Summary Trial procedure

Questions and Answers

What must the prosecution be given before a magistrate can decide on a submission of no case to answer?

A requirement to justify the charges.

The chance to present additional evidence.

The ability to cross-examine defence witnesses.

An opportunity to make representations. (correct)

How do justices determine if there is a case to answer during a submission?

By evaluating the general public opinion on the case.

By considering if a reasonable bench could convict. (correct)

By determining if the evidence satisfies a moral obligation.

By assessing the likelihood of a jury decision.

What is the standard set out in Galbraith regarding the prosecution evidence during a submission of no case to answer?

It cannot be so tenuous that a properly directed jury could convict. (correct)

It must be substantial enough to warrant a jury's attention.

It must meet the threshold for beyond a reasonable doubt.

It should be conclusively shown to be credible.

What role does the credibility of prosecution witnesses play in a no case to answer submission?

Issues of credibility should be left for the jury to decide. Signup and view all the answers

Are justices obligated to provide reasons if they reject a submission of no case to answer?

No, they have no obligation to give reasons. Signup and view all the answers

What outcomes might result from a submission where evidence is deemed perverse?

The accused is acquitted without further ado. Signup and view all the answers

What is the primary consideration for justices during a no case to answer submission?

Whether the evidence is compelling enough for a likelihood of conviction. Signup and view all the answers

Under what condition can a magistrate acquit the accused on the grounds of insufficient evidence?

If no reasonable tribunal could convict based on the evidence presented. Signup and view all the answers

What is the primary purpose of informing the defendant after a conviction?

To provide reasons for the conviction Signup and view all the answers

What impression did the magistrates create in D's conviction that led to its quashing?

The defendant failed to prove his innocence Signup and view all the answers

What is the default position in magistrates' courts when an accused does not attend a trial?

The court can proceed without the accused if they are aware of the trial. Signup and view all the answers

What is a limitation on justices regarding verdicts on charges?

They cannot find the accused guilty of a lesser offence when only one charge is presented Signup and view all the answers

Which of the following factors is NOT considered by the court when assessing the interests of justice related to an accused's absence?

The previous convictions of the accused. Signup and view all the answers

In which situation might a court find an accused guilty of a different charge?

When a driving offence allows findings of lesser offences Signup and view all the answers

What must the court do when an accused provides a legitimate medical note for non-attendance?

Consider the note and give reasons for any decision made. Signup and view all the answers

What is the significance of a duty to give reasons for a verdict?

It ensures transparency in judicial decision-making Signup and view all the answers

In the case where the accused was excluded from the court but wanted to attend, what did the justices rule?

The accused should still be tried in his absence. Signup and view all the answers

What occurs when a magistrate wrongly convicts for a lesser offence?

The conviction may be quashed if not based on separate charges Signup and view all the answers

What ruling did Underhill J make regarding the accused's exclusion from court?

His exclusion was not justified as he was prevented from attending. Signup and view all the answers

Why might a false impression arise regarding the burden of proof in a case?

Because of vague wording used in the magistrate's decision Signup and view all the answers

What action is the court NOT obliged to take if no reason for absence is offered by the accused?

Investigate the circumstances of the absence. Signup and view all the answers

How might a court handling of just driving offences differ from other charges?

They have wider discretion in determining guilt Signup and view all the answers

How should the court address an accused's misbehaviour that leads to their exclusion from the trial?

Consider the misbehaviour but allow the trial to proceed in absentia. Signup and view all the answers

What might be an implication of the justices' ruling regarding the accused's behaviour in court?

The determination of absence can be contentious based on behaviour. Signup and view all the answers

What is the primary consideration for justices when evaluating a submission of no case to answer?

The overall weight of the prosecution evidence Signup and view all the answers

What opportunity does the prosecution have when the justices are considering a submission of no case to answer?

To address the justices before a ruling is made Signup and view all the answers

What would justify a court in later overturning its first decision?

A significant change of circumstances Signup and view all the answers

In what scenario can an error of law form the basis for an appeal under s. 111 of the MCA 1980?

If there is an error in law after a final determination in the magistrates' court Signup and view all the answers

In what manner are justices required to provide reasons for their verdicts?

With sufficient reasoning, but not necessarily in elaborate form Signup and view all the answers

What might influence a justice's decision to allow a trial to proceed despite a submission of no case to answer?

The existence of reasonable prosecution evidence that could lead to a conviction Signup and view all the answers

What is the primary limitation placed on the power of a lower court to revisit its own orders?

The need for new evidence or circumstances Signup and view all the answers

Under which condition can a ruling take effect despite the absence of the accused?

If the defendant has filed a written guilty plea under rule 24.8 Signup and view all the answers

If justices are provisionally inclined to dismiss a case based on no case to answer, what is their next step?

To allow the prosecution to present their arguments Signup and view all the answers

Which of the following best describes the justices' stance on the credibility of witnesses during a no case to answer submission?

Justices typically disregard witness credibility unless it is blatantly clear Signup and view all the answers

What is required for an efficacious administration of justice regarding lower courts revisiting decisions?

A strict approach to the power to revoke earlier decisions Signup and view all the answers

What conditions are required for the review of a decision according to existing circumstances?

Circumstances must have existed but were previously undisclosed Signup and view all the answers

What should a party do if they want a detailed explanation for a magistrate's decision?

Ask the magistrates to state a case for clarity Signup and view all the answers

What general principle guides justices when considering whether to acquit on no case to answer submissions?

The trial should progress if there's any potential for a conviction Signup and view all the answers

What triggers the applicability of sections 8A and 8B regarding a decision?

The decision of a summary trial proceedings Signup and view all the answers

What is the most infrequent reason for a court to overturn its first decision?

An earlier existing circumstance not drawn to attention Signup and view all the answers

Study Notes

Submission of No Case to Answer

Credibility issues should not typically influence justices when considering a submission of no case; however, some may adopt a pragmatic approach if prosecution evidence appears unconvincing.
Justices are generally required to allow a trial to proceed if a reasonable tribunal could potentially convict based on the prosecution evidence.

Prosecution's Right to Reply

Justices must call on the prosecution for a response before upholding a submission of no case to answer, granting the prosecutor the opportunity to argue against dismissal.

Duty to Provide Reasons on Verdict

Courts must give "sufficient reasons" when convicting or issuing a hospital order but do not need to provide an extensive judgment.
Detailed reasoning can be requested if necessary, ensuring the defendant understands the basis for the conviction.

Accused Finding of a Lesser Offence

Justices may only find the accused guilty or not guilty of the exact charge presented; they have no authority to convict for a lesser offence unless the case includes separate charges.
Certain driving offences allow a conviction for a lesser charge even if only the greater charge is before the court.

Insufficient Prosecution Evidence

Magistrates can acquit if prosecution evidence does not reasonably support a conviction, either on defense application or their own initiative, provided the prosecutor has a chance to respond.

Credibility of Prosecution Witnesses

Justices should assess whether prosecution evidence is so weak that a properly directed jury could not convict, focusing on the evidence's strength rather than witness credibility.

Absence of Accused During Proceedings

In magistrates' courts, absent defendants who knew about the trial date and did not provide justification are generally treated as voluntarily absent.
The refusal to investigate the absence of a party is contingent upon the absence of reasonable justification.

Challenges Around Exclusion from Court

A just ruling may occur despite a defendant's disorderly behavior leading to their exclusion; misbehavior does not negate their rights to attend.

Revisiting Court Decisions

A court can only overturn previous rulings under specific conditions such as changed circumstances or overlooked details from the original decision.
Generally, the common-law rule discourages revisiting decisions without substantial justification.

Procedure When a Party is Absent

Specific rules govern trials when a party is absent, including exceptions for those who have submitted a guilty plea or when special procedures are applied.
If the prosecutor is not present, the court retains certain powers to proceed.

Studying That Suits You

Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.

Description

This quiz covers key aspects of magistrates' court procedures, particularly the default position regarding the absence of an accused. It explores the responsibilities of the court when no reasons for absence are provided, as well as considerations for the interests of justice in such cases.