The narrative of race was developed swiftly, solidifying within a single generation to address immediate economic needs.
Thomas Jefferson's 'Notes on the State of Virginia' served exclusively as a detailed account of Virginian agriculture, avoiding commentary on its inhabitants.
Thomas Jefferson's 'Notes on the State of Virginia' served exclusively as a detailed account of Virginian agriculture, avoiding commentary on its inhabitants.
Thomas Jefferson hypothesized that individuals of African descent were inferior to those of European descent in both physical and intellectual capabilities.
Thomas Jefferson hypothesized that individuals of African descent were inferior to those of European descent in both physical and intellectual capabilities.
Jefferson's articulation of racial theory was completely detached from his socio-economic status as a slaveholder.
Jefferson's articulation of racial theory was completely detached from his socio-economic status as a slaveholder.
At the zenith of his career, Thomas Jefferson's ownership of enslaved people never exceeded 50 individuals.
At the zenith of his career, Thomas Jefferson's ownership of enslaved people never exceeded 50 individuals.
The Founding Fathers circumvented the conflict between advocating for liberty and upholding slavery by asserting intrinsic differences in non-white populations.
The Founding Fathers circumvented the conflict between advocating for liberty and upholding slavery by asserting intrinsic differences in non-white populations.
The concept of inalienable rights was universally applied to all people living in America at the time of its founding.
The concept of inalienable rights was universally applied to all people living in America at the time of its founding.
American nationality was shaped by including all residents into a universal human family, promoting equality for all.
American nationality was shaped by including all residents into a universal human family, promoting equality for all.
The dispossession of Native American lands was unrelated to the contradiction between American ideals and the practice of inequality.
The dispossession of Native American lands was unrelated to the contradiction between American ideals and the practice of inequality.
The concept of race is universally understood and has consistent implications across different societies and cultures.
The concept of race is universally understood and has consistent implications across different societies and cultures.
Thomas Jefferson's 'Notes on the State of Virginia' primarily aimed to criticize European influence on American culture.
Thomas Jefferson's 'Notes on the State of Virginia' primarily aimed to criticize European influence on American culture.
Jefferson's views positing African inferiority were universally accepted and unchallenged during his time.
Jefferson's views positing African inferiority were universally accepted and unchallenged during his time.
The justification for slavery was solely based on economic factors, completely disregarding any social or cultural arguments.
The justification for slavery was solely based on economic factors, completely disregarding any social or cultural arguments.
The concept of race remains unchanged since its initial construction, maintaining the same meaning and implications.
The concept of race remains unchanged since its initial construction, maintaining the same meaning and implications.
Jefferson's personal ownership of slaves was inconsequential to his public stance on liberty and equality.
Jefferson's personal ownership of slaves was inconsequential to his public stance on liberty and equality.
The exploitation of non-white peoples was a marginal issue, having little prevalence in the founding of America.
The exploitation of non-white peoples was a marginal issue, having little prevalence in the founding of America.
The idea of American nationality has always been inclusive, embracing diverse populations into a unified national identity.
The idea of American nationality has always been inclusive, embracing diverse populations into a unified national identity.
The American contradiction refers to the conflict between espousing equality and practicing discrimination.
The American contradiction refers to the conflict between espousing equality and practicing discrimination.
White privilege, as discussed, primarily refers to financial advantages over other races.
White privilege, as discussed, primarily refers to financial advantages over other races.
In the described exercise, participants move forward or backward based on how questions relate to their experiences.
In the described exercise, participants move forward or backward based on how questions relate to their experiences.
The exercise aims to diminish the perceived differences in privilege among participants.
The exercise aims to diminish the perceived differences in privilege among participants.
Being the only person of your race in a room results in taking a step forward in the exercise.
Being the only person of your race in a room results in taking a step forward in the exercise.
The exercise uses solely questions centered around linguistic background and family history.
The exercise uses solely questions centered around linguistic background and family history.
If your parents warned you about racism then you take a step forward in the exercise.
If your parents warned you about racism then you take a step forward in the exercise.
The exercise concludes with participants maintaining their initial positions to reflect equality.
The exercise concludes with participants maintaining their initial positions to reflect equality.
Russell experienced a sense of isolation and frustration after observing the results of the activity.
Russell experienced a sense of isolation and frustration after observing the results of the activity.
Sarah felt alienated in the group, standing away from the majority.
Sarah felt alienated in the group, standing away from the majority.
Henry believed everyone should begin in different starting positions to account for privilege.
Henry believed everyone should begin in different starting positions to account for privilege.
The exercise is designed to show that society provides equal opportunities to all.
The exercise is designed to show that society provides equal opportunities to all.
If you've never had to worry about your family being searched then you take a step backward.
If you've never had to worry about your family being searched then you take a step backward.
The activity is aimed to foster understanding of different perspectives on privilege.
The activity is aimed to foster understanding of different perspectives on privilege.
The purpose of this activity is purely academic and has no emotional impact on its participants.
The purpose of this activity is purely academic and has no emotional impact on its participants.
The experience led all participants to develop a shared sense of equity.
The experience led all participants to develop a shared sense of equity.
When asked if English is your parent's first language you step backward.
When asked if English is your parent's first language you step backward.
The questions posed during the exercise are intentionally framed to provoke contemplation.
The questions posed during the exercise are intentionally framed to provoke contemplation.
The white privilege activity is designed to attribute fault among particular races or ethnicities.
The white privilege activity is designed to attribute fault among particular races or ethnicities.
The lesson on white privilege resulted in Russel embracing the idea that society treats everyone fairly and equitably.
The lesson on white privilege resulted in Russel embracing the idea that society treats everyone fairly and equitably.
After doing the white privilege exercise, Henry ended up at the back showing that the exercise favored certain people which he thought was equitable.
After doing the white privilege exercise, Henry ended up at the back showing that the exercise favored certain people which he thought was equitable.
The doll test experiment showed that children do not hold prejudicial views towards others who are of a different skin color.
The doll test experiment showed that children do not hold prejudicial views towards others who are of a different skin color.
Flashcards
Race (initial perception)
Race (initial perception)
Classification of people based on perceived physical traits like skin color and body shape.
Race as a biological construct
Race as a biological construct
The false belief that race is a fundamental, biological division among people.
Race business
Race business
Observable traits used to categorize people into races.
Linking external and internal differences
Linking external and internal differences
Signup and view all the flashcards
Genetic markers and race
Genetic markers and race
Signup and view all the flashcards
Race is an ascribed characteristic
Race is an ascribed characteristic
Signup and view all the flashcards
Paradigm Shift
Paradigm Shift
Signup and view all the flashcards
Who was Richard Lewontin?
Who was Richard Lewontin?
Signup and view all the flashcards
What is Gel Electrophoresis?
What is Gel Electrophoresis?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Lewontin's key finding
Lewontin's key finding
Signup and view all the flashcards
Genetic Variation: Geography vs. Race
Genetic Variation: Geography vs. Race
Signup and view all the flashcards
"Out of Africa" theory
"Out of Africa" theory
Signup and view all the flashcards
Impact of genetic mixing?
Impact of genetic mixing?
Signup and view all the flashcards
Time Scale and Subspecies
Time Scale and Subspecies
Signup and view all the flashcards
Skin Color and Genetics
Skin Color and Genetics
Signup and view all the flashcards
Story of Race
Story of Race
Signup and view all the flashcards
Equality Contradiction
Equality Contradiction
Signup and view all the flashcards
Jefferson's Theory of Race
Jefferson's Theory of Race
Signup and view all the flashcards
Writing Out of the Human Family
Writing Out of the Human Family
Signup and view all the flashcards
The Problem of American Liberty
The Problem of American Liberty
Signup and view all the flashcards
"All men are created equal"
"All men are created equal"
Signup and view all the flashcards
Social Construction of Race
Social Construction of Race
Signup and view all the flashcards
Narrative of Race
Narrative of Race
Signup and view all the flashcards
"Notes on the State of Virginia"
"Notes on the State of Virginia"
Signup and view all the flashcards
Restricting Inalienable Rights
Restricting Inalienable Rights
Signup and view all the flashcards
Excluding Non-White People
Excluding Non-White People
Signup and view all the flashcards
Exclusion from the Human Family
Exclusion from the Human Family
Signup and view all the flashcards
White Privilege
White Privilege
Signup and view all the flashcards
Emotional Impact of Inequality
Emotional Impact of Inequality
Signup and view all the flashcards
Awareness of Unearned Advantage
Awareness of Unearned Advantage
Signup and view all the flashcards
Privilege Exercise
Privilege Exercise
Signup and view all the flashcards
Frustration with Inequality
Frustration with Inequality
Signup and view all the flashcards
Racial Othering
Racial Othering
Signup and view all the flashcards
Racial Profiling
Racial Profiling
Signup and view all the flashcards
Racial Awareness
Racial Awareness
Signup and view all the flashcards
Study Notes
- In the 1960s, Richard Lewontin investigated the distribution of genetic variation within and between groups considered races.
- America's core ideal of equality was contradicted by the existence of slavery and the dispossession of land from certain inhabitants.
- This contradiction led to the creation of a "story of race" to justify unequal treatment based on skin color and national origin.
- Race is not just about physical appearance, but about the meaning assigned to it.
- Race is a concept that evolves over time and is constructed by society to further political and economic goals.
- This concept has become a powerful and enduring narrative in America.
The American Contradiction
- The US was founded on the revolutionary ideal that "all men are created equal."
- This ideal was created while some inhabitants were enslaved.
- This ideal was also erected while some inhabitants were being dispossessed of their lands.
- American society had to create justifications for unequal treatment based on skin color and national origin.
- A narrative of race was created to reconcile this contradiction.
Lewontin's Methodology
- Lewontin used gel electrophoresis, a new technology applicable to any organism, to examine genetic variation by grinding samples.
- Data was obtained from blood samples collected worldwide by anthropologists and geneticists studying blood groups, proteins, and other genes, though ethical concerns existed.
Key Findings on Genetic Variation
- Lewontin's research was further confirmed by subsequent studies on proteins, blood groups, and DNA sequences.
- About 85% of all genetic variation among humans occurs between any two individuals within a local population.
- This holds true regardless of their racial or geographic origin.
- There is as much, if not more, genetic diversity within any racial group as there is between different racial groups.
The Role of Geography and Migration
- Geography explains the observed accumulations of certain genes in specific locations better than race does.
- Patterns of genetic variation are due to the species' recent origins and its history of movement and mating.
The "Out of Africa" Theory and Modern Humans
- The human lineage began in Africa; however, initial migrations of early hominids (not modern humans) occurred around two million years ago.
- These migrations led to isolated lineages that current evidence suggests died out
- A second migration involved Homo sapiens who populated the world less than 100,000 years ago.
- All modern humans are products of this second migration.
Genetic Mixing
- Migration has caused genetic mixing, allowing genes to move out, mix, and re-assort in numerous ways over about 100,000 years.
- The slight movement of smaller groups or their genes also adds to genetic diversity.
Evolutionary Time Scale
- Human populations haven't been isolated long enough to evolve into separate subspecies.
- Limited genetic variation exists and mostly impacts superficial features like skin color and hair form due to the short time frame in evolutionary terms.
- Humans are essentially the same genetically beneath these visible differences.
The Construction of Race
- Race is not solely about physical appearance but about the meaning assigned to those appearances.
- The idea of race evolves over time and is constructed by society.
- Race is constructed to further specific political and economic goals.
- The narrative of race was created over four centuries.
- Race has become a powerful and enduring narrative.
- Examining moments in America's past reveals how the idea of race became the lens through which people view the world.
Jefferson's Theory of Race
- Thomas Jefferson, a slaveholder, wrote the Declaration of Independence, proclaiming human equality.
- Jefferson also wrote "Notes on the State of Virginia," which expressed his views on the inhabitants of America, Europe, and Africa.
- Jefferson speculated that blacks were inferior to whites in both body and mind.
- Jefferson is argued to be the first person to articulate a theory of race in the United States.
- This theory served to justify his ownership of slaves despite his belief in equality.
- "Notes" appeared to justify slavery at a time when the Founding Fathers were being criticized for supporting human bondage while espousing freedom.
- The problem was how to promote liberty, freedom, and democracy while maintaining a system of slavery and exploitation of non-white people.
- The solution was to argue that there was something different about these people, and that inalienable rights only applied to certain people.
- The moment America became a nation was critical for understanding American nationality and race.
- "Notes on the State of Virginia" was a sales pitch for America.
- Jefferson's views on race were created to reconcile owning slaves while declaring that all men are created equal.
- Jefferson owned approximately 175-225 slaves at the peak of his slaveholding.
The Contradiction of Equality and Slavery
- Americans accepted the notion that all men are created equal, but some enslaved people were not considered fully human.
- Certain people were effectively written out of the human family to maintain the ideas of American nationality.
- Some argued that enslaved people were not fully men, thus excluding them from the concept of equality.
- Ideas of American nationality were maintained by excluding certain people from the human family.
Exploring Racial Bias
- This activity explores how society favors one race over others.
- White privilege is not about wealth, but about the absence of the consequences of racism.
Questions and Impact
- In the activity, participants step forward if a question applies to them.
- Participants stay where they are if a question does not apply to them.
- "English is your parents' first language": Taking a step forward.
- "If you have ever been the only person in the room of your race": Taking a step back.
- "Never been asked where you come from": Taking a step forward.
- "If you've never had to be worried about your family unsearched": Taking a step forward.
- "If your parents have ever warned you about racism": Taking a step backwards.
- The exercise causes a divide to widen, highlighting the inequality of positions.
Reflections on Position
- Russell feels alone, frustrated, and notes that society isn't fair.
- Sarah feels frustrated standing at the back with few others, while the majority are at the front because society appears to be unfair.
- Henry feels it's weird to be at the very front and thinks everyone should start at the same point, but recognizes that the questions favored some people, which he finds unfair.
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.