Cultural Relativism vs. Universalism
40 Questions
2 Views

Choose a study mode

Play Quiz
Study Flashcards
Spaced Repetition
Chat to lesson

Podcast

Play an AI-generated podcast conversation about this lesson

Questions and Answers

According to Aristotle's conception of happiness, what is the definition of Εὐδαιμονία?

  • A state of character concerned with choice, lying in an extreme
  • Doing well and living well according to virtues with and for others (correct)
  • Acting unfairly towards oneself
  • Complete virtue used only for oneself

    • What is the main idea behind the doctrine of the 'golden mean' in Aristotle's virtue theory?

  • Virtue is a state of character, concerned with choice, lying in a mean (correct)
  • Virtue is a fixed state of character, never changing
  • Virtue is an extreme state of character
  • Virtue is only concerned with oneself

    • What is a disadvantage of the Virtue Theory of Global Ethics?

  • It is difficult to apply globally (correct)
  • It only considers individual virtues
  • It permits inappropriate partiality
  • It is too context-insensitive

    • According to the Virtue Theory, why should women have the capability to have sexual pleasure in their lives?

    <p>Because it is essential for their Eudaimonia</p> Signup and view all the answers

    What is the main argument against FGM based on the virtue of care?

    <p>FGM is embedded in systems that denigrate women, and needs to be challenged</p> Signup and view all the answers

    What is the main idea behind Aristotle's concept of justice as a virtue?

    <p>Justice is a complete virtue that can be used also towards another</p> Signup and view all the answers

    According to the Virtue Theory, what is the importance of finding the mean in virtue?

    <p>It is crucial for virtuous actions at the right times, with reference to the right objects, towards the right people, with the right motive, and in the right way</p> Signup and view all the answers

    What is an advantage of the Virtue Theory of Global Ethics?

    <p>It permits appropriate partiality</p> Signup and view all the answers

    What is the main conclusion of the cultural relativist argument against universalism?

    <p>There is no objective ground for judgments concerning X</p> Signup and view all the answers

    What is the dependency thesis in the context of cultural relativism?

    <p>There are no moral truths that hold for all peoples at all times</p> Signup and view all the answers

    What is the primary flaw in the cultural relativist argument, according to the 'Greeks and Callatians' example?

    <p>It derives a substantive conclusion from the mere fact that people disagree</p> Signup and view all the answers

    What is a consequence of accepting cultural relativism, according to the argument?

    <p>Morality reduces to aesthetic tastes</p> Signup and view all the answers

    What is the fourth claim of cultural relativism?

    <p>It is mere arrogance for us to try to judge the conduct of other people</p> Signup and view all the answers

    What is the fundamental mistake in the cultural relativist argument, according to the critique?

    <p>It derives a substantive conclusion from the mere fact that people disagree</p> Signup and view all the answers

    What is an implication of cultural relativism, according to the argument?

    <p>Racism and genocide are morally equivalent to their opposites</p> Signup and view all the answers

    What is the role of premise A in the cultural relativist argument against universalism?

    <p>It states that if there is an objective ground for judgments concerning X, then different cultures will not make different judgments concerning X</p> Signup and view all the answers

    What is the primary concern in cosmopolitanism?

    <p>The individual's moral worth</p> Signup and view all the answers

    What is the claim of autochthony related to?

    <p>Athenian purity and superiority</p> Signup and view all the answers

    What is the main feature of cosmopolitanism that matches with Kantianism?

    <p>Universality</p> Signup and view all the answers

    What is the focus of institutional cosmopolitanism?

    <p>Global institutions, structures, and associations</p> Signup and view all the answers

    What is the primary action of moral cosmopolitanism?

    <p>Commitment to helping human beings as such</p> Signup and view all the answers

    What is the main feature of cosmopolitanism that matches with utilitarianism?

    <p>Impartiality</p> Signup and view all the answers

    What is the core idea shared by all cosmopolitan views?

    <p>All human beings are citizens in a single community</p> Signup and view all the answers

    What is the purpose of international law, according to the content?

    <p>To ensure state sovereignty and autonomy</p> Signup and view all the answers

    What is the primary claim of institutional cosmopolitanism?

    <p>Global distributive justice is the primary goal</p> Signup and view all the answers

    Who is credited with the phrase 'I am a citizen of the world (kosmopolités)'?

    <p>Diogenes</p> Signup and view all the answers

    What is the primary distinction between negative and positive rights?

    <p>Negative rights involve the duty of others not to interfere, while positive rights involve the duty of the government to facilitate.</p> Signup and view all the answers

    According to Hohfeld's table of jural correlatives/opposites, if A has a claim, then what does B have?

    <p>A duty</p> Signup and view all the answers

    What is an example of a positive right?

    <p>The right to adequate food</p> Signup and view all the answers

    What is the relationship between power and disability according to Hohfeld's table of jural correlatives/opposites?

    <p>If A has a power, then A lacks a disability</p> Signup and view all the answers

    What is the significance of the Cairo declaration for the elimination of female genital mutilation (2003)?

    <p>It provided a framework for governments to eradicate FGM</p> Signup and view all the answers

    What is the relationship between immunity and liability according to Hohfeld's table of jural correlatives/opposites?

    <p>If A has an immunity, then A lacks a liability</p> Signup and view all the answers

    What is the primary obstacle to the elimination of FGM in Tanzania?

    <p>Deeply entrenched cultural practices</p> Signup and view all the answers

    What is the main purpose of Article 5 of the Maputo Protocol?

    <p>To condemn and prohibit harmful practices that negatively affect women's human rights</p> Signup and view all the answers

    What is the consequence of not complying with the Maputo Protocol?

    <p>Sanctions and penalties</p> Signup and view all the answers

    What is the primary focus of the Constitutional Provisions in Tanzania regarding FGM?

    <p>Right to equality and non-discrimination</p> Signup and view all the answers

    What is the significance of Section 169A of the Penal Code in Tanzania?

    <p>It protects the rights of children under 18 years old</p> Signup and view all the answers

    What happens when international and local norms collide regarding FGM?

    <p>Individuals may or may not choose to change their thoughts and actions</p> Signup and view all the answers

    What is the impact of FGM on individuals, according to the Penal Code?

    <p>It may cause suffering or injury to health, including injury to, or loss of sight or hearing or limb or organ of the body</p> Signup and view all the answers

    What is the relationship between the Maputo Protocol and FGM in Tanzania?

    <p>The Maputo Protocol aims to prohibit and condemn FGM in Tanzania</p> Signup and view all the answers

    Study Notes

    Cultural Relativism

    • Premise A: If there is an objective ground for judgments concerning X, then different cultures will not make different judgments concerning X.
    • Premise B: Different cultures make different judgments concerning X.
    • Conclusion: There is no objective ground for judgments concerning X.
    • 4 Claims of Cultural Relativism:
      • There is no objective standard to judge one societal code better than another.
      • The moral code of our own society has no special status; it is merely one among many.
      • There is no “universal truth” in ethics; no moral truths hold for all peoples at all times (Dependency Thesis).
      • It is mere arrogance to try to judge the conduct of other people; we should adopt an attitude of tolerance toward the practices of other cultures.

    Critique of Cultural Relativism

    • Is Relativism really tolerant?: If you believe there are no moral rules, there can be no rule that requires tolerance as a moral principle.
    • Absurd Consequences of Cultural Relativism:
      • Morality reduces to aesthetic tastes.
      • If relativism is accepted, then racism, genocide, oppression of the poor, slavery, and other morally wrong acts are as equally moral as their opposites.
    • First argument against Cultural Relativism:
      • The fundamental mistake in the Cultural Relativist Argument is that it attempts to derive a substantive conclusion about a subject from the mere fact that people disagree about it.
      • There are 3 parts of an argument, and the conclusion does not follow from the premises.
    • 4 Additional arguments against Cultural Relativism:
      • Argument from values underlying practice.
      • Argument from moral experience.
      • The Aristotelian conception of happiness - acting fairly (Εὐδαιμονία = doing well and living well according to virtues with and for others).
      • The doctrine of the “golden mean” (Virtue is a state of character, concerned with choice, lying in a mean).

    Virtue Theory and Global Ethics

    • Advantages of Virtue Theory:
      • It is context-sensitive.
      • It permits appropriate partiality.
    • Disadvantages of Virtue Theory:
      • It is difficult to apply globally.
      • Conflicts of virtues are difficult to negotiate (see the inquiring murderer case).
    • Virtue Theory and FGM:
      • Argument based on Eudaimonia: Women should have the capability to choose to have sexual pleasure in their lives.
      • Argument based on care: Care is a virtue, and FGM is embedded in systems in which women are denigrated rather than cared for, and they need to be challenged.

    The Ethical Toolbox - Political Theories

      1. Cosmopolitanism:
      • Historical origin: Diogenes (“I am a citizen of the world (kosmopolités)”).
      • Definition: All human beings, regardless of their political affiliation, are (or can and should be) citizens in a single community.
      • Main features:
        • Individuality: The individual has moral worth and is the ultimate concern.
        • Universality: Each individual should be treated equally.
        • Impartiality: Persons are the ultimate purpose for all.
      • Similarities with:
        • Kantianism: Universality (treating individuals as equals).
        • Utilitarianism: Impartiality.
      • Taxonomy of Contemporary Cosmopolitanism:
        • Moral (weak/strong) vs. Institutional (Society of States vs. World States).
        • Focus: Human individuals vs. global institutions, structures, and associations.
        • Claim: All individuals have equal dignity (moral status) vs. global distributive justice.
        • Action: Commitment to helping human beings as such vs. commitment to certain global political institutions.

    Human Rights and FGM

    • Negative Rights: The duty of others not to interfere in the exercise of a person’s rights.
    • Positive Rights: The duty of the government and other agencies to facilitate the exercise of our rights.
    • Hohfeld’s table of jural correlatives/opposites:
      • Opposites: Claim vs. no-claim, liberty vs. duty, power vs. disability, immunity vs. liability.
      • Correlatives: Claim vs. duty, liberty vs. no-claim, power vs. liability, immunity vs. disability.
    • Example of positive rights: The basic right to adequate food.
    • Human Rights and FGM:
      • You have the power to waive, annul, or transfer your claim against others not to violate your body.
      • You have immunity against other altering your claim against others not to violate your body.
      • You have liberty (privilege) to control your body.

    Case of Tanzania

    • FGM is a deeply-entrenched cultural practice.
    • The country has ratified international and regional human rights instruments.
    • The Maputo Protocol (2005):
      • It is binding for whatever country ratifies it.
      • Art. 5: States parties shall prohibit and condemn all forms or harmful practices that negatively affect the human rights of women and are contrary to recognized international standards.
      • Awareness and educational information campaigns.
    • Constitutional Provisions:
      • Right to equality and non-discrimination (art. 12).
      • Right to life (art. 14).
    • Legislative Measures:
      • Penal Code, section 169A: Cruelty to children, including FGM.

    Studying That Suits You

    Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.

    Quiz Team

    Related Documents

    Notes M1 - Global Ethics & Restorative Justice PDF

    Description

    Explore the cultural relativist argument against universalism, examining the premises and conclusion of this philosophical debate. Delve into the claims of cultural relativism and its implications.

    More Like This

    Understanding Cultural Relativism
    22 questions

    Understanding Cultural Relativism

    GodGivenRegionalism avatar
    GodGivenRegionalism
    Global Ethics: Cultural Relativism
    24 questions

    Global Ethics: Cultural Relativism

    FestiveWildflowerMeadow avatar
    FestiveWildflowerMeadow
    Cultural Relativism Overview Quiz
    12 questions

    Cultural Relativism Overview Quiz

    LuxuriantOstrich avatar
    LuxuriantOstrich
    Cultural Relativism Module I
    40 questions

    Cultural Relativism Module I

    ProductiveVerisimilitude8757 avatar
    ProductiveVerisimilitude8757
    Use Quizgecko on...
    Browser
    Open
    Browser
    Browser