Podcast
Questions and Answers
Which of the following best describes the primary concern regarding institutional problems associated with imprisonment?
Which of the following best describes the primary concern regarding institutional problems associated with imprisonment?
What concept relates to the idea that the elite exert power over the underprivileged through punishment?
What concept relates to the idea that the elite exert power over the underprivileged through punishment?
Which philosopher is associated with critiquing the naturalness of punishment?
Which philosopher is associated with critiquing the naturalness of punishment?
Which problem for victims is associated with experiencing further trauma due to the criminal justice system?
Which problem for victims is associated with experiencing further trauma due to the criminal justice system?
Signup and view all the answers
What is a potential disadvantage of private prisons compared to state-run facilities?
What is a potential disadvantage of private prisons compared to state-run facilities?
Signup and view all the answers
In the context of punishment, what aspect do Durkheim's views emphasize?
In the context of punishment, what aspect do Durkheim's views emphasize?
Signup and view all the answers
What is a common economic problem faced by prisoners after release?
What is a common economic problem faced by prisoners after release?
Signup and view all the answers
Which of the following statements aligns with the philosophical critique of punishment as competition?
Which of the following statements aligns with the philosophical critique of punishment as competition?
Signup and view all the answers
What was one of the main defenses used for Johnny during his trial?
What was one of the main defenses used for Johnny during his trial?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the primary purpose of deterrence in punishment philosophy?
What is the primary purpose of deterrence in punishment philosophy?
Signup and view all the answers
Which principle of punishment emphasizes making a punishment proportionate to the crime committed?
Which principle of punishment emphasizes making a punishment proportionate to the crime committed?
Signup and view all the answers
According to the prosecution's argument, what was a reason for increasing the severity of Johnny's punishment?
According to the prosecution's argument, what was a reason for increasing the severity of Johnny's punishment?
Signup and view all the answers
Which of the following is a disadvantage of sending criminals to prison?
Which of the following is a disadvantage of sending criminals to prison?
Signup and view all the answers
What is the focus of the principle of rehabilitation in punishment?
What is the focus of the principle of rehabilitation in punishment?
Signup and view all the answers
What does the 'elimination' principle in punishment primarily address?
What does the 'elimination' principle in punishment primarily address?
Signup and view all the answers
Which statement reflects a key consideration in the philosophy of punishment?
Which statement reflects a key consideration in the philosophy of punishment?
Signup and view all the answers
Study Notes
Lecture 2: Punishment - Opening Problem
- Johnny, part of the Wild Cats gang, engaged in violent crimes, drug use, and graffiti.
- After drinking heavily, Johnny stole a Ferrari and crashed it, nearly harming an elderly woman.
- Despite no serious injury, Johnny was prosecuted for theft and reckless endangerment.
- The defense argued Johnny's disadvantaged upbringing, poverty, and addiction.
- The defendant is a father of two young girls and imprisonment would cause them emotional distress
- The prosecution countered that Johnny deserved punishment for his criminal history.
- A case study analysis was suggested for students to decide if Johnny should be sent to prison and why.
Lecture 2: Punishment - Advantages of Prison
- No specific advantages listed in the provided text
Lecture 2: Punishment - Principles of Punishment
- Retribution: Philosophy of "an eye for an eye" aiming for Justice in the past
- Considerations for retribution: Fair, proportionate punishment.
- Deterrence: Aims for the greater good by discouraging future offences through prevention
- Considerations for deterrence: Severity and certainty are crucial
- Elimination: Protecting safety for the greater good in the future
- Considerations for elimination: Justice and procedure must be upheld.
- Rehabilitation: Focuses on victims of circumstances, offering care to the present.
- Considerations for rehabilitation: Ethical considerations and potential complications need attention.
Lecture 2: Punishment - Applying Theories of Punishment
- No specific information presented regarding this part of the lecture in the provided text.
Lecture 2: Punishment - Disadvantages of Prison
- No specific disadvantages listed in the provided text.
Lecture 2: Punishment - Problems for Prisoners
- Imprisonment: Causes various issues for prisoners:
- Economic problems
- Labeling: Social and professional consequences.
- Institution-alisation: Problems with reintegration into society.
- Social Problems
Lecture 2: Punishment - Problems for Victims
- Criminal Justice: Leads to secondary victimization for the innocent.
- Justice for Victims: Inadequate compensation or support for victims.
- Secondary Victimization: Negative outcomes and emotional distress for victims of crime.
- State Compensation: Insufficient financial support, and insufficient means for the affected party.
Lecture 2: Punishment - Problems for Society
- A circular diagram represents a continuous process involving several key components.
- The components of the diagram illustrate the economic and social effects of a legal system on society at large and its citizens.
Lecture 2: Punishment - Should We Send Criminals to Prison?
- No concrete answer to the question.
- The presentation explores the debate on this topic from several philosophical perspectives.
Lecture 2: Punishment - Philosophical Critiques of Punishment
- Pro-Prison (Durkheim): Collective consciousness, the collective good
- Anti-Prison (Kropotkin): Competition vs. Cooperation in society
- Anti-Prison (Foucault): Punishment as unnatural, problematic, negative consequences
Lecture 2: Punishment - Questions and Discussion
- Question 1: Evaluating the advantages and disadvantages of private prisons compared to state-run prisons. Should private prisons be favored?
- Question 2: Matching theories of punishment to images. Justifications needed.
- Question 3: Examining the proposition that punishment is an act of power from a privileged class. Discussion on whether this argument holds merit.
Studying That Suits You
Use AI to generate personalized quizzes and flashcards to suit your learning preferences.
Related Documents
Description
Explore the complexities of criminal justice through the case study of Johnny, a member of the Wild Cats gang who faces prosecution after a series of violent crimes. This quiz examines the principles of punishment, including retribution, and considers the implications of imprisonment on his family. Analyze whether Johnny should be punished and the factors that should influence your decision.
