Podcast
Questions and Answers
What does Cultural Relativism suggest is the only way to improve a society?
What does Cultural Relativism suggest is the only way to improve a society?
- By making the society align with its own ideals (correct)
- By completely transforming societal structures
- By imposing external ideals and standards
- By promoting universal values among all cultures
Why do many people reject Cultural Relativism according to the content?
Why do many people reject Cultural Relativism according to the content?
- It allows for rigid adherence to harmful practices like slavery (correct)
- It emphasizes the importance of scientific reasoning
- It encourages cultural homogeneity across societies
- It promotes a one-size-fits-all approach to moral values
What is often misunderstood about the differences between cultures?
What is often misunderstood about the differences between cultures?
- Cultural morality is often universally accepted
- Cultures always share the same religious beliefs
- Values of societies are entirely based on material conditions
- Differences in customs indicate differences in values (correct)
Which reason is given for why people in some cultures may not eat certain animals?
Which reason is given for why people in some cultures may not eat certain animals?
What is a reason the content provides for differing customs in societies?
What is a reason the content provides for differing customs in societies?
How do the values of a culture relate to its customs according to the passage?
How do the values of a culture relate to its customs according to the passage?
What example is given to illustrate a significant cultural difference concerning values?
What example is given to illustrate a significant cultural difference concerning values?
What underlying theme is suggested about moral disagreements across cultures?
What underlying theme is suggested about moral disagreements across cultures?
What must be a tradition in any enduring culture for its young to survive?
What must be a tradition in any enduring culture for its young to survive?
Why is honesty viewed as essential in society?
Why is honesty viewed as essential in society?
What would be a likely result in a society that places no value on truthfulness?
What would be a likely result in a society that places no value on truthfulness?
What outcome would result from a society with no rules against murder?
What outcome would result from a society with no rules against murder?
What is stated as not being common in successful cultures?
What is stated as not being common in successful cultures?
What does the need for prohibitions against murder imply for societal structures?
What does the need for prohibitions against murder imply for societal structures?
What common goals contribute to shared values in societies?
What common goals contribute to shared values in societies?
Which of the following moral rules is universally present across cultures?
Which of the following moral rules is universally present across cultures?
What is a more accurate term for 'female circumcision' as referred to in Western contexts?
What is a more accurate term for 'female circumcision' as referred to in Western contexts?
What conclusion can be drawn about cultural differences in moral rules?
What conclusion can be drawn about cultural differences in moral rules?
What does the Cultural Differences Argument attempt to achieve?
What does the Cultural Differences Argument attempt to achieve?
How did Fauziya Kassindja manage to avoid excision initially?
How did Fauziya Kassindja manage to avoid excision initially?
What controversy surrounded Fauziya Kassindja's asylum case?
What controversy surrounded Fauziya Kassindja's asylum case?
According to Cultural Relativism, how should we view moral practices of different societies?
According to Cultural Relativism, how should we view moral practices of different societies?
How many women globally are estimated to have undergone excision?
How many women globally are estimated to have undergone excision?
What might be a consequence of accepting Cultural Relativism?
What might be a consequence of accepting Cultural Relativism?
What perspective did some observers express regarding cultural practices like excision?
What perspective did some observers express regarding cultural practices like excision?
What is a major critique against Cultural Relativism as per the content?
What is a major critique against Cultural Relativism as per the content?
William Graham Sumner's perspective on Cultural Relativism emphasizes which of the following?
William Graham Sumner's perspective on Cultural Relativism emphasizes which of the following?
What experience did Fauziya Kassindja endure during her 18-month imprisonment in America?
What experience did Fauziya Kassindja endure during her 18-month imprisonment in America?
Which area is NOT mentioned as a place where excision occurs?
Which area is NOT mentioned as a place where excision occurs?
In what way does Cultural Relativism affect the criticism of oppressive practices?
In what way does Cultural Relativism affect the criticism of oppressive practices?
What is implied if one accepts Cultural Relativism's stance on morality?
What is implied if one accepts Cultural Relativism's stance on morality?
What stance does Cultural Relativism take regarding the morality of the Chinese government's practices?
What stance does Cultural Relativism take regarding the morality of the Chinese government's practices?
What is one of the primary health risks associated with excision?
What is one of the primary health risks associated with excision?
Why might some defend the practice of excision despite its harmful effects?
Why might some defend the practice of excision despite its harmful effects?
What question can be used to evaluate the practice of excision from a culture-independent perspective?
What question can be used to evaluate the practice of excision from a culture-independent perspective?
What is indicated about the social benefits of excision?
What is indicated about the social benefits of excision?
What might discourage individuals from condemning excision despite its harmful effects?
What might discourage individuals from condemning excision despite its harmful effects?
Which of the following is NOT a claimed benefit of excision according to its defenders?
Which of the following is NOT a claimed benefit of excision according to its defenders?
How is excision viewed by some men according to the content?
How is excision viewed by some men according to the content?
What is one of the short-term effects of excision mentioned in the content?
What is one of the short-term effects of excision mentioned in the content?
Study Notes
Cultural Relativism and Moral Truths
- Cultural Differences Argument fails to establish universal moral truths based solely on disagreement among societies.
- Even if Cultural Relativism were accepted, it would prevent criticism of harmful practices, such as political oppression.
Consequences of Cultural Relativism
- Prohibits declaring other societies' customs as morally inferior, creating challenges in condemning oppressive actions like those of the Chinese government.
- Limits social reform ideas to merely aligning ideals within a society without challenging the ideals themselves.
- Cultural Relativism contradicts the widely accepted belief in the moral progress represented by the abolition of slavery.
Overstated Cultural Differences
- Cultural differences in morality may be exaggerated; seemingly significant differences often stem from underlying shared values or beliefs.
- Example: A society that prohibits eating cows might hold this belief due to cultural values, not differing morals.
Essential Moral Rules Across Cultures
- Fundamental moral rules such as prohibitions against murder and lying are necessary for societal existence.
- Societies must value qualities like truthfulness for communication and cohesion; differing customs do not equal differing values.
Shared Human Values
- Many societal values, such as the desire for clean water and good healthcare, are common due to shared human needs and nature.
Case Study: Female Genital Mutilation (Excision)
- Excision affects over 200 million women, conducted in various countries often as part of cultural rituals.
- Fauziya Kassindja fled Togo to escape excision; her story highlights the clash between cultural practices and human rights.
- Excision is painful, leads to health risks, and has no clear social benefits, raising ethical concerns.
Assessing Cultural Practices
- Justifying excision with claims of benefiting society fails morally; the welfare of affected individuals must be considered.
- A potential culture-independent moral standard assesses whether a practice promotes or hinders the welfare of individuals affected.
Reluctance to Critique Other Cultures
- Even those horrified by practices like excision hesitate to condemn them due to fears of imposing one's cultural standards or misunderstanding the nuances of other cultures.
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.
Description
Explore the complexities surrounding the Cultural Differences Argument and its implications on moral truths. This quiz examines the idea that disagreement among societies does not necessarily lead to valid moral conclusions. Delve deeper into the nuances of cultural perspectives and ethics.
